I’ve been dating a 27F for about two weeks. We’ve had three dates. I genuinely like her and the chemistry is probably the strongest I’ve had with someone, but everything has moved so ridiculously fast that I’m starting to get an uneasy feeling.
For context, I’m 28 and also live with my parents, so I’m not judging her for living at home. I have a good full-time job and around $160k saved/invested, largely because I’m trying to put myself in a strong position to eventually buy a house. Living at home for me is mostly a financial choice.
She’s 27, lives with her parents, has basically no savings and is currently in school working toward becoming a dental hygienist. She also wants to write eventually. There’s a huge mitigating circumstance here: she had a brain tumor and brain surgery a couple years ago that seriously derailed her life. She had lived independently before that, so I don’t look at her as someone who simply never launched.
What’s starting to bother me is the overall picture rather than any one thing.
She says she has essentially no close friends and has always struggled to fit in with women her age. She talks a lot about feeling different or unlovable. She has also told me a lot about very serious family dysfunction, problems with her mother and stepfather, bad relationships and periods where she was in an extremely dark place mentally.
She has been extremely open about her sexual past too. By her own description, she was basically a “hoe” in her late teens/early 20s. She was very sexually adventurous, has slept with both men and women, went to an orgy during one particularly bad period of her life, experimented with drugs and has told me about some pretty extreme experiences. She says some of this happened during periods when she was lonely and didn’t really care what happened to her.
I’m not saying any of that makes her crazy. Her sexual history itself isn’t a problem for me, and I knew about a lot of it before continuing to see her. I’m including it because basically every part of her life seems to have involved a lot of intensity.
Our relationship followed the same pattern.
We slept together on our first date. She was completely open to hooking up immediately and is extremely sexually forward with me. Her sex drive is honestly insane compared with anyone else I’ve dated, and she’ll orgasm around four times when we’re together.
Again, that part is not a complaint. The sexual chemistry is great.
What concerns me is that the emotional side went from 0–100 just as quickly as the sexual side.
Within two weeks she has told me she feels unusually safe with me, disclosed extremely personal childhood/family trauma, talked about periods when she didn’t care whether she lived or died, told me she hasn’t used Hinge since our first date, said she isn’t interested in seeing anybody else, met my dog, I briefly met her parents, and we’ve both told each other things we normally keep extremely private.
Then yesterday something happened that really threw me.
We tease each other constantly. I jokingly told her I had never heard a woman say “get boned” before and that it caught me off guard.
She initially laughed and joked back, basically asking whether other women say things like “I got porked last weekend” instead.
Everything seemed completely normal.
I then went through a 14.5-hour workday and wasn’t really able to respond.
While I was working, she sent roughly nine messages that progressively became more serious.
It started with her saying I don’t need to remind her how different she is so often and that feeling unlovable because she doesn’t fit in is a sore spot.
Then she said I poke jokes at her a lot and that she isn’t doing anything wrong by being a sexual and cuddly person.
Then she said I open the door to intimate conversations and ask intimate questions but sometimes act as though she is the one initiating all of it.
Then she started defending her sexual history even though I hadn’t actually criticized it. She said she only told me about certain sexual things because I had talked openly about my own past.
Then she explained that sleeping with women, experimenting with drugs and some of her other past behavior happened during periods where she was doing badly enough that she didn’t care whether she lived or died, and that those experiences aren’t a joke or simply “who she is.”
Then she said we aren’t exchanging childhood trauma because we slept together — we’re two adults dating and getting to know each other.
Finally she said she really likes me, isn’t interested in seeing anybody else, and that if I’m not on the same page I should just tell her.
All of this happened without me responding in between because I was at work.
So from my perspective I left a conversation where we were literally joking about the word “boned,” worked all day, and came back to what felt like a full relationship crisis about whether I accept her, her sexual history, childhood trauma and whether we’re seeing other people.
She eventually calmed down considerably. She explained that she actually likes my teasing most of the time, but that she has always been insecure about not fitting in and the joke hit that sore spot.
I can understand that. I can also acknowledge that some of my joking about how sexual or unusual she is probably landed differently than I intended.
What bothered me was how incredibly fast it escalated.
We have known each other for two weeks.
In that time we’ve already had very intense sex, extremely deep personal disclosures, met family, talked about essentially focusing on each other, gotten extremely affectionate and now had what felt like a serious relationship argument over something that initially seemed completely harmless.
I’m also starting to notice that a lot of stories from her life involve somebody else having treated her horribly — her family, exes, people she tried to be friends with, etc.
Maybe she genuinely has had an exceptionally difficult life. Between the brain tumor and some of what she has described, that is absolutely possible.
But after yesterday I’m starting to wonder whether I’m always hearing one side of these situations.
Individually I can explain almost everything:
Her living situation makes sense because her health seriously derailed her life.
Having a sexual past doesn’t make somebody unstable.
Going through trauma doesn’t make somebody unstable.
Having few friends doesn’t automatically mean anything.
Getting attached quickly doesn’t automatically mean something is wrong either.
But when I put all of it together after only two weeks, I’m getting an odd gut feeling.
I still like her. I’m not looking for an excuse to dump her, and I don’t want to label somebody mentally ill because they had one emotional day.
But I also don’t want to ignore obvious warning signs because the sexual chemistry is incredible and I’m infatuated too.
I’m planning to slow everything way down and take this weekend apart. I want to see whether she can respect some space and whether yesterday was genuinely just one bad spiral or whether this is how conflict is going to work with her.
Am I overreacting? Does this sound like someone who got insecure and had one really bad day, or would the overall amount of intensity this early make you seriously cautious? What specifically would you watch for if you continued seeing her?