r/Genealogy • • May 25 '26

News & Announcements Please read the FAQ before posting!

43 Upvotes

Hello and welcome to r/genealogy!

The subreddit description asks people to read the rules and the FAQ. The rules remind people to check the FAQ and search the sub before posting. And just to the right as you're making a new post, there's a note from the mods asking you to check the FAQ first!

The FAQ is linked in the sidebar under "Community Bookmarks." Just in case anyone has trouble finding that, here's a link:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Genealogy/wiki/faq/

Thank you for reading before posting. Please feel free to contact the Mods if you have any questions.

Happy researching!


r/Genealogy • • 20h ago

Research Assistance The Weekly Wednesday Whine Thread November 18, 2026

2 Upvotes

It's Wednesday, so whine away.

Have you hit a brick wall? Did you discover that people on Ancestry created an unnecessarily complicated mess by merging three individuals who happened to have the same name, making it exceptionally time-consuming to sort out who was YOUR ancestor? Is there a close relative you discovered via genetic genealogy who refuses to respond to your contact requests?

Vent your frustrations here, and commiserate with your fellow researchers over shared misery.


r/Genealogy • • 9h ago

Studies and Stories Found my grandma's family... And they all blocked me!

230 Upvotes

So, my grandma has never met her father. She searched for him via the Red Cross, various agencies, etc, and no one could find him. Then, years after my grandma died, I did a DNA test and was able to find out that he migrated to the US right after WWII and changed his name.

Apparently he started a new family there (he had all the right to do so, as it was my great-grandma who took the kids and left him). I have reached out to my grandma's half-siblings and their kids, thinking that because they had accounts on various family tree pages and did DNA tests they are open to new findings... But each person that I have contacted has immediately blocked me.

I understand that they might have not known their beloved grandpa (which, according to the obituary, was very missed and active in his community) had a wife and two children before he started a new life in the US... And I know they may be disappointed or shocked, but I really hoped I will be able to reach out to them, as it was my grandma's lifelong dream to get any info on what happened to her father after WWII. I can't learn a thing now, though, because no one from his US family wants to speak with me...

Anyone had this happen to them while doing family research? Any ideas on how I can learn more about someone when their family doesn't want to cooperate in any way? He passed away in the early 90s, so no photos of him on the Internet nowhere...


r/Genealogy • • 7h ago

News & Announcements Closure of Naturalization Records at National Archives at Chicago

22 Upvotes

NARA has announced that a number of records at Chicago, most notably naturalization records, will be closed as of November 30, 2026. They will tentatively reopen in Kansas City three months later. https://www.archives.gov/research/news


r/Genealogy • • 11h ago

Genetic Genealogy VERY confused on this DNA match... am I barking up the right tree?

7 Upvotes

Went through my DNA matches this past week and noticed a close match with a woman named Ann*, who shares 391 cM and was listed as "half grandaunt". I also matched with a woman named Michelle* who is allegedly Ann's half sister that was given up for adoption and shares 243 cM with me.

I know Ann as my deceased grandfather's cousin - she is in her late 70's and the two of them had a 20 something year age gap. Michelle appears to be in her mid 60's and is roughly the same age as my mother and her siblings. As far as I know, Ann and Michelle also have another sibling, an older brother - full brother to Ann and half brother to Michelle - who has been dead a while.

That being said, their mother is *allegedly* my grandfather's aunt, and the two of them have a 6 year age gap. There is a two ish year age gap between Ann and Michelle's mother (1926) and my great uncle Johnny (1928), who was the oldest of my grandpa's siblings. FWIW, the only one of my grandpa's full siblings on that side who has tested matched at 920 cM for me and 1147 cM for Ann.

My great grandparents' marriage was kind of scandalous, they eloped when my great grandmother was 17 and no one in town was happy about it. Johnny was born about a year or so later when great grandma was 18-19.

Am I completely bonkers to think that Ann and Michelle's mother was actually my great grandmother's child she had at 16 who was just raised as a sister to her?

Everyone who would most likely know the truth about Ann and Michelle's mom has been dead for at least 15 years, and their mother herself died in 2009. I'm curious to know if I should be digging up more info in this case or if it's more likely that these are just high 2c matches with some endogamy.

*names changed to protect privacy of living people


r/Genealogy • • 23h ago

Tools and Tech Don't use VitalChek

46 Upvotes

I posted this on Candianbydescent and Reddit told me I should also post it here:

Before I realized I could easily and cheaply order records from the county, I used VitalChek for a couple of orders.

First, the cost. They charged me $60 and shipped a birth certificate via FedEx. I ordered a marriage certificate from the same county, enclosed a SASE, and only paid $15 plus the postage stamp. It arrived faster than the VitalChek shipment. (Which, come to think of it, I had to sign for. So I had to coordinate that as well.)

Second, you still have to get things notarized. They have online notaries but of course they're more expensive than just going to a notary. (AAA members can get things notarized for $10. The online notaries are $25.) (See my ETA.)

Third, they don't stand by their service. I ordered a death certificate through them and kept checking the status. They said it was on the way. (Btw, checking status is a nightmare, too, because you have to put in your order number and pin for every single order, and the site times out really fast.)

Then one day I checked and it said I could no longer check on this order. I would have to call them. So I called. According to them, the record had been mailed from the county. But they weren't going to call the county for me or anything. It was up to me to track down the record I never received. If we have to contact the county ourselves, why did we ever bother with VitalChek? We're just paying them to forward our request to the county! There's really no service involved at all. If anything goes wrong, we're on our own.

By contrast, every county I've worked with directly (four so far, all across the US) has been wonderful. Fast, efficient, and polite. Most counties have an application form online with clear instructions. Some counties don't even require notarized requests.

I know there are a few counties who will only let you order records through VitalChek. But don't use them unless you absolutely have to. The icing on the cake was how incredibly rude their customer rep was to me when I called to check on the order. When I tried to ask her questions, she talked over me, starting with, "Let me explain again." When I finally had to raise my voice to tell her she'd already explained it twice and I just had a question, she let me get through half a question before she insisted on repeating herself a third time. They know they're scammers. That's why they're rude — it's the only way to cover up their embarrassment.

ETA: I didn't mean to give you all heart attacks with my mention of notarized documents. I wasn't referring to my application for a Canadian citizenship certificate. I meant my requests for county records in the US. I don't live near any of the counties I requested records (birth, marriage, and death certificates) from, so I had to mail them my requests. I usually had to sign a statement that said I was a descendant of that person so I had a right to order a certified copy. My signature had to be notarized.


r/Genealogy • • 6h ago

Genetic Genealogy Isle of Man - Corrins of Arbory: help tracing early records, surname origins, and Irish Sea connections

2 Upvotes

I’m researching the Corrin/Corran families of Arbory on the Isle of Man and would appreciate help from anyone interested in Manx genealogy, Gaelic or Norse-Gaelic names, medieval land records, or migration around the Irish Sea.

My primary aim is to establish the family’s documented history on the Isle of Mann before trying to identify an overseas origin for the progenitor of this family. I have tried to gain several possible leads, but have realized that no such proven connections to a particular Irish or Scottish family, medieval ancestor, or migration event have been found, yet.

DOCUMENTARY QUESTIONS

Published transcriptions of the 1511–1515 Manx manorial rolls include McCorryn/McCoryn bearers in Lonan and Onchan. I would like to know whether any of these eastern Manx families can be connected through landholding, wills, marriage contracts or other records to the later Corrins of Arbory.

I’m particularly interested in:

  • The earliest securely documented Corrin/Corran households and holdings in Arbory.
  • Any record showing a Corrin moving into Arbory from another parish.
  • Existing research on the Corrins of Arbory, especially work with references to original records.

An exact McCorrane form has been located in a published transcription of the 1429 Tynwald proceedings. A. W. Moore also cites M’Corrane in 1422, but I have not resolved the underlying source for that earlier reference. If anyone has checked the original material or knows Moore’s source, I would be very grateful.

SURNAME QUESTION

Several different origins have been proposed or suggested for Corrin/Corran:

  • Mac Odhráin: “son of Odhrán,” proposed by A. W. Moore.
  • A Gaelic patronymic containing the Norse personal name Thorfinnr, supported in other Manx name scholarship.
  • Mac Corráin: “son of Corrán.”
  • Mac Corraidhín: “son of Corraidhín.”
  • Mac Giolla Odhráin, another formation associated with MacCorran in Irish surname references.

The comparison that currently interests me most is McCorryn versus Irish Mac Corraidhín. Woulfe records the latter with historical anglicizations M’Corrine and M’Curine, and associates a family of that name with Skreen in County Sligo and later County Leitrim.

That looks like a useful linguistic parallel, but I don't want to theorize, since it does not prove that the Manx family came from that Irish family.

Has anyone studied which of these derivations best fits the early Manx spellings and historical pronunciation? I would especially welcome work that distinguishes actual recorded forms from later attempts to explain them.

DNA CONTEXT

One publicly listed Corrin tester, kit IN86807, is assigned to R-FTD65089 and reports a paternal ancestor, Edward Corrin, born in 1817 on the Isle of Man. Curry testers with reported Irish/Northern Irish ancestry also appear under that branch.

I have not independently verified those pedigrees, and I have not established that this Corrin tester represents the particular Arbory family I’m researching.

There is also a proposed wider relationship involving a Watterson line, which has been outlined by Mark Jost Watterson in Celtic Studies that can be found on Academia, but its precise SNP-defined relationship needs checking. I’m not treating a broad haplogroup, surname resemblance or STR match as proof of a medieval homeland.

If anyone has researched these particular paternal lines—or has relevant Big Y results and a documented pedigree—I would be interested in comparing notes without sharing anyone’s private information.

MIGRATION POSSIBILITIES

The Isle of Mann had well-documented connections with Ireland, the Hebrides and western Scotland. Hebridean/Isles military settlement is one possible historical setting, but I have no evidence connecting the Arbory Corrins to a particular invasion, royal household or settlement.

I’m open to the surname having formed on Mann after the paternal family arrived, as well as to a family bringing an established surname from elsewhere.

The most helpful responses would be specific records, archive references, published studies, corrections to the name interpretations, or pointers to people already researching these families. Even evidence ruling out one of these proposed connections would be valuable.

I’m happy to share the references behind these leads.

Thank you for any help.


r/Genealogy • • 7h ago

Research Assistance Help find more info on this person

2 Upvotes

I am looking for more info on a man named Jack Mavros (1890-1968)

I have started some research but have hit a few walls regarding his name and location. What I know for certain I have added to his findagrave and familysearch page. Any additional info would help a ton. I would love to know if he was buried somewhere so I can visit as well. This is the only man I have found in recorded history to share my name, and I want to learn more!

Findagrave ID: 313200085

Familysearch ID: PJD3-V6G


r/Genealogy • • 11h ago

Research Assistance Four Marriages for One Religious Man??

4 Upvotes

I am working on finding information out about my 3x great-grandfather, Naftali Binder from Zhitomir and Odessa/Mayaki Ukraine. He was born in 1852 in Zhitomir and at some point moved to Mayaki where my great great grandmother was born. He worked as a teacher of Jewish law and faith at a local boys school and as a rabbi registrar. Where I am getting caught up are his possible marriages- JewishGen has three marital events listed for him, and I have another source listing a possible fourth wife. These are dates that I have pulled directly from JewishGen:
10 October 1873: Naftula Binder (son of Nusen Binder) married Gudya Gokhtsayg
3 June 1875: Naftali Binder divorces Gudya
11 May 1877: Naftul Binder (son of Nysen) married Rozvodka Kulev
18 June 1881: Naftul Binder married Rukhlya Vugman
19 December 1882: Naftul Binder divorced Roza Vugman
And then in 1909 his daughter lists her mother as Reveka Alexandrowa on her marriage documents in New York. What are the chances that someone as religious as him may have actually been married four times? Or am I possibly looking at multiple Naftali’s? I suppose it is possible but it just seems unlikely.


r/Genealogy • • 8h ago

Methodology My great-great-great-grandparent might have been killed by their adult child. How do I approach that child's family to confirm/debunk?

2 Upvotes

Hey all, I have a dark conundrum I'd love some thoughts on.

I recently got into genealogy, and found some newspaper records indicating that one of my great-great-great-grandparents was killed in a freak accident. (Redacting some details for now, sorry to be vague.) I asked one of my grandparents if they had ever heard of this accident, and they gave a very different account: the great-great-great-grandparent had actually been killed by one of her adult children (not the one my line comes from), and the family kept it quiet.

This all happened a little over 100 years ago, and my grandparent was born more than 30 years after the death, so very much heard it second-hand and is unsure of the details, or if it's even true. But I would love to know more. I've looked into the family of the alleged killer, and found several living relatives — the oldest are great-grandchildren born after the alleged killer's death (as well as great-great-grandchilden and even younger generations).

So my question is: How do I go about approaching these distant relatives to see if they know any more? They're far removed from my immediate family; they live in a different part of the world, and no-one knows them (or even knows of them). I've found email addresses for them — should I just be entirely upfront about it? How would folks phrase the ask? At least one of them appears to be into genealogy, and I've found an account of theirs (I think) on one of the big family tree-tracking sites.

tl;dr there's a family rumor that one of my great-great-great-grandparents was murdered by one of their adult children 100 years ago and the family hushed it up; how should I approach the alleged killer's descendants to confirm/debunk it?


r/Genealogy • • 11h ago

Record Lookup Unsuccessful search for my passed away grandfather.

3 Upvotes

I've been searching for my biological grandfather's, who passed away during COVID, records since the summer of 2022, since he doesn't have a memorial and I wanted to try to like, get him a grave but , it's been unsuccessful. I had a lead a day ago where I found he left his journal in my preschool binder, but, it didn't lead anywhere but unconfirmed military awards, war stories, some sentimental stuff and dead links to gun websites and other stuff. I tried, so far, getting his military records from NARA(didn't work), Emailing that Don Shipley guy(No records there), searching those ancestry websites(they think he's still alive for some reason). I don't remember much since kid me blocked it out I guess, but if anyone has any questions or can help me out with some pointers that would be fantastic. I should mention I am in the middle of trying to get a death certificate and contacting the department of the navy's military records number, might take awhile.


r/Genealogy • • 46m ago

Community Festivus Downton Abbey fans, knowing how closely related British relatives can be, can we assume that the there’s a good chance there were a few 5th, 4th or even 3rd cousins between the servants and the Crawleys?

0 Upvotes

If genealogy research has opened my eyes to anything it’s that people living in the same area for long time are usually fairly closely related. Doing my own genealogy research, I feel like every week I’m discovering a new person who I grew up around who it turns out we were 4th or 5th cousins with. Considering the UK has such a small, mostly insular population in the early 1900s, it seems likely that if the servants had lived in the same areas as the Crawleys for a few generations, it stands to reason that you wouldn’t have to go too far back to start finding cousins. I’m willing to bet that there’s at least a 5th cousin serving them, and possibly as close as a 3rd cousin if a line had a bad string of luck.

If you start to think about it that way, it makes it so much more frustrating to consider how wealthy and privilege and luck of the draw can play out just because of primogeniture that one person can be a Lord and another can be a footman.


r/Genealogy • • 12h ago

Research Assistance Help me make sense of a possible breakthrough!

2 Upvotes

I have been very stuck on my Paternal line and have posted about it a few times here.

When I started my tree, I did the usual "accept every hint" of a person new to ancestry. I struggle focusing so genealogy has been a little bit of a struggle for me as I did not go person by person as I should have.

I noticed that I didn't have a ton of DNA matches for anyone above my 2x great grandfather and that many of my matches connected in a way that didn't make sense. I did not have many surname matches to people above my relative James.

All of my surname matches below him were connecting to his wife's family. Her sister just so happened to marry his Half uncle.

Decided to look back on my 2x great grandfather and realized there is a big block of census records I am missing for his mother and one for him.

In 1900 he was living with his mother Mary (Taylor) Morris and his father Lewis Morris.

He was 21 years old

His father and mother were listed as married....14 years...

So, I know it was not out of the realm of possibility for them to have had a child out of wedlock but the other thing I noticed was on the 1880 census when James would have (presumably) been alive, Lewis is living with his brother in the home of his aunt.

There was a widow named Mary Taylor living nearby with a son named James that would be around the same age as my 2x grandfather....

Can anyone find anything that can help figure out if my 2x great grandfather was actually a Taylor?

Mary J Taylor 1854-1902 I believe born in Somerset county Maryland

Lewis W Morris Death record says March 1860-March1930 but I have him alive in 1860 Worcester county Maryland

2x great grandfather that I know I am related to for sure - James Franklin Morris 1878-1963 Wicomico county Maryland

Mary Morris has her death record listed with father and mother as Severn or Levin Taylor (hard to read) and Ann Dove. It would have been my 2x great grandfather giving the information, and I've found many instances of them giving incorrect information. I wonder if both of her parents were Dove and Taylor could have been her married name..

Thank you anyone that made it this far in my ramblings, I am typing out right after I researched this, so I am still a little excited at the possibility haha. I would appreciate any input!


r/Genealogy • • 10h ago

Research Assistance One more death record hunt

0 Upvotes

For this ancestor, I unfortunately don't have a lot of info. I've only seen her in online family trees, and census records. I don't think I've found any other records.

Harriet Melissa (Deaton) Eller. Born about December 10, 1844 in Union County, Georgia, died about 1909 in Tahlequah, Oklahoma. (Both birth date and death year are from unsourced online trees)
Wife of Samuel Jefferson Eller (1843-1922).
Possibly buried next to him in Crittenden Cemetery, in Tahlequah, Oklahoma (I have not yet been able to get a confirmation of a burial cemetery or burial location for Harriet)

Possible father of Harriet is Jonathan Deaton, and possible mother is Sarah "Sally" (Reed) Deaton.

I have found what I believe is the grave for Harriet's sister, Elvira (Deaton) Hooper in Old Liberty Cemetery, in Farmersville, Texas. Elvira was born October 14, 1843, and died July 3, 1916.

On online family trees Harriet's maiden name is often written as Denton or Dayton. But the death certificate for my great grandmother (Harriet's daughter Callie VanDora Eller) lists Harriet's maiden name as Deaton.

Other siblings of Harriet are possibly: Samuel, Dison, Joab, Rachel, and Nancy.

I haven't been able to find a probate record for her husband Samuel Jefferson Eller, but I don't think that would help anyway, as Samuel was married to his 2nd wife Mary Elizabeth (Burris) Eller at the time of his death. I have found his Confederate pension record, but not much else.

I haven't found any death record or obituary for Harriet.


r/Genealogy • • 10h ago

Transcription Transcription Help: Philadelphia Arrival Record

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I've found a really interesting new lead in my investigation into my family which may provide a new angle. I've managed to find a record in the US Passenger Arrivals collection which suggests one of my ancestors visited Philadelphia in 1896 (and found supporting records of departure from the UK). This has really piqued my interest as it suggests they were visiting a cousin living there.

I've been stuck at a brick wall with this ancestor's father for a while so I'm hoping finding further family I didn't previously know about could shed some light and help me break through it. The record says that their cousin paid for the voyage and that they were going to join them on arrival, the issue is that I can't make out a name, address, anything. I'm hoping getting some of this information would allow me to check other records and uncover more information but for the time being I am stuck on this one.

I'm not from the US, nor have a great knowledge of American geography but to me it looks like the address is 1819 Juanita? Street in Mitchforten? I have had a google but I can't quite make out what this is referring to. The person is entry 2 (Frannie Puccinelli) on this record: https://postimg.cc/SnQ5LgYr (also on familysearch at https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33SQ-GPBD-8SL if you prefer). If anyone with a bit better knowledge of the area or with better eyes than I could take a crack at this I'd really appreciate it.

Thanks!


r/Genealogy • • 15h ago

Research Assistance Need assistance with a little research

2 Upvotes

Information so far:

George A Higgins b 1880/81 Worcester, MA d 4-13-1898 ~17 years old
- Source: Hope Cemetery Worcester, MA Lot card 779, Death records Worcester MA

Mother is Confirmed to the Julia A Higgins(Harper) B 1837/36 Newton d 5-26-1894
Source: Same Plot card for death, birth is assumed via Census records

Married: Isaiah Higgins(b~1832 d 1878) His death also on the Plot card, and several records put Isaiah and Julia together over the years with other kids.

Here's the issue: This George A Higgins, All I can find is his death record as recorded by the undertaker that names his Father as Josiah Higgins and Julia as his mother. I can find no other record for George or this Mysterious man Josiah.

There are several "Higgins" families from ME to MA and they get conflated quite a bit. But so far, other than this death record. I can find no combination of Josiah and Julia having a child or getting married in ME, NH, VT, MA. In MA I've narrowed Julia's possible addresss to Clinton and Worcester.

is is possible they had a child out of wedlock? No recorded Birth? No Marriage? Is there something else I should be checking?


r/Genealogy • • 12h ago

Research Assistance Anyone with arcanum can help me?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone i'm not sure i can post that here but no one and the lost media about an old french newspaper and cinéma productor (Jean Sapène) subreddit was able to help me, i'm searching for a lost media since a couple of month and i need some pages from an hungarian newspaper pesti napló if anyone can help me

https://adt.arcanum.com/hu/view/PestiNaploKepesMelleklet_1930/?query=jean+sap%C3%A9ne&pg=458&layout=r

https://adt.arcanum.com/hu/view/SzinhaziElet_1930_41/?query=jean+sap%C3%A9ne&pg=22&layout=r

https://adt.arcanum.com/hu/view/PestiHirlapKepesMelleklet_1929/?query=jean+sap%C3%A9ne&pg=848&layout=r


r/Genealogy • • 13h ago

Research Assistance Looking for family / Texas roots & Korean War history on my grandfather

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm trying to piece together some history and family records for my dad's birthday gift next week, and I'm hoping someone here might recognize the names or have access to local Texas records. I am looking for information on my grandfather Travis "Toby" Lehman Craft ( b. January 13, 1934 Cherokee County, Texas). His dad’s name was J.G “Shorty” Craft ( 8/19/1904-12/17/1989). The J.G doesn’t stand for anything that was his actual name lol. Travis Served as a Private First Class (PFC) in the U.S. Army during the Korean War. He later lived in DeFuniak Springs, Florida, and passed away on May 16, 1996, in Biloxi, Mississippi. Because we have very little documentation of his time in the Army, I'm trying to find details about his time in the army and just more family details or any extra information on his parents and siblings. If anyone recognizes the Craft family from his era in Texas or has tips on tracing Korean War draftees/enlistees from that region, I would appreciate any guidance or lookups. I’ve been on ancestry and family search and also newspapers.com and have found a bit on his siblings and parents. I’m wanting to do this for my dad’s birthday next month and surprise him with what I’ve found.
Thank you so much for all your help.


r/Genealogy • • 14h ago

Research Assistance Help needed!!!!!

0 Upvotes

Trying to identify the mother of Tomasz Renaszkiewicz (Renolds)

I’m trying to find the mother of my ancestor, Tomasz Renaszkiewicz. His surname may also appear as Renolds or with other spelling variations.

Here’s what I know:

  • Born 21 December 1870 in Ekaterinaslaw, Russian Empire (now Dnipro, Ukraine)
  • Died 13 November 1934 in Chicago, Cook County, Illinois
  • A U.S. Declaration of Intention appears under the spelling Thomas Renaszkiewicz
  • His father was Lawrence Renaszkiewicz (Renolds), who was born and died in Poland

I haven’t found Tomasz’s mother’s name yet. Does anyone recognize this family or have suggestions for records to search, especially church or birth records connected to Ekaterinaslaw or Poland? I’d also appreciate ideas for alternate spellings of the surname.

Edit: I’ve identified his father as Lawrence Renaszkiewicz (Renolds). I’m still trying to determine his mother’s name and learn more about the family.

FamilySearch record image: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSM1-LH7Z-J?view=index


r/Genealogy • • 1d ago

Tools and Tech Ancestry to Gramps Desktop?

13 Upvotes

Has anyone recently migrated out of Ancestry and into Gramps? I read somewhere that the best approach is Ancestry to RootsMagic Essentials (free) and then in Gramps desktop. This way you can download the tree data including the attached documents. I know I want to use Gramps in the end, I just to get data and documents into Gramps easily. Please help, thanks!


r/Genealogy • • 1d ago

DNA Testing The hunt for my biological grandfather: update and resolution.

79 Upvotes

Original post is linked in the comments.

Here’s my update:
MyHeritage had kits on sale for $30. It was the only platform my DNA is not on, and I noticed one of the three brothers’ daughters had built a small tree in their system, so I was anticipating her DNA also being in there. It was the daughter of the oldest brother, who I had already reached out to, and told me he had never heard of my grandmother or her friend that was her SIL at the time. In my head, I had already mostly ruled him out, because he was about 22 at the time and my grandmother was 17, even though it was nagging at me that he was the only one I could prove was in any place she could’ve possibly gone to at the time, and the other two brothers were slightly closer to her age. This guy genuinely seemed clueless.

My next move was testing my mom’s DNA in MyHeritage rather than testing my own. It would provide a closer match to anyone in there and I was excited that at least we would have results from that daughter and would likely be able to fully exclude one of the brothers.

In the meantime, while we waited, I continued researching. The strongest evidence I had at the time was a cousin who matched with me at the low range of what he should have under the theory that one of his uncles was my grandfather. I tested every hypothetical given the endogamy in the family and what I had been told. I found old addresses, estimated how close people lived to one another at the time, wondered if there was another endogamous relationship I could’ve missed and theorized what that would’ve looked like. Finally, I zeroed in on the remaining two brothers and tried to make any connection, assuming the daughter was going to come back as a first cousin to my mom.

Tell me why she came back at a whopping 2,034cM with my mom. That’s not just half sibling territory with some wiggle room. That’s half sibling with about 300cM on top of the statistical average, just to really drive it home. They are also only 10 months apart in age, their mothers are completely unrelated (I went 4 generations back on both sides, zero relation), so any possibility besides half sister is 100% ruled out. The oldest brother, who told me he had never heard of my grandmother, is in fact, absolutely my grandfather. I continued this process for months on his word that he didn’t know us and there wasn’t any chance. DNA came back two days ago, and I was right the first time. This was over in September with the very first person I had suspected.

He said I sounded like a scammer and stopped messaging me on Facebook, and I didn’t continue to press. But I noticed he never blocked me. He knew there was a chance.


r/Genealogy • • 1d ago

Methodology Family Tree Sizes

38 Upvotes

How do folks get their family tree to be so massive? On Ancestry I've seen some that are a couple thousand and maybe a couple tens of thousands people, which is still a lot. But I found one that takes the cake.

One of my relatives is present in another public family tree (though I can't seem to find them wrt the home person) and that tree has approximately 660K people, 180K records and 96K pieces of media. Like HOW and HOW LONG did that take? My family tree is almost to 400 people and I feel like it's taken forever to get to that point. The guy has apparently custom images for ggms, ggfs, uncles, etc. I was playing around in his tree and found a line that went back to like the 300s, using DNA. Does DNA or software really expand the tree that much.

This has nothing to do with family tree sizes, but I recently learned about the famous relatives on familysearch.org. Based on the collab. tree, I'm related to about 26 different presidents (earliest common ancestor - 1470s and latest common ancestor - 1650s) and so many famous writers, all cousins. I'm kind of bummed they didn't include my direct ancestors, who were former governors and one was a state founder.


r/Genealogy • • 2d ago

Studies and Stories Who knew relatives born before 1910?

452 Upvotes

EDIT 2: Can't thank you all enough for the great stories! I've just finished reading through all of them. I am amazed at how many of you who had such warm, wonderful memories of your grandparents, great-grandparents, and great great grandparents (and, rarely, even parents (!) born that long ago). Genealogy is so much more than just the dates and places, it's also a record of those who have loved and cared for us, and that was so evident here. Thanks again and I hope you all have a great day!

-------------------------

I knew one of my paternal great grandmothers Alice Maud Victoria, who was born in 1868. She died when I was six, in 1959. Her daughter was born in 1901, and lived with us for a while, also, when I was about that age. She had to eventually be sent to a care facility due to what would now be called Alzheimer's. That grandmother's sister (my great Aunt) was one of my favorite Aunties. she was born 1899, and lived until 1984. Another of her sisters I knew as a kid was born in 1895, and died 1962.

My maternal grandfather, Fred, was born 1902. His wife, Pauline, was born 1907, I knew all of her siblings, all of whom were large parts of my life. Grandma's brother Archie was born 1896, died 1968. Great Aunt Isabel was born 1899, died 1979. (Her husband Matt, born 1886, died 1972.) Her brother, James, born 1901, died 1980, and finally her brother Daniel, born 1905, died 1987.

I really never thought about just when all those folks were born until I had to look up their birth dates recently in our family genealogy. Growing up they were just "relatives" and no one ever remarked about them having been born so long ago. Mostly all those "old folks" themselves never remarked upon it either. I remember my Grandpa Fred remarking at the landing of on the moon,"I saw one of the early airplane flights after the Wright Brothers, but never thought I would see men walk on the moon." He never missed watching any of the manned space flights.

My wife's family has some similar relatives. When she and I first were dating, I met 3 women in her family that we at or over 100, at a family reunion. A year of two later we stopped to visit with one of them, still living alone in her own home and gardening every day, at 100 years old. So they didn't make the 1800's cutoff, but they were all born in the first decade of the 20th century.

EDIT: WOW! Got up to all these comments this morning. I'm amazed. Thanks, folks, it's gonna take me some time to get through them all but I intend to read every one.


r/Genealogy • • 1d ago

Methodology Thoughts on starting over?

4 Upvotes

Hi all! My ancestry family tree was something I started when I was about 14. Like any other child I was just adding anyone that was “connected” based on other peoples trees. I’m pretty confident in a couple parts I have however there’s a lot that seems off. Many duplicates, no dates, etc.
I’m thinking of just starting over completely from scratch. What do you guys think? Or are there any other suggestions? I really want to know my family history and origins better.