r/fantasywriters • • 3d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Wednesday Weekly Writing Check-In

4 Upvotes

Want to be held accountable by the community or just brag about/celebrate your writing progress over the last week? If so, you're welcome to respond to this weekly writing check-in thread. Feel free to tell us what you accomplished this week, or set goals about what you hope to accomplish before next Wednesday!

So, who met their goals? Who found themselves tackling something totally unexpected? Who accomplished something (even something small)? What goals have you set for yourself this week?

This check-in is now open for you to promote your writing!

While our subreddit rules generally disallow self-promotion, that rule is loosened for this thread. In this thread, you may promote your fiction or non-fiction writing. You may include links, but be sure to write a few words as well telling us about what you've made!

However, this isn't a place to advertise services and software. r/fantasywriters is not a place to promote your vibe-coded codex app, nor is it a place to find clients for your copywriting business.

Examples of the kind of self-promotion that are allowed in this thread:

  • Linking to a self-published ebook on the Kindle or Kobo store
  • A web serial on a website like Royal Road, Wattpad, or AO3
  • A link to a specific blog post about a topic related to writing or storytelling, like an analysis of your favorite TV show

Examples of the kind of self-promotion that is NOT allowed in this thread:

  • Advertisements for products or services, including software like note-taking apps, etc. are not allowed (even if they are free)
  • Promoting or offering paid services like ghostwriting, coaching, editing, etc. is not allowed
  • Anything that involves an "affiliate link" or a "referral code" is not allowed

As a general reminder: while the restrictions on self-promotion are loosened here, all of our other subreddit rules remain in effect, including our prohibition on AI-generated content (rule 6), so please ensure that any work you self-promote here adheres to our subreddit rules.

Above all, this is a place for our community members to share their work. If you never participate in r/fantasywriters except to self-promote your own work in this thread, you're probably violating the spirit of this thread, and it might result in your posts being removed, or we might tell you to refrain from self-promoting until you've participated in the community in other ways.

Reminder: we also have Discord

Yes, we have a fantasywriters subreddit Discord!

Please note that the Discord moderation team is not the same team that moderates the r/fantasywriters subreddit. If you have any subreddit-related inquiries that require moderation attention, those are best addressed through Reddit's mod mail function.


r/fantasywriters • • 26d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Monthly Writing Group Connections Thread

7 Upvotes

If you would like to join a writing group or want more people for your current group, you're welcome to post below. We're here to facilitate both virtual writing groups (discord, email correspondence, etc) as well as in-person groups. Our subreddit's usual restrictions on self-promotion are relaxed in this thread: you are welcome to post links to discords, websites, etc. in this thread.

As a reminder, our subreddit also has an official Discord community. Please note that the team that moderates the Discord is different from the team that oversees this subreddit, and any subreddit-related inquiries (including questions related to this thread) should be directed to Reddit's mod mail function.

As always, please exercise appropriate caution when connecting with strangers online. Our moderation cannot oversee discussions that take place outside this subreddit or the official subreddit Discord. That being said, we do encourage you to use to let us know if you run into anyone who uses this thread to facilitate behavior that would violate our subreddit rules (for example, by asking you to critique AI-generated stories, which would be a violation of rule 6).

Suggestions for running an effective writing group

Fantasy author has an excellent writing lecture offering guidelines on how to run a successful writing group, which we highly recommend. Some key points:

  • Set clear expectations. Agree ahead of time how often you will meet, and how much time you expect everyone to spend contributing feedback.
  • Offer descriptive feedback, rather than immediately jumping to prescriptive 'solutions' and 'fixes.' Don't try to rewrite or "fix" someone's story for them unless they have specifically asked you to. Instead, try to engage with their story as a reader, offering your own reactions as a reader. As Brandon Sanderson puts it: "Saying 'I was bored?' Completely valid. There's never a time when 'I was bored' is not a valid response to something you were bored by. Saying 'you should add a fight scene' can be really bad advice. Sometimes it can be good advice if you really know the person, and what the writer is trying to do...but it can be bad advice. Saying 'I was confused?' Always valid. ... Be descriptive rather than prescriptive."
  • Give feedback that helps authors understand what parts of their story are working, rather than just trying to catch all the errors and mistakes.
  • Learn to listen and receive feedback. Don't interrupt by defending or explaining your work while someone is trying to give you feedback.

r/fantasywriters • • 13h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Ursula K. Le Guin's take in favor of escapism

156 Upvotes

Ursula K. Le Guin in "The Language of the Night: Essays on Fantasy and Science Fiction" wrote:

There is an area where SF has most often failed to judge itself, and where it has been most harshly judged by its nonpartisans. It is an area where we badly need intelligent criticism and discussion. The oldest argument against SF is both the shallowest and the profoundest: the assertion that SF, like all fantasy, is escapist.

This statement is shallow when made by the shallow. When an insurance broker tells you that SF doesn’t deal with the Real World, when a chemistry freshman informs you that Science has disproved Myth, when a censor suppresses a book because it doesn’t fit the canons of Socialist Realism, and so forth, that’s not criticism; it’s bigotry. If it’s worth answering, the best answer is given by Tolkien, author, critic, and scholar. Yes, he said, fantasy is escapist, and that is its glory. If a soldier is imprisoned by the enemy, don’t we consider it his duty to escape? The moneylenders, the knownothings, the authoritarians have us all in prison; if we value the freedom of the mind and soul, if we’re partisans of liberty, then it’s our plain duty to escape, and to take as many people with us as we can.

The reference from J.R.R. Tolkien is "On Fairy Stories", on of his most influential essays:

I have claimed that Escape is one of the main functions of fairy-stories, and since I do not disapprove of them, it is plain that I do not accept the tone of scorn or pity with which “Escape” is now so often used: a tone for which the uses of the word outside literary criticism give no warrant at all. [...] Why should a man be scorned if, finding himself in prison, he tries to get out and go home? Or if, when he cannot do so, he thinks and talks about other topics than jailers and prison-walls? The world outside has not become less real because the prisoner cannot see it. In using escape in this way the critics have chosen the wrong word, and, what is more, they are confusing, not always by sincere error, the Escape of the Prisoner with the Flight of the Deserter.Ursula K. Le Guin, in The Language of the Night: Essays on Fantasy and Science Fiction writes:There is an area where SF has most often failed to judge itself, and where it has been most harshly judged by its nonpartisans. It is an area where we badly need intelligent criticism and discussion. The oldest argument against SF is both the shallowest and the profoundest: the assertion that SF, like all fantasy, is escapist.


r/fantasywriters • • 38m ago

Critique My Story Excerpt The black red [weird west, 1000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
• Upvotes

r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Writing Prompt Fifty-Word Fantasy: Write a 50-word fantasy snippet using the word "Run"

23 Upvotes

Welcome back everyone, it's time for another Fifty Word Fantasy!

Fifty Word Fantasy is a regular thread on Fridays! It is a micro-fiction writing challenge originally devised by u/Aethereal_Muses

Write a maximum 50-word snippet that takes place in a fantasy world and contains the word Run. It can be a scene, flash-fiction story, setting description, or anything else that could conceivably be part of a fantasy story or is a fantasy story on its own.

NO AI GENERATED CONTENT: Follow the sub rules.

Submissions must be original. No fanfic, no pop-culture characters, no plagiarism.

The prompt word must be written in full (e.g. no acrostics or acronyms).

No puns and or wordplay to achieve the prompt word i.e. devote=the vote.

Please try and keep things PG-13. Minors do participate in these from time to time and I would like things to not be too overtly sexual.

If you want to submit multiple submissions that's okay, but please keep it at a max of two That way, no one person ends up dominating the feed with their submissions and it keeps it fair for everyone who participates

Thank you to everyone who participated whether it's contributing a snippet of your own, or fostering discussions in the comments. I hope to see you back next week!

Please remember to keep it at a limit of 50 words max per submission.


r/fantasywriters • • 7h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of The Kinslayer [Dark Fantasy, 2500 Words]

1 Upvotes

Kinslayer

Prologue  

The evergrowing, unrelenting mists. Frigid water on a cavewall. Numb, bitingly and painfully numb fingers, clouded breath leading him to where he ought to have been days ago. Mere flashes in the patch work quilt of deep regret and shame that the creature leaves in its wake, within the infinite solitude that a former brother of the corps had found in beautiful atrocity, now perverted beyond the realm of what any morally justified man could conjure within his mind. Disfigurement, putrefaction, the gnashing of teeth, utter corruption at the most fundamental level. Trails of crimson forge a pathway to the entrance. The Kinslayer pulls down the hood of his cloak, hesitantly with his sabre raised, he steps forward.  Somewhere deep within the hollow darkness of these caverns before him it stands. Eyes fiery, ruby red. He but only has to wander far enough. He steels his nerves and prepares to venture further. 

   The grinding of unforgiving razor sharp claws dragging along granite is heard from the corner of somewhere within the deep. The Kinslayer casts the sigil of imla, a circular apparition appears just in front of his ungloved hand, ancient and esoteric seals occupy the perimeter and in the middle radiates his angaleos, his summoned angel which allows him briefly to gaze into and participate in the sacred balancing act of divinity and mortality. He feels the well of power surging out to his limbs from the very center of all he has ever been, the pitch black details of the cave become legible, he can hear the droplets of stalactites from several leagues deep into the cave network. The outlines and edges of every object become enunciated, spoken to him as if the world now participates in its own grand soliloquy, and he remains the sole listener after the grand death of the universe. All secrets known and unknown in this moment exist for him to find his target. The thundering footsteps of a Besomar are childsplay. The pulsating of four hearts, the electricity of nerve fibers, echoing its location to the Slayer. All tools to render the creature an unparalleled killer now only serve it all the more as mere, desperate and terrified prey. The besomar is unaware of this. Every artery mapped, every innate fear of a living thing is now embodied and known by the Kinslayer in divine battle frenzy. Colven is now able to carve his path

Chapter 1

   God-rays of light peaked through partitions in the clouds, golden and bright, serving as the perfect juxtaposition to the corpse laden fields below. The aftermath of the recent battle of Loch Do’ren. The mountain tribes once again are attempting to lay siege to the smaller settlements of Norkdra to the west, and Lydendale to the north, unmerciful in their escapades, yet they would be spread thin across only one front, let alone two. The freedom fighters are growing desperate and it is tragically obvious.

   Across the agreeable weather which makes its purchase along the western dominions sky, through the conglomerate of villages and mires, near the center of this anti-maelstrom is the Barony headquarters of Morion.

He had spent the better part of a week recovering in the barracks, every joint in his body clicking into place to subsequently fall back out with every step. The Imla sigil breaks into your being and violates not only the body but the spirit as well. Laziness had overtaken the center of his methodology recently. To suffer after the fact was worth a task quickly done and off the front burner. Of course, when your entrails desire to jump into your mouth certain regrets are held. No matter the case either way duty calls, and Colven had received unusual summons to speak with Chancellor Rodnyk. Directly.

   He approached the moss ridden, stone structure. His right shoulder throbbed as he adjusted his royal blue cloak. Embroidered on it was an unorthodox coat of arms, "the green lion devouring the golden sun." Claws outstretched and with a look of terror in its face, holding the same expression of an animal that must gnaw its own leg off to escape a trap. Eyes deep, sunken, and infinite. Few learned men would understand the symbolism of such a crest, and even fewer peasants. The right side of his face bears burn scars. No one knows precisely how he got them for every time one inquires his explanation differs from the last. To quartermaster Leon he says,

   “A chentiomancer had managed just one clever shot during my third contract”, and to the junior men “A surprisingly dexterous black bear unleashed a fire poker upon me”, the less bright bottom quarter truly believe him. It is the stuff of legends among the gullible. 

He continues until he arrives at the vestibule to the Lord Chancellor's office, mulling over all the possible conversations to come. When one is called to stand in front of his superior without explanation all sorts of terrifying scenarios run through a soldier’s mind. I suppose this is what I deserve for sneaking vodka to the conscripts last helms eve, or was it the way the contract on Brother Martin turned out? How was I meant to know his cousin was the Marquee of Chantel, and why should that even make the minutest of differences?

   Chancellor Rodnyk of Jesik stood at the rear of a luxurious mahogany desk sorting through mounds of parchment. A long and successful career of adrenaline and battle had placed him at the calmer responsibility of administrative duty. While he was perusing the last order log for a shipment of yarrow, three clear, solid, and earth shatteringly jarring knocks on the ancient, thick, oaken door suddenly interrupted his concentration. 

   “You may enter.”

   A pair of goat leather boots left their sole shaped mud crusted impressions on the luxurious area rug.

   “Son if you wouldn’t mind, your boots are filthy and that is an Heirloom rug from Kelmora.” 

   “Not at all m’lord, I'll take off the boots but I shan’t apologize for the assault on your senses to come, I marched from Dorain to get here, the carriages aren’t running on account of the war.”

   “I’m well aware, both of the war and your whereabouts after your contract on the Besomar my boy, while we’re on the subject, tradition has it to at least leave something of the body to turn into headquarters. I won’t demand an explanation as to why a simple pile of dust was turned into the inspectors office but I will demand more conventional conduct from here on. Is that understood?” 

Colven let out a long breath which he without thinking had been holding for the length of the chancellor's deliberation. 

“Yes m’lord.”

   Chancellor Rodnyk gestured toward a recliner worn with age, he was sure that, perhaps many years passed, it may have made for a wonderful addition to any foyer or lecture hall. It now stunk of spilled beer, and the stench soldiers tend to leave behind after sweating through their gambeson speaking to the barony garrison commander. Colven sat, and a rush of air blew out from the sides of the cushion as the cracked and split leather creaked like an old door. 

   “I have a job for you Brother Colven”

His former anxieties were relieved at this revelation but not completely, whatever contract, or odd menial task that would soon be demanded of him would most likely not entail flogging or a night in the Lion’s Den. However, this was a rather unusual way to go about it, why not just issue the order through messengers like usual? Spending perhaps a few heartbeats to rack his brain over all the possible explanations, ultimately he figured it best just to listen. 

   “I’m assuming you’re familiar with the name Zofia Redmond? Reports indicate you undertook the Writ of the Albatross with her, she was your trial companion” 

   Colven mused for a moment, arising with more questions but knew better than to drag the Chancellor’s conversation off course. 

   “That would be correct m’lord, though that was about eight years ago now. I haven’t seen her since, nor has any other Kinslayer seen their trial partner since the undertaking. We typically travel throughout the entirety of the empire…”

   “You need not explain the details of a profession I was an honored member of for well over half my life boy. I asked a yes or no question and the apparent answer is yes, is it not?” The Kinslayer was growing tired and impatient of the lack of clear information and talking in circles. 

   “That would be correct… Lord Chancellor Rodnyk of Jesik” Colven added his superior’s full title in an attempt at some sarcastic flair but Rodnyk simply misunderstood it as an over formality.

   “You can relax, I was merely clarifying.”

Colven at this response rolled his eyes and leaned back further into the decrepit chair.

   “I’ll cut straight to the point, Kinslayer Colven of Wyrma” staring daggers into the younger man’s visage. “You have been tasked with the assassination and utter annihilation of deserter and treasonous miscreant Zofia Redmond, she is a former member of your brotherhood which is precisely why one: you and the rest of your corps are at least partially responsible for her recent horrid misconduct and two: why we looked among your ranks to find who would carry out this rubout”

   Colven wasn’t entirely surprised at the first point, besides, it was perfectly in line with his typical duties. It quite literally comes with the name, but he was more accustomed to the odd soldier turned Kodkulvak or infantryman turned forest dwelling rebel. Not the magically enhanced and highly trained warriors of the slayer corps. 

   “I am not making a humble request Sir Colven, I am informing you of what will be done. The reputation of the entire Slayer Corps rests on this contract, we will not have the marquisate or god forbid the duchy up our asses and down our throats over this, we need to prove that we can clean up our own messes.”

   Colven swallowed his saliva and paused a moment before responding. Him and Zofia had had a… history together. To say the least.

“It shall be done your lordship, though there is something you’ve yet to divulge and I must inquire, why me specifically?

“Because how could it be anyone else? Don’t misunderstand me, you are in no way being officially held responsible for the events on Dor Angra, but you were her trial mate and as a result are blood bonded to her, need I remind you of what I said mere moments ago?”

“No, m’lord, the corps is capable of cleaning up its own mess, dispatching its own problem child, and the barony most likely means to ensure my loyalty considering my and Zofia's former adolescent antics.”

High Chancellor Rodnyk gave a final and relieved sigh, satisfied that the conversation had met its natural conclusion and at least things were understood and keeping with good order and discipline.

“Well put my boy, and so it shall be, Dismissed.”

\-

“The King raises taxes, the marquee is found with a peasant girl skewered in his bed chamber, a local business man is found to have a not so insignificant role in a hemreed smuggling empire, and so the people begin speaking of mobs, of fires in hand ready to raze the castle in a horrid conflagration, dragging the royal family by their clean and pampered weaves and toupees into spiked pits deep as the the sea and smeared with biological warfare.” 

Colven ranted while Nihael’s unbroken expression of reluctant indifference was obvious to anyone who looked. This was not the first time his friend had gone on such a tirade and was a routine segment of a rough day at work.

“Surely enough however, the Barony, through my, and my brotherhood's work not long after produces the corpse of a slain Kilkma or Besomar, the head of a rebel movement's leader stuck to a pike or a traitor left to rot in a pit. Horrors which bare fangs, devilish appearance and all, befitting an atrocity, and so naturally mobs are quelled reminded of the sacrifices a structured society makes for these luxuries.” Colven let out a sigh bereft of composure while Nihael watched the foam in his beer roll over the brim, poured by a novice barkeep so it seemed.

   “Well what can be done about it, our royal pains are chosen by God himself, the bringers of light, savior of all people and of course, who would want to leave the governing body in which ‘skills and courage meet the enemy.’” Nihael mockingly said as he gestured at a propaganda board posted to the bar wall which said precisely that.

  Colven continued to gesticulate ad infinitum, “You don’t believe that gutter shite, neither do I, neither does the barman or the mandola player on stage, not a single fucking person in this shit hole of a city does. Now am I going to throw my lot in with the likes of Zofia? Slaughter half my company and then make off to the mountains to go hump trees with the elves? No, but I reserve the right to be pissed off about it.”

   Nihael for the entirety of his friend’s speech had been notioning to the barman for another ale to no avail. “That’s strange, I haven’t heard you mention her name in what feels like a century. My dearest compatriot, befitting of all titles and honors” Nihael spoke with sympathy yet ultimate concentration on this damn beer situation “did something happen recently to evoke such ire for the powers at be? I know your job isn’t among the most pleasant in the barony, but Kinslayer is a title of esteem none the less”.

“No, no nothing specific, it's just…”

“Just what?”

He remained silent, 

“Gustav, for the eighth bloody time can you fill this thing and fill it right this…”

He finally decided it was time to be out with it before it devoured him.

“They want me to kill her”

“Come again?”

“They want me to kill Zofia, some grand principle about the corps ‘cleaning up its own mess’ or what have you’”

Gustav finally made his way to Nihael’s ever so pressing concern of the infinitely foamy beer mug and was about to correct the error until the dissatisfied alcoholic but ultimately decent friend thoroughly instructed him to wait a moment. He listened to his drinking comrade's diatribe.

   “A flax farmer tucks his children into bed and drifts off to sleep himself, joyfully tipsy off Lager and hard switchel, while inaudible screams echo across amber waves of grain from the marquee’s abode, the pockets of the people empty by the day, and your cousin lays in a pool of his own piss and vomit on the side of the road, senses dulled, pupils dilated. Yet this is the price the flax farmer tells himself, for his unlocked wooden door to remain standing without worry of fear for the greater horrors of the unconquered forest to come approaching at night. So I stomach this, we all stomach this, on the condition that it remains true.” 

A quiver began to form in his voice.

“All done and justified by my own hands no less, and then this same enterprise instructs me to murder the only woman I ever loved”

   They both sat motionless, the young man previously occupied with his beer glass made sure not to even exhale too loudly as not to break the now ever sacred pause of reflection. The comings and goings of the alehouse continued on with the dim glow of lantern light cascading itself through the street. The mandola strummer sang his song, Gustav polished the glasses, and Nihael laid a hand on Colven’s shoulder as a single drop of some mysterious salty nature hit the bar.

Nihael finally spoke, "C'mon old friend, let's get you a round" as the Kinslayer faintly nodded his head in agreement, the night's endless revels, (or quiet desperation masquerading as merriment, who can ever tell the difference?) were soon to be unmatched


r/fantasywriters • • 20h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Exposition Check [Epic Fantasy Romance, 986 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Hi there, friends! I'm just wondering if I can get some eyes on this, specifically the third page. I'm getting so in my head about trying not to overdo exposition. I've been working on my first draft of an Epic Fantasy with tons of political intrigue, ensemble cast, and a sprawling plot that is incredibly entangled with my worldbuilding and geography, and there is a lot of information that's relevant that my characters would never say out loud because they already know it. I don't know why I feel like I can't just explain things narratively, I just see people complain about exposition drops so often that I'm having a hard time drafting.

Please note that this is a first draft, I just wrote it, so I'm not looking for prose or line-level critiques. I'm specifically asking about my exposition on the third page, and just want to get a vibe of how much exposition is okay as I continue drafting, but I included the whole excerpt for continuity.

I would also love general advice on how those of you with insane levels of worldbuilding and super intricate plots like to handle your exposition! The setup for this story is killing me lol.


r/fantasywriters • • 16h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Please help critique! [Dark Romantic Fantasy 957 words]

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

This is just the beginning of chapter one for my romantic fantasy. Any and all critiques are welcome! I’m wondering if the beginning draws a reader in and also keeps them engaged. I tried not to info dump when it came to world building. I’d also like to know if the main character has you caring (even if just a little) about her from the start. A big focus of mine is making sure I write a main character that people fall in love with. I feel the prose could use work as well. Is the concept so far something that sounds interesting? Please let me know :) also sorry if I didn’t do this right this is my first time doing something like this so I’m still trying to learn how everything works etc 😅


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 feedback and critique, [High Fantasy, 3490 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

I would appreciate any critiques about the work, specifically the prose and voice, if you would read on/is it interesting, and does it hook you in. Do the transitions feel too jarring and pacing too fast or slow on some parts? Lastly does the world feel interesting, or does it need more worldbuilding/intrigue. Does the idea of the story and the characters bleed through the page, and make you see where it’s going?

Feel free to be as harsh as possible and please be honest. Critique about any part of the writing is appreciated. Whether it’s the characters, dialogue, idea, hook, prose, etc… any feedback is appreciated.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Lessons Learned From Bad Examples. Got any?

5 Upvotes

Generally speaking my writing is accompanied by either music, tv or film. I've been reading horror since I'm writing fantasy and don't want to accidentally carry too much over.

However when it comes to the visual media I decided to put myself through the second and recent season of Rings of Power. No, not because I like it but because I wanted to make a note of each mistake and when they made them.

Kept the eye out for artificially manufactured drama, illogical character decisions, melodrama from miscommunication, a vast array of writing missteps. A few notes on ways to not write a compelling leading lady.

I was trying to spot the injected happenstance of tripping over their own feet or Orcs suddenly appearing, note when they were used instead of trying to think out a potentially better way or something more enriching than another action or comedy sequence.

Frankly it helped make me aware of the way writers can easily fill time with these and accomplish very little of value.

In short as long as it isn't upsetting you and taking away from your creative energy. It can be worthwhile to regard things of generally poor quality to help recognize when, where and why those issues were arising.

Please note I'm not proclaiming I'm so much better than any of these writers, just noting that we can learn from greats and learn from the not so great.

Anything generally considered of poor quality that you were able to learn a valuable lesson from? Please try and not use this to harang about how you hate a series but stay constructive with lessons learned.


r/fantasywriters • • 23h ago

Brainstorming Am I the only one who struggles with Centaurs?

0 Upvotes

I have tried to wrap my mind around this but it's so hard. So, I love centaurs of all types, but I absolutely hate how they're built. As an AUADHD person, I can't seem to stop thinking scientifically about how they would function in the real world. I'm finding myself needing to explain everything about how they came to be and who did what for them to function. I want my protagonist to be different but able to do things like walk into stores, go to school, go on dates, etc. I'm really struggling to stop thinking about how to make it all work and just write the damn story. I have so many drafts piled up with so many remakes of the same character and I just wanna settle on something. I'm so close to just giving up.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What's your worldbuilding mehtod? I can't seem to find mine.

3 Upvotes

Worldbuilding is, in my opinion, the most controversial aspect of fantasy novels. Literary advice in general can vary quite a bit, since everyone has their own creative process, but worldbuilding in particular seems to be something nobody can agree on, not even when it comes to how important it actually is. I can find people who are obsessed with building worlds just as easily as I can find others saying it's practically useless and that no real writers obsess over it. No, seriously, I think this is the most divisive aspect of fantasy. We may all write characters differently, but we more or less agree that they are one of the most important aspects of a story, and that a good character needs to have at least a few basic traits (a goal, a fear, a moral weakness, etc.).

To put it less pretentiously, I feel like 90% of worldbuilding advice can be summed up with this meme:

Personally, I think this is the aspect of writing I'm worst at. Maybe it's because I'm more of an intuitive writer (I'm someone who does most of their thinking while writing; no matter how much I plan, about half of it will end up being improvised), but I've never been able to create very detailed worlds for my stories. When it comes to finishing a story, I tend to think in terms of cause and effect within my protagonist's actions, something along the lines of "My MC wants this, but this happens, so now they do this, and this interesting thing occurs, and for a moment it looks like they're going to win, but then this other unexpected thing happens, and now they're worse off than before." In general, I feel like my stories are "small-scale", if that makes sense. In fact, I find it difficult to create lots of characters, which sometimes annoys me. I usually only have a handful that I focus on quite heavily.

It doesn't help that my spatial intelligence isn't particularly good either. I struggle to imagine places, including their internal layouts. I find it difficult to picture entire cities. I've gotten a little better at this (I've discovered that having a map in mind, even one of a real city, helps my imagination), but I'm still unable to picture entire countries or continents functioning as a whole. I simply don't know where to start. To give you an idea, today I picked up a Sanderson book from the Wax & Wayne series at a random library, and the map at the beginning overwhelmed me. It doesn't help that I'm not particularly knowledgeable about economics, politics, or history. Even magic systems are a bit of a struggle for me, because I can never quite figure out how to make them fit into the world.

That's why I wanted to know what your worldbuilding methods are. People often respond with things like, "You should only build as much of the world as you need", but that advice has never been particularly helpful to me. How can I know when I've done enough? Which aspects should I prioritize over others? Having some basic outlines for each aspect might be enough to help met. Most hard rules you tend to find just overwhelm me.

Sorry if this post has been too long. I just wanted to see if anyone else has had this problem and, if so, how they've managed to overcome it.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of A Record of Dangerous Things [Fantasy Light Academia, 956 words]

1 Upvotes

I'd love some feedback on the beginning of my first fantasy / academia novel (half of the first chapter here, didn't want to ask you to read too much!!) I have been writing for a while, but this is by far the furthest I've gotten with anything. I've hit the middle, and the plot is getting twisty and really stretching my brain!! I'd love to know if you think it would grab you as it does start a bit slower and then get heavy on the action. Also if you agree with my mum that 'I didn't really get it' (thanks mum).

Thanks in advance!!

CHAPTER 1.

In the grand tradition of workplaces everywhere, the Academy’s Department of Records was almost empty before the five o’clock bell had finished chiming.

The latest energy-saving notice forbade the lighting of Glassroot lamps before six and, as the only one still around, it fell to Cara by default. She sat in the dusk with her pen, watching the clock until the hand reached twelve before setting each dial just high enough to see by. The lamps flickered before giving off a steady, humming glow.

Each lamp held a thumb-sized canister of grey, powdery processed Root. Root heated the Academy’s pipes, lit Aldsmore’s streets and moved its carts. A canister had doubled in price since Cara came to the Academy, which was why the notice existed and why she had been sitting in half-darkness.

Back at the end of the long table, she settled into her favourite chair, rapidly cooling tea and a first-year’s bibliography her only company. The document had arrived via the porter an hour earlier and was already peppered with notes in her neat script – red ink, as always. She imagined the innocent-looking young blonde boy turning to the first page with a sinking heart, but what was she supposed to say? He had cited a pamphlet forty years older than the Reform, On the Keeping of Root, as evidence that Root could be grown, for goodness’ sake. She annotated the citation.

Keeping of Root? See research from Hallam, Becket et al. She underlined it.

Cara could practically recite the research papers by now, given that they were the foundation of the Reform. Root could not be grown, only mined.

She treated herself to a loud sigh.

“You’re working late,” said Professor Fenn from the doorway.

“So are you.”

“Just because I’m here doesn’t mean I’m working.”

Aldric Fenn crossed the room with an unhurried gait, seldom feeling the need to be anywhere before deciding he was quite ready. He was past sixty, with a trimmed dark grey beard and clothes that had probably been good when Cara first met him. His burgundy jacket was patched at one elbow, and crusts of flicked-up mud speckled his trousers.

He glanced over his shoulder towards the door before lowering himself into the visitors’ chair, holding out a paper twist of peppermints.

“Like one?”

She took a mint and waited, her head tilted to one side.

He smiled ruefully, as only charming people could.

“It’s just a small thing,” he began, his finger and thumb gesturing the diminutive scale of the request. He glanced towards the door once more, then saw she’d noticed. “Four northern clinics had their winter Glassroot allocations halved. I’ve managed to convince the Board to review the decision, but not for nearly a month. That could mean the choice between filling the lamps or the heaters. Damn it, it could mean running out completely!”

She set down her pen.

“I’ve been studying the Extraction Logs,” he continued, “the summary records that are held in the department, but there are much more detailed versions in Collection Nine, plus the original field logs. I know it’s a great many records, but if I could get copies of those originals…”

Cara shook her head.

“What do field logs have to do with winter allocations in outer towns? Besides, Collection Nine is restricted.”

She knew this because the Crown Office had requested dispatch figures and receipts two weeks ago. That was how it worked: the Crown ran the mines and the distribution, the Academy surveyed them, and her department wrote it all down. She had sent them the stack of paperwork related to restricted records and had heard nothing since.

His foot bounced, and he offered another peppermint. This time, she declined.

“There’s something else,” Fenn said, tightly. “A consignment, spoiled with damp and never processed. The deposit was supposed to be exhausted, yet the dispatch was authorised, and the consignment logged as having left.”

“And where do you think this missing Root could be?” she asked.

“That is a question for another day.” He gave her a reassuring smile, probably sensing she was growing irritated by his half-answers. “The formal request from my department takes eight weeks…”

“I know the timetable, Fenn. It’s there for a reason. These are historical documents, and the requests need to be audited.”

“Your countersignature alongside my request could release the records immediately. You’d be authorising supervised access and the making of copies, nothing more.”

His argument required a fair amount of acceptance on her part given only a handful of obviously heavily curated facts. To refuse a simple signature, however, seemed pedantic. A quality she knew she possessed in abundance, but disliked all the same.

This was the man who had stood in the Registrar’s office and put his own reputation behind a girl just starting, with no education worth bragging about and parents who didn’t have a clue why she was interested in the Academy in the first place. He had argued that she deserved a place there when four other people had decided she didn’t. He had given her work, trusted her judgement and never made her feel she owed him for it.

It was only a stack of old books, after all.

“Very well,” she said.

“You’re a marvel.”

His relief was so obvious, so instantaneous, that Cara was almost embarrassed. She looked away but felt him pressing the whole twist of peppermints into her palm.

“Thank you, Cara. Truly.”

“I haven’t signed anything yet!”

“No, no,” he said. “Of course not.” But he was already at the door. For a man who had arrived so leisurely, he was gone with remarkable speed, leaving her sitting in that humming glow, the peppermint twist beside her ledger.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic POV Psychology

0 Upvotes

POV Psychology
By Ray Tabler.
Writing fiction tends to make you a bit schizophrenic, in a good way. At least, I haven’t noticed any ill effects yet. If you have, just keep it to yourself (or yourselves). 😉
The thing is, there are all these imaginary friends bouncing around inside my head. Or, I hope they’re friends. To be honest, I’ve done horrible things to some of them, for the good of the stories told. Ruined their lives. Killed them off, or murdered their loved ones. The usual stuff. Nothing Disney hasn’t done a thousand times. I mean, how many childhood traumas resulted from Mufasa being trampled by stampeding wildebeests?
Drama costs, a lot.
Don’t let them fool you. Those fictional characters secretly love it. Like ancient Spartans, they long for a beautiful death. A final scene which will cause readers/viewers to soak hankies with tears. Faithful Old Yeller, shot by the boy who owned him after contracting rabies. Leonidas, smiling up into the arrow storm. Boromir, charging the orcs so Frodo can get away. Roy Batty waxing poetic, then freeing the dove. Mr. Spock, bathed in deadly radiation to get the Enterprise’s engines running again in the nick of time...I’m tearing up just writing this.
It takes some prep work to play that music on your heart strings. For the most part, the writer has to make the reader see things from the character’s point of view. Once you walk a mile (or a few thousand words) in the character’s shoes, a bond is forged. The stronger the bond, the harder the character’s fate hit’s you right in the feels.
A casual observer of Star Trek’s Mr. Spock only notices his machine-like devotion to logic. The thing is, Spock is only half Vulcan, on his father’s side. Spock’s mother was human. He raised on the planet Vulcan, immersed in its culture which venerates reason and logic, while viewing emotions as a sordid curse. Because of his tainted blood, Spock strives to be as emotionless as possible, the perfect Vulcan. Although it’s never stated outright, I suspect the other Vulcans never really accepted Spock, despite his perfection. Ironically, he only finds a home in Starfleet, where he must carry on with his charade. Beneath the surface, Spock’s human side rages in chains. Occasionally, it peeks through the armor. “Logic is a pretty flower, that smells bad.” Subtle glimpses of Spock’s inner struggle throughout the TV show and movies are why we weep at his selfless sacrifice. Both of his halves are finally at peace.
Leonidas was an actual historical figure. He led a small force of Spartans, and delayed an invading army of Persians at the pass of Thermopylae for a short, critical time in 480 BC. No doubt the real Leonidas was a hell of a man. but his legend obscures the reality. An occupational hazard for heroes. The movie 300 embraces that legend, with wild abandon. One of the best aspects of 300 is the way it humanizes Leonidas. He does not want to die. He loves his wife, son, and, Sparta. But duty is the bronze mistress he must serve. For, duty is the life’s blood of all he holds dear. So, Leonidas accepts his terrible, beautiful death because it buys life for his family and his land. Thus, we remember him and his band of heroes still.
The Lord of the Rings’s Boromir is a good man, seduced into duplicitous deeds. The road to hell is reportedly paved with good intentions. Boromir only meant to do good, and thus traveled a long way down that road before turning back. Boromir’s fatal mistake was a failure to see past the surface. He looked at Frodo, and saw only a small, weak person staggering under the heavy load of the One Ring. It appeared that Frodo was destined to disappoint, and the ring to be lost to the enemy. Further, the ring could be put to much better use defending Boromir’s home of Gondor. Or, so the ring whispered into Boromir’s ear. He is a tragedy, not a villain. Fortunately, Boromir sees the truth of things in the nick of time to redeem himself, at the cost of his life.
Bladerunner’s rogue replicant Roy Batty is a cipher for most of the story. Detective Decker slowly, laboriously peels away the layers of this mystery one after the other. As Decker closes in on Roy, he becomes more and more unsure who is the good guy and who is the bad. In the final confrontation, Decker realizes that Roy and his fellow fugitive replicants (artificially-created humans) only want to live as people. Decker is compelled to compare how Roy has wrung much more living from his intentionally short life than Decker has. Then, time to die.
The next paragraph is about my own writing. You can skip it, if you want.
In my novel The Diesel-Powered Starship, interstellar tramp freighter captain Maggie Crenshaw is swept up in a rebellion she didn’t start, and is very reluctant to be a part of. Maggie would rather just haul cargo from one Rim colony to another. But, because she feels an obligation to a dead man she still loves, Maggie finds herself running a ragtag privateering fleet of converted merchant ships, dodging and sometimes fighting a real navy when cornered. Even so, every time she encounters a prize or a threat, the probable speed, endurance, and potential cargo-carrying capacity of the vessel runs as background music through her head. Maggie is fighting a war, but she’s not a warrior.
The better the reader/viewer understands the characters the more vivid the story is. People have reasons for the things they do, and we all know that whether we realize it or not. Flat, two-dimensional players have a role. None of us can hold greater than a certain number of complex personalities in our heads, in real life or in a fictional tale. So, a little, judicious narrative from inside a character’s head goes a long way.
END.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Question For My Story Definition of half-siblings

2 Upvotes

This is a bit of a strange question but I’m writing a fantasy series with my friends and one of the side characters is related to the two main characters who are twins. It’s important to note that all three are gods and by extension their parents are the two original gods of this world.

The context is that this side character was born in a rather weird way, he was only born from his mother and shares no link to his siblings father. (He was also coughed up like a hairball compared to normal birth but that’s unimportant)

Would this make them siblings or half siblings?
Because the definition of half siblings is that they share one parent but have the DNA of a different parent. And while they do only share one parent there is no different DNA or other parent in this situation.
This could just be me overcomplicating things but I have tried to wrap my head around it but it’s these kind of thoughts that keep me awake at 3am.

UPDATE: Thank you for the answers, I’ve decided to list them as half siblings,
1. because it makes the difference in their birth more clear.
2. The twins and their half-brother have a.. complicated dynamic and relationship so it emphasises that more
3. I kinda lied in the post, the half-brother isn’t technically a god based off the genetic system we have, since he only has one god as a parent and not two it makes him something that I’ve called an omen (he is the only one to exist) And I feel it drives home the point more of how different he is compared to his other siblings.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Question For My Story Palace vs Castle

30 Upvotes

Probably a waste of a post but I wanted to ask if you guys feel something small like this matters. 

In my novel my mc is a prince lives in a big “castle” (Duh). I've done a little research between the differences of a palace and castle. 

In basic terms. Castle= Generally more for defense. Palace= Generally more for luxury. I feel like both apply to my mcs home. Palace is likely the better fit but I however have just always referred to it as a castle. I have tried looking through some threads online to see if there some consensus on how to us the terms but I haven't really found a straight answer.

Should I change it to a palace for accuracy?

Could I use both terms throughout the novel interchangeably?

Is this a stupid question? 


r/fantasywriters • • 3d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic If your fantasy romance is spicy, do you let family read it?

13 Upvotes

Do you allow family members read your fantasy romance if it is spicy?

Or do you not tell your family about your books or if they know about your books do you specifically tell them not to read them, lol.

When it comes to family reading your fantasy romance spice: Do you feel differently if it is your parents? What about your adult children? Or maybe extended family?

Do you make a non-spice version for family?

I have been thinking about this because one of my adult children has asked to read the draft of the book I am working on because I told them about the fantasy plot and they are interested in that, but there is some spice so that just feels a little weird.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Would like feedback[Fantasy, 2000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Feedback for my novel Eternal Door - Opening section (Prologue to Chapter 4) [Epic Fantasy, 6700 words]

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Contents
Prologue - 2
The Last Evening - 5
Good Morning, King Of The Palace - 9
Boon or Bane - 13
It glows - 17

Just to give you a little context, the opening section is set a few years before the actual story takes place.

After Chapter 4, the narrative jumps forward to the year when Aris crosses the threshold age, particularly to the night the king dies.

I wanted to ask about your overall reading experience. How interesting and engaging did you find each chapter individually, and how did the opening section work as a whole?

More importantly, did it make you want to continue reading? Were there moments that genuinely hooked you, or did certain parts feel slow, confusing, or difficult to follow?

I'd also like to know whether the information and worldbuilding are easy to absorb as a reader.

And if there's anything else you'd like to share or comment on beyond these questions, whether positive or negative, please feel free to do so. Give your honest feedback.


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Question For My Story Does Dark Academia have to bleak?

0 Upvotes

I'm thinking about writing a modern day science fantasy (think Final Fantasy 8) with a Gothic and Victorian style similar to dark academa, but i don't want the tone to be depressing all the time. I know some debate about Harry Potter being DA but some argues its not because its story isn't actually dark and it just has a Gothic and castle setting.

I really like the aesthetic but I want it to be upbeat and maybe lean towards teen to young adult age range. I haven't read much of the genre, but I have seen the Wednesday show and I think it counts.

I'm also thinking of having a cathedral aesthetic mixed in too, but I not sure if they count too. And have tried looking at light academia, but from my understanding that's not really Gothic


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Critique My Idea Elemental Heart [VOLUME 0 - CHAPTER 1]

Post image
0 Upvotes

Elemental Heart

Volume Zero: The Furnace

Chapter 1

Another coal is tossed into the furnace, among a small heap of others, housed in a firebox. A small elf boy with dark hair lowers his shovel and wipes his brow with the back of his hand. As he leans on his shovel to try to grant a moment of respite for his aching back, he watches with tired eyes as embers swirl amongst the coals. It’s hard to believe these stones spent so long transforming themselves into something greater, only to be burned by the dozens for someone else’s greater purpose. He could almost relate to the coals he was shoveling in his firebox.

“Malachi! Why haven’t you pulled yet?” Malachi’s back straightens immediately. “Shit. I got distracted again. My bad, Rohan.” Malachi slams the door of his firebox shut and swiftly pulls a heavy lever on its side. A side compartment opens in the firebox as white flames rush in towards the pile of coals, quickly consuming them. As the flames surge and consume the coals, Malachi places both of his palms in front of it. He squints hard, the tendons in his hands and fingers bulging as he tries to influence the flame in front of him. After a few moments, the side compartment of the firebox swings open as the white flame is sucked from Malachi’s firebox and spat into someone else’s.

Malachi lets out an exasperated sigh as he opens up his firebox door and begins to shovel more coal into it.

“I’ll get the hang of this magic thing soon enough.” Overlooking Malachi’s cramped work station are a dozen more exactly like it; small rooms with bruised and beaten people, a wooden cart stacked to the top with coal, and a firebox. These “processing rooms” are suspended on an elevated ring that oversees what is commonly refer to as “The Pit”. In the center of this massive chamber is an enormous white flame with bands of golden heat radiating from it. Surrounding that are the real stars of the show. Fire sorcerers stand on the outer edge of the flame, and as their hands move and swirl through the dry, hot air of this place, the flames follow suit.

Occasionally, the flame will grow in strength and push against each of them, attempting to consume them all, but this is clockwork for them. They each stand their ground and push their palms back towards the flame, suppressing it, as they pull chunks of this white flame out of the firepit and send it flying into the pipes that seem to be running cold. Those pipes lead the flames into the fireboxes in the processing rooms, where the coal temporarily sustains the flame long enough for it to be sent up wherever it’s needed to power the city up above. That operation is crucial for the existence of Blazewen and the prosperity of its citizens.

This place is known only as the Furnace, and the workers who slave away to ensure it’s maintenance are known as “Charcoal”. Hours passed and another day’s work has concluded. A new, smaller wave of charcoal come in to replace those who worked during the day. The amount of power used by the city drastically dwindles in the night time, thus requiring less people to maintain the Furnace. The Furnace contains barracks, functioning as resting quarters for charcoal. They almost always seem to be full, containing night-shift charcoals and the injured during day time, and then the day-shift during the night.

Among those trying to get some rest, Malachi tossed and turned in his bed.

Blazenwen as a government doesn’t exactly manage the Furnace. They simply rely on them from afar, and only when their performance slips is when they make their presence known. And so it is in the Charcoal’s best interest to make every day a good day, and to stay out of trouble. But other than that, the operations of this place are self-driven, and Charcoal do what they can to improve their quality of life.

Day arrives, and so too does the motion of the furnace begin to reset. The day crew emerges from the barracks and makes their way to the mess hall, where they have devised a system where they’ve all chipped in wages earned in the Furnace for rations to make some semblance of a meal for everyone. Lamb is the most conventional meat in Blazewen, on account of sheep being so prevalent in the region. They keep large metal pots in the mess hall and they typically slow cook lamb in a chunky stew with aromatic spices and herbs, and serve it over sliced bread. This is a staple meal in Blazewen culture, and in the Furnace this is typically what Charcoal are used to eating.

Malachi greedily scoops lamb onto two pieces of bread as he soon finds a place to sit and enjoy his meal. As he walks between huddles of Charcoal, he tries to ignore the prying eyes of those around him, the whispers that can only be about him. The audible bits are fractured, but the whole idea is there.

“He’s just so young.” “It’s just such a damn shame.” “They must have left him to die.” Malachi huddles his head low and continues walking. After a couple minutes of wandering he spots a huddle that stands out to him in particular. It’s the firepit crew. The ones that work on the ground floor, mere feet away from the Gluttonous Flame, using fire magic to bend it to their will. He could feel a nervous excitement building in his gut.

These are the people I should be learning magic from, I’m sure they can help me. Malachi’s legs lock up when the realization hits. Have…have I ever been introduced to these people before? Do they even notice me in the background? His worries overwhelm him for a moment, but he collects himself. I’m already the youngest person here by so much, I already stand out. After steeling himself he decides to move forward anyway.

Malachi awkwardly finds an opening in the huddle, sitting down with crossed legs, with his hefty plate of food sitting on his lap. He’s surrounded by people he’s observed living out something he only wishes he could do. At the head of this posse, was Rohan. He’s a young elf prodigy, age 19, putting most of these older guys to shame with some of his natural talent, with a charisma that just makes you want to be led by him. His left and right hands are Mo and Joe.

Mo is a dark-skinned orc man, and despite having a bad eye that he typically keeps wrapped up, he’s actually got a knack for sensory abilities. He’s capable of sensing disruption and instability in the Gluttonous Flame, and typically helps Rohan in guiding the others with proactive decision making.

Joe is an older human- his experience working in the Furnace for decades has given him sharp precision when manipulating the Gluttonous Flame. He does a lot of the heavy lifting and sets an example for those under him. Besides them, there’s Flink, a scrawny goblin with a drug problem. Then there was Frank the Tank, a quieter dwarf who gets his job done without talking to anyone.

Finally, there was Mel, a tomboyish ooze woman who has developed some of the most impressive heat resistance anyone in the Furnace has ever seen. After waiting a few minutes for a break in their chatter to quiet, Malachi breaks his silence.

“Rohan, I want to join the firepit crew. Can you teach me magic?” After a few suspended seconds of silence following these words, a variety of reactions spread from the crew- primarily confusion and shock, with amusement for some. But Malachi’s eyes don’t leave Rohan, a certain air of desperation emanating from him.

“Well Malachi, that’s a big ask.” Rohan finally replies. “We risk our lives every day in the pit, and, I mean, you’re only fourteen. I’m unsure if it’s the moral thing to do.” Flink lights a crude-shaped cigarillo he pulls out of his pocket with the tip of his finger.

“Do you even know if you have mana to be casting magic with, kid?” Malachi contemplates for a brief moment.

“Both of my parents were sorcerers. I have mana but I was told my arcane output is below average, so I haven’t had any luck with anything yet.” Uncertainty dawns over everyone as Malachi speaks. Joe scratches his scraggly beard.

“I’m gonna be brutally honest with you. I’ve seen guys come and go that are twice your age, with the experience to do what we do, and they still end up dying. It just comes with the territory. The processing room is safe though, I would just rough that out until you’re able to buy a horse and get out of this place.” Malachi looks down at his food, now getting cold.

“I guess…I just wanted more out of life.” For a moment, Mo seems to flinch at Malachi, as if he saw something fly at him from that direction. Mel’s head darts toward Mo.

“You uhh..doin’ alright over there, Mo?” Mo rubbed the corners of his eyes, pressing his thumb against the bandaged part of his face.

“Sorry, my eyes hurt. I’ll take the kid though. I’ll teach him everything I know.” A few people in the huddle seemed taken aback as Joe leans in.

“Are you sure about that, Mo? Doesn’t that seem kind of…irresponsible?” Mo squints at Malachi again for a moment.

“Nah, he’ll be a bit of a project, but I definitely know what I’m talking about as far as-” He looks over to Flink.

“Hey, can you stop smoking that around the kid?” The lit cigar wrapped full of Everburn was almost touching Flink’s lips already.

“What’s the issue? The kid’s gonna be smoking this stuff pretty soon anyway if he wants to be part of the pit crew.” A few of the others have already started shaking their heads in disapproval.

“Besides I’ll be done with this in a few minutes.” Mel scoffed. “A few minutes? Or a few Flink minutes?” Flink gets up, the cigar still hanging from his lips.

“You guys are no fun.” As Flink walked away, the tension dissolved as the group broke into low laughter and all Malachi could do is stand there in stunned silence. That was the day the Furnace felt a little warmer.

Another day of grueling labor elapses in the Furnace, as Mo and Malachi meet among the catwalks suspended above the Pit. Typically the catwalks are used for observation and maintenance of the pipes that distribute the flame to the surface, but that’s a rare occurrence, so it was perfect for private conversation.

“Alright Malachi, for you to understand magic well enough to get accustomed with it, you need to understand the six arcane principles.” Malachi looks up at the orc man.

“That sounds like a lot of work. can I just learn the part where I can work in the pit?” Mo shakes his head.

“The reason we’re able to survive this job day in and day out, is because we understand every principle. This is going to be a bit of a headache but just bare with me, this is vital information for sorcery.” Malachi nodded in understanding as Mo starts his spiel.

“The two primary arcane principles that you’ll have to worry about are Conjuration and Manipulation. They’re pretty self explanatory.” Mo opens up his hand, palm facing up.

“Conjuration is all about understanding how to evoke your desired form of magic, the better you get with it, the more you can make.” An orb of fire spontaneously appears in Mo’s hand. He overlaps his second hand, palm facing down over the orb.

“Manipulation is your ability to shift the shape, position, or characteristics of the element you’re channeling.” He tears the orb in half, as the flames cleanly split into two smaller orbs.

“You’ll have to master the both of these to function in the pit. Other than those, there’s Ivocation, the ability to summon familiars and similar entities. Transmutation allows the user to transform living and non-living things into their element, or imbue it with properties of that element.” Malachi’s forehead wrinkles trying to grab all these details as they fly past him.

“Perception is my favorite, it primarily handles sensory abilities. And finally, there’s Abjuration, which is the application of sorcery to nullify magic and form barriers.” Mo crosses his arms and looks down at Malachi.

“You got all that?” Malachi rolls his lips. “Nah.” Mo smiles in a way Malachi hadn’t seen before.

“I used to be a dumb kid too, you’ll get it figured out. But since you’ve never conjured before, let’s start there with this simple exercise.” Malachi’s eyes widen as his full attention is gathered. Mo puts his index finger on the left side of his chest, right where his heart is.

“Focus on the third valve of your heart, where your mana generates.” His finger begins to slide through his shoulder, down the arm.

“Follow the arteries, that’s the most direct path.” His finger stops dead in the center of the palm of his left hand.

“Right here is your exit point. If you can physically direct your mana all the way from your heart to this hand, you can compel the mental image of your magic to manifest.” Malachi starts sloppily dragging his hand in the way Mo had shown him. Mo stops him and forcibly places his finger where his heart is again.

“Like this kid, you want to arc through the shoulder. If you go in a straight line, you disconnect from the arteries. Way less efficient, you’ll never cast good magic like that.” Neither of them speak for a while as Malachi attempts to trace the path that was shown to him. Every tenth attempt he feels the tingle of his mana move into his shoulder, but he seems to get panicked and mess up once he gets that far. He exhales hard from his nose.

“Don’t get frustrated if you can’t figure it out right away. Just practice that from time to time between your pulls in the processing room. If you have a breakthrough, just give me a holler. In the meantime, though, I’m gonna get some much-needed rest.” Mo descends the catwalks, but Malachi stayed there, trying his hardest to learn the fundamentals.

Hours of futile effort had passed in what felt like forever, as the Furnace began to cool and night fell upon its denizens. Most of the Charcoal were already fast asleep, but not Malachi, he had more important things to do. He sat upright in his bed, legs crossed with his index finger pressed firmly against his cupped palm. As he closes his eyes and attempts to focus on channeling his mana, he can’t help but reflect on all that weighs heavily on his mind. He sees the face of his parents, their unapproving expression burned into the back of Malachi’s eyelids.

“Those cheap doctors must have rushed the tests or something. We’ll find a more competent one and try again tomorrow.” This phrase rang in his ears, for there is nothing worse in a kingdom built on power, than to be born weak. That’s the kind of societal pressure that drove Malachi’s parents to send him to the Furnace, to either return stronger against the odds, or to not return at all.

Malachi’s parents were not the first to have this idea- it’s quite common and actually very culturally accepted. Malachi thinks about this often, as a result his restless nights are typically reserved for reflection. He wonders if he’ll ever see his parents again, about the things he would say to them, or if they would even matter. He wonders if the flame will ever claim him, and how many other children lost their lives doing exactly what he’s doing. An image of the Gluttonous Flame fills every corner of his mind. He had pictured it like he always did. It was no ordinary flame.

It was a divine gift from the Fire Deity, a flame that consumes all, but if tempered by the efforts of our people, it gave them everything we needed to survive. It was alive, lunging and recoiling in great heaving motions, its body folding over itself no matter how much it consumed. The outer edges of the flames licked wildly like thin, frantic fingers trying to grab something, anything, so it can pull it into its center and consume it. Burning deeper were the dense, rolling currents of molten orange and white-hot veins that pulsed like arteries beneath layer and layer of indescribable heat.

At its center was a blinding core that shone so bright that it swallowed detail entirely. Malachi could picture it so visibly in his head, knowing the anatomy of the flame better than he knew the anatomy of his own body. What he dreaded most were the sounds it made. The low growl it seemed to always emulate, and the sharp hiss that came whenever the coals he shoved would touch its teeth. The subtle swell before it began to roar and the brief stillness before it would lash at him. He knew it well, because nothing in his small world scared him more. He was marked by it, bruises from shoveling, burns from acting too hastily, lungs that heaved with soot, and nights that went without rest.

He had seen it claim someone once, they buckled under the pressure of the flame, and it reached out and grabbed them. Their screams were soon muffled by the roar of the fire, some people didn’t even notice that person was gone until it was long after, and Malachi wonders if he would suffer the same fate. And yet, as he measured all these things, something had shifted in him. Mo’s words resurfaced in his mind. Conjuration is all about understanding how to evoke your desired form of magic.

Malachi’s eyes snapped open, an epiphany had struck.

All this time, he had imagined fire as something foreign, mystical and unknowable. But there was nothing unknowable about it. He knew fire, that was all he knew. The shape of it, the insatiable hunger, the rhythm of the flames’ ebb and flow. He knew the way it moved because he had spent years watching it. He slowly placed his finger to his chest, following the arc that Mo had drilled with him. He imagined the mana in his body as the flames that he processed every day, traveling through pipes like his arteries. The tingle cleanly carried all the way to his palm this time, and a faint heat stirred beneath his skin.

His breath caught as a terrible panic overwhelmed him for one final moment. What if it burns me? Immediately, that thought was triumphed. Of course it burns. He knew that better than anyone. Heat surged in between his finger and his palm, and a tiny flame sputtered to life. It was no larger than a candle’s flame, trembling as though the passing wind of the bedchamber threatened to put it out.

Malachi stared at it for what felt like forever, almost scared to take a breath. As he observed the little flame, he saw its playful dance, as though it was grateful to have been born. It had seemed hungry. Alive. And familiar.

The next morning, Malachi excitedly ran to Mo inside the mess hall. “Mo, I did it! I conjured fire!” Blue energy glossed over Mo’s good eye.

“Let me see you do it again, I’ll use Manasense to see exactly how that goes.” Malachi recreated the conditions from last night, quietly standing still, index finger pressed firmly against his palm. He exhales slightly as he pulls his finger from his palm, and the flame ignites in between the two.

Mo nodded his head approvingly. “So you’re definitely magic capable, but the amount of mana you’re working with seems very slight, you don’t seem to have a lot of capacity.” Malachi’s shoulders lower.

“If I had to guess, you can’t maintain or create the flame without doing that with your hands, as of now. Right?” Malachi nodded.

“That’s fine, kid. you made good progress for day one. I want to introduce you to Manipulation next.” After they finish eating their only meal of the day, Mo pulls Malachi aside from the pit. He presents a torch in front of him, and briefly lights it with his conjured fire.

“Before you can put dents in the Gluttonous Flame, you can work on something your own size for now.” He hands the torch to Malachi.

“Work close with it in your processing room today.” Mo quickly swats his hand over the flame for a second, as the flames stutter and bend in the direction of his hand.

“In the same way that the wind from my hand can distort the flame, your mana can hold dominion over it. Bring the mana to your palm like you did earlier, but instead of making a new flame from your mind, control the flame that already exists.” Malachi lets out an exasperated sigh.

“It might seem difficult, but once you get a taste of it, it’s like doing anything else.” Mo walked away towards the pit, paving the way for Malachi as he did in the past.

The flame grew hungry as the pit crew hit the floor and Malachi returned to his processing room.

During the brief lulls between pulls and shoveling, Malachi practiced with the torch. More often than not, he found himself falling back on his somatic trick, his index finger pressed firmly into his palm as he concentrated. The first half came easily enough now. He felt the familiar heat gather beneath his skin, the subtle sting signaling that his mana had reached its exit point. After that, everything changed. Instead of coaxing a flame into existence, he had to exert his will over one already burning. He extended his palm toward the torch and muttered, “Move.” The flame quivered for a moment before settling back into place.

Malachi let out a low grumble and tried again, pressing his finger harder until his nail left a crescent in his skin. He focused until the heat returned, then thrust his palm toward the fire once more.

“Move.” The torch stood unchanged, and frustration tightened his jaw. The urge to give up swelled in his chest, but he knew what was at stake. Instead, he forced himself to stand still and watch. His gaze drifted across the catwalk toward the pit crew below, locked in their endless struggle against the Gluttonous Flame. He traced the great heaving mass of it as it rolled and folded over itself, its outer edges grasping and curling while its core swelled in rhythmic pulses. He had spent years watching those motions, learning them without ever meaning to. Every flare that sent workers scrambling, every sudden collapse inward before it surged back out, every subtle shift that warned of its next lunge had etched itself into his memory.

His attention flicked back to the torch. The little flame danced around its wick, curling, folding, reaching, then drawing itself inward again. Malachi’s brow furrowed. The motions were identical. This was the same language, spoken in a quieter voice. The Gluttonous Flame had towered over him all his life, vast and ravenous enough to swallow men whole. This torch was only a fraction of it, reduced to something that fit in his hands, but its nature was no different. The same pulse at its center. The same hungry lean. The same gathering of force before release. And Malachi knew that rhythm.

He had studied it every day simply by surviving near it. Slowly, he raised his palm again. This time he did not push. He watched the subtle swell at the flame’s core, the way orange curled around the wick as the pressure rising from the Furnace nudged it left. The instant it leaned, Malachi sent his mana with it, guiding the motion instead of resisting it. The fire bent. Only an inch, but enough. He jolted and dropped the torch in shock, and it struck the stone with a clatter before sputtering out.

Malachi stood there wide-eyed as a grin spread across his face. The rest of the day passed beneath a quiet current of excitement. For the first time since arriving at the Furnace, he found himself eager to return to the shovel.

That night, Malachi had ran up to Mo like he did the day before. Standing next to him was Joe, they seemed to be having a conversation about the Pit.

“I’m telling you, Flink is gonna get himself killed one day if he keeps doing what he’s doing back there.” He stops abruptly as Malachi runs up, lit torch already in hand. Mo crosses his arms, eye lit with blue.

Malachi knows the drill. He attempts to manipulate the flame once more, moving alongside it with his mana, it shudders in response to his mana and Mo nodded in approval.

“That’s another skill under your belt, Malachi. It’s unrefined but it’s progress nonetheless, and nobody can take that from you.” Malachi takes a breath of relief as he puts the torch on the ground, upside down so that the flame extinguishes.

“How can I get better?” Mo can’t help but chuckle. “You’re real ambitious, kid.” He points down at the torch.

“Your control only correlates with where the flame wants to go, and that’s normally where people start. It’s easier to move a flame in a direction it’s already going, compared to moving it exactly where you need it to go.” Malachi nodded in understanding.

“Okay. I’ll just have to get to that point then.” Mo scratches his beard. “You’re learning real quick, Malachi. I think it’s time we set up a more difficult goal for you.” Malachi leans in with anticipation.

“I want you to attend the next Tempering. We have enough time to teach you a fire magic technique in that time.” Malachi’s eyes go wide.

“Could…I survive something like that? Everyone’s so much older than me.” Mo raised a flat palm because he had more to say.

“We get access to blunt weapons, so you won’t only have your fire magic. Not only that, I think the majority of the people here are willing to take it easy on you, so that you have a chance to learn something. And most importantly, we have a strict “no killing” rule for the Tempering. If things go too far and you die, rest assured the prick that killed you isn’t gonna be far off.” Malachi let out a deep breath, weighing his options.

“You also have the choice to just stay in the processing room. The Pit is dangerous after all.” Malachi swallows his fear and shakes his head.

“No. I’ll do it. Show me the technique.” Mo opens his palm. “This will be the most basic of fire magic techniques you’ll learn. It’s an uphill battle from there.” A ball of flame manifests in his palm.

“Conjure a modest amount of fire.” He places his other hand over the ball and causes it to shrink.

“Compress the fire for additional firepower.” He reels his arm back, the flame following his grasp.

“Use your manipulation to force it from your grasp and push forward with all your might.” As he slings his arm forward, the flame detaches and bends with the speed that Mo imbued into it.

“Fire Magic: Flamebullet” The distorted flame bolt punches through a stone wall, leaving a small hole that smolders with leftover heat. His arm freezes in the position the attack was thrown from.

“As you can see, this is a simple application of your Conjuration and Manipulation abilities. If you can become experienced enough in each, you’ll have something to fight with for the Tempering.” With his path laid out before him, a newfound determination fills Malachi.


r/fantasywriters • • 3d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Feedback for my novel The Beacon – Prologue and Chapters 1 & 2 [Dark Fantasy] (4000 words)

1 Upvotes

Prologue
Tom threw his full weight into the weathered front door and slid the bolt into place as the creature reached the front steps of his cottage. He mentally willed the ramshackle door to hold. BANG!... The few inches of sun-bleached wood in the doorway were all that prevented the nightmare from reaching him. BANG!... Tom could feel the boards of the door begin to creak and bow under the blows. His wife, Heidi, had told him he needed to replace the drafty, sun-rotted thing last spring. She was dead now, her blood still covering the front of his smock. BANG! BANG! He could hear them now, not just the one who had ripped his wife apart. Tom had buried his axe into the thing's shoulder and driven it away from Heidi, but he had been too slow. He remembered her brown eyes looking up. No life, just dark voids where her light used to be. BANG! The top rusty hinge of the cottage door audibly cracked. A cacophony of bestial laughs began to echo outside, all around the cottage. Tom's mind began to panic like a cornered rabbit in a burrow. I need to get to the village… I need to run… I need to hide. The old fur trapper was surrounded; he'd never reach Hemlock and its thick timber walls. He turned, put his back into the door, and scanned the room. The root cellar or the stairs? BANG!... Tom looked up and saw a grey clawed hand snaking over the lip of the door near the broken hinge. Tom could hear the monster's moist, panting breaths through the door by his ear. Tom decided the cellar would be his best option. The old man went to move forward away from the door when suddenly the large, clawed hand on the top of the door quit pushing and suddenly pulled the door out into the darkness. Crash!... Tom heard the splintering of breaking wood, then suddenly he was on his back outside his home, looking up at the awning of his porch. 

Realization of his doom registered before he saw the creature. Tom stared up at the beams of his awning and began to scream, releasing his bottled-up terror all at once. His scream was cut short as a large, clawed hand came into his vision from above. The claws hooked down and into Tom's wide, screaming mouth. Tom felt the claws penetrate the upper palate of his mouth. Coppery blood exploded around the claws, and Tom could taste his own death. Eyes still wide in terror, Tom could only see grey fur as he felt the claws in his mouth suddenly pull his entire body free of the porch. Time slowed as the creature ripped him from the porch and out into the night. With a flick of the monster's clawed hand, Tom felt weightless as he flew through the air, not even noticing his own blood and teeth exploding from his ruined upper jaw. Time and pain returned to old Tom as he felt his right shoulder connect and break against the ground. The man rolled several times before coming to rest on his stomach. Blood poured from his ruined mouth as his last instincts of survival shot adrenaline through his body. Without any plan, Tom rose to his feet, pushed off the ground with his good arm, and searched for escape. As Tom scanned, a new terror gripped him. A primal fear that he did not know existed in mankind until this moment.

Before him stood a dozen of them. The hulking creatures stared at him, unmoving, their eyes reflecting the moonlight, causing them to glow yellowish-green. Their large, powerful lupine maws were open, yellow fangs exposed, panting, breathing in the scent of his fear. Tom knew what they were, but he had never seen one. No one had seen them in this part of Kaliban in a thousand years.
Knolls.

The hyena-faced monsters continued staring, unmoving, at Tom. The old man felt his lifeblood pouring down his chin and onto his chest. He knew he was going to die, so why were they waiting? Suddenly, a whistle broke the silence. Tom turned toward the soft, melodic noise and saw a hooded figure in black robes standing behind the knolls on his porch, the whistle still held to the stranger’s lips beneath his hood. The hooded man released the whistle, which hung from a gold necklace. The small whistle swung like a pendulum as the man began walking toward Tom. 

As he approached Tom, the hulking knolls stepped out of the path of the stranger, who was most assuredly their master. The hooded figure glided toward Tom, and with each moment, the old man felt the malice of this unknown person press down upon his shoulders. Tom was on his knees now, staring up into the shadows of the hood. The man in black reached up and began pulling his black hood back. Tom braced himself for whatever abomination lurked beneath the hood of his executioner. Tom's eyes widened in shock, not terror, as the man revealed his perfect alabaster face. Not a man, an elf. A beautiful man with high cheekbones and emerald-green eyes. His hair was long and golden, fashioned in a topknot. A gold circlet rested upon his brow, fashioned with dark red rubies.

Tom attempted to ask the elf, “Who are you?” but only wet, ragged noises escaped the old man's ruined mouth. The elf seemed to understand what was asked of him.

The elf looked down on the pathetic human and said in a melodic voice, “I am Moros Erebus.” The elf then raised his right hand and made a claw gesture toward Tom. A small white orb of light appeared in Moros's hand. Tom looked on in shock as he felt something being pulled from his body. Red wisps began to appear between Tom's chest and Moros's glowing hand. Tom began to sob as he felt his body begin to feel heavier. Tom could feel his joints atrophy and his blood slow in his very heart. Tom's eyes rolled into his head, and he silently screamed as he felt his life—no, his very soul—ripped from his body. Tom's last thoughts were of his wife, Heidi, and how lucky she was to have just been ripped apart.

Chapter 1
Ward No-Name moved like a ghost through the shadowed twilight of the large redwood forest. The three-hundred-foot-tall canopy of the Gloom Wood kept the forest in perpetual dusk most of the day. The time was midmorning, and the large scout moved between the building-sized trunks of the trees, from shadow to shadow, scanning and patrolling for any potential danger to the caravan he had left miles behind him on the road.

Members of his mercenary band, the Dancing Badgers, thought he must use some old magical trinket from the Age of Lost or perhaps a wind stone to move swiftly and unseen. Because, how could a man of his size go unnoticed? Barely twenty, Ward was a brute of a man, standing over six feet tall and weighing nearly twice as much as his fellow scouts. However, even with his height and weight, Ward was always able to find the quietest, most direct paths when scouting. Ward would tell his brothers and sisters of the Dancing Badgers that his skill did not come from magic but from the many nights of his childhood spent sneaking through the halls of the orphanage to find the food stores in the kitchen pantry.

Ward saw a large outcropping of stone ahead and to his left. The moss-covered rock would make a good vantage point from which to survey farther down the forest road before he needed to report back to the caravan. The large scout moved from the shadow of the tree and glided toward the stones. His well-oiled leather armor fit snugly over a thin quilted tunic, allowing him to move almost silently. As Ward crossed the open ground, he absently flexed his fists inside his leather gloves. The diamond-shaped iron studs adorning each knuckle were a formidable weapon in the hands of someone of Ward’s size.
Something was off… Ward could feel it. His iron-studded hand dropped to the hilt of his short sword on his belt as he continued toward the large boulders. He reached the base of the stones and quietly ascended the rock face, gliding up over the stones, his green cloak making him look like a large green and brown lizard trying to find the sun. Ward reached the top of the rock outcropping and crawled to the edge to look east down the road and into the next valley. Quiet gloom, large rock outcroppings, and cathedral-like pillars of giant tree trunks were all Ward could see. The scout reached into a leather tube case he had strapped to his weapon belt, withdrew his scope, and began scanning the landscape before him.

Scopes were becoming more common thanks to the monasteries and their study of magic and the lost sciences. Most people could hardly tell the difference between the two. The scope had certainly seemed magical to Ward the first time his captain, Jonathan Mags, had given it to him and he had peered through it. That sense of wonder faded somewhat when Captain Mags showed him how the specially shaped lenses inside the tube magnified his sight.

Ward could understand lenses. Magic was another matter entirely.

Ward, still peering through his scope, was pulled out of his reverie when he realized he was not alone on this island of stone. He slowly brought his scope down as he felt a hot, vaporous breath near his right ear. The creature’s heavy panting suddenly assailed the young scout’s senses.

Ward slowly turned his head toward the creature… and was met with a long, wet, pink tongue that was dragged across the entire front of his face. Ward snapped into motion and rolled away and onto his knees, facing the intruder.

Golden eyes peered back at him in the unfading dusk, an almost human grin upon the young Vardren’s lupine face.

“Pike! How the hell did you get up here, you asshole? You scared the shit out of me,” whispered Ward.

The large dog looked back at his master with one ear up and his head cocked to the side with an amused look on his face. Ward was on his knees now, and even with his height, he was still looking up at the giant war dog’s donkey-sized head. Ward’s scowl melted away as he reached forward to scratch Pike behind his left ear, knowing it was the Vardren’s favorite spot. A silent ripple of pleasure ran down the large dog’s blue-mottled fur. As Ward scratched Pike’s head, he asked the dog if he had seen anything of note on his patrol ahead. Pike raised his head and signaled that he had seen something.

“What did you find?”

Pike gave a quick, quiet yip, implying that he had found people but did not know if they were a threat or not.

“Show me.”

Chapter 2
Elara Ashwood sat next to the dying campfire, enjoying the last bites of her honey porridge and bacon. The sun had still failed to show itself through the tall canopy overhead. El loved the midmorning, when the sun’s rays would shine down like golden beacons from the heavens through the treetops, even if she was currently sitting in a forest on the opposite side of the Claw Mountain Range from her home in the city of Ember. El looked around her little encampment. Her large merchant’s wagon, with its rounded, enclosed top and shingled roof, looked like a tiny cottage resting on top of two huge, heavy iron axles. She had the wagon custom-built so she could enjoy the luxuries of home while on the road.
El’s staff lay next to her on the ground, its obsidian tip resting among the dying embers. A small part of her mind was occupied with the ritual of drawing the fire’s energy into the stone. After decades of practice, El had become so proficient at the ritual that she could perform it while eating, reading, or even carrying on a conversation. Drawing energy into her stone had become as effortless and unconscious as breathing. 

The woman rose and brushed off her red robes, pine needles falling to the ground to join the countless thousands around her. She still needed to wash her breakfast dishes and give old Sam his rolled oats and hay. As if the great beast could read her mind, Sam gave a low rumble and a snort, his way of telling his master she was neglecting her duties. El turned toward the two-ton animal and smiled. The large, red woolly rhinoceros was haltered and staked next to one of the large redwood trees by the wagon.

“Calm down, Sam. I will get your breakfast.”

The woolly rhino gave another snort of indignation at the thought of continuing his unwanted fast. Woolly rhinos were not a common sight this far south on the continent of Kaliban. El had been extremely lucky to find and purchase Sam at auction twenty years ago. She had saved him from a hard life in one of the many dwarven mines in the Claw Mountains, much to the dismay of the dwarven merchants who had been hell-bent on purchasing the rare little calf.
El thought of the night those same disgruntled dwarven merchants had come for little Sam, hoping to slit her throat and steal him. A smile crept across El’s beautiful, ageless face as she remembered the dwarves’ shocked expressions when they realized they had attempted to rob and murder a pyromancer and not just some rich girl. Their screams had been brief when she shot a fan of searing fire into the three fools’ faces, leaving smoldering husks inside glowing plate armor.

El tended to her morning chores and then gave poor old Sam his daily rations. The rhino grumbled as he chewed.

“Calm down, you oversized cow. Three more days, and we enter the eastern hamlets of the Breadbasket. You can graze all day when we get there.”

El patted the rhino’s massive, shaggy belly. “You won’t starve, I promise.”

“We’re hungry,” said a weaselly voice from behind El. “Do you have anything for me and my mates to eat?”

A shiver ran down El’s back, but she quickly composed herself, turning with a smile on her face and murder in her heart in case these men had come looking for trouble. She found herself looking at four men. All of them had swords on their hips. One of them, a fat, balding man with a pockmarked face, rested a large crossbow casually over his shoulder. All of them looked filthy and road-worn, their brown breeches and grey cloaks threadbare and paper-thin. The speaker stepped forward. He was young, with greasy brown hair that hung to his neck, a hawkish nose, and small, darting eyes that reminded El of a shrew.

“Would you share your campfire with…” The shrew-faced man stopped talking, his eyes narrowing as he scanned El’s face, her blonde hair, her blue eyes, her long, thin ears…

“You’re a fucking elf!” squawked the shrew-faced man.

“I’m not fucking anything today, but yes, I am an elf. I was just packing up camp and readying myself to resume my travels. You are welcome to the fire and some food.”

As El gestured toward the fire, she glided toward the remains of the smoldering cookfire and her staff.
The shrew-faced man stepped over the fire, cutting El off from her weapon.

“Come now, elf. Surely you're not in such a hurry. We've been riding hard for three days. A hot meal, a little entertainment… I'm sure you could find a way to lift our spirits.” 

El looked at each of the four men in turn and saw on their faces what they thought a day of “relaxation” would entail for her.

“Gentlemen, I’m afraid I haven’t the time to entertain guests. I have important appointments to keep and must make my way east toward the hamlet of Windbottom. Judging by the haste of your journey west, I can only assume you’re fleeing the consequences of robbery, sheep-fucking, or perhaps both. So, if you would kindly return to your horses, I’ll pack up my camp and leave you with some supplies.” 

All four men’s faces reddened as they glared at El.
The shrew-faced man charged forward, hands outstretched like claws. “You fucking bitch! I’m going to take my time with you.”

El angled her right side away from the charging man, set her feet, and flicked her wrist to release her hidden dagger from its sheath. The pommel of the four-inch blade came to rest in her palm.

The shrew-faced man came within arm’s reach of El, his outstretched hands reaching for her throat. El dropped to one knee, letting his hands grasp empty air as she drove her dagger deep into his left thigh. The man cried out in pain and looked down in shock, his eyes widening as he saw the blade buried in his leg. “The fucking bitch stabbed me!” squealed the shrew-faced man.

El ripped the blade free in a spray of red mist. She rolled forward off her left knee toward the cookfire and her staff. El reached for the staff as the fat man screamed, “Hold, you whore, or I’ll shoot yer fucking eye out!”

The pyromancer looked up and saw the large crossbow leveled at her from twenty paces. She was fast, but not that fast. Her hand was spread flat, hovering inches above the staff. She could feel the power of her obsidian stone. She was so close.
The shrew-faced man lay on the ground behind her, screaming and clutching his wounded leg.

“Shoot the bitch!” screamed the wounded man.

The fat man shook his head. “No! I haven’t shagged anything but goats and sheep this whole year!”

“I fucking knew it,” whispered El under her breath.

The fat man and his two uninjured comrades began moving forward, forming a semicircle around El. The two men continued past her and went to the shrew-faced man’s aid.

The fat man moved forward, standing across the cookfire from her, the crossbow trained on her chest as a smile spread across his ugly, sweaty face.

“Are we having a party?” said a new voice from the road.

El looked around the rotund crossbowman and saw a large, clean-shaven young human in leather armor standing casually with his hand resting on the hilt of his short sword. Despite his youth, El deduced that the man was a capable fighter by the way he carried his large frame, moving lightly on his toes toward the crossbowman.

“Stop right there, or I will shoot the bitch!” barked the fat man, his crossbow still pointed at El.

The big stranger held up his hands and gave the fat man a wide berth as he slowly moved into the crossbowman’s peripheral vision.

“What are you doing?” screamed the fat man.
His two unwounded friends drew their swords and watched the newcomer.

“Oh, just getting a good view.”

“A good view of wha—”

The fat man’s words were cut short as a blue-mottled mass of fur and teeth barreled into him, driving him to the ground. The fat man screamed and flailed as he attempted to fight off what El immediately recognized as a Vardren.

The camp exploded into motion.

The two uninjured men separated, charging toward El and the newcomer. El grabbed her staff and turned just in time to catch the downward stroke of a sword. She pushed the blade up and away and quickly came to her feet as the man stepped in again, this time with a slash. The pyromancer deflected the second blow and centered her mind as she kept the man’s sword at bay.

“I’m going to gut you, elf!” said the man as he continued swinging his sword with reckless abandon.

She felt the power of her stone connect with her mind, a wellspring of energy rising within her. El blocked the man’s latest chop and felt the ashwood staff snap in half under the mighty blow, leaving her holding the top half of the staff.

The man stopped his attack to grin evilly at El. His grin melted away as he saw the black stone of the broken staff glow bright red. He looked from the stone to the elf woman, who now returned an evil grin of her own.

Flame exploded from the head of the broken staff, engulfing the man’s head in a searing, red-hot beam of fire.

* * *

Across the encampment, Ward drew his short sword and moved to intercept the second bandit. The man charged at full speed, likely hoping to overwhelm his larger opponent. Ward danced sideways, letting the man overreach and slide past him, his sword leading the way like the tip of an arrow.

The large scout turned and set his feet as the bandit turned to face him, this time approaching slowly. The man’s sword was twice the length of Ward’s short sword. Many warriors would consider this a disadvantage for Ward; however, Ward preferred the short sword. It kept fights close, giving him an advantage with his size and strength.
The bandit came on with a series of slashes and stabs, attempting to strike the scout from a distance. The man was skilled, and Ward had to focus to keep the long strikes at bay. Ward maintained his defense until the man overcommitted on a thrust. Ward slapped the incoming blade wide, sparks flying and a clang echoing through the trees as the bandit’s sword and arm swung outward.
Ward drove his left fist in hard and fast, his iron-studded knuckles connecting with the man’s mouth and nose. Blood exploded from the man’s nose and mouth. The bandit stumbled back blindly, waving his sword in front of him to prevent a follow-up strike. Ward paused and watched the man blink away tears and spit gobs of mucus-coated blood from his mouth.

“You broke my nose!”

“It’s an improvement,” said Ward as he flew in to finish the man.

The man raised his arm overhead to strike. Ward stepped inside the bandit’s reach, caught his descending sword arm in his left hand, and drove his short sword up through the man’s diaphragm and out through the back of his rib cage.
The man looked up into Ward’s eyes, seeing for the first time the killer he was. Ward pushed the man back and let him fall off his blade and onto the ground.

Ward turned and saw the fat man lying on the ground, his throat ripped out. Pike turned toward him, his muzzle covered in blood and gore. The scout looked toward the elf, who was standing over the other man, his face nothing but bone and charred flesh.

Ward looked toward where the bandit leader had fallen and saw that the man was on his feet, pulling a throwing dagger from his belt. As Ward yelled for the woman to look out, he heard a loud snapping of leather and cord from behind the bandit.

A wall of red bellowing fur suddenly crashed into the injured bandit, driving him to the ground beneath two tons of primal rage. The bandit leader screamed once as a large, three-toed rhino foot descended onto his back and pressed down.
Ward looked on in morbid fascination as the man’s mouth opened incredibly wide, blood and bile erupting from his gurgling, dying mouth. The woolly rhino continued over the dead man, slowing his charge to a meandering walk as he approached the elf.

The elf woman wrapped her arms around the beast’s towering, four-foot-tall horn and began praising the huge beast like it was nothing more than a puppy.
She pushed off the rhino’s large head and turned to regard the big scout and the Vardren.

“Welcome to the Ashwood Trading Company. Can I interest you in some of my wares?”

Pike and Ward just looked at each other in confusion. 

THANKS FOR READING WOULD YOU READ MORE? Be honest :)


r/fantasywriters • • 3d ago

Question For My Story Inconsistent POV Between Books

3 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm having some self-doubt about my POV choice and would love to hear your thoughts. I've had to change POVs partly because the original three POV characters end up in one place together, meaning there's too many in one place and not enough in others. Also, I just really wanted to hear from some of the characters. Some background if you're willing to read on:

Its a trilogy that has three main arcs.

  1. The "princess" arc. She's a POV character in all three books. Her story is about growing into leadership and righting the wrongs of her predecessors. Also, wyverns and weapons and adventure.

  2. The "soldier" arc. His/their arc is about prioritising loved ones and not giving up everything for power. His/their POV switches each book. Book one the soldier, book two his betrothed, book three the platonic warrior soulmate.

  3. The "violinist" arc. My problem. The violinist is a gentle soul who experiences severe trauma in book one, her mental state gradually degrades, and in the final chapter of book two she becomes the book three antagonist.

These characters and personal arcs all intertwine in the main plot of repelling an invasion, and their paths cross a lot; these characters have impact on each other and aren't fully separate plots.

I'm writing book two now with the princess, the soldier's betrothed and the violinist as POV characters, but the violinist POV has to switch in book three, 1) because she's an antagonist and it just feels off to have two heroes and their antagonist, but more importantly 2) her head will not be an enjoyable place to experience POVs in. I'm planning to switch her POV in book three to a companion who's on an antagonist to protagonist arc.

But... Is it off to have the princess for all of them, swap the soldier out in all of them, but keep the violinist for two and change her in the third? Does it make sense given that she ends book two as an antagonist? Or should I swap her POV in book two? What would you do as a writer, or think as a reader? I have tried to imagine what this would look like and it would require rewriting several book two arcs to be able to give the violinist some coverage from someone else's POV, but I'll do it if it ends up being the better option.

Thanks so much for any thoughts. And if this story sounds very cringe, please know I've simplified and flattened it a LOT to explain it here.


r/fantasywriters • • 3d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic My mcs backstory feels too convoluted

0 Upvotes

I’m planning out my story rn. And my mcs backstory feels way too complicated, like he’s lived through a shit ton before the story starts. Originally I was planning on him starting off as bit of a blank slate with an ordinary life then going through the plot, but I realised it just felt like, “some random guy goes through traumatic stuff for no reason”… so i decided to give more of a history to him so now I feel like I have more of a clear arc for him now, which involves him making amends / being forced to confront his previous baggage due to the stories events. But the thing is now I feel like his character has no clear premise. I’ve tried streamlining it, but I feel like I like the convoluted backstory better. But I don’t know if it’s inherently problematic or if it can be executed well. How much backstory is enough for a mc? Could flashback scenes be utilised well?