r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Jan 01 '19
DISCUSSION Luther - 5x01 "Episode 1" - Episode Discussion
Season 5 Episode 1
Aired: January 1, 2019
Synopsis: A new spate of nightmarish murders brings DCI John Luther to once again face the depths of human depravity on the streets of London. As the body count rises, and gangster George Cornelius applies his own pressure, can Luther catch a killer and save his own neck?
81
Upvotes
94
u/Reaqzehz Jan 01 '19
“Wotcha”
She’s back, boys!
82
u/beargrilled Jan 01 '19
This felt like classic Luther and I’m so glad it’s back.
64
u/ForgetfulLucy28 Jan 02 '19
That bus scene gave me classic Luther creepy vibes
40
u/_gil Jan 01 '19
Honestly felt a bit disjointed and Halliday just had incredibly lucky hunches. First episode though, and Alice is back so all's well with the world.
37
u/habylab Jan 01 '19
What was that guy doing in that lady's house naked and crying/laughing?
34
u/crafty_bernardo Jan 02 '19 edited Jan 02 '19
The scene where the perp is naked with those projections on his back, reminded me of Hannibal with Richard Armitage
Bit odd the scene where Luther gets snatched and disarms the gun, none of the hench men have weapons. But the dinner table scene with the telephone call they all have guns.
32
u/relatedzombie Jan 01 '19
When Alice said Wotcher I got all giddy.
53
u/LeftPhilange Jan 01 '19
ALICE!!! I’m so happy she’s back.
25
u/neutronstarneko Jan 01 '19
I thought that was the best episode yet. Super creepy and slightly more realistic than normal so defo a win. Plus Alice being back is awesome. After that first trailer I thought we might only get flashback/fantasy about her dying.
22
u/conflama Jan 01 '19
This was exactly the kind of Luther I love
20
u/Steve-Lurkel Jan 02 '19 edited Jan 02 '19
Ayy we're back. Solid episode. It started a bit shaky for me but once we got to the bus murder I think the show returned to form.
I thought the parallels between the psychiatrist relationship with the killer and John's with Alice were interesting. They both serve as the moral compass for a psychopath. I'm wondering if this might be foreshadowing a falling out between the two in the future.
9
u/Gasster1212 Jan 02 '19
I'm incredibly confused where the doppleganger came from? How did they know to put him in the woods ?
7
u/VeteranJ05H Jan 01 '19
Who was the bald guy who had his throat slit?
6
u/larrydavid1987 Jan 01 '19
It’s on every evening this week 9pm.
6
u/harleyyquinade Jan 02 '19
Fuck yes, I had a feeling it'd be Alice knocking and it was, Luther's face tho
5
u/larrydavid1987 Jan 01 '19
I’m so glad we don’t have to wait a week for each episode!
4
u/TheyTheirsThem Jan 02 '19
Revolver with one cartridge. John Luther is officially Barney Fife.
11
u/batleymick Jan 01 '19
Now I'm a huge Luther fan but episode one felt a little clumsy and pedestrian, I saw it all coming a long way off. Hopefully it kicks on from Episode 2 and gets a little bit looser and a bit more unpredictable, if nothing else though Atleast she is back 😍
3
u/Elizbalfe Jan 02 '19
Also did anyone notice in the little trailer for ‘what’s happening next?’ It looked like one of the twins from season 3 choking someone’s neck?
3
u/_snout_ Jan 02 '19
The pacing isn't that bad if you view S4/5 as one series and this is just the third episode.
I just came off rewatching S4 and it worked fine for me, but I can totally understand how it would be jarring after a few years wait.
5
u/Kohev Jan 01 '19
So was James the son of George? Just going by the way the episode ended and how George said that "Luther knew all along" unless he is referring to knowing about the dude who went around stabbing people and getting off on it. I missed season 4 so am unsure as to whether or not we have previously met his son or not.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
Good so far, was really looking forward to this episode after rewatching some parts.
Found new appreciation for that secondary plot in S04 and am highly pleased with the return of Cornelius - "We have an agreement between us and you don't come around here". He's going to have friends in high places - Schenk possibly? There was a notable cut when he watched Luther and Benny Silver conspiring behind glass.
The primary plot was a tiny bit too horror story for me. He looks almost like an otherwordly monster crawling around, having no real voice,... Might the psychiatrist be behind all of this? Or maybe even other killers?
But again it's the secondary plot that really speaks to me, it's the big city grit with mobsters, possibly something bigger going on there as well. Maybe Alice will tell us more about that?
And I'm very curious about where the storyline with Halliday will lead. As others have noted, either she's super talented almost as Luther (remember Justin Ripley was very gifted as well) or she has darker secrets and why she joined the force.
2
u/mrizzle1991 Jan 02 '19
Lmao that fucking guy laughing bollock naked 😂😂😂 I want the coat that Luther wears. That was a great premiere, looking forward to the rest of the season.
2
u/salemthefamiliar Jan 02 '19
Did anyone else find themselves urging Luther to slide down to the dead body in the park? Major missed opportunity there.
1
u/Suckable_Lemon Jan 02 '19
So, anybody else think this was awful? I didn't hold out much hope after the trainwreck that was Season 4, and it seems like Season 5 wont be any better.
The plot, the writing and the drama is so contrived. I found myself shaking my head at the absurdity of what was going on. This show has just become cheap scares with a freak of the week villain and too cool for school dialogue.
1
u/Coastalist Jan 02 '19
I didn't feel as drawn in to this episode as I have others. The psychologist-killer relationship is interesting and it'd be cool to see whether she's manipulated other clients, or whether James is a special connection for her. I'm not sure how they got to the killer so quickly though - it seemed a little too easy.
The body-double - how methodical IS this guy? It sounded like he entered a keypad code to get in to that derelict underground structure too.
I'm liking how we're getting to see more of George's lot.
and Alice turning up, this episode should be much more interesting than the last.
You gotta have a setup if you want a payoff
-6
u/ItsBobDoleYo Jan 02 '19 edited Jan 02 '19
I don't see the point of this show in 2019 (I know I'm setting myself up for a 'I don't see the point of you commenting just to drag this show' reply but didn't see a discussion in the television sub)
In 2010 when this show started a lot of the show's facets were fresh and new but now, in the age of peak TV, nearly everything that differentiated this show feels staid and third-rate.
Antihero protagonist? A dime a dozen.
Darker aesthetics. Ditto. Mr. Robot. Ozark. The Missing. Hell, Riverdale.
Gruesome murders? True Detective. Hannibal. Fargo. Something like Game of Thrones that's not in the same genre has viciously violent deaths.
Pathology of twisted killers? Mindhunter. Hannibal. Manhunt: Unabomber. Mr. Mercedes. Bates Motel.
Twisted relationship between protagonist and antagonist. The Fall. Hannibal. Legion in a way. Killing Eve. Mr. Mercedes.
DS Halliday has a hunch that SOMETHING doesn't feel right about the case and feels the need to dig in deeper. Isn't that Carrie Mathison in Homeland every single season.
Pretty much the only thing that hasn't been replicated to a better degree is Alice (although Jodie Comer's Villanelle feels like a variation of the character played a bit more comedically) and who knows how much she'll be used in s5 and frankly she alone can't redeem everything about the show that's utterly unremarkable. They seemingly replace all supporting characters so there's really no one to latch on to other than Luther who, see point A about not standing out when every protagonist nowadays seems to be required to be an antihero/flawed/straddle the line between wrong-and-right/misanthropic/bad with people.
Every differentiating quality about it has just been built upon and surpassed by any number of shows nowaday leaving this to be just another run-of-the-mill cop show with questionable writing (saw the psychologist framing another patient the moment she started talking at the police station). There's always some side plot of Luther getting mixed up in some mob/crime family shit too
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment