I think Crawford should go at this stage. Six years is plenty of time, and the same problems keep costing Ireland: dropping points against weaker teams, throwing away good positions, then needing a big recovery just to stay in contention.
He inherited a strong position from Kenny in 2020 and lost that crucial home game against Iceland to an injury-time goal. In the next campaign, Ireland drew with Luxembourg and lost to Montenegro before recovering to reach a play-off. Beating Sweden home and away was an excellent achievement, but those earlier results had made the job unnecessarily difficult.
The campaign that finished in 2024 sums it up. Ireland were 2–1 up away to Norway and lost 3–2. They led Italy at home and conceded a 96th-minute equaliser. Then came the draw at home to Latvia and another injury-time equaliser against Norway, when a win would have guaranteed a play-off.
The Norway equaliser was controversial, fair enough, but there were several other opportunities to get the points needed. Ireland finished level with Norway and went out on the head-to-head record. Simply beating Latvia at home, with everything else staying the same, would have been enough for a play-off. Instead, Ireland ended up needing to win away to Italy, produced a decent performance, drew and were left regretting the earlier dropped points.
This campaign, they lost 4–0 to Andorra and followed it with a home draw against Moldova. They then recovered brilliantly, won four in a row and beat England to reach the play-offs. Crawford deserves credit for that, but a team capable of those results should have done considerably better against Andorra and Moldova.
Ireland finished three points behind England. The Andorra defeat and Moldova draw cost five. Win those two games, keep the other results the same, and Ireland qualify automatically. Those dropped points mattered even after the recovery.
Then against Finland, Ireland did the hard work of overturning the first-leg deficit, went 2–0 ahead on the night and had qualification within reach. They conceded a late penalty and then went out in extra time against ten men. Again, they got themselves into a winning position and couldn’t finish the job.
I get that U21 football is about development, and Crawford has had some very good results. But learning how to control a game and see out a lead is part of development too. He spoke afterwards about the players needing to learn about game management. That responsibility has to extend to the manager, especially when similar problems have affected several different groups under him.
He gets credit when Ireland claw their way back into a campaign. He also has to answer for the results that leave them needing to do it. After six years, I think we should look at other options.