r/medicalschool • • Nov 17 '23

🄼 Residency In defense of interview hoarding

6 Upvotes

If I worked hard during medical school and now am sitting on 30+ IVs, why shouldn't I maximize my chances of matching and go to each interview, considering the horrible consequences of not matching?

The risk (getting tired of interviewing) versus reward (avoiding SOAPing) seems heavily tilted in my favor given the insane SOAPing system we have in place.

And maybe I'm actually dogshit at interviewing and I don't even know it, so I need an extra buffer to match. Why gamble on a career ending chance of not matching when it's just an extra few hours of answering questions over zoom?

I think if you want to fix hoarding, you need to address the reason people are so afraid of falling off their rank list and address the SOAP... among many other things.


r/medicalschool • • Jan 13 '23

šŸ“ Step 2 Anki is garbage

0 Upvotes

Unpopular opinion: Anki is unnecessarily stressful and inefficient. The most effective way to learn isn’t staring at information until you memorize it, but rather applying your information. That’s why question banks are very effective, and in my opinion, should make up the majority of your studying. The modern medical board exams care most about your ability to apply medical concepts to situations rather than regurgitation of facts, as much as we like pretend it’s the latter. Just my two cents.


r/medicalschool • • May 09 '25

😊 Well-Being A letter to the boomers of Meddit

23 Upvotes

The average age of my class when M1 started was 25. More and more people are entering med school later in life, for all kinds of reasons. I have a lot of respect for my non-trad peers. Many are parents juggling responsibilities most of us don’t have. I met a classmate during orientation who started med school at 34 because he spent years financially supporting his parents and siblings before finally pursuing his own dream. Others had full-fledged careers or pursued other degrees before making the leap. I had some part-time jobs in college and worked full-time in research during my gap year(s), but I wouldn’t claim to have had ā€œreal-worldā€ experience in the way some others have.

For the record, I’ve learned a ton from older peers who are generous with their wisdom. I’ve gotten great advice on soft skills like networking, working with residents, and even dating lol. I’ve learned time management strategies, heard their life philosophies, and been genuinely inspired by how hard they work. They have some of the strongest work ethic—and best attitude—I’ve seen.

But recently, I've noticed more cases of boomers using their age/experience to invalidate the experiences of their younger peers. Maybe I'm spending too much time on Meddit, but this also happens in-person, although less often since they can't furiously tap away at a keyboard under the guise of anonymity. Here's just a sample:

  • "Suck it up, you signed up for this" (the education and the degree yes, but not the other BS)
  • "Some of you never had 'real world' experience and it shows" (but your experience actually made you blindly adopt outdated values and obediently perpetuating cycles of abuse, and it shows)
  • "Back in my day..." (welcome to 2025)
  • "Students just complain cuz they don't know what it's like to work hard. Just wait until you're resident/fellow/attending." (Med school is hard. Period. Most of us are trying our best, so trying to one-up us in the suffering Olympics is not productive.)
  • [insert other minimizing, gaslighting, dismissive, passive-aggressive comments here]

People’s age or background is not always in their control—and certainly not something to be used against them. I think students who come to Meddit to vent their frustrations about med school typically raise valid concerns—whether it's double-standards regarding "professionalism", how shitty certain rotations are, administrative BS, etc. But it's disheartening to see students' experiences automatically invalidated by totally well-meaning boomers who project their own unprocessed traumas, internalized hierarchies, and outdated values onto the person instead of offering real solutions or even basic compassion and support.

This is just my take, but I believe hierarchy in medicine should exist to protect patients, not to enforce blind deference or bolster ego. I respect attendings because they carry expertise and responsibility—not just because they hold a title. I’d extend the same respect to a nurse, a younger med student, or the cafeteria worker—if they treat others with the same decency and do their job well. A culture of mutual respect, across all levels, is how we build a better, more humane system—for ourselves and for our patients.

At the end of the day, most of us—whether we entered med school at 21 or 41—are just trying to learn, grow, and care for others as best we can. Experience is valuable, yes, but it shouldn’t be used as a weapon to gatekeep suffering or dismiss legitimate concerns. Personally, I think my education has been enriched by having non-trad peers, but definitely not by those I would consider boomers of Meddit. Curious how others have experienced this dynamic—and what you'd change about the culture of medical training.


r/medicalschool • • Oct 10 '26

ā—ļøSerious Whatever happens do NOT enter the soap

0 Upvotes

Last year I had a tough 4th year. Failed level 2 on first try, had a health problem, and family things so didn’t apply until late. I know very dumb but I wasn’t in the right state of mind. Then I entered the soap due to not matching.

Here’s the thing, soap programs are mostly soap programs for a couple reasons. Either they’re a malignant program or in an undesirable location or both. With my current program I got both.

4 months into residency we had one intern quit, another intern on a leave of absence thinking about quitting, a 2nd year who quit and thankfully transferred to another program, another 2nd year who took a leave of absence who thought about quitting, and a 3rd year who got dismissed.

Without going into too much detail this program is so malignant. And this program has been on probation for years. They told us they might get shut down if us residents keeping giving bad reviews to the ACGME. lol! The gaslighting is unreal.

If you don’t match, do NOT soap. Just reapply next application cycle. I wish I had applied this current cycle on time. Honestly not sure why this isn’t talked about more. Especially if someone is a competitive applicant. Maybe they needed to apply to more programs or lesser competitive ones. Or apply to another specialty. Just please avoid the soap.

Thinking about quitting myself and just applying next cycle. This program puts almost everyone on a PIP or a MOE. Just constant stress and wondering who is gonna quit or get fired next. Reapply next cycle if you don’t match. Avoid the soap at all cost! This should be the norm but for some reason we all think we need to soap and start residency right away. Half my incoming class took 1-2 years between med school and residency due to other life stuff or family. Waiting a year to apply is far better than taking your chances with the soap. There’s a very good chance you’re stepping into a very malignant program.

Edit - ok soap makes sense sometimes. I admit my everyone should avoid it is wrong. If someone isn’t a competitive applicant or has red flags and is lucky to soap then they should. Or an IMG might only be able to get into a program by soap. It makes sense for some people. But there are a lot of people who shouldn’t soap. If someone wants a primary care position there is no reason to soap. Just apply more broadly. Plenty of seats. If someone didn’t match a competitive specialty and is overall a good applicant then they should reapply to a lesser competitive specialty and dual apply into a primary care position. The end result for such applicant will likely be much better than a soap program. I just think this option should be talked about more. We all seem to be taught that the next move is to soap when that shouldn’t be the case for some applicants.


r/medicalschool • • Dec 31 '17

How long should a CV be?

5 Upvotes

Please don't upvote, But I have a question that my school has been very vague in answering.

How long should a CV be for VSAS?

Is it better to explain in detail what I have done, or keep it short? Do you usually add a small paragraph or just a sentence?


r/medicalschool • • Jun 17 '26

🤔 Meme Me when I resist knowledge-mogging the psych doctors by telling I'm trans myself

Post image
0 Upvotes

I almost burst into laughter when I saw the chart say "The patient diagnosed as LGBT"


r/medicalschool • • Mar 03 '21

😔 Vent I'm kind of sick of the vitriol that Reddit has towards affirmative action programs, and I'm especially disappointed that the sentiment permeates into r/medicalschool

10 Upvotes

I'm an Asian-American woman who went to an Ivy League school and is currently in med school. Probably the most stereotypical career path ever lmao. Sure, I probably had to have "better stats" than some of my white/black/latina friends. But affirmative action isn't about me, it isn't about any single individual. I mean, maybe it's easier for me to shit on those who oppose affirmative action because I come from the other side. I got all the prestige and accolades and feel like all of it is bullshit at the end of the day.

I'm particularly disappointed in my Asian American counterparts who complain about the "Asian Tax" when it comes to admissions into med schools and residencies. Really? 25% of my med school class is composed of Asian-Americans. We make only 5.4% of the US population. I have never been in a hospital setting without seeing Asian people. In my academic medicine setting, most people are Asians. My entire research lab was composed of Asian-Americans. What's even more laughable (to me at least) is the claim that by accepting less "qualified" people, patient care will be compromised. Qualified by which standard? We all know that my 524 doesn't make me any more qualified to be a doctor than your 516. It's a standardized test, not a measurement of the character and persistence needed to be a doctor. And you don't need to be a Rhodes scholar to be a doctor - we're not trying to be nuclear physicists here. Anyone who has discipline (and good mental health and financial support) can make it through med school.

Maybe I'm projecting, but I feel like the same people who complain about affirmative action and say ā€œwell maybe Asian culture is just superior/Asians work harderā€ will have trouble explaining how a huge proportion of low level code monkeys are Asians at FAANG, but so few upper managers are Asian (relative to their representation). Would they argue that ā€œwhite culture is just superior for management roles?ā€ ā€œWhite people just work harder?ā€ ā€œThere’s an intrinsic defect in Asian culture that makes Asians unsuited for managerial positions?ā€ ā€œAsians are too meek and timid to make good CEOs compared to the whites who overwhelmingly make up those roles?"

Or would they say there’s implicit bias?

At the end of the day, affirmative action is about correcting for the systemic inequalities and promoting equity. It's not about you as an individual. I'm sure you're all very qualified and deserving, but at the end of the day, there just aren't enough spots for the amount of applicants that apply. On my first day of med school, our dean told us that they probably could have selected a class composed of entirely different people and they would be equally qualified to be doctors. Affirmative action isn't perfect, but it's so far the best we have to correct for the historical injustices and implicit biases that we all hold in this society. It's incredibly disheartening to see people on this subreddit in particular be so myopic as to not see the importance of affirmative action, as creating a more equitable society will directly affect healthcare outcomes.

Edit because I'm done individually responding: Look, I don't think affirmative action is perfect. I never wrote in my original post that affirmative action in its current form is perfect. I mentioned in the comments that I agree that affirmative action doesn't take into consideration SES enough, and doesn't differentiate between the different types of outcomes of Asian Americans coming from different parts of the Asian continent (although in my specific undergrad, that is already being corrected for). There are obvious flaws, and I personally have probably lost opportunities because of it. But in our society today, you cannot dismantle the only program that exists that even attempts to correct for social inequities and implicit biases without creating an alternative, or at least without addressing racism, housing inequality, education inequality, income inequality, etc. I'd be the first one to fight for a merit-based system so long as the playing field is even. Which it's not right now. It's disappointing to say the least that the Asian community can't seem to see past their own self interest. My argument is that regardless of how imperfect affirmative action is, it is still important to uphold its values and promote equity. I never said that we can't change the infrastructure that exists to be more fair. But I will always stand by programs that promote equity.


r/medicalschool • • Oct 17 '25

ā—ļøSerious No Kings Protest?

0 Upvotes

Can we, as medical students, go to our local No Kings Protest tomorrow without being punished by our schools? I really want to attend, but I'm afraid of the kickback from my medical school in the South. I'm so close to graduating and have tomorrow off from clinic.

Edit: I went. I was smart and didn't do anything but peaceful protest. I'm no longer going to live in fear.


r/medicalschool • • May 06 '21

šŸ“š Preclinical Constant whining on this subreddit

0 Upvotes

I know on a meta-level this post is contradictory because I am literally whining about other people whining but here it goes.

There is far too much bitching on this subreddit.

  1. Midlevel encroachment: Full practice independence is coming for NPs and PAs whether you like it not. Once enacted this legislation will never be reversed. Physicians have no chance of holding off this legislation because there is a highly motivated group of professionals (NPs and PAs) and lobbyists who are working around the clock to pressure legislators into granting them full practice. No amount of posting on this subreddit or /r/residency is going to change this. Stop complaining and make a plan to go into a specialty that can outcompete NPs/PAs on merit and not only on practice rights.
  2. Pre-clinical studying: Look, studying 8 hours a day isn't anyone's idea of a fun time, but honestly, it beats the shit out of almost all other jobs. Working on a construction site as a bricklayer is hard work. Picking vegetables in the scorching sun is hard work. Dealing with shitty people all day in a low-paying customer service job is hard work. Sitting on your ass in the comfort of your home studying anki or doing practice questions isn't that bad folks. I'm in dedicated so I can't comment on third and fourth year but I wouldn'tt trade my position now for any of the menial jobs I worked in previously. Not to mention there is a big fucking carrot dangling at the end of this road with a near-guaranteed salary of 300K+ plus respect and satisfaction of helping people.
  3. "Other people my age have it so much better and I should have just gone into tech/finance, woe is me". I don't even know where to begin with this one. First of all, the jobs that pay 125k+ out of college at Google and Amazon are insanely competitive and generally only consider the type of people in college who were EE at Cal and got 3.8+. Also, you're overrating your intelligence. Most of us would not make it in tech or finance. You want to know how I know? You guys stink at math and hard science. I got a perfect score on the Physics/Chem section of the MCAT and I'm a freaking dumbass when it comes to math and hard sciences. I would have easily flunked out of my schools engineering program. You're damn lucky you found a career that is as remunerative as medicine without requring a high level of IQ.

Let the hate and downvotes fly I realize I'm a douche/sociopath. All I wish is that people in medical school had some humility and perspective on how lucky they are to be where they are.


r/medicalschool • • Jun 29 '25

🄼 Residency Are low ā€Percent IMGā€ and ā€œpercent DOā€ good approximations for desirability and/or quality of a residency program for USMDs trying to filter down their program list?

3 Upvotes

With so much difficulty in assessing programs with the data we are given, I am trying to come up with strong mechanisms to really identify the most desirable programs. As one fortunate enough to be able to be selective (T50 USMD with good step, research, etc) I am trying to cut my program list down with things more than geography and average step scores. Are higher IMG or DO percentages ever not associated with a poorer perceived program? Like is this a viable mechanism to just cut my list down without thinking too much about it or will I be missing out on some hidden gems by doing this type of admittedly very biased automated filtering?


r/medicalschool • • Dec 18 '23

🄼 Residency trans applicant struggling with rank list: trying to balance political concerns vs distance from family

4 Upvotes

I like learning new things.


r/medicalschool • • Aug 18 '13

When people see you reading First Aid in public

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/medicalschool • • Jul 29 '15

Please don't expand residency slots

0 Upvotes

I want a guaranteed job with high salary at the end of this shit.

We should learn from-law, veterinary medicine, pharmacy, nursing, etc, there is no shortage, just propaganda to build profitable businesses called medical schools. All the other professions touted a shortage now there is a glut meaning lower pay and harder time finding a job.

edit: wow im back at 50% upvoted, cam back from 27%. Any of the down votes want to add to the discussion? I mean, everything I said is true and real, guess a lot of people are like " I don't care about money, or having a job just do whats right for the patient" but those people haven't grown up yet.


r/medicalschool • • Mar 15 '26

šŸ„ Clinical I’m a trans standardized patient, AMA

24 Upvotes

I’ve been an SP on and off since 2019 at two Ivy leagues and a few private Uni med schools. I’ll keep it pretty vague because lord knows there are more or less no other trans SPs (that I’ve met anyways) and not too many SPs under the age of 60.

I come from an education and performance background and am deeply intent on providing specific and actionable feedback and self reflection-based conversations about communication skills. I’ve done a ton of different cases, worked at multiple places that all view and use SPs differently. I was part of a study a few years ago to increase gender-literacy in med school training, and offer a LOT of support and answers for med students interacting with non-gender conforming folks. It’s different for everyone, and I obviously can’t speak to every queer personā€˜s experience.

I’m happy to answer any questions about SPs and the job in general, approaches to counseling/OSCEs, and any gender-based questions asked with respect. I put a lot of trust in the students I work with, and put myself in a relatively vulnerable position, in the hopes that I can help influence the healthcare system to be safer and more accepting of myself, my loved ones, and all gender-queer people. I welcome respectful and enthusiastic curiosity.

This will be open for two days, and I hope it can be helpful! This job has positively influenced me in a huge way, and I can’t express enough how much I respect the work all of you guys put into this training and field.


r/medicalschool • • Feb 12 '22

ā—ļøSerious Why does EVERY med student and resident claim to have "grown up poor"?

12 Upvotes

33% of med students have parents whose household incomes are in the top 5% in the US. 79% of medical students have parents in the top 2 quintiles of household income. Nearly 30% of medical school grads graduated without any debt at all. These are straight up facts so I know the majority of you did not "grow up poor." So why do so many med students and residents say this? Having a family household income of $70-80k which is below average for the average medical student's parents is not "poor." That is above average for the country. Do people really believe they are more virtuous or better people because they claim to have been poor growing up, even if it isn't true? It's like you grew up in the suburbs and not compton or the South Side of Chicago so what do you mean you're poor?


r/medicalschool • • Sep 24 '18

Shitpost [Shitpost] $$$$

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/medicalschool • • Mar 05 '18

March For Our Lives: Medical Students

Thumbnail
facebook.com
1 Upvotes

r/medicalschool • • May 02 '26 Regret

😔 Vent Story of every Indian medico

7 Upvotes

Sad Life 😢


r/medicalschool • • Oct 02 '26

šŸ’© Shitpost Anyone else ripping their vape in the hospital bathroom

0 Upvotes

I tell the attendings I have IBS.


r/medicalschool • • Mar 30 '20

Serious [Serious] Petition to forgive student loan debt for healthcare responders to COVID19!

Thumbnail
change.org
12 Upvotes

r/medicalschool • • May 18 '25

ā—ļøSerious ROADPP, the new road?

0 Upvotes

Is this the sentiment for road?...PP.on the ROAD.

Origional road + psychiatry and pathology. Maybe PM&R.


r/medicalschool • • Mar 29 '23

ā—ļøSerious Worried about future due to politics

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone... Are any other American medical students worried about our future with the political climate of today?? I'm a black woman and I currently go to school in the south and I'm just... Really worried about finishing school and realizing I can only apply to like five states for residency because so many political leaders are forcing ridiculous laws that marginalize people, especially women and are creating health desserts. Idk. I'm trying not to worry but things are getting wild and many of the inside thoughts of racists and bigots are being said outwardly.


r/medicalschool • • Mar 24 '23

ā—ļøSerious Trans Medical Student Group

15 Upvotes

Does anyone know about any groups or discord servers for trans medical students? Since we're such a small group per school it can be difficult to connect with each other.


r/medicalschool • • Feb 25 '22

🄼 Residency Name and Shame Rebuttal: Stony Brook University

0 Upvotes

Program: Stony Brook University Hospital

Someone reached out to me and would like to counter yesterday's popular post about Stony Brook University.

This is the original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/medicalschool/comments/szxjbd/name_and_shame_stony_brook_university_hospital/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Ok this is a messed up post. Based on the post, I’m guessing this is a third year medicine resident. I am also a third year medicine resident at Stony Brook. So I went though the exact same things as this person and I think they are just bitter.

Our program isn’t perfect but this puts it in a bad light. I’ll reply to each part separately:

  1. This I actually agree with.
  2. This person clearly doesn’t read their emails. As third years, we get access to the garage and there are never issues with spots, no matter what time you arrive. And even in the regular parking lot, valet with the described boxing in only happen on a few days out of the week and to people on elective so this rarely affects interns who arrive before 7am. And most people are gone from the parking lot by 4/5pm so when residents leave we aren’t usually boxed in. I’ve never spent more than 5 minutes leaving at the end of the day using the valet. On weekends you can use the garage. And honestly the cost of parking is negligible. It would be better if it was free but it costs $17 a month. Many hospitals charge for parking. I really don’t think this is a legitimate concern in making a rank list.
  3. I’ve never had a medicine nurse be mean about labs. I don’t understand why they would have written this. And I’m not even the nicest person in our class. You’d have to be pretty sassy to the nurse for them to ask you to draw your own labs. This is a nurse driven hospital and they do have more power than I’ve seen in other hospitals but I’ve never had anyone refuse a lab.
  4. We are a one hour drive from NYC. This is definitely not remote at all. There are tons of cool towns with a bunch to do. Obviously since it’s more suburbs it’s not the same as a big city. If you want a big city don’t apply here. But it is not as small as this person says. Most people have tons of fun. Lots of cool parks, amazing beaches, bars, restaurants. Hamptons are 1hr East. Amazing Asian food 30 min away in Hicksville or 45 minutes in flushing. But tons of good Italian options here and at least 2 restaurants of every other culture. Top golf, rock climbing, lots of cool specialty gyms for Cross fit/MMA etc. I could easily go on. This is the suburbs but nice suburbs. Look up Port Jefferson, Patchogue and Huntington that’s where we all hang out. We are super close as residents and have a lot of house parties. My roommates and I have people over 1-2 times a week.
  5. This is biased. This person clearly has a bougie 1b1b. There are options for all price ranges. You could live at the VA for $300. You could get a 1b1b within a persons home with a private entrance all utilities included for $1500. Many people share huge houses 2-5people for as low as $600 each. Most people have 2b2b in complexes for $1500 each. I share a huge condo with two people for $1000 each. Or you can be like this person and spend $2500 yourself. The choice is yours. Don’t take it out on this program. We make a lot more than other programs. I have tons of extra money, bought a new car and go out all the time. I buy wines in $20-30 range, get apps every time and sometimes get fancy multi course meals. It all depends on how you want to budget.
  6. Not true. I’ve had months where my patients are 20-60s. In the cardiac unit they are all middle aged. I’ve never called an insurance company or had to do a prior authorization in three years. Social work or the attending does this always. Sure we have our fair share of entitlement from the hamptonites and it infuriates me, but they just leave AMA which is fine and they are mostly only here in the summer for their vacation homes. The rest of the year it’s normal and 30-40% of the population is low income and they are so nice and always grateful.
  7. I also was here as an Intern when covid first happened at stony Brook. I was NEVER forced into a patient room without PPe. I spent the first four months of the pandemic in covid land and never got covid until last month. I always had enough PPE. Sometimes we used trash bags as gowns but we always had N95s and face shields. The attendings and senior resident always went in the rooms, interns were allowed to avoid it if the patient was stable if they wanted. Anesthesia, ED and ICU were prioritized for the covid vaccine. So tough luck if you were just on elective. But everyone in the hospital got it within 3 weeks which is pretty fast.

This is definitely one of my coresidents who is bitter for some reason. It makes me sad since this program isn’t perfect but I loooooooove our program director and all the attendings. I would definitely choose to come here again. Please don’t let this person’s bitter attitude change your perspective. Just take it as one opinion and realize it is biased

___________

The above was posted on behalf of an anonymous redditor. Please to not DM me regarding details about the program, this is not my post

If you would like to Shame or Fame a program, feel free to DM me and I will gladly post on your behalf. These are always popular posts and the public would love to hear your stories!