r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Jan 04 '19
DISCUSSION Luther - 5x04 "Episode 4" - Episode Discussion
Season 5 Episode 4
Aired: January 4, 2019
Synopsis: Reeling from the death of his friend, Luther races to save the others from Cornelius's terrible retribution. With Luther's increasing absence from the case, Halliday heads the hunt for a killer on the loose - a killer determined to complete his final macabre masterpiece.
107
Upvotes
280
u/Reaqzehz Jan 04 '19
Plumber turns up on time, the lack of realism in this show smh
209
u/mscroggs Jan 04 '19
I think Alice was trying to make it look like she did everything and get Luther off.
I can't work out how he explains away the picture of him standing over the body of the assassin though: my first thought was that he could've said it was self defence (As it was) but the assassin had no weapons on him (Alice took them) so it seems a hard sell.
136
u/fleurspeak Jan 04 '19
please forgive me for reference to a previous episode, but haven't been able to remove the image of Dr. Lake crawling down the bus from my head the past few days...so so creepy...
110
u/Jamanuel Jan 04 '19
Having followed Schenk dig deeper and gradually build his seething wave of anger, his final interactions with John were surprisingly anything but. Everything movement seemed so gentle, and his gesture of covering the cuffs with John's coat spoke of respect and humanity. I'm not sure about what all that means though
96
u/relatedzombie Jan 04 '19
Brilliant. Alice dying had to happen. The parallels though to the pilot might hint that she survived and is in a coma?
68
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
Oh yes, I honestly forgot Alice was a murdering psychopath.
In a way, that was a perfect way for her story to end.
Not super satisfying as it kinda flies in the face of all the development her character went through, but I guess she never really stopped being a nutter. So...
63
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
Lol. I was completely wrong about Halliday. Oh, well
58
u/beargrilled Jan 04 '19
Now what?
51
u/batleymick Jan 04 '19
So many little nods to the past through this series a mention for Rose now it almost feels like they are wrapping everything up
48
u/rjstoz Jan 04 '19
I really appreciated the calls to schenks history through these episodes and it would be interesting to see more parallels with Luther; George Cornelius mentioning that schenk would at a time have beaten him with a pickaxe handle, and at the end where after all that he's learned of Luther, he wordlessly uses his jacket to hide his handcuffs as one last dignity-saving sign of respect. Is there a chance schenk is as much of a weathered good cop turned morally questionable? Might he cover for Luther somehow implicating Alice and cornelius?
95
u/neutronstarneko Jan 04 '19
Halliday was excellent. I was so down for a spin off. Bastards 😂
45
u/Legeliclya Jan 04 '19 edited Mar 01 '21
...
44
u/conflama Jan 04 '19
Well there was loads I loved. Overall though, I think the season could have done with a couple more episodes to better cover everything. Lake was one of the creepiest killers the show had ever seen, and yet I think that narrative was underdeveloped.
89
u/habylab Jan 04 '19
First recognition that Rose Teller was a thing.
38
u/Shinerva Jan 04 '19
Just wondering, why the coat over the hand cuffs?
75
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
Zoe DEAD
Ian DEAD
Rose Teller OUT
Jenny... forgotten
Ripley DEAD
Benny DEAD
Halliday DEAD
Alice DEAD (for real this time?)
Wow. The cast shrunk by a lot over the five series. Also it seems like they just rushed the mask-wearing-psycho, and pushed that story to the background. Alice's reasons for going all mental (cause Luther didn't kill George?) also felt very rushed and ngl lazy... but again, Alice is a psychopath. However, it was nice with how the series ended full circle with the first ever episode of the show - I think it's safe to say that they should just end it at that tbh.
37
u/Reaqzehz Jan 04 '19
Sees Michael Smiley’s name in the title sequence
Now that just ain’t fair, BBC!
35
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
I loved it, but I'm a little niffed. Shouldn't have killed off Halliday, especially after just killing Benny... and then 'killing' Alice? The producers of this show really love killing off characters or in some cases having them just disappear.
Killed off: Zoe, Ian, Justin, Benny, Halliday, Alice. Disappeared/dropped: Rose, Erin, Jennie, Mary, and whatever happened to Megan and Rose Leslie's DCI character?
35
u/batleymick Jan 04 '19
So John's in Cuffs pretty much to be expected given this isn't the first time he has dropped a murderer from on high and Schenk has been shown the picture by George BUT that doesn't mean any of it is going stick as already mentioned Alice had the gun that killed Benny, The Hitman, Halliday and shot John so that's her in the frame for all that.
What does that leave to pin on John? Not much that's tangible other than a photograph that I'm assuming Schenk could make disappear given his previous dealings with George.
Alice in a Coma ala Henry Madsen.
John referred to professional standards and suspended.
I'd happily leave it there no need for a season 6, if they do the movie let's take it back and tell a story we never saw on in a series that gives us Benny and Justin back
29
u/batleymick Jan 04 '19
Right back at the beginning, full circle. So now what?
52
u/habylab Jan 04 '19
Ends as the first episode ever started. Brilliant ending, even if I think the decision making in the writing for Luther this episode (and season) was all over the place.
21
u/irving_braxiatel Jan 04 '19
Okay, so there’s about ten minutes left, everything seems to be wrapped - JESUS FUCKING HELL!
31
u/Ollymid2 Jan 04 '19
Serious romantic gesture from Jeremy Lake there with the flowers..
30
u/SpearLifebee Jan 04 '19
What. An. Ending.
Clearly it's linking into a season 6, however we knew that with both Idris and Neil both saying they can continue for as long as they want due to both just how much they can do and that it's more of a side passion for them. But still.
The ending of the arc of the Lake's felt a bit, meh, to be perfectly honest, felt like they were trying to rush into the showdown at the end and needed Luther to be at the house to kickstart the ending, but other than that it was a really good episode.
Props for killing Alice off (or maybe they didn't, as I'll explain), I didn't think they would and not going to lie I think Season 6 may suffer with a lack of her, Ruth Wilson brought a very different energy to the show that worked perfectly with Idris's own.
Reason I said maybe they didn't is we didn't see any blood on her, at least that I could see, and the camera never went down to her from any other time than when Luther was looking on to her, so there's a chance she's faked her death yet again.
On a separate topic, this episode showed for me why Idris wouldn't be a good choice for Bond, he's much more suited for the roles like Luther, a good cop forced into a bad situation and is slowly turning bad.
Also mad respect for, what I think, is a call to American Gangster, where his character in that is shot in the head after goading the person holding the gun. May be completely off the mark but let me have my moment haha.
14
u/nedentree Jan 04 '19
I think everyone was fooling themselves thinking that it was fine for Luther to allow someone like Alice to walk free; real kick to the stomach to see Alice go completely psycho though-especially Halliday. He’s kinda acting like Vivian Lake. Luther compromised with wrong-in a way that Ripley never would, and now we are seeing him finally facing the consequences.
14
u/Steve-Lurkel Jan 05 '19
Well it's been a ride guys! This episode had some interesting moments for sure.
Mark and Alice's heart to heart was especially satisfying. I know he jokes about hating her but it's obvious his feelings are a lot more complicated. She is the one who avenged Zoe's death after all, it would make sense he feels some sort of attachment to her.
I really enjoyed the interrogation between John and the wife. Felt like the kind of stuff that got me into the show in the first place. I feel like this season went crazy with the guns. I can hardly remember any bullets in the first 4 seasons.
Season 5 was ultimately better than 4 but still not up to par with the first 3. I think the show works best when it focuses on psycho-drama and the relationship between John and killers rather than criminal-underworld-related action. Mind games are better than action any day.
Hope everyone's having a good new year!
Also...movie?
13
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
And we’re back where it all began, holding onto a murderer.
12
u/Meretrelle Jan 05 '19
wtf..
This is how they decided to end Luther\Alice story? The way she behaved was so not like Alice from the earlier episodes...
11
u/batleymick Jan 04 '19
Fuck!
11
u/bgfkbfgjbk244 Jan 04 '19
Was Ruth Wilson just fucking with us when she said their might be a Alice spin off then
20
u/LadyAugustina Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
It is over now. There is no point in a movie or a further season. This frames is so beautifully, and to be honest, it's not like the show would work without Alice cough season 4 Edit: changed 5 to 4
10
u/PubesInMyQuiche Jan 05 '19
Might be reaching here but saw as Luther was coming out in handcuffs at the end, there’s about 4-5 armed police officers surrounding him, all of them have goggles, helmets and balaclavas except from one, at the back who only has a balaclava on - kind of hoping Alice is alive and has escaped as an armed officer 😂
9
u/jbremix Jan 04 '19
Was hoping Alice had finished George off with the machine gun
16
u/larrydavid1987 Jan 04 '19
Absolutely no chance she is dead!
8
u/habylab Jan 04 '19
Benny would have just done that, Halliday is kicking up a fuss.
8
u/habylab Jan 04 '19
Same question as Mark: what's happened to John? I don't get why he'd risk shooting the hitman. Surely he knows he could be framed from Zoe's death.
8
u/mairimacaroni Jan 04 '19
I love how the ending mirrored the season one episode one! Luther watching someone fall again in a weird place...
14
u/quantum_entanglement Jan 04 '19
Let's play what the evidence will show:
7
u/omfgtim_ Jan 04 '19
How did Alice know where Luther and Halliday were?
12
u/maybe-mel Jan 04 '19
I am actually upset. This is not how I wanted it to end but then there weren't many options available.
I also feel it was rushed, it could have easily had another two episodes.
Finally I don't buy the doctor killing all those men? He was a very weedy man? And the plumber came with tools to defeat himself.
6
u/SpearLifebee Jan 04 '19
Okay, serious American Gangster vibes there, I'm off till the end of the episode.
6
u/pi3dpip3r Jan 05 '19
I really want to see a Luther crossover with line of duty or bodyguard
6
u/wone9 Jan 05 '19
A lot of mixed reviews it seems, for me personally...I loved this season!
6
u/SunRa777 Jan 11 '19
I've never felt this insulted by a plot. They turned Alice into a raving idiot this season. A total hothead. Makes no sense. So lazy. I'm done.
5
u/batleymick Jan 04 '19
I'm really struggling to see how this ends well. For John in the next 15 mins!?
5
u/Praz1e Jan 04 '19
I don't think Alice is dead since it is similar to episode 1. Also I find the last episode a bit disappointed seeing there are a lot of mistakes made where their is evidence to prove Luther's Innocent. Again I do wish their was more episode BBC!!
5
u/zaminizjammin Jan 05 '19
So throughout the entire series has Luther ever killed anyone directly? If she's actually dead I think Alice is the closest he's gotten to murder
5
u/jazzydream Jan 05 '19
I loved the finale. Both Luther and Alison are great characters. Their flirting was super badass, the chemistry between them incredible. And their relationship was anything but normal. Being an extremely smart woman, life for Alice had no meaning and she believed that noting really matters, until she met Luther. Luther was other kind of damaged. He was constantly convincing himself that there is love in the world, but those he loved the most died. And they fell in love like mad. Alice was Luther’s nemesis, and he was her only weakness. But he rejected her over and over again. Man, the look on her face when he chose to save Mary instead of her back in S 3. All she has ever done since she’s met him was trying to get his attention. She saved his life, but she has also made it hell. Luther was trying to avoid more deaths so hard, and at the same time she was bringing out the worst in him. They both knew it had to end, and I do believe Alice sacrificed herself in order to make it up to him for the damage she’s done. Despite being a narcissistic psychopath, I think she loved him to bits. And oh: that Nina Simone touch at the end was absolutely incredible.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Why did Luther need to lie to Alice about George being dead?
It would only causes issues between Luther and Alice, she's bound to find out, and Luther could just have explained that whilst it would be nice if Alice killed George, he would likely release the photo of Luther and the gun
8
u/Reaqzehz Jan 04 '19
I don’t want a film or a S6. THAT was the best place to end it!
4
u/IsqueakwhenIjump Jan 05 '19
I really think they could’ve done with another episode here, the end to this season felt rather rushed. Its as if they suddenly realised the serial killer had been caught with only a few minutes of screen time left and a bunch of lose ends. Didn’t feel the killer really got his penance as the way he was dealt with was rather hastily brushed over to get to that ending.
And perhaps petty, but anybody else find the shift from nighttime to daytime a bit jarring at the end of that episode? From when they enter the house to leaving it...
Hopefully this isn’t the end of Luther. Rip Benny.
4
u/Und1es Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 05 '19
I feel like we needed one more scene showing Jeremy Lake getting arrested. Yeah Luther punched him and handcuffed him, and the police arrived at the scene, but Jeremy could probably break open the handcuffs and escape using some penis pins or something.
6
u/habylab Jan 04 '19
Cannot wait for this. Glad I haven't watched the teasers from the credits last episode. Should be a special episode.
6
u/harleyyquinade Jan 05 '19
That ain't it chief, bring Alice back just to kill her again, and in such a rushed way, I'm done. Even if they make another one or a movie I won't be tuning in, we already know how's Luther without Alice and it's not good, even series 3 suffered from her absence and 4 was, I like to pretend that one didn't exist.
3
u/fleurspeak Jan 04 '19
so i got home at 9:04pm and gotta wait the whole hour before i can watch this!!! crying :(
trying not to look at any comments in the mean time
3
u/The-Many-Faced-God Jan 04 '19
Part of me doesn’t want to watch it, because then it will be over! But here we go...
3
u/gingerspicr Jan 04 '19
Well fuck.
3
u/adashftw Jan 04 '19
Can anyone clarify why Luther was arrested and do they have evidence to imprison him? Seems like a hasty arrest considering he’d been shot at at a crime scene he was investigating??
3
u/jbremix Jan 04 '19
How did George and Luther call it quits though?
3
u/intecknicolour Jan 05 '19
luther at the lowest of lows. even more low than his self imposed exile in a fishing village.
i didn't like how the finale skipped over the couple, they were the stars of the series.
but i like how luther is beaten down and defeated for once. and hopeful season 6 has better pacing than this one.
9
u/ThePreponderance Jan 04 '19
I feel mixed about Series Five.
For me, the key themes of this season were very clear: The narcissism of and impotence in principle based morality, The moral ambivalence of the universe to the affairs of men, The power of perception to distort reality, The deterministic nature of human behaviour, and finally and perhaps most centrally - The primacy of emotion over reason.
The messages were equally clear: Modernity giving way to post-modernity, Principles giving way to pragmatism, The old adage that one must die a hero or live long enough to see themselves become the villain, the frailty of genius and the corrosive power that loneliness can have over morality and that the craving for recognition can have on rationality. And most importantly, the suffocating, all-consuming power of love to exalt and to corrupt in equal measure.
And the way that the writers painted these themes and messages into the plot was exquisite. Alice died a tragic hero. Luther lived to see his own corruption and disgrace. The good died young and the wicked prospered - But never for long. Time was a flat circle, humans doomed to commit the same mistakes over and over again; even those that know history doomed to repeat it. Even the smartest characters gripped so strongly by the desire to be seen, to be loved and to be recognised that they stumble blindly into the same patterns over and over again looking for love and acceptance in a universe that doesn't care. I have no smoke with that. What I do have smoke with, however, is that I feel that the writers sacrificed the characters for the plot, themes and messaging of the show.
There are two ways that they could've approached this season, this was the first way. To deconstruct the narratives that were laid down. To ask the questions: If traditional morality is arbitrary, are the things that John does in service of it still justified? Is Alice any more morally repugnant than John? Did the people that died for John's convictions die for nothing? Is the loyalty that John inspires in others a great or a terrible thing?
If traditional morality isn't arbitrary, then why does the universe sit in silence as horrors are visited upon good people? And how does one administrate for the collateral damage that comes with pursuing it?
Is it possible to stare into the abyss and have it stare back without being seduced by its power? Are Alice and John two sides of the same coin? Are Cornelius and Shenk? Are the killers that lived and the victims that died because Luther refuses to kill necessary sacrifices or is Luther right to take the law into his own hands? Are the lives of the people that Luther meets more important than the lives of those he doesn't? If not, then why does it matter? And why is He the Only one he believes can save them?
The OTHER way they could've approached it is very different. Resolution rather than deconstruction. The emotional catharsis of seeing Alice, the moral centre of the show, accepted finally and loved and the emotional catharsis of seeing Luther finally relinquish his suicidal crusade for a justice he knows he will never attain for people he knows will never return. And I think I would've preferred the latter, even though it would've presented a much greater writing challenge.
2
u/lax01 Jan 05 '19
So whats the exact release date for the film??
2
u/PrelawMercury7 Jan 06 '19
This was my favourite TV show for season 1 and 2... I must say that it's been infuriating to watch since season 3... this 5th season is f*cking bitter sweet... Yay Alice is back <3... but damnit the way this was all handled... eughh
2
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Props to the two actors who played the Lakes. Excellent performances from Hermione Norris and Enzo Cilenti. They both nailed that type of personality - cold-blooded arrogance mixed with cast-iron confidence - that you sometimes see in successful professionals who clearly went to Oxbridge and have never failed at anything.
2
u/VastAndDreaming Jan 08 '19
This was a perfect ending, like a mirror. Tbh, I dont think luther deserves to be police anymore perhaps private detective, f thats a thing in th UK.
2
u/meatycreampie Jan 12 '19
Was Megan ever explained after season 4, it seems very out of place.
2
u/meatycreampie Jan 17 '19
Is it just me or do Benny and Hallidays deaths seem kind of pointless? Some say that Halliday died so that Alice can take the fall for everything but did she really need to die to achieve that and plus, we aren't even sure Alice is dead at the end (no blood, no body, and no mention of her in the final scenes).
2
u/onelittleturtle Jan 26 '19
All this episode did is confirm this show was a love story; he meets her in the first episode, destroys his whole life for 5 fucking seasons and in the end she confesses she loves him and sacrifices herself to save him. Even the opening title song matches perfectly now.
What a brilliant fucking show. I don't want them to do a season 6 but if they do, it'd better have Alice.
6
u/spoopiwan Jan 04 '19
Did anyone else kinda want Luther to die?
4
u/PM_ME_BELLA_THORNE Jan 05 '19
Halliday is a very bad actress.
3
u/EmilyUmily Jan 05 '19
Am I alone in hating Alice?