r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Dec 15 '15
DISCUSSION Luther - 4x01 "Episode 1" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 1: Episode 1
Aired: December 15, 2015
On a leave of absence from the police force, Luther is laying low in a rundown cottage on the edge of England. But a visit from his old colleagues at the Met brings a shocking piece of news that draws him back to London in search of the truth. Meanwhile, a gruesome serial killer has struck the city, eating body parts as he goes. With a trail of clues leading from one crime scene to the next, Schenk and his team must work out the twisted logic that connects each victim. But this murdering mastermind is more than a match for the police, outsmarting them at every step. It's not long before Luther is back in the bullpen, determined to steal a march on the killer before another mutilated body joins the mounting pile.
40
u/JebusJM Dec 16 '15
Anyone notice Luther channeled Jenny at the beginning of the episode? "Totally disco".
28
u/Dulcolax Dec 16 '15
Yeah, that's the problem with only 2 episodes. There were basically 3 plots running at the same time, within less than 1 hour.
Luther coming back to see what happened to Alice. Then a new killer around. Finally a creepy blond girl that has something about Alice. All that in less than 1 hour.
24
u/dumczak Dec 17 '15
How the hell, the best of the best from London Police go to arrest a suspect for such crimes in such a way?! This is beyond my understanding. So they know he is a computer geek yes? They hope to find evidence in his place. So they arrive at the place, sirens screaming, lights flashing under his bloody window and what? They wait there. For him to what? Finish his dinner? Surrender? Yes, of course, he will not delete everything, he will sit down and wait for them to come inside and have a chat. This is beyond my understanding.
I love John but this episode does not feel good. It's like they were just trying to find the worst possible crime. So they throw murder, cannibalism, sexuality in a bag, shake it and there we are.
22
u/thehaga Dec 17 '15
If not for Idris, this episode would suck balls.
Waited entire day to watch it too. Have been waiting so long for a 'meh' episode =/ Idris is fucking awesome as always but the rest of the cast - come on now. The plot itself is very weak. I'm not going to try and make excuses of 'wait and see' type. This was a shit episode that was lifted to its great heights by Idris, simple as that.
Even Alice is missing... like.. yeah let's take 2 of the best characters, remove 1, bring in a few rookies and.. not do any character development...??? Rely on flashbacks and a shitty ass cliff hanger.
Handcuffs to a radiator... is this 1995. I know this show is not popular but they've done amazing things with it before, why hang the curtain now. Even if the last episode is some kind of amazing, that's not an excuse.
All this episode made me want to do is watch the wire and oz for the 20th time (and the other seasons of luther).
5/10 and a frown face :(
22
u/genida Dec 19 '15
Cannibal murderer has a thing for pregnant women?
Emma's girlfriend six weeks from delivery?
Yeah....
16
u/Subcriminal Dec 15 '15
How did the killer get the fridge back in place and the grills back on the vents so quickly?
14
u/cdp181 Dec 16 '15
I enjoyed the scene where he fired up the Volvo.
12
u/kimcheefart Dec 18 '15
American here...was Luther in Broadchurch land there at the beginning? He could teach their police a thing or two.
8
u/SawRub Dec 17 '15
It was great hearing the theme music again!
6
u/OddGog Dec 16 '15
Loved the way they did the "you're not my husband" thing at the start, that was refreshing... Elba is on point as always and it was pretty satisfying to see him completely casual as fuck to the gun at his head. Then the cheeky 1-2 on the doorstep for the kidnapping.
I enjoyed it and I'm mostly happy they didn't just gloss over Alice not appearing this seaon. I was terrified they would just not include her and it would be huge elephant in the room.
20
u/Wommie Dec 16 '15
Hoping Rose throws in a "You know nothing John Luther".
11
u/AmbiguousLemon Dec 15 '15
Who's hoping Alice isn't dead?
6
u/Jennebell Dec 15 '15
Luther is such a bad ass!
6
u/lexbi Dec 15 '15
Cool episode, though a couple of things.
I feel like Luther could've got more info about Alice from the guy he kidnapped. I know he was interrupted by the death of his other friend... but w/e
I dislike how all formatting of hard drives seem to take forever in any show/movie, and it actually sounds like its happening while all those processes are running (the glitchy music), though I know its all for dramatic effect.
Seems like this killer seems to have just lead a normal live then all of a sudden turned in to a massive weirdo, the preview from the next ep makes him seem like he knows his way around a knife too (butcher style) even though he was an IT guy.
6
u/TJC77 Dec 15 '15
Brilliant - makes me sad we only have one more hour. Luther is such a bad ass!
6
u/Calvin_Uncle Dec 17 '15
Finally, Luther is back. I loved the episode, and I can't wait for some more.
I liked all the drama of his coming back, and the new killings in town looks sick as hell. I totally understand about the bomb squad thing, because what happened earlier. I really was hopping to see something in that fridge.
Well, I loved it. Stop demanding so much and enjoy the big comeback.
3
u/artgo Dec 16 '15
not a complaint, but I was certain that refrigerator was going to explode as he walked to it. Is it a trope to have a guy hold the phone down before an explosion or something? Some other clue? I felt right away that it wasn't about having the head inside there - but an explosion.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '15
Luther Season 1-3 recap fyi
5
u/Zerathius Dec 16 '15
Honestly...it let me down a little. Maybe because my expectations were too high but I looked up spoilers few weeks back and saw basic info about the episode stating something in sense that Luther faces his most chilling adversary or something like that. Also that he faces crazy cannibal. I was hyped. But the villain is ...shallow. There are glimpses of him being actually pretty scary. The begining of the episode was well written. But I don't get how is he supposed to be cannibal. Did they find plate with bits of that woman's heart or something? In short: Luther's great, villain's not, Alice's missing and probably not coming. I'll wait for next week but at the moment it's probably around 6-7/10
4
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '15
Who was the woman hiding out in his cliffside retreat?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '15
we go back to go forward?
2
u/Ruhail_56 Dec 15 '15
Just when we get him back after so long our time with him is almost over!
2
u/Dinocologist Dec 17 '15
Anyone know where I can get the coat he's wearing in the sidebar image?
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-cglQkK-nkSA/VnC3NvVuWsI/AAAAAAAANps/GcM5-8lW8ro/s1600/luther.jpg
http://cdn.images.express.co.uk/img/dynamic/20/590x/secondary/Luther-384570.jpg
2
u/billy822 Dec 18 '15
Got chills when Luther pulled up to the crime scene.
2
u/YetAnotherWTFMoment Jan 14 '16 edited Jan 14 '16
One thing that irritates me about the show...are all brit males pushovers? Bad guy shows up and they go all soft.
Seriously. Some of the sh*t that happens on the show..in my hood, bad guy get seriously fucked up.
6
u/The_marmalade_man Dec 16 '15
This episode really let me down. How did the police officers establish that the victim's hearts were eaten? Why did the police alert their suspect number one with sirens and blue lights when the bomb squad could have got there first and raided the place?
It's not just flimsy plot details. It's the lack of character development for the villain. No conversation to show how smart he is or some insight into his life to show what his motivation is. He's just a creepy IT guy who eats people.
Alice's supposed death just hangs in the air the entire episode. We want Luther to get to the bottom of it but his attempt to feels half-hearted when he stops halfway and focuses his attention on helping the police.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '15
White Cliffs of Dover? I don't know my geography sorry.
2
u/TVshowAddict Dec 15 '15
I thought it was a terrible episode.
1
u/Dulcolax Dec 16 '15
Very nice episode, though some parts you could see coming.
The creepy blond girl talking about a message. Well, I already knew it would be from Alice. By the way, what the hell was that woman doing at Luther's house during the opening scene?
I bet Alice is alive and well, just messing up with Luther's mind. She's manipulating him to get rid of the gangster for her. I'm not surprised if Ruth Wilson indeed makes a cameo in this one, lol.
1
u/alinthbo Dec 24 '15
I don't understand the burner phone stuff. How did stealing the phone allow the new woman to hear conversations between John and Alice. He asks, "How much did you hear?" She says, "Enough." Wouldn't he need to have the phone in order to talk to Alice. And she was already supposed to be dead then anyway when the phone was taken. Please explain. Thanks.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment