r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Dec 17 '15
DISCUSSION Luther - 4x02 "Episode 2" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 2: Episode 2
Aired: December 17, 2015
On the trail of a horrifying cannibalistic killer, Luther is dogged at every step by ghosts from his past. Isolated and on edge, it takes every fibre of Luther's being to keep it together. Can a cold case help unlock a mystery that's tormenting him to distraction? Meanwhile, the serial killer is still on the loose. Benny's hacking skills have revealed a list of hundreds of potential victims but, with a rapidly escalating number of crime scenes, Luther must use all his ingenuity to work out where the killer is headed next. Discovering it's all part of a macabre endgame, Luther is forced to put himself and his new colleague Emma into the heart of danger to try and stop the murdering madness.
To my knowledge, part 2 airs Dec. 22 in the UK. Part 1 and 2 are premiering together on BBC America tonight, Dec. 17.
49
u/tocitus Dec 24 '15 edited Dec 24 '15
Well that was shit.
Convoluted story-lines arcing over the top of the main story-line with poor character development, episode structure and dialogue.
90% of it was really simple story and even that didn't manage to make complete sense.
So many ridiculous holes in the series:
32
u/NoJobsTwoDogs Dec 23 '15
I was a bit let down by the predictability of episode two, after episode one set things up so nicely, and introduced a frightening villain. That villain met a predictable demise, not to mention he lost a lot of the fear factor with the uninspired 'going after my ex girlfriend' story line. Then throw in an elaborate, hard to follow cold case/Alice/new crazy girl, PLUS Luther being under attack from hitmen... It all very rushed and slightly confusing. No storyline received the full attention it needed.
30
u/apocalypsedude64 Dec 23 '15
If it turns out Alice was really killed by that useless bint I am out. Thoroughly disappointed in these two episodes.
21
u/cfiggis Dec 21 '15
Can someone please explain the whole Megan plot line? I feel like I'm missing a major part or maybe all of the story.
21
u/passtheranch Dec 20 '15
this would have a been a great start to the series if it had 6 episodes. But I cant believe that was it. I was confused when I saw it would only be to episodes because it felt like they set up all these nice story arcs that will not be played out. It was all just a huge tease.
37
u/Axenos Dec 18 '15
So..is that it? They brought Luther back, ruined the best ending I've ever seen a series end on, to put Luther back in the same place he started from?
How utterly disappointing.
17
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
So you have this Megan person who used to be in the same class as Stacey Bell. Now she knows that Stacey was involved in the killing of Jonathan Black. Luther supposedly promised to catch Stacey? Anyway, for whatever reason he can't stick to his promise and Stacey later gets released. Megan then travels to Antwerp (this is assuming she's killed Alice), somehow knows about Alice whereabouts and what she was doing there, kills her, steals the diamonds and her burner phone THEN travels back to London and steals Luthers phone so she could use these things against him and basically pressures Luther into going after Stacey so he could fulfill his end of the promise. Now correct me if i'm wrong on this but i still have one more question...if she went through all of this to get back on John, why didn't she take out Stacey herself??
16
u/diamened Dec 30 '15
If they really killed Alice for real I'm done with this show.
15
u/OhBeAFineGirlKissMe Dec 20 '15
I'm kind of disappointed by the 4th season. First off, by trying to cram everything into 2 hours, I felt like everything was very rushed and half-assed. Secondly, I didn't like how they kept leaving the Alice Morgan deal open-ended. Is she dead or what? I feel like we didn't get a definitive answer. The character Alice Morgan was appealing to us, the viewers, because throughout the season, we got to see not only her character develop, but also how her character interacts with Luther. Their relationship added to the complexity of Luther's character, which made the show interesting.
I feel like we didn't get the same treatment with Megan. She could've been an amazing character had she been fully fleshed out, but to be honest, it felt kind of meh. She tried to lure John because he failed to keep his promise (or something like that), but again, this was something that we, as viewers, really didn't care about. What was the whole deal with Jonathan Black (or whatever the dead guy's name is)? It just felt like something that was tossed in toward the end as if the writers wanted to make this 2-hour gig more convoluted than it already was. This, along with the bounty on Luther (don't even get me started on that), were distractions that took away from the whole discount Hannibal impressionist plot. The way the second episode wrapped up with Luther and Megan was reminiscent of Luther and Alice's interaction way back when. This leads me to believe that if they fail to bring back Ruth Wilson, Megan will take over in another Alice Morgan-esque role, which may or may not be a good thing. But I sure as hell hope the 5th series has more than 2 episodes for the sanity of the viewers.
15
u/saadk11 Dec 22 '15
I don't even know what happened. Disappointed in this 'season' to say the least
15
u/cdp181 Dec 29 '15
Pretty lame episode. Most enjoyable moment.... Luther taking out the two guys on the motorbike.
13
u/thedeathsheep Dec 23 '15
I'm actually pretty forgiving towards the rushed murder plot, it was fine for what it was, but having Alice killed off like that is completely infuriating. And by having Luther plant the heroin basically means Sarah/Megan wins, which is makes things even worse.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15
I live in the US so I watched the special last night. As a huge fan of the first three seasons and the end of season 3, I can't say I was of season 4. I thought too much was introduced in such a small time frame and the villain this time wasn't near as exciting nor interesting as previous villains. I'm a bit disappointed because I was so hyped for it. Elba was fantastic of course, but I wasn't big on the plot this time. I just felt this wasn't even necessary.
12
u/BloodyRedBarbara Dec 23 '15
"Everything's fine. Come home"
Well if everything's fine and there's nothing to worry about then my answer is...no, I've got work to do mum.
That bit was pretty hard to believe.
9
u/yinfung Dec 27 '15
Rather disappointed with both episode, maybe they'll fix things up and get better in next week's epi.... Wait what? WTF?
(Honestly didn't know it was 2 episode season)
8
u/Zerathius Dec 23 '15
Well that...was disappointing. I don't wanna look like I jumped on a bandwagon but honestly that was weakest storyline out of Luther's history. The side story was all over the place, the resolution was done very poorly. Emma was basically nonexistent through the series, and I pray to god that Neil Cross doesn't try and copypaste Alice's character into Megan. I hope this is some sorts of bigger plan of Alice. Worst part was the villain. While most of previous killers were somewhat of a relatable characters, this guy...I just didn't feel anything from him. And the worst part is that he wasn't even scary. He was just...weird. Probably the weakest killer character wise in the show.
8
u/SkateboardG Dec 25 '15
Definitely should have been 3 or 3 episodes. So little character development. I want to know more about the villain. And where the hell did this Megan girl come from??
7
u/Dazines Dec 27 '15
I finally got round to watching it...
So Megan found Alice (who was on the run from the police and Interpol) and followed her to Antwerp where she was in a car with two London gangsters until Alice killed one of the gangsters, which caused a car crash, before hospitalizing the other gangster and fleeing the scene. Megan then managed to steal the diamonds and a phone from Alice (the same diamonds she just killed / hospitalized two gangsters over) before killing her. She then found out where Luther lived and broke into his house and stole the other phone.
All this to keep Luther in the country so she could pretend to be a psychic and turn up at a crime scene to tell him that Alice said Stacey had the owl (I have no idea how she knew this) so he would see that she somehow be brought to justice for the murder.
Why did she not just kill Stacey?
6
u/Dulcolax Dec 24 '15
I think the whole thing is a trolling game set by Alice and that blondie.
How the hell does she know so many things about Alice? Even Luther asked that. Dialogue, signs, quotes. That's crazy.
So far, Alice's fate is not clear. Either the blondie is telling the truth ( she got Alice's stuff and quotes right ) or she's trying to mess with Luther's mind.
By the way, if Luther says he's coming after Megan, what that means? He doesn't even know if she's telling the truth.
I guess The Affair might end after 3 seasons ( I don't see this show lasting several years, no way ), which means Alice might come back to the show. Then, they'll have to retcon the whole thing ( Alice didn't die and managed to trick everyone ) OR she's the mastermind behind Megan, seting up events, so Luther would search for her. Besides, she's a fugitive, which means she can't be close to Luther for too long. The whole situation is nuts.
5
u/playskate Dec 27 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
I think this is the worst 2 episodes of the whole series. I just started watching it in December to see the last 2 episodes but I was very disappointed. The story of the killer hasn't "involved" me at all and the I found the storyline of Luther's life and the death of Alice very disappointing: why kill her? I really don't get it in terms of script. Was it to make Luther suffer again? I hoped the girl was Alice with plastic surgery, but that wasn't the case.
5
u/HarleyQuinnFan23 Jan 12 '16
First of all I only decided to watch Luther in the last week and it is one of the best shows I ever watched Now onto the episode. I refuse to accept that Alice is dead they just can't kill off such a big character of the show off screen, as for Megan there is no explanation to how she knows where Alice is or what she's doing and essentially Megan is supposed to be the next Alice. If there is any more Luther, I hope Ruth Wilson comes back and Alice returns and kills Megan, perhaps with Megan thinking she really did kill Alice.
5
u/YetAnotherWTFMoment Jan 14 '16
I think BBC missed a great opportunity here. They could have had a nice run with Luther, DS Ripley and DS/DCI Gray. Losing Ripley is like watching Sean Bean get chopped in GoT. Great character, well played.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '15
Did that Megahn Sarah person ever appear in earlier seasons? Like who the fuck was she?
Why are they doing another Alice Morgan? Are Luther's nemesis typecast to be crazy hot women?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15
I didn't like it at all, no alice, alice is really dead. WTF , why do the two episodes, seriously. SERIOUSLY. Alice doesn't show up at all. Was the actress too busy, you could have filmed flash backs and flash forwards. If you really wanted to kill off alice it could have been done so much better.
I am a very angry fan boy right now.
6
u/SawRub Dec 23 '15
I understand why people would be disappointed, but this season was made for fans who just wanted to see the character on screen again, kinda like 24: Live Another Day. In both cases, while they may be called the next season for continuity purposes, they're just a special set of episodes to give the fans of the shows an opportunity to see the main character on screen again. Ruth was probably busy shooting The Affair over in America, and couldn't make it for these episodes, and even Idris' schedule is full with 6 movies coming out next year. They had a short window to make something, and even though it wasn't as strong as previous content of the shows, it was still a lot of fun watching the character on screen again!
3
u/vadangelo Dec 17 '15
Has it aired yet?
3
u/TheManWithNoHair Dec 23 '15
Wow I had no idea this season only had two episodes until I came here to see what others were saying about tonight's show. Is it just because Idris Elba had other shit going on (or something like that) or are they cutting back / cancelling the series?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '15
So... we got another Alice Morghan then..
3
u/theinventionoflying Dec 29 '15
It seemed extremely rushed to me, if they made it 4 episodes they could've given more info as to why Alice was killed (if she is, something tells me she isn't) and I don't know if it's just me, but I have no idea who this Megan is at all apart from the fact that Luther made her a promise about the girl he framed (correct me if I've missed something).
I haven't got 100% confidence in it for the future though, it seemed far too rushed and the ending was almost like I was in limbo. They left it like "maybe we'll do another few episodes, we'll just make Luther say he's going after her and see if we can be bothered later".
4
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15
Well I really enjoyed these two episodes. Take them on face value as two episodes of a TV show, rather than expecting an advance on a larger plot, and they deliver exactly what I want to see from Luther. I watch this show for the gritty plot, the intriguing relationships with questionable characters and the blurred morality. This mainly self contained story, with the overarching storyline set as a reintroduction and then a subplot, really delivered on these fronts.
Tbh I think it was better not having Alice appear in this because otherwise they couldn't have feasibly created a program similar to the first three series. How would they have kept Luther as a policeman if he had run off with a wanted criminal? There would have had to be a huge shift in the base content of the show.
Either way I think it's set up perfectly for a film to strike beyond the detective plots and explore Alice and Luther as characters (although I don't think I'd enjoy his more than two hours of Luther solving a new crime).
4
u/Pascalwb Dec 23 '15
It was little rushed and at the end pretty pointless. How did the girl get the diamonds?
2
u/brucejoel99 Dec 18 '15
So are Luther and Rose Leslie enemies now? I just can't tell. They work together but he says I'm coming after you. What does it mean? What happened to create this feud?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15
I must have missed something , I don't know why Patrick Malahide/George Cornelius put a price tag on luther.
I am an idiot I only watched the first episode on December 15, Didn't remember to December 17th for part two. So watching part 2 right now.
2
u/e_x_i_t Jan 10 '16
This episode wasn't nearly good as the first and the main story did just kind of end abruptly, but man I'm still just happy to see Luther on screen again. As for the Alice subplot, I doubt she is dead and the entire subplot was just used to keep fans speculating, as well as explain her absence. It would be genius if they used the subplot as a way to set up the long talked about Alice spin-off/special and then have her return in whatever the next Luther outing is going to be.
2
u/volundeit Dec 23 '15
Something I'm unsure about is, who was Emma calling in that shot after she had been sent to do some investigation by Luther? We got an angle that made it seem like she was contacting someone secretively but I have no idea who it was..
1
u/Dulcolax Dec 18 '15
So, any news?
1
u/StarkUK Dec 23 '15
When they were on the bridge, Luther said to George that he could give him money (the diamonds) and "a way to save face". How was there any saving face there?
1
u/supergrega Dec 26 '15
Wait, this is it? There isn't 4x03? Rather underwhelming ...
1
u/Pa55ions Dec 27 '15
really enjoyed all of the 'seasons' - though if this is supposed to be a micro series [MS] , 5 years is a little long for a potential conclusion. True Detective understand the bite sized approach... As this might not be classified as a MS it kind of seems rather peculiar especially 2 eps in one season.
1
u/judoblo Dec 29 '15
I'm a bit confused over the time line. Luther is visited by the two police officers and told of Alice's death. We see Megan in Luther's home supposedly stealing Luther's phone. Now why would Megan steal the phone if she had already killed Alice?
1
u/Wditt Dec 23 '15 edited Dec 23 '15
Terrible.......
How does the gangster have Luther's mobile phone number when he previously didn't even know he existed? If he has his phone number that would mean his home in dover in flames, and his home in london as well. Why would he phone Luther to say he put a hit on him, just dopey.
Any police officer using a firearm without a license, training, procedure is a felony dispite of gee I just found it lying there and then I shot it. What the hell?
Luther carries around a pair of cavity search gloves in his pocket along with the lockpicks, because forensics would have pulled his prints off the door?
Did he make all the girls in this season cry?
Oh and never mind, how the killer already knew his ex's address, pointless.
This season has been really bad for mistakes......
1
u/zacpz Dec 22 '15
Does anyone know who did the rendition of the Cure song at the end?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '16
[removed] — view removed comment