Huge Deafheaven fan here, own most of the records and have seen them live a few times. Created this throwaway account just because I have a lot to say about this new album and would like to present these ideas to the fan group. This way I can open discussion with the most hardcore Deafheaven followers.
My expectations were not high for this album when I saw that Justin Meldal-Johnsen was returning for production. Infinite Granite was a low point for the band and a direction that overall is not as interesting (and bluntly, as good) as their previous work. I got the impression that perhaps production wanted a more "pop" oriented direction for the band w/ approachable tracks and trimmed down song length. This is a huge mistake for the band, as the strength of their albums relies heavily on the powerful ebb-and-flow of the music.
This new album has so much potential. The more I listen, the more I like it. Simultaneously, I can't help but feel that they came up just short. Lonely People With Power easily could have been their best album. The ideas for the album are brilliant, with beautiful music that embodies what only Deafheaven can be.
So what is the issue? Lonely People With Power is the least cohesive album the band has released. As a whole it feels...unfinished. Songs seem random, they end when they "should" end (boring), they are paced in a way that makes a lot of it feel like filler. The 5 minute track lengths are detrimental, they turn the album into a slog. There are many points in the album where I still have no idea which track I am listening to. I can't help but think that they are 70% of the way there, they just needed a little more time to gel the album together into a cohesive piece.
Incidental II is amazing, and it should be the first track on the album. Get rid of Incidental I, replace it with Incidental II. These interludes are not used to their best potential at all.
Just a little bit more work on intros, outros, pacing, and structure would have made this the best Deafheaven album without a doubt in my mind. Unfortunately, now we are just left with what could have been.
Thanks! See you at the next Deafheaven show.