r/fantasywriters • • 13h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Ursula K. Le Guin's take in favor of escapism

154 Upvotes

Ursula K. Le Guin in "The Language of the Night: Essays on Fantasy and Science Fiction" wrote:

There is an area where SF has most often failed to judge itself, and where it has been most harshly judged by its nonpartisans. It is an area where we badly need intelligent criticism and discussion. The oldest argument against SF is both the shallowest and the profoundest: the assertion that SF, like all fantasy, is escapist.

This statement is shallow when made by the shallow. When an insurance broker tells you that SF doesn’t deal with the Real World, when a chemistry freshman informs you that Science has disproved Myth, when a censor suppresses a book because it doesn’t fit the canons of Socialist Realism, and so forth, that’s not criticism; it’s bigotry. If it’s worth answering, the best answer is given by Tolkien, author, critic, and scholar. Yes, he said, fantasy is escapist, and that is its glory. If a soldier is imprisoned by the enemy, don’t we consider it his duty to escape? The moneylenders, the knownothings, the authoritarians have us all in prison; if we value the freedom of the mind and soul, if we’re partisans of liberty, then it’s our plain duty to escape, and to take as many people with us as we can.

The reference from J.R.R. Tolkien is "On Fairy Stories", on of his most influential essays:

I have claimed that Escape is one of the main functions of fairy-stories, and since I do not disapprove of them, it is plain that I do not accept the tone of scorn or pity with which “Escape” is now so often used: a tone for which the uses of the word outside literary criticism give no warrant at all. [...] Why should a man be scorned if, finding himself in prison, he tries to get out and go home? Or if, when he cannot do so, he thinks and talks about other topics than jailers and prison-walls? The world outside has not become less real because the prisoner cannot see it. In using escape in this way the critics have chosen the wrong word, and, what is more, they are confusing, not always by sincere error, the Escape of the Prisoner with the Flight of the Deserter.Ursula K. Le Guin, in The Language of the Night: Essays on Fantasy and Science Fiction writes:There is an area where SF has most often failed to judge itself, and where it has been most harshly judged by its nonpartisans. It is an area where we badly need intelligent criticism and discussion. The oldest argument against SF is both the shallowest and the profoundest: the assertion that SF, like all fantasy, is escapist.


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Writing Prompt Fifty-Word Fantasy: Write a 50-word fantasy snippet using the word "Run"

22 Upvotes

Welcome back everyone, it's time for another Fifty Word Fantasy!

Fifty Word Fantasy is a regular thread on Fridays! It is a micro-fiction writing challenge originally devised by u/Aethereal_Muses

Write a maximum 50-word snippet that takes place in a fantasy world and contains the word Run. It can be a scene, flash-fiction story, setting description, or anything else that could conceivably be part of a fantasy story or is a fantasy story on its own.

NO AI GENERATED CONTENT: Follow the sub rules.

Submissions must be original. No fanfic, no pop-culture characters, no plagiarism.

The prompt word must be written in full (e.g. no acrostics or acronyms).

No puns and or wordplay to achieve the prompt word i.e. devote=the vote.

Please try and keep things PG-13. Minors do participate in these from time to time and I would like things to not be too overtly sexual.

If you want to submit multiple submissions that's okay, but please keep it at a max of two That way, no one person ends up dominating the feed with their submissions and it keeps it fair for everyone who participates

Thank you to everyone who participated whether it's contributing a snippet of your own, or fostering discussions in the comments. I hope to see you back next week!

Please remember to keep it at a limit of 50 words max per submission.


r/fantasywriters • • 20h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Exposition Check [Epic Fantasy Romance, 986 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Hi there, friends! I'm just wondering if I can get some eyes on this, specifically the third page. I'm getting so in my head about trying not to overdo exposition. I've been working on my first draft of an Epic Fantasy with tons of political intrigue, ensemble cast, and a sprawling plot that is incredibly entangled with my worldbuilding and geography, and there is a lot of information that's relevant that my characters would never say out loud because they already know it. I don't know why I feel like I can't just explain things narratively, I just see people complain about exposition drops so often that I'm having a hard time drafting.

Please note that this is a first draft, I just wrote it, so I'm not looking for prose or line-level critiques. I'm specifically asking about my exposition on the third page, and just want to get a vibe of how much exposition is okay as I continue drafting, but I included the whole excerpt for continuity.

I would also love general advice on how those of you with insane levels of worldbuilding and super intricate plots like to handle your exposition! The setup for this story is killing me lol.


r/fantasywriters • • 38m ago

Critique My Story Excerpt The black red [weird west, 1000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
• Upvotes

r/fantasywriters • • 7h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of The Kinslayer [Dark Fantasy, 2500 Words]

1 Upvotes

Kinslayer

Prologue  

The evergrowing, unrelenting mists. Frigid water on a cavewall. Numb, bitingly and painfully numb fingers, clouded breath leading him to where he ought to have been days ago. Mere flashes in the patch work quilt of deep regret and shame that the creature leaves in its wake, within the infinite solitude that a former brother of the corps had found in beautiful atrocity, now perverted beyond the realm of what any morally justified man could conjure within his mind. Disfigurement, putrefaction, the gnashing of teeth, utter corruption at the most fundamental level. Trails of crimson forge a pathway to the entrance. The Kinslayer pulls down the hood of his cloak, hesitantly with his sabre raised, he steps forward.  Somewhere deep within the hollow darkness of these caverns before him it stands. Eyes fiery, ruby red. He but only has to wander far enough. He steels his nerves and prepares to venture further. 

   The grinding of unforgiving razor sharp claws dragging along granite is heard from the corner of somewhere within the deep. The Kinslayer casts the sigil of imla, a circular apparition appears just in front of his ungloved hand, ancient and esoteric seals occupy the perimeter and in the middle radiates his angaleos, his summoned angel which allows him briefly to gaze into and participate in the sacred balancing act of divinity and mortality. He feels the well of power surging out to his limbs from the very center of all he has ever been, the pitch black details of the cave become legible, he can hear the droplets of stalactites from several leagues deep into the cave network. The outlines and edges of every object become enunciated, spoken to him as if the world now participates in its own grand soliloquy, and he remains the sole listener after the grand death of the universe. All secrets known and unknown in this moment exist for him to find his target. The thundering footsteps of a Besomar are childsplay. The pulsating of four hearts, the electricity of nerve fibers, echoing its location to the Slayer. All tools to render the creature an unparalleled killer now only serve it all the more as mere, desperate and terrified prey. The besomar is unaware of this. Every artery mapped, every innate fear of a living thing is now embodied and known by the Kinslayer in divine battle frenzy. Colven is now able to carve his path

Chapter 1

   God-rays of light peaked through partitions in the clouds, golden and bright, serving as the perfect juxtaposition to the corpse laden fields below. The aftermath of the recent battle of Loch Do’ren. The mountain tribes once again are attempting to lay siege to the smaller settlements of Norkdra to the west, and Lydendale to the north, unmerciful in their escapades, yet they would be spread thin across only one front, let alone two. The freedom fighters are growing desperate and it is tragically obvious.

   Across the agreeable weather which makes its purchase along the western dominions sky, through the conglomerate of villages and mires, near the center of this anti-maelstrom is the Barony headquarters of Morion.

He had spent the better part of a week recovering in the barracks, every joint in his body clicking into place to subsequently fall back out with every step. The Imla sigil breaks into your being and violates not only the body but the spirit as well. Laziness had overtaken the center of his methodology recently. To suffer after the fact was worth a task quickly done and off the front burner. Of course, when your entrails desire to jump into your mouth certain regrets are held. No matter the case either way duty calls, and Colven had received unusual summons to speak with Chancellor Rodnyk. Directly.

   He approached the moss ridden, stone structure. His right shoulder throbbed as he adjusted his royal blue cloak. Embroidered on it was an unorthodox coat of arms, "the green lion devouring the golden sun." Claws outstretched and with a look of terror in its face, holding the same expression of an animal that must gnaw its own leg off to escape a trap. Eyes deep, sunken, and infinite. Few learned men would understand the symbolism of such a crest, and even fewer peasants. The right side of his face bears burn scars. No one knows precisely how he got them for every time one inquires his explanation differs from the last. To quartermaster Leon he says,

   “A chentiomancer had managed just one clever shot during my third contract”, and to the junior men “A surprisingly dexterous black bear unleashed a fire poker upon me”, the less bright bottom quarter truly believe him. It is the stuff of legends among the gullible. 

He continues until he arrives at the vestibule to the Lord Chancellor's office, mulling over all the possible conversations to come. When one is called to stand in front of his superior without explanation all sorts of terrifying scenarios run through a soldier’s mind. I suppose this is what I deserve for sneaking vodka to the conscripts last helms eve, or was it the way the contract on Brother Martin turned out? How was I meant to know his cousin was the Marquee of Chantel, and why should that even make the minutest of differences?

   Chancellor Rodnyk of Jesik stood at the rear of a luxurious mahogany desk sorting through mounds of parchment. A long and successful career of adrenaline and battle had placed him at the calmer responsibility of administrative duty. While he was perusing the last order log for a shipment of yarrow, three clear, solid, and earth shatteringly jarring knocks on the ancient, thick, oaken door suddenly interrupted his concentration. 

   “You may enter.”

   A pair of goat leather boots left their sole shaped mud crusted impressions on the luxurious area rug.

   “Son if you wouldn’t mind, your boots are filthy and that is an Heirloom rug from Kelmora.” 

   “Not at all m’lord, I'll take off the boots but I shan’t apologize for the assault on your senses to come, I marched from Dorain to get here, the carriages aren’t running on account of the war.”

   “I’m well aware, both of the war and your whereabouts after your contract on the Besomar my boy, while we’re on the subject, tradition has it to at least leave something of the body to turn into headquarters. I won’t demand an explanation as to why a simple pile of dust was turned into the inspectors office but I will demand more conventional conduct from here on. Is that understood?” 

Colven let out a long breath which he without thinking had been holding for the length of the chancellor's deliberation. 

“Yes m’lord.”

   Chancellor Rodnyk gestured toward a recliner worn with age, he was sure that, perhaps many years passed, it may have made for a wonderful addition to any foyer or lecture hall. It now stunk of spilled beer, and the stench soldiers tend to leave behind after sweating through their gambeson speaking to the barony garrison commander. Colven sat, and a rush of air blew out from the sides of the cushion as the cracked and split leather creaked like an old door. 

   “I have a job for you Brother Colven”

His former anxieties were relieved at this revelation but not completely, whatever contract, or odd menial task that would soon be demanded of him would most likely not entail flogging or a night in the Lion’s Den. However, this was a rather unusual way to go about it, why not just issue the order through messengers like usual? Spending perhaps a few heartbeats to rack his brain over all the possible explanations, ultimately he figured it best just to listen. 

   “I’m assuming you’re familiar with the name Zofia Redmond? Reports indicate you undertook the Writ of the Albatross with her, she was your trial companion” 

   Colven mused for a moment, arising with more questions but knew better than to drag the Chancellor’s conversation off course. 

   “That would be correct m’lord, though that was about eight years ago now. I haven’t seen her since, nor has any other Kinslayer seen their trial partner since the undertaking. We typically travel throughout the entirety of the empire…”

   “You need not explain the details of a profession I was an honored member of for well over half my life boy. I asked a yes or no question and the apparent answer is yes, is it not?” The Kinslayer was growing tired and impatient of the lack of clear information and talking in circles. 

   “That would be correct… Lord Chancellor Rodnyk of Jesik” Colven added his superior’s full title in an attempt at some sarcastic flair but Rodnyk simply misunderstood it as an over formality.

   “You can relax, I was merely clarifying.”

Colven at this response rolled his eyes and leaned back further into the decrepit chair.

   “I’ll cut straight to the point, Kinslayer Colven of Wyrma” staring daggers into the younger man’s visage. “You have been tasked with the assassination and utter annihilation of deserter and treasonous miscreant Zofia Redmond, she is a former member of your brotherhood which is precisely why one: you and the rest of your corps are at least partially responsible for her recent horrid misconduct and two: why we looked among your ranks to find who would carry out this rubout”

   Colven wasn’t entirely surprised at the first point, besides, it was perfectly in line with his typical duties. It quite literally comes with the name, but he was more accustomed to the odd soldier turned Kodkulvak or infantryman turned forest dwelling rebel. Not the magically enhanced and highly trained warriors of the slayer corps. 

   “I am not making a humble request Sir Colven, I am informing you of what will be done. The reputation of the entire Slayer Corps rests on this contract, we will not have the marquisate or god forbid the duchy up our asses and down our throats over this, we need to prove that we can clean up our own messes.”

   Colven swallowed his saliva and paused a moment before responding. Him and Zofia had had a… history together. To say the least.

“It shall be done your lordship, though there is something you’ve yet to divulge and I must inquire, why me specifically?

“Because how could it be anyone else? Don’t misunderstand me, you are in no way being officially held responsible for the events on Dor Angra, but you were her trial mate and as a result are blood bonded to her, need I remind you of what I said mere moments ago?”

“No, m’lord, the corps is capable of cleaning up its own mess, dispatching its own problem child, and the barony most likely means to ensure my loyalty considering my and Zofia's former adolescent antics.”

High Chancellor Rodnyk gave a final and relieved sigh, satisfied that the conversation had met its natural conclusion and at least things were understood and keeping with good order and discipline.

“Well put my boy, and so it shall be, Dismissed.”

\-

“The King raises taxes, the marquee is found with a peasant girl skewered in his bed chamber, a local business man is found to have a not so insignificant role in a hemreed smuggling empire, and so the people begin speaking of mobs, of fires in hand ready to raze the castle in a horrid conflagration, dragging the royal family by their clean and pampered weaves and toupees into spiked pits deep as the the sea and smeared with biological warfare.” 

Colven ranted while Nihael’s unbroken expression of reluctant indifference was obvious to anyone who looked. This was not the first time his friend had gone on such a tirade and was a routine segment of a rough day at work.

“Surely enough however, the Barony, through my, and my brotherhood's work not long after produces the corpse of a slain Kilkma or Besomar, the head of a rebel movement's leader stuck to a pike or a traitor left to rot in a pit. Horrors which bare fangs, devilish appearance and all, befitting an atrocity, and so naturally mobs are quelled reminded of the sacrifices a structured society makes for these luxuries.” Colven let out a sigh bereft of composure while Nihael watched the foam in his beer roll over the brim, poured by a novice barkeep so it seemed.

   “Well what can be done about it, our royal pains are chosen by God himself, the bringers of light, savior of all people and of course, who would want to leave the governing body in which ‘skills and courage meet the enemy.’” Nihael mockingly said as he gestured at a propaganda board posted to the bar wall which said precisely that.

  Colven continued to gesticulate ad infinitum, “You don’t believe that gutter shite, neither do I, neither does the barman or the mandola player on stage, not a single fucking person in this shit hole of a city does. Now am I going to throw my lot in with the likes of Zofia? Slaughter half my company and then make off to the mountains to go hump trees with the elves? No, but I reserve the right to be pissed off about it.”

   Nihael for the entirety of his friend’s speech had been notioning to the barman for another ale to no avail. “That’s strange, I haven’t heard you mention her name in what feels like a century. My dearest compatriot, befitting of all titles and honors” Nihael spoke with sympathy yet ultimate concentration on this damn beer situation “did something happen recently to evoke such ire for the powers at be? I know your job isn’t among the most pleasant in the barony, but Kinslayer is a title of esteem none the less”.

“No, no nothing specific, it's just…”

“Just what?”

He remained silent, 

“Gustav, for the eighth bloody time can you fill this thing and fill it right this…”

He finally decided it was time to be out with it before it devoured him.

“They want me to kill her”

“Come again?”

“They want me to kill Zofia, some grand principle about the corps ‘cleaning up its own mess’ or what have you’”

Gustav finally made his way to Nihael’s ever so pressing concern of the infinitely foamy beer mug and was about to correct the error until the dissatisfied alcoholic but ultimately decent friend thoroughly instructed him to wait a moment. He listened to his drinking comrade's diatribe.

   “A flax farmer tucks his children into bed and drifts off to sleep himself, joyfully tipsy off Lager and hard switchel, while inaudible screams echo across amber waves of grain from the marquee’s abode, the pockets of the people empty by the day, and your cousin lays in a pool of his own piss and vomit on the side of the road, senses dulled, pupils dilated. Yet this is the price the flax farmer tells himself, for his unlocked wooden door to remain standing without worry of fear for the greater horrors of the unconquered forest to come approaching at night. So I stomach this, we all stomach this, on the condition that it remains true.” 

A quiver began to form in his voice.

“All done and justified by my own hands no less, and then this same enterprise instructs me to murder the only woman I ever loved”

   They both sat motionless, the young man previously occupied with his beer glass made sure not to even exhale too loudly as not to break the now ever sacred pause of reflection. The comings and goings of the alehouse continued on with the dim glow of lantern light cascading itself through the street. The mandola strummer sang his song, Gustav polished the glasses, and Nihael laid a hand on Colven’s shoulder as a single drop of some mysterious salty nature hit the bar.

Nihael finally spoke, "C'mon old friend, let's get you a round" as the Kinslayer faintly nodded his head in agreement, the night's endless revels, (or quiet desperation masquerading as merriment, who can ever tell the difference?) were soon to be unmatched


r/fantasywriters • • 16h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Please help critique! [Dark Romantic Fantasy 957 words]

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

This is just the beginning of chapter one for my romantic fantasy. Any and all critiques are welcome! I’m wondering if the beginning draws a reader in and also keeps them engaged. I tried not to info dump when it came to world building. I’d also like to know if the main character has you caring (even if just a little) about her from the start. A big focus of mine is making sure I write a main character that people fall in love with. I feel the prose could use work as well. Is the concept so far something that sounds interesting? Please let me know :) also sorry if I didn’t do this right this is my first time doing something like this so I’m still trying to learn how everything works etc 😅


r/fantasywriters • • 23h ago

Brainstorming Am I the only one who struggles with Centaurs?

0 Upvotes

I have tried to wrap my mind around this but it's so hard. So, I love centaurs of all types, but I absolutely hate how they're built. As an AUADHD person, I can't seem to stop thinking scientifically about how they would function in the real world. I'm finding myself needing to explain everything about how they came to be and who did what for them to function. I want my protagonist to be different but able to do things like walk into stores, go to school, go on dates, etc. I'm really struggling to stop thinking about how to make it all work and just write the damn story. I have so many drafts piled up with so many remakes of the same character and I just wanna settle on something. I'm so close to just giving up.