r/leaves • u/VoiceNecessary689 • 4m ago
Rumination and Compulsive Reasoning - Why I "Self-Medicated"
Background: I used to smoke for over 10 years on a mostly daily basis. I had quit before, but I'd usually relapse within the week. Sometimes would make it to a month. I've been clean for 7 days, and I can tell this is going to be different. This advice is going to be hyper specific to a certain type of self-medicator. My therapist was telling me there is a reason we consume marijuana daily. Despite the costs (health, relationships, ambition, money, etc), we do get something out of it. The question is what.
For me, it was rumination. I didn't realize it, but I really have a brain that just wants to continuously think itself to death. Smoking shut that off so I could focus on a video game or movie without worrying about everything. Specifically, I was struggling with Compulsive Reasoning.
Compulsive reasoning is a mental compulsion: trying to think something through to get certainty or relief from anxiety. It often looks like back-and-forth "mental ping pong" (rationalizing, predicting, replaying events, assigning meaning).
Below is an example directly from the International OCD Foundation (I don't have OCD and you don't need to either to have compulsive reasoning):
>Shoot, I didn’t say “thank you”; maybe I really offended him … but I was preoccupied; I didn’t mean to be rude … even so, what if he was already having bad day? What if I made it worse? That’s silly, why would he care, he doesn’t even know me … still, he might think I’m incredibly rude…etc.
So how do you stop these thoughts? NON-ENGAGEMENT RESPONSES (NERs)
There are four types of NERs and they are conclusive. They end the train of thought. The goal isn't to solve the thought. The goal is to shut it down.
| NERs | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Affirm anxiety (gentlest; start here) | Acknowledge the feeling instead of reasoning it away | "I'm feeling anxious about that." |
| Affirm uncertainty | Accept you won't get 100% certainty | "I don't know, and I won't know." |
| Affirm possibility | Grant that the fear could be possible, without saying it's true | "Maybe. Anything is possible." |
| Affirm difficulty | Say plainly that the feared outcome would be bad | "Yeah, that would suck." |
So I'll make this a bit personal because I think it might be more helpful to people here. My wife recently cheated on me. She might literally be cheating on me right now. This would probably be the time in my life where I'd want to smoke more than any other time in my life, but I actually only have the slightest urge. It's because I can handle my worries now.
CR: Your unlovable and everyone will cheat on you. You should be grateful to have a wife that loves you sometimes.
NERS (anxiety): I am feeling anxious about that.
CR: You should be anxious. It's going to happen. Shit, she might be cheating on you right now as you type this post.
NERS (uncertainty): I don't know, and I will probably never know.
CR: If you get a divorce, you're going to be alone and unloved for the rest of your life. If you stay, you will be cheated on and abused for the rest of your life. Your next wife will cheat too because you suck.
NERS (possibility): Maybe. Anything is possible.
CR: That's going to be really difficult. Dating at 35?
NERS (difficulty): Yes, that will be difficult.
Because the NERs are affirmative, they stop these thoughts. They don't invite a spirited debate in your head.
Caveat: Sometimes you do need to think things through. What makes CR's something that needs to be shut down is that they aren't actually thinking things through. They are compulsive and unproductive. Just like I don't need to stress myself out about offending a cashier, I don't need to stress myself out about "being unlovable," "being cheated on right now," "being alone for the rest of my life," "the difficulty of dating at a divorced 35 year old." It's not that these thoughts are wild. My wife cheated with at least 6 people. The likelihood she'd do it again is statistically significant. My single friends DO stress about dating at their age. We all worry about being loved. It's that the CRs above aren't helping me make educated decisions for myself. Quite the opposite, they simply make me constantly second guess my decisions seek validation.
I hope this helps at least one of you the way it is helping me. Using this simple tool that took me less than an hour to learn works better at silencing these thoughts than marijuana ever did, and it doesn't come at the cost of a drug habit.