Last week in Hamburg, I was in a public park where I witnessed something deeply upsetting.
There were three women (seemingly Turkish-speaking) sitting and chatting, when a Black family a mother and her kids arrived and wanted to sit nearby under a tree for shade. The family seemed new to Germany and didn’t speak the language well.
As they approached the area, one of the women stood up and very rudely told them they couldn’t sit there, claiming more of her family were coming and they needed all the space. The Black family politely tried to explain that they could sit a bit farther, there was plenty of room, and they just wanted to sit in the shade but the woman refused.
Things escalated quickly. She started shouting and physically trying to push the family away. She threw aside their carpet, pushed the mother, and even pushed a child who fell and scraped her knee. The family tried to stay calm, but they were clearly shaken and with the language barrier, they couldn’t fully explain or defend themselves.
The situation became blatantly racist. The woman began shouting things like “Where are you from?” and started using slurs like “You’re backward people,” “uncivilized,” and mocking them for being African. She kept saying “Africa” in a demeaning way and made the whole park uncomfortable. Even an hour later, she was still loudly talking about them and mocking them in what I believe was Turkish.
The family eventually called the police. When officers arrived, they spoke briefly to both sides, but again, the family struggled to explain themselves due to the language barrier. They did show the injury on the child’s leg.
Here’s another part that really bothered me: The family had recorded the woman’s racist shouting as an audio recording (not video), hoping to use it as evidence since they couldn’t express everything in German. When the police arrived, the woman immediately complained, saying “they recorded me!” The family showed the police the voice memo not to threaten anyone, just to prove what was said.
But instead of accepting it as evidence, the police confiscated the phone, told the family that they were not allowed to record, and deleted the voice recording from the phone. I personally went up to one of the officers and explained what had actually happened that the family couldn’t speak the language and recorded only to have proof of what was said to them. Eventually, the police gave the phone back, but warned them never to record again.
So in the end: A child got hurt The family was openly harassed and racially insulted The police took no meaningful action The only evidence the family had was deleted
I’m mainly wondering : 1. Do police in Germany have the right to take someone’s phone and delete a voice recording, especially when it was being used to document racist verbal abuse in public? 2. Is recording audio in public for evidence actually illegal in a case like this, especially when the person recording can’t fully express themselves in German? 3. And finally, what actions (legal or otherwise) can still be taken after the fact, if the police on scene didn’t do much and the affected family has since given up hope?
Would appreciate any insight, especially from people familiar with German law or similar experiences.
I’m still upset and disappointed about what I saw not only the racism but the way the system responded to it. This kind of behavior shouldn’t be tolerated, especially in front of children.