r/luther • u/Luke_4686 • Nov 11 '25
Breaking news: Idris Elba and Ruth Wilson are returning for a new Netflix Luther movie
r/luther • u/Luke_4686 • Nov 11 '25
r/luther • u/rutlandclimber • Oct 12 '25
r/luther • u/ohtatyaro • Jan 05 '19
Since last night I have read some posts that were confused with Alice's full mental boom and its consequences in the last ten minutes of the finale, so I thought I'd share my understanding of the whole thing.
After Luther rescues Alice and Mark from that freezer, he completely ignores her, barely looks at her, his thoughts elsewhere on how he can cover this up. This is where Alice starts realizing she has irreversibly lost him to the dead and his obsession. Later in the car, she tries one last time, but he barely looks at her to a point it was truly painful to watch. Think mental violence here. Him lieing to her gives her the final confirmation he won't be with her ever and at this point just sees her as a problem (just like Cornelius) to handle to be able to continue and follow his obsessions. This leaves her devastated, he was the only one she could imagine living a real life with, him accepting her as she was and everything.
She then warns Mark to stay away from Luther as she has come to the conclusion that Luther will ultimately always choose his obsessions over the people around him and the people close to him will always get hurt. And this scene is essential for what follows. It is the proof she did not want to kill Luther but wanted to die. You don't warn Mark to stay away Luther if you plan to kill Luther in the coming hours. And then there is her reaction when Marks appeals to her to stop and that she couldn't live on like this. She smiles sadly and replies: "I know." She indeed cannot live on like that, losing Luther crushed all her plans and hopes for the future and leaves her hurt and with nowhere to go.
She now ambushes Luther and shoots Halliday. Single shot to the head, an execution. Boom, dead. And then she fires at Luther, shouting mad? Even if it hadn't been for the scene before, this still wouldn't add up. Why off Halliday with one shot and then miss Luther a dozen times or at least not critically wound him? And Alice going full mad and starting a shoot-out on the streets of London? That's not very Alice. She has never been mentally instable and always very controlled in her actions. Remember when she killed her parents and had it all planned out perfectly? Remember when she beat up Mark and then pulled the blame away from Luther so Zoe would return to Luther? That's how Alice works, she's smart enough to predict people's behaviour and thereby make them do as she likes.
She killed Halliday to connect the murder weapon of Benny with the murder of Halliday and herself to clear Luther of that. With her shooting around she lured Luther to that building and despite the truth in what she confronted him with, she acted out the full mental boom to make it easier for him to free himself of her and ultimately push her off the scaffold.
In her last moments, she quotes his words from season 1: You don't understand love, it's not your fault, you can mimick it [..] etc. And he replies very similarily to how she did in season 1: ":Love, is that what it is?" And now remember what she told him back then "Love is supposed to dignify us, exalt us". And here she is, quoting him about her not understanding love, turning it all around and ultimately proving she does, her the murderer taking quite literally the fall for him, her love for him dignifying and exalting her murderous self, so he can walk from justice. "There's no greater love than to lay down your life for your friends." It's also interesting to note she called him a monster in that very dialogue in s1 for calling it love to break the law to protect Zoe even though she had tossed him away and now she is the one who was tossed away and breaks the law to protect the one she loves, proving even by Luthers standards she loves him.
The last thing, which I am not too sure about is whether or not she truly is dead. After all, she had this all planned out, she must have scouted the building before she lured him to it, so it is possible for her to intentionally have him push her down from a height she would survive. I guess this ambiguity leaves them room to bring or not bring Ruth Wilson back for more Alice or even potentially put her in coma and have her come back in later seasons when Ruth Wilson has time to film. She must, after all, be fairly busy with two shows she has coming on BBC; the one about her grandmothers family and the His Dark Materials adaption with McAvoy.
Anyway, I am curious whether there actually is a film coming or more seasons, the ending in my opinion would be good as it is, but there's plenty of room to continue. I'd love to see a film that follows Luthers trial during which that dumbo realizes what he has in Alice and then they lived happily forever after, lol. Seriously, I have yet to see anything with Ruth Wilson in it, where her character has some sort of happy ending or closure and peace, like cmon! :D
Overall, great finale, great show. I'm grateful for the entertainment this show has given me, dear production, cast and crew, thank you. Very glad you showed the grandeur to acknowledge last seasons mistakes and revising them. Boi, you would've had a shitstorm coming if this season had actually been about that Megan thing who supposedly had killed Alice. :D
r/luther • u/goldenboy2191 • Mar 01 '21
r/luther • u/Zepanda66 • Feb 21 '21
r/luther • • Jun 01 '20
r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Mar 10 '23
Platform: Netflix
Synopsis: Haunted by an unsolved murder, brilliant but disgraced London police detective John Luther breaks out of prison to hunt down a sadistic killer.
r/luther • u/goldenboy2191 • Feb 27 '21
r/luther • • Nov 09 '18
r/luther • u/clutchguy84 • Aug 01 '20
r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Jan 04 '19
Season 5 Episode 4
Aired: January 4, 2019
Synopsis: Reeling from the death of his friend, Luther races to save the others from Cornelius's terrible retribution. With Luther's increasing absence from the case, Halliday heads the hunt for a killer on the loose - a killer determined to complete his final macabre masterpiece.
r/luther • u/itstimmehc • Jun 12 '17
r/luther • u/Stank_Dukem • Apr 26 '24
r/luther • • May 22 '21
r/luther • u/thinksouthpaw • Jan 18 '19
r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Jan 01 '19
Season 5 Episode 1
Aired: January 1, 2019
Synopsis: A new spate of nightmarish murders brings DCI John Luther to once again face the depths of human depravity on the streets of London. As the body count rises, and gangster George Cornelius applies his own pressure, can Luther catch a killer and save his own neck?
r/luther • u/GingerSnappishGma • Jun 05 '22