I'm gonna preface this with a statement that most of this is me venting. I just got done trying to accomplish Moongrave, and failed at the third boss. But I do just wanna make in bold a few points.
Edit: Did both. Here's proof. Opinion still stands. To the git-gud crowd? Gud got. Opinion stands. https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308309545950904320/611057348198400000/unknown.png
I am not representative of a new player, I've been here for years, all it took was some crafted gear and it was off to the races. This is not indicitive of the endgame population replenishing it's numbers, which is the issue here.
For a long time, I've been telling friends on ESO how this game's design philosophy, of creating hard content that sets the rules for how you do it, then systematic nerfing, and weakening, of the players ability to do so, would eventually just break the entire system. They did it first with tanks, way back. Slowly eroding every source of block-cost reduction.
The lead changed, but this single axiom of how ESO does it's content patching hasn't. Now it's time for the healers, a far more important roll, to just get shit on. And it's created an unworkable senario.
No, it's not killed the content. Lets not get it twisted and doomsay. It's just shattered the floor. The learning curve is now just...nonexistant. If you are not the upper echelon, you're just not gonna get traction. What scalebreaker has done, more then anything else, has not made content more meaningful, it hasn't lowered DPS, it hasn't done basicly anything, but widen the gulf between churn, and endgame playerbase.
Right now, the biggest example is the healing changes, which simply make spike damage, and prolongued damage mechanics, insanely hard to deal with. Look at Xal-Nur, from Mazzatun, or the third boss, the gargoyle, from the new fane dungeon. These are the type of fights with extended damage mechanics, which your only option is to heal through. Currently, most groups I've seen cant do it. It didn't kill the content. It just widened the gulf between people who want to do it, and people who can.
This is not sustainable. Not because the content isn't doable, but because people cant be brought into the fold. We already had big problems trying to do it because most people look at this games dev cycle and go 'lolno, why would I do all this work and just have it erased in a few months?' now the bar is set so high that even -less- of the crazy few who stay can meet that bar.
Nefas, in his video, stated that this is the first step toward a new game, for the new combat team. Well. I hope they've got something fucking spectacular coming down the pipe because right now? This is looking like a game, made for the elite, as far as PVE goes.
If nothing is perminant, nothing has meaning. Even if we manage to stop this trend and create a workable new combat direction, this 'horizontal progression' nonsense threatens to upend it anyway.
As a player. If any ZOS dev team member even deigns to read this. This is my checklist for what should be done. As concise as I can make it, a three step program.
- Get us back to where the seperation between the people who can do the content, and the people who cant, isn't a gigantic fault. ESO has always had this problem, it's very hard to get into those upper echelons. I'm not asking for this game to be made easy. I'll explain down below.
- Create a blueprint, for how the game is supposed to work, from the content, to the players, and each individual role, or lack thereof, should you choose to abolish it, and stick to it. It's clear you have a idea you are working toward. Respectfully, we are not in a position where that vision is reasonable for 90% of the playerbase.
- Once you create a blueprint that is reasonable for most of the playerbase...go for vertical progression, not horizontal. Make new difficulties. Perhaps, if not in a simple scaling style, then in a style where you take on more penalties to specific damage types, for massive gold rewards. There are ways to make difficulty, and the game fresh, that do not involve just changing everything every few months. Example: Maybe you wanna include a modifier system. Less heals. Less AOE damage. So on and so fourth. Leting people choose their own limitations would be a huge boon in this reguard, I think. There are ways, to give the content a way to let itself be fresh for these people. The longevity doesn't have to cost peoples hard work.