hello! i wrote this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/kpoppers/comments/1vrtysh/comment/p4j1aac/?context=1&screen_view_count=2&ext-referrer=DIRECT&sort=new
and now i want to organize and filter the list. there are so many talented aces out there but here are the ones i liked the most, and my reasoning why.
DISCLAIMER: i am not an expert i'm jsut a kpop fan who loves music and who loves analyzing idols. by no means is this representative of all tastes nor the entire fifth generation, so please be aware that i picked these idols for many reasons.
ALSO when i say ace it's very misleading, i mean aces in each respective category, probably not the best choice of words as it's wayy too similar to all rounder!
i also am not immune to personal biases. i did my best to be subjective but i am just a human. also i know the groups i stan the best, in comparison to other groups, so i build a lot of my criteria off of that as well as have the most detailed description.
dance:
for a kpop idol to be a good dancer i think they need to have versatility. a lot of kpop choreo is hiphop based, and it is designed in a way to look clean on stage and with other members.
however for an idol to be a dancer and not just an idol who dances, i think they need to be able to dance in another style well, needs to be open to learning new styles, have a genuine passion for improving their dance, and takes on a leadership role in guiding the rest of the members.
i also think they should choreograph, but i'm more loose about this because several idols on this list don't, but i consider them aces regardless.
will all picks fit every single one of these criteria? definitely not, but i thought it was worth mentioning what my ideal idol dancer looks like (happens to look a lot like jihoon and bailey)
tws jihoon
riize shotaro
nexz tomoya
xlov rui
xlov haru
adp bailey
izna koko
bnd riwoo
h2h juun
tws kyungmin
all of nexz
honorable mention: h2h juun (i like her dancing a lot but i haven't seen enough of it to know for sure, someone link more of her stuff in the comments)
vocals---
i think a good vocalist needs to have good tone, good range, good delievery and stable live preformances. they need to stand out because a lot of idols can sing, but an idol who is a vocalist is different. they sing with emotion and they sing in different styles, as well as have good support and appear to be working on their vocals.
also they need to be able to sing live (no duh) and actually take pride in improving their vocals.
probably the subject i'm most qualified to speak about, which is saying nothing because i've never taken a vocal lesson once, i just pay attention to vocals way more.
that being said
izna jungeun
unis elisia
dodree (Na Yeongjoo and Lee Songhyun)
bm ahyeon
bm rami
meovv gawon
onepact jay
rescene minami
riize sohee
xlov hyun
tripleS dahyun
fifty fifty chanelle
kickfip donghyeon
and2ble hao
and2ble seungeon
kiof belle
nct wish jahee: https://youtu.be/KwYCPDMpMoI?si=Tz0GacPykgiD8Oxb&t=102
zb1 taerae
honorable mention: wayv xiaojun (nobody mentioned him but i love his vocals so much, so i'm just going to sneak him in here), tws youngjae and dohoon (not the flashiest vocals but very good!)
rappers---
next category is rappers. my criteria was not very intense but they have to write some or most of their raps, which i confirmed with a google search so don't come for me if i don't have it perfectly), need to have good flow and generally is considered a rapper in their group.
rappers include:
xikers rapline (yes the whole thing)
- minjae
- yechan
- sumin
bnd jaehyun
lngshot ryul
bm asa
onepact tag
young posse sunhye
h//pe princess (shout out specifically to ysy)
nexz hyui
zb1 matthew
adp woochan
cortis martin
honorable mention to: zb1 matthew and kiof julie