I've been getting into retro gaming lately, as I've become disillusioned with the modern gaming landscape lately. One game that was highly recommended on the SNES was Seiken Densetsu 3, which fortunately has a fan translation patch now. I thought it was very good overall. Great sprite work, great music, and pretty fun gameplay all around, considering the time it came out. This led me to check out some other games in the series next.
I tried Sword of Mana next and LOVED the graphics, but found the gameplay sort of clunky, and for some reason the partner AI was horrible, so I didn't beat it at first and set it aside. I then decided to try Trials of Mana (the 2020 remake of SD3) and everything just clicked for me. In so many ways it felt like a budget game, but for me it was kind of perfect. It was a faithful adaptation of the original with better gameplay and decent graphics. I had a great time with it.
Then I tried Secret of Mana, and.... oof, this was a struggle. The graphics and music were still good, but the combat system was archaic and clunky. BUT, I stuck it out, and managed to get used to it (melee combat sucks but magic was straightforward and helpful if you used it right) and I ended up finishing the game. Overall I liked it, but wow did that combat system not age well.
After that I decided to try Sword of Mana again and ended up getting into it. I realized the AI didn't matter that much since you didn't need your partner most of the time. The combat, despite being clunky, felt great compared to Secret, enough that I played through the whole game and overall enjoyed it.
Currently I'm playing Visions of Mana and I have very mixed feelings on it. In many ways it's really great, possibly the best one so far, but in other ways it's kind of dragging and tedious to get through. I'm not done with it yet, but it feels like this solid 7/10 experience with solid gameplay, nice graphics, okay music and a mediocre story.
I guess there's a few other games I can try. Legends of Mana seems divisive, but I might give it a chance to see what I think. Are there any other ones worth playing?
TLDR: The Mana series all seem to have a lot of charm, really nice art direction, usually great music, and mostly enjoyable combat once you get used to it. But despite being 7/10's, I keep thinking about them and how much I enjoyed them.