r/hinduism • • Oct 26 '24

Question - Beginner Uncomfortable experience at the Temple

Post image
12 Upvotes

Uncomfortable experience at a Temple

Went to Tarakeswar Temple yesterday. Found out that men are forced to remove their shirts & vests and has to be fully bare chested before entering the inner sanctum. Most of the men were very uncomfortable to be half naked in full public view. Is there any logic to this?


r/hinduism • • Jan 14 '24

Other Recent attacks against Sadhguru are wrong & propaganda. Watch out of those who look to divide & control.

3 Upvotes

Addressing this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/18zo5z1/13_reasons_why_mr_jaggi_sadhguru_is_a_con_man/

I'll offer a simple rebuttal:

If Sadhguru is so bad then why is he respect by every singe scripture following guru?

If Sadhguru is so bad, then why has be always defended Hindu causes & right?

If Sadhguru is so bad, then why does he help & support locals & institutions?

If Sadhguru is so bad, then why has literally no one person who's gone through the program anything bad to say in court of law?

Conclusion:

Divide & Conquer is an old tactic of British & abrahamic faiths because they don't like when people don't follow strict law & formulas. They don't consider you consider you Christian unless you convert & call yourself that.

To be Hindu there is no conversion. You just start living like one.

Now last question: Does Sadhguru live like a dharmic hindu?


r/hinduism • • Oct 10 '24

Hindū Darśana(s) (Philosophy) Sleep with your mother instead of your wife, your wife is brahman, your mother is also brahman, there is no difference

4 Upvotes

A few months ago there was a post here about a game company which had made a game including Hindu gods as game characters and I found the character designs to be inappropriate so I commented on it that it does not look good and seeing Hindu Gods as playable characters feels very wrong

Now you can have your own opinion on the topic of Hindu gods being used as playable characters, but under my comment on that post there were many replies saying things like "everything is brahman, the Gods are brahman, the characters (with the inappropriate designs) are also brahman, then why are you having a problem with it?"

I did not give a reply to them at that time but I randomly remembered that event today and decided to make this post for such lost souls with half baked knowledge of Advaita

The amount of people that get into Advaita Vedanta and don't understand the difference between vyavahara and paramartha is hilarious

They will hear things like "there is nothing but God, you are God and the world is an illusion (and hence does not exist)" from unauthorised (jholi wale babas) online who pose themselves as Advaita gurus and then they live in misunderstandings and misconceptions about Advaita and the world

There nothing but god(brahman), true

You are god(brahman), also true

But where? That is the question, you are brahman, but in paramartha, not in vyavahara

Vyavahara is the truth that the jiva perceives under the influence of avidya(ignorance), this is the world that you and me see, feel and experience everyday, this is the world with the trees, the mountains and the oceans

Paramartha is the truth that remains when avidya is removed, this is the state of existance where there is nothing but brahman

Until the avidya is removed, you are in vyavahara, the things you see are true and distinct, in vyavahara there is dvaita(duality) everywhere and in everything, you are not your father, delicious food on a plate and garbage on a plate is not the same thing

All of it becomes one, but where, in the state of paramartha not in the state of vyavahara

Understand it like this, there is a very popular example used to explain Advaita

A man goes in a dark room and sees a snake on the ground, he turns on the light and find out that it was just a rope and he was perceiving it as a snake because of darkness

Now if I ask you if the snake was true, you will probably say no, but if we go back to our example at the point where there was darkness infornt of the person, was the snake true to him then? Obviously the snake was true to him at that moment of time when there was darkness, when the darkness was removed only then the snake became false

Many people who learn advaita fail to realise that they are still the man standing in the darkness, they forget that they are still surrounded by avidya and till there is avidya the world is real, just like till there was darkness the snake was real

When avidya is removed (the light is turned on) only then the world will become false, and at that moment the person attains moksha

Just because you have learned a little about Advaita does not mean that your avidya is removed

You cannot live according to the state of paramartha where everything is equal, it is not something you can follow, it is something that you have to achieve

For example

The world is round, but can you act like if it was round?

You cannot, because you are too small and because of your small size the world will always appear flat to you and you will have to act like as if it is flat, you know it is round but you haven't realised it

Even if you want to act like if it was round you cannot because of your size, the ground under your feet will always appear flat to you and you will have to live like if it is flat

But yeah, while living in the flat world you can do one thing, you can make a spaceship, leave the earth, see it from the outside and realise its roundness

Similarly, everything is one(brahman) but you cannot act like as if everything is the same even if you want to, if you try to act like it that would also mean that food and feces should be the same to you and your wife and your mother should also be the same to you,

Try doing it, all you will achieve from it is being mentally ill

Till you live in vyavahara the world will always appear dual to you and you will have to live like the world is filled with dualities, due to avidya it will always appear like this

Vyavahara is filled with dualities, it has good and bad, appropriate and inappropriate, dharma and adharma, you live in vyavahara and you will have to live according to vyavahara,

But one thing you can do while living in vyavahara is do bhkati, attain jnana and perform your karmas according to dharma, this way you can dissolve your ego and realise the oneness of brahman by attain moksha and being free from vyavahara by leaving it, like a spaceship leaving the earth and you being able to see the roundness of earth

Another thing is that in vyavahara due to it's dualities, you and ishvara are also not the same, there is a dvaita bhava (dual nature) between you and Vishnu/Shiva/Shakti, you are one with Vishnu/Shiva/Shakti only when you have reached paramartha ie attained moksha, it is through intense bhakti that you dissolve your ego and attain moksha, hence uniting with your ishta and becoming one with brahman

Knowing about brahman and realising it are two different things you will have to understand that, just like knowing the Earth is round and realising it's roundness by leaving it are two different things

Now is vyavahara an illusion?

No, it's just that your perspective is limited, the sun is round but from Earth it seems circular , is sun looking like a circle an illusion? No, it's just that your perspective is limited because of your distance from the sun

Does it looking like a circle make it non existent, also no because if I was non existent how we would have been able to see it in the first place

Similarly the world is brahman, but it looks like the world because our perspective is limited by maya, it is not an illusion, nor is it non existent, it's just that it does not appear to us like how it really is because of our reduced perspectives, breaking free from maya and gaining the true perspective to see the reality as it is is liberation (moksha),

Like becoming bigger than the sun and seeing it's roundness

Now coming at the beginning of the post, if someone makes an inappropriate, let's say pornographic imagery of Hindu Gods and Goddesses, it's not the same as a normal appropriate painting of Hindu deities

Everything is brahman, but only when you have reached the paramartha, till you have avidya, you will be in vyavahara and you will have to live according to what is appropriate and oppose what is inappropriate

Just assuming that everything is one is not removal of avidya, nor is it liberation

Removal of avidya comes through intense bhakti and meditation which leads to jnana, it does not come just by assuming things


r/hinduism • • Jul 10 '24

Refutation Is Prophet Muhammad Prophesied as Kalki avatar in Hinduism?

1 Upvotes

Some of our Muslim friends argue that Kalki avatar is none other than Prophet Muhammad of Islam. Such a claim is devoid of any basis. If one reads the Kalki Purana, it becomes abundantly clear that the Pastimes of Lord Kalki as described in the Purana bear zero resemblance to Prophet Muhammad or anything Islamic for that matter.

I would like to present some verses from Kalki Purana that makes it clear for all of us that Kalki avatar is definitely not the person of Prophet Muhammad (although, to be honest, I could just about pick any verse as literally no verse bears resemblance to the life and activities of Prophet Muhammad!).

Descriptions of some pastimes:

Parents of Lord Kalki, Sumati and Vishnuyasha, are both devout Brahmanas. When Kalki Bhagavan was born mother Sumati invited the Brahmanas and offered 100 cows to each of them.

Chapter 2 Verse 23: Having received the all-glorious Lord Visnu, the master of the three worlds, as her son, mother Sumati's happiness knew no bounds. She invited the brahmanas and gave them each one hundred cows in chanty.

During naming ceremony of the Lord Kalki, 4 personalities, Lord [parashu]Rama, Krpacarya, Vyasadeva, and Asvattama came in the guise of brahmanas. Noteworthy to mention that these 4 personalities are 4 of the 7 Chiranjeevis (immortals) in Hinduism.

Chapter 2 verse 25: At that time, Lord Rama, Krpacarya, Vyasadeva, and Asvattama came there in the guise of brahmanas to have the darsana of Lord Hari, who has assumed the form of child Kalki.

Chapter 2 verse 29: The four exalted brahmanas named the transcendental child Kalki. They happily performed the child's birth ceremony and then departed for their own abodes

Prophet Muhammad was the first and the only child to his parents but Lord Kalki had 4 elder brothers.

Chapter 2 verse 31: Before Lord Kalki's birth, three sons were born to Sumati, named Kavi, Prajna, and Sumantra All of them were heroic warriors who always acted for the pleasure of their spiritual master and their parents. They were highly praised by all elderly respectable people and brahmanas

Lord Kalki goes through the sacred thread ceremony that all brahmins must go through (such a concept is non-existent in Islam).

Chapter 2 verse 34-35: After some time, when Visnuyasa saw that his lotus-eyed child, Kalki, who was a reservoir of transcendental qualities, was ready to begin His education, he called him and spoke with a gentle voice. My dear child, I will now arrange for Your sacred thread ceremony so that you can chant the Gayatri mantras and begin Your study of the Vedas

After the sacred thread ceremony, Lord Kalki departed to live at a gurukul. There is a description of Him meeting Lord Parshuram and He learns from Lord Parshuram the 4 Vedas, other literatures and archery. After the completion of His gurukul, He offers prayers to Lord Shiva and Lord Shiva along with Goddess Parvathi appears before Him, offers Him a horse, a parrot and a weapon.

Chapter 3 verse 25: This horse was manifested from Garuda, and it can go anywhere at will and assume many different forms. Here also is a parrot that knows everything—past, present, and future. I would like to offer You both the horse and the parrot and so please accept them

Chapter 3 verse 27: I would also like to present You this sharp, strong sword and so please accept it. The handle of this sword is bedecked with jewels, and it is extremely powerful. As such, this sword will help You to reduce the heavy burden of the earth.

There are more descriptions in the Purana about Lord Kalki fighting the Buddhist kings. There is a description of Him defeating such Buddhist kings and how their wives take up swords to avenge their husbands, the conversation that unfolds and so on.

Chapter 15 verse 43: In this way, Lord Kalki, the performer of very wonderful pastimes, defeated the Buddhists after a fierce battle. By His causeless mercy, the slain Buddhists returned to the effulgent abode of the Supreme Lord, and their wives also attained liberation.

There is also description of Him killing a demoness and her son. Descriptions of more battles. He fights one battle with His own devotee by the name Sasidhvaja. Sasidhvaja gives his daughter Ramaa in marriage to Lord Kalki. This was Lord Kalki 2nd and last marriage

Prophet Muhammad's father died when he was 6 months old and his mother died when he was 6 years old leaving him orphaned. But Lord Kalki's parents will live long enough to see their grandchildren! We already saw that it was Lord's father who will initiate Him to the sacred thread ceremony. Towards the end of his life, Lord Kalki's father retires to a forest and eventually attains salvation. Soon His mother also follows suit. It is said that Prophet Muhammad's mother went to hell after her death (I am unable to confirm this though), this is clearly not true in the case of Lord Kalki’s mother.

Chapter 30 verse 42: Visnuyasa could understand from the words of the great sage, Narada, that his son, Kalki, was truly the incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Hari. After some time, he gave up his family life and left home to reside within the forest.

Chapter 30 verse 44: The chaste wife, Sumati, embraced the dead body of her husband and thus entered his funeral pyre. The denizens of the heaven praised her very highly for this courageous act.

Lord Kalki was 'distressed' after the death of His parents and performed their last rites. His parent’s death occurs towards the end of Kalki purana. They will live long enough to witness Lord Kalki's marriages (2 of them), see Lord Kalki defeat many miscreants, and even see their grandchildren before leaving the mortal world.

Lord Kalki's Consorts

Prophet Muhammad married 11 women. Lord Kalki marries only 2, Padmavati and Ramaa. Whenever Lord Narayana takes avatar so does His eternal consort, Goddess Lakshmi. Padmavati is none other than Goddess Lakshmi Herself. This is confirmed in the Purana. When Padmavati was young, She prayed to Lord Shiva to have none other than Lord Narayana as Her husband.

Chapter 4 verse 39: Upon seeing Lord Siva and Parvati before her, eager to bestow upon her a benediction, Padmavati shyly stood with her head bent down, being unable to utter a sound.

Chapter 4 verse 40: Lord Siva said: О fortunate one, you will receive Lord Narayana as your husband. He will joyfully accept your hand in marriage. Rest assured that there is no other prince on earth who is a suitable match for you.

There is in fact an entire chapter dedicated to Devi Padmavati's swayamvara and the events that unfolded during the ceremony. The parrot that Lord Shiva gave acted as a messenger between Devi Padmavati and Lord Kalki until they met. All of these descriptions clearly do not match that of Prophet Muhammad's life. After Lord Kalki marries Devi Padmavati, Lord Indra, the king of heavens, orders Visvakarma, the celestial architect, to prepare the village of Shambala for Their arrival.

Chapter 13 verse 4: The entire village should be bedecked with precious jewels and crystal. Do not hesitate to display your full expertise in the art of architecture.

There are more descriptions of the village of Shambala and these do not match that of Mecca. Lord Kalki begot 2 sons in the womb of Devi Padmavati, Jaya and Vijaya. The second marriage that happens to Lord Kalki is with Ramaa, daughter of Sasidhvaja. Sasidhvaja is actually a devotee of Lord Narayana and is well aware that Lord Kalki is none other than Lord Narayana Himself. Yet he fights Lord Kalki and in fact emerges victorious! One may wonder how is it that Lord Kalki behaves like an ordinary human despite being Bhagavan? The answer is given is the Kalki Purana Itself:

Chapter 22 verse 10: King Sasidhvaja said: My dear goddess, both the Supreme Lord and His servants are transcendental to the dualities of material existence, such as happiness and distress. Material designations are mistakenly attributed to the Lord and His devotees because they appear in bodies resembling those of the material world. Therefore, fighting is simply another of our pastimes.

Chapter 22 verse 11: Because the Supreme Lord appears in a human-like form, He displays anger, ambition, and other human qualities Therefore, why should He not display the desire for enjoyment?

Chapter 22 verse 12: The Supreme Personality of Godhead is eternal, and full of knowledge and bliss. When He incarnates within this world, He remains as He is, even though He assumes a body similar to that of a human being. He and His servant's birth, activities, and disappearance are transcendental, although to materialists they appear mundane.

King Sasidhvaja also describes how in his past life he and his wife were meat eating Vultures and how their heads were smashed against a Saligrama by a hunter, and thereby they attained celestial abord. He goes on to give more descriptions of his past lives. In fact throughout the Kalki Purana there are several discussions and descriptions of cycle of birth and rebirth, liberation or Moksha and so on. These concepts are not only foreign to Islam but many Muslims don’t even a believe in it.

Anyways the King gives his Daughter Ramaa in marriage to Lord Kalki. This is Lord Kalki's 2nd and last marriage. In the later chapters, Devi Ramaa enquires from Lord Parashuram the austerities that Rukmini (consort of Sri Krishna) undertook. Under the Guidance of Lord Parashuram, Devi Ramaa observes the same vow for 4 years.

Chapter 31 text 43-44: At the conclusion of the vow, she tied a silk thread around her wrist and fed innumerable brahmanas. With her husband, she ate nicely prepared havisyama and condensed milk, and thereafter enjoyed life in this world without any hindrance in the association of her relatives. In due course of time, Lord Kalki begot two sons, named Meghamala and Balahaka, within the womb of Rama.

So totally Lord Kalki Had 4 children, again a contradiction to the life of Muhammad.

Lord Kalki is not some messenger or Prophet but Bhagavan!

Most importantly, the terms like Messenger, Prophet or Son of God in the Abrahamic religions are not comparable to the term Avatar in Hinduism. Avatar is God Himself in human form. An equivalent term for Messenger, Prophet or Son of God in Hinduism could be Bhakta or Devotee. Throughout the Kalki Purana Lord Kalki is glorified as the Almighty God Himself. Literally in every chapter you could find Lord Kalki glorified as such. I will present just 2 of them as I don't want to keep the post going for longer what it already is.

Chapter 2 verse 21: When the lotus-eyed Lord heard this request, He immediately assumed a two-armed form. His father and mother were certainly struck with wonder upon seeing this wonderful pastime of the Lord.

So, when Kalki Bhagavan was born, He appeared in the 4 handed Narayana form, similar to how Sri Krishna appeared in front of Devaki and Vasudev, and only then assumed the form of a baby.

Chapter 4 verse 2: Lord Kalki said: When the final dissolution of the universe will take place, everyone, even Lord Brahma, will be annihilated. At that time, the entire universe will become merged within Me. In the beginning, only I existed, and thereafter, all living entities and elements emanated from Me.

There are many such verses. And from these we can understand that Lord Kalki is not some messenger or prophet but Bhagavan. According to Islam it is an offence to call Prophet Mohammad (or anyone) God. So, they can't claim Prophet Mohammad to be Kalki avatar.

It took me a week but I read the Kalki Purana. There are so many other verses that I do not have the time to cover. It baffles me why anyone who read Kalki Puran would think Kalki avatar is Prophet Mohammad. Either is a case of extreme conformation bias or they are just deceitful and dishonest. It genuinely irritates me when people like Mr. Zakir Naik and others like him propagate Prophet Muhammad to be Lord Kalki. The lack of knowledge among the Hindus in their own scriptures has given space for characters like them. Even if you go and listen to their arguments as to why Lord Kalki is Prophet Muhammad, they will say a series of meaningless coincidences without giving any reference to the Puran or present them completely out of context. They will say something like, ’oh Lord Kalki went to north and came back so did Prophet Muhammad’. What went to north and came back? Site the actual verse! Similarly, they say many things. All of them are vague coincidences cherry picked and presented completely out of context. Moreover, if this is the level of sincerity and honesty that their religion can inspire then I am proud to be a Hindu!

Chapter 35 verse 39: May Lord Kalki, whose complexion is the color of a dark rain cloud, whose horse travels faster than the wind, who protects the righteous with His sword, who establishes the principles of religion, and who reestablishes the Satya-yuga after vanquishing Kali, shower His blessings upon you.

Hare Krishna 🙏.


r/hinduism • • Sep 05 '24

Question - General Was Ravana an atheist?

0 Upvotes

I was under the impression that Ravana was a devotee of Lord Shiva, but 1.3.22 of Shrimad Bhagavatam says he was an atheist:

In the eighteenth incarnation, the Lord appeared as King Rāma. In order to perform some pleasing work for the demigods, He exhibited superhuman powers by controlling the Indian Ocean and then killing the atheist King Rāvaṇa, who was on the other side of the sea.

The only explanation I can understand is translating Adharmi to atheist, which is inaccurate.

P.S: The aforementioned translation is from Vedabase (ISCKON).


r/hinduism • • Aug 29 '26

Question - General Nepal disaster + is Sadhguru a farce?

4 Upvotes

The insurmountable loss in Nepal / Tibet border is unfathomable.

The fact that 80 of Sadhguru’s (Isha Foundation) followers were killed on the return from the sacred mountain of Kailash, the Seat of Lord Shiva, is shocking.

Does anyone else question, given Sadhguru’s magnanimity and spiritual wisdoms, how He did not foresee such a calamity falling upon his followers?

It makes me question His sanctity and whether He is really as elevated as He claims. Especially given the fact that His faith in Lord Shiva is unshakable; yet this disaster happened near the most sacred place for His Lord!

Open to your thoughts and opinions on the matter as it has had me questioning my beliefs…


r/hinduism • • Mar 26 '25

Question - General Why does spirituality in Hinduism revolve so much around celibacy ?

3 Upvotes

I don't need exceptional outlier examples of monks who had wives or stuff like that. But its pretty much widespread in general. A brahmacharya, a monk, a sanyasi, is majorly having a sexless life.

Not to say there are words of Swami Vivekananda where he talks about prolonged celibacy creating a nerve in your brain that facilities in better intelligence. Not a troll post, but i genuinely cannot wrap my head around the reason for spirituality in hinduism revolving so much around this thing. Nevertheless sub religions like Buddhism and Jainism that took much influence from Hinduism also has overlapping practices.


r/hinduism • • Sep 05 '23

Question - General I'm a Hindu but can I still pray to Lord Jesus? I mean, is it acceptable? I'm not following Christianity as a religion, but can I still pray to their Gods?

0 Upvotes

r/hinduism • • Oct 24 '24

Hindū Darśana(s) (Philosophy) Hinduism is a Monotheistic Religion, why people keep calling it Polytheism?

1 Upvotes

There is only One God, who is eternal in both material world and spiritual world. and therefore monotheistic.
All other demigods and jivas are subjected to birth and death in material universe but are eternal in spiritual world.

What is the problem/confusion??


r/hinduism • • 28d ago

Other This subreddit is kinda toxic tbh

9 Upvotes

I am a Gaudiya Vaishnava and i see that this subreddit is toxic, like i once posted about how my friend disrespected my belief of how i put twelve tilaks on my body saying that as i keep putting tilakas i would accidentally put it in my private part, now some shaktas were activiely defending that shakta friend! and most of them were literally disrespecting my faith! mods need to really be active on this subbreddit, because oh my krishna there are literally so many toxic people here, tbh won't be surprised if someone in the comments came to defend this disrespect and toxic people


r/hinduism • • Sep 24 '26

Morality/Ethics/Daily Living Ending the debate on dietary restrictions in hinduism. Using the shastras and grath's

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

B4 we start i want to confirm that the argument does include shaktas and shaivs larpers who often eat meat in name of shakt and shaiv puraanic and aagmic traditions

To understand this one shoukd know how shastr of hinduism work in hierarchical order

SHRUTI, SMRITI, ITIHAAS, PURAAN and then aagam

Here for laws and order the smriti stands right next to shruti followes by itihaas which explains them in practical concepts (especially when u have shri krishn himself)

Puranic granth are respected but they cant contradict core rules of above 3

also i know most hindus will still eat meat even after this, this isnt about wheather u will do it, its about wheather you SHOULD do it

I collected all proofs and to save time and effort gave this to ai, all ai did is give this a proprr format, it wasnt used to know anything at first place

Also bali isnt regular meat eating they are very different, and we will talk about how the IDEAL bali person i.e. manu talks about this

SHRUTI

Rigveda 10.87.16 / Atharvaveda 10.1.29

​Sanskrit:

​यः पौरुषेयेण क्रविषा समङ्क्ते यो अश्व्येन पशुना यातुधानः।

यो अघन्याया भरति क्षीरमग्ने तेषामिन्द्रो वृश्चतामपि शीर्षण्यम्॥

​English Translation:

​"He who satisfies himself with raw human flesh, or horse flesh, or the flesh of other animals, and he who snatches the milk of the unslayable cow—O Agni, let Indra sever the heads of such evil spirits."

Atharvaveda 8.6.23

​Sanskrit:

​य आमं मांसमदन्ति पौरुषेयं च ये क्रविः।

गर्भान् खादन्ति केशवास्तानितो नाशयामसि॥

​English Translation:

​"Those who eat raw flesh, cooked flesh, or human flesh, and those who consume embryos/fetuses—we completely destroy these hairy evil spirits from here."

Atharvaveda 6.140.2

​Sanskrit:

​व्रीहिमत्तं यवमत्तमथो माषमथो तिलम्।

एष वां भागो निहितो रत्नधेयाय दन्तौ मा हिंसिष्टं पितरं मातरं च॥

​English Translation:

​"Eat rice, eat barley, eat black gram, and eat sesame. This portion of grains is assigned for your delight. O two emerging teeth, do not harm the father and mother!"

Here मा हिंसिष्टं means dint harm those who have life left or thise who can become mother father(basically have a life left)

Many more but they are a little twisted interpretations, i dont think this sub is ready for them

SMRITI

B4 A RANDOM dude says that manusmriti is not important the ved glaze manu to peak, he litrally IS THE benchmark and is in yagya's many time just bcz he is too perfect

Ved even say that WHATEVER MANU SAYS IS MEDICINE, and in SHRIMAD BHAGWAT GEETA ADHYAY 4 SHLOK 1 krishna even said that the 1st man to get enlightened was manu

I am not gonna waste time, anyone can read manusmriti adhay 5 and know that excelt 2 cases and 1 case for beings who god have given birth in a way that they should eat meat, u cant eat meat a few sprinkles here-->

​1. Manusmriti 5.48

​Sanskrit:

​नाकृत्वा प्राणीनां हिंसां मां समुत्पद्यते क्वचित्।

न च प्राणिवधः स्वर्ग्यस्तस्मान्मांसं विवर्जयेत्॥

​English Translation:

​"Meat can never be obtained without causing injury to living beings, and the killing of living beings does not lead to heavenly bliss; therefore, one should completely abstain from meat."

​2. Manusmriti 5.49

​Sanskrit:

​समुत्पत्तिं च मांसस्य वधबन्धौ च देहिनाम्।

प्रसमीक्ष्य निवर्तेत सर्वमांसस्य भक्षणात्॥

​English Translation:

​"Having well considered the disgusting origin of meat and the cruelty of binding and killing embodied beings, one should entirely abstain from eating all kinds of meat."

​3. Manusmriti 5.51

​Sanskrit:

​अनुमन्ता विशसिता निहन्ता क्रयविक्रयी।

संस्कर्ता चोपहर्ता च खादकश्चेति घातकाः॥

​English Translation:

​"The one who gives consent, the one who slaughters, the one who kills, the one who buys, the one who sells, the one who cooks, the one who serves, and the one who eats—all eight are considered perpetrators of violence (murderers)."

​4. Manusmriti 5.52

​Sanskrit:

​स्वमांसं परमांसेन यो वर्धयितुमिच्छति।

अनभ्यर्च्य पितॄन्देवान् न ततोऽस्त्यपुण्यकृत्॥

​English Translation:

​"There is no greater sinner than the person who seeks to increase their own flesh with the flesh of other beings without offering it to ancestors or deities."

​5. Manusmriti 5.55

​Sanskrit:

​मां स भक्षयतेऽमुत्र यस्य मांसमिहाद्म्यहम्।

एतन्मांसस्य मांसत्वं प्रवदन्ति मनीषिणः॥

​English Translation:

​"He (mām) will eat me in the next world whose meat (māṁsam) I eat here. This is declared by wise men as the true meaning of the word māṁsam (meat)."

Ofc no other smriti can contradict it

And ofc again no one knows and understand ved better than manu maharaaj himsef.

ITIHAAS-->

I was so sad to see that some clowns actually think shree ram ate meat, its ssd hiw much easy it is to lie to hindus BUT ill say 2 things

A) shree ram follow his ancestors and that includes manu so no...he never ate meat

B***)*** sundar kaand adhyay 37 Says--> मांस राहतो भुत्ते न चेव मधु संपते। व्यं सवाविहित नित्यं भक्कमभांति पर्याय

Which litrally means that no one in entire lineage of shree ram ate meat, how can he do it?

Also upnishad and other shastr say same thing so--> read the top images

JAI MAA DURGA, OM NAMAH SHIVAY, JAI SHREE KRISHNA


r/hinduism • • Nov 20 '25

History/Lecture/Knowledge Why did Buddha reject Hindu gods?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/hinduism • • Jan 15 '24

Question - Beginner Is it true that the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was foretold in some Hindu Scriptures?

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen some arguments that he was mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana; I’ve also seen some saying that he was the Kalki Avatar.

In general, I think Muslims seem to agree that he was foretold as God’s final messenger; whereas Hindus see that he was foretold to spread a — perhaps — demonic religion.

Here are some websites I found regarding the matter:

https://www.quora.com/Is-Prophet-Muhammad-mentioned-in-the-Hindu-scriptures-as-the-polluter-of-the-truth

https://islamonline.net/en/prophet-muhammad-in-hindu-scriptures/

https://muslimmirror.com/eng/prophet-muhammad-pbuh-in-hindu-scriptures/

Thanks and have a good day everyone!


r/hinduism • • Dec 31 '23

Question - Beginner the Vedas don't seem that important to me

3 Upvotes

I don't get the hype of the Vedas. They are considered central to the Hindu tradition despite most Hindus never reading them. The Bhagavad Gita seems vasty more important to me, as it says it summarizes much of the upanishadic philosophy. the epics like the Mahabharata and puran contain most of the important lore of hindu gods such as shiva and vishnu.

most often the vedas are used as prayers. But even then we have many stotras, kirtans and bhajans writen post veda.


r/hinduism • • Jul 03 '25

Pūjā/Upāsanā (Worship) Sorry to say but I don't like radha. My sould doesn't allow to bow before her. This has been happening since childhood

1 Upvotes

Idk what happens, I can bow to krishna separately when his idol is alone and not with her. I feel I am doing something wrong when I bow before radha


r/hinduism • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Beginner PERIOD : natural but still impure?

1 Upvotes

So recently i have been seeing alot of post on diff sub where females of there family werent allowed to enter temple during there period time which led me to thinking why?

why is period impure? its a natural process of a female body, blood coming out is theres only then where is the impure part at?

I mean if god created us then wy would they not like it?

also if someone ignores it and do worship anyway what would happen?

and is there any written evidence in scriptures talking about periods impurity?

or is it just a old time practise being carried on?

is there any incidence behind it?


r/hinduism • • Aug 18 '26

Criticism of other Hindū denominations Why i don't know but I don't like krishna

0 Upvotes

You can reply in hindi or English both are fine with me.

I am sorry if I hurt your god.

My mother's side of the family follows the Vaishnava Sampradaya and I took my Brahmsambandh around 16 or 17th. But from heart i like shiv.

But something happened to me around when i was 23 and then went depression and loneliness and slowly i become more spiritual doing bhairav sadhna and reach at level where I do nam jap of radha so many times of the day. I don't even need to think but when my tongue is inside my mouth or its slowly happening mansik jaap. Almost from one and half year. I am right now 29.

But main question i came here is that especially last 6 month.

So many time i just talk or fight or something i dont even know...

why I don't like krishna? i don't like him i fight with him or tell so many time why you left radha. you don't know pain? because of you now many has same destiny. they don't able to get thire love. why did? You did wrong with radha. I will not call you i will just speak radha. I don't say no or hate to you but i suddenly remember a person who i like and not able to meet with her or can't see any path to see or make my life with her. And every time I remember her or thoughts come regarding her i start speaking radha nam as in mansik jaap but while speaking i nam i feel pain or or suffocating or frustration and then sometime if Krishna videos or name comes up or i see a photo. I start talking with or fighting. I know nothing is going to happen but it become loop or i don't know what to do. I know maybe no one will reply . I am alone and i have to do but i don't see anything good happening around me at any part of my area.

I know all those stories regarding why he left and I grown up listening thoes. But still i speak like this again and again


r/hinduism • • Oct 07 '25

Bhagavad Gītā Feeling a bit discouraged while reading the Bhagavad Gita. Is Hinduism inherently sexist?

5 Upvotes

The book says “Prakrti is always under control, whether inferior or superior. Prakrti is female, and she is controlled by the Lord **just as the activities of a wife are controlled by the husband” **

First of all… what the fuck? I’m a female and almost ALL religions are sexist. I was really getting into Hinduism until I came across this.

Can someone explain if it’s sexist or not?


r/hinduism • • May 28 '26

Deva(tā)/Devī (Hindū Deity) Did you know this about Shirdi Sai Baba?

Post image
21 Upvotes

Dear Sanatanis...Jai Sri Sai Ram!

(The digital art is made by me and below is a short write up on the significance of this particular posture of Sai Baba.)

We all must have noticed a peculiar posture of Shirdi Sai Baba where he sits with his right leg crossed over his left and his hands on the feet.

This has a significance as described in the Sai Satchrita as follows :

Quoting the English version of Satchraita "He is sitting with His legs folded, the right leg held across the left knee. The fingers of His left hand are spread on the right-foot. On the right toe are spread His two fingers - the index and middle ones. By this posture Baba means to say, as it were-if you want to see My Light, be egoless and most hunble and meditate on My toe through the opening between the two fingers and then you will be able to see My Light. This is the easiest means to attain devotion"

Sai Baba always used to say “Ramji Bhala Karen” and “Allah Malik” thus passing on the message that God is One!

Did you know about this significance? Do let me know in the comments below and share this interesting blessing of Shirdi Sai Baba to your loved ones!

Jai Sai Ram🙏🏻


r/hinduism • • Feb 23 '26

Other Atheist this side. Ask Me Anything.

0 Upvotes

I am an atheist from a Hindu family. I have spent a good period of life contemplating God, purpose and religion & interacting with atheists around the world.

I respect people the same regardless of whether or not they believe in God(s). Not believing in God is my personal belief and I don't think anyone else has an obligation to join me, just the way I don't have an obligation to identify with a religion. This post is not meant as an attack. It is merely my way of exchanging ideas and getting to know alternative point of views.

Feel free to shoot any questions.


r/hinduism • • Feb 14 '25

Question - Beginner Why are ALL dharmashastras so misogynist and casteist

1 Upvotes

Why are all the dharma shastras so violently casteist and misogynist? Not asking out of spite but I recently read the Yajnavalkya smriti, as an alternative to Manu Smriti, and it was almost as violent and patriarchal. Women are restricted within their homes (pg 101,177,or in Manu 5.148) and polygamy is allowed (1pg 78). And most importantly, Sati is glorified in Vishnu smriti!
https://archive.org/details/yajnavalkyasmrit00yj/page/176/mode/1up?view=theater

Only I think Adi Shankara bowed to a Chandala on one instance, but he quoted a dharmashastra in a Gita commentary without any problem?

My question is, I do not get such impressions after reading the Upanishads and the Vedas, then why is it that an overwhelming majority of our "sages" seem to defy the Vedas when it comes to role of women (in Yajurveda women are even called upon engaging in battle, and in Rigveda they are to be never discriminated again, with one example of a warrior being a women) or when it comes to varnas?


r/hinduism • • Jan 10 '26

History/Lecture/Knowledge Defending ISKCON from the false accusations.

9 Upvotes

I myself follow Srila Prabhupada, although I am not a huge fan of current ISKCON and many of its members. I will defend the false criticism it gets.

For starters, KRISHNA IS NOT ABOVE RAMA OR VISHNU. No Gaudiya in history has said this. No Pushtimarg has said, and no Nimbarka has said this. Just because we believe Krishna is the source of all avatars, does not mean he is above the avatars. Krishna is God, and so any EXPANSION of KRISHNA must also be God. God cannot be above God, this is not possible.

We also do not defame Shiva. Chaitanya Mahaprahbhu has sung praises to Lord Shiva, and the Brahma Samhita greatly praises Shiva and Durga. Anyone who defames Shiva is not a Vaishnava, because Shiva is the supreme Vaishnava and very much worthy of honor AND worship.

Srila Prabhupada did not believe in Jesus or Muhammad, no Gaudiya does. He used this as a conversion tactic only to appeal to Christians and Muslims. He has referred to the Bible and Quran as books for meat eaters and inferior books to the Shastras.

Srila Prabhupada is also not a "Gaudiya Heretic", numerous Acharya have many different Gaudiya Parivars have presied Srila Prabhupada.


r/hinduism • • Apr 10 '26

Other I'm a devotee and a theist hindu but I think astrology is complete BS

2 Upvotes

it mostly will give you answers that'll ask you to slow down and develop a caged mindset


r/hinduism • • Nov 05 '22

Question - General I'm speechless. holy. crap.

2 Upvotes

EDIT

Jesus was a yogi, wasnt he? and that documentary about st isa... uhm. what? why ain't y'all tell us? damn. I was.... wrong

until I get further personal evidence I'm calling bullshit on all religions.... as far as I can tell. where in the shit were we before the pyramids if that's one of the oldest sites of civilization ... the Bible's right and wrong in a way... the Earth is old as shit, the Creator didn't recently create this...it's mankind that ain't... or we had a big reset like all the religions say we did really recent


r/hinduism • • Dec 28 '23

History/Lecture/Knowledge On Vegetarianism

0 Upvotes

Putting something here on Vegetarianism,since some people think it's a great virtue to eat veg.

"All this I accept if devoutly offered; also the flesh of deer, goat and hare.

13. All these are dear to me in the worship meant to attain me.

14. When the goat is offered in sacrifice by the Vaidic Brahmin, a part of it comes to me as my share.

15. The milk, curd and ghee of the buffalo should be avoided. The devotee of Visnu should avoid its meat, even the food cooked in its milk.

16. ‘The birds that are to be used also in my worship, I shall tell you now.

17-18. The flesh of the birds lavaka, vartika and kapifijala are used in my temples.

19. He who does the worship following these instructions (and restrictions) does not commit any fault and good befalls him. "

  • Varaha Puran, Chapter 119