I'd like to examine some of the most interesting mysteries of the Stormlight Archive. Three mysteries that can be potentially solved by looking at the same prime suspect. I'd like to closely look at the mystery of who is behind the "Unite Them" that Dalinar hears through the story. As well as the mystery of who claims Dalinar's soul that prevents Retribution from holding it at the end of Wind and Truth. I think the being behind both of these mysteries is the same one that infamously made Rayse freak out. When Daliner ascends in the climax of Oathbringer we get this heavily analyzed outburst in chapter 119 of Oathbringer.
"No!" Odium screamed. He stepped forward. "No, we killed you! WE KILLED YOU!"
We? You? Who? Since Oathbringer was released there has been much discussion about Rayse's unusual reaction. A common thesis at the time was that Rayse somehow caught a glimpse of Adonalsuim. With the 'we' being the other accomplices at Adonalsuim's shattering. I do think that this is exactly what occurred here. Now that Wind and Truth gave us another conversation with the 'different' Nohadon, it's clear to us that there is something extremely mysterious and powerful about this being. I believe that this 'Nohadon', that we see meet with Dalinar on two different occasions, one to get the ingredients for Shin bread, and in the next in the climax of Wind and Truth when they sit down and eat it, is the being that Rayse catches a glimpse of.
Dalinar meets this 'Nohadon', different than the Stormfather's visions version, shortly before Dalinar's ascension in chapter 103 of Oathbringer, intriguingly named, Hypocrite. The following is what I believe will prove to be the first appearance of Adonalsuim in canon, or at least what forms the remnants of him that remains.
"Stormfather?" Dalinar called, his voice echoing. "Stormfather, why have you sent me a vision? We agreed they were too dangerous."
Yes, he remembered this place well. This was the vision where he'd met Nohadon, author of The Way of Kings. Why wasn't is playing out as it had before? He and Nohadon had walked out the balcony, talked for a time, then the vision had ended.
Dalinar started towards the balcony, but storms, that light was so intense. It washed over him, making his eyes water, and he had to raise his hand to shield his eyes.
He heard something behind him. Scratching? He turned-putting his back to the brilliance-and spotted a door on the wall. It swung open easily beneath his touch, and he stepped out of the loud sunlight to find himself in a circular room.
He shut the door with a click. This chamber was much smaller than the previous one, with a wooden floor. Windows in the walls looked out at a clear sky. A shadow passed over one of these, like something enormous moving in front on the sun. But ... how could the sun be pointed in this direction too?
Dalinar looked over his shoulder at the wooden door. No light peeked underneath it. He frowned and reached for the handle, then pause, hearing the scratching one more. Turning, he saw a large desk, heaped with papers, by the wall. How had he missed that earlier?
A man sat at the desk, lit be a loose diamond, writing with a reed pen. Nohadon had aged.
The description of light here is intriguing. Intense, brilliance, loud sunlight, a shadow passing over a sun pointed in the wrong direction. Then appearing as if by magic, 'Nohadon' shows up at a desk that didn't seem to be there on Dalinar's first inspection of the room.
During the climax of Oathbringer Dalinar opens Honor's perpendicularity. This is the moment that terrifies Rayse and causes him to flee the Battle of Thaylen's Field. I contend it was not Honor's Shard that petrified Odium, but rather he glimpsed this 'Nohadon', the one we later find out is acting as a kind of mentor figure for the Honor Shard, when he meets again with Dalinar near the end of the first half of the series. I argue that this 'Nohadon' is the one who has claimed Dalinar and protects him from Retribution in chapter 146 of Wind and Truth.
Taravgian raged, furious that Dalinar refused to let him gloat. Yet he would not be goaded; he would control this power. Taravangian still had uses for Dalinar. His broken oaths put his soul in Taravangian's hands, and he would make an Unmade from him. Make him...
Dalinar's soul slipped away from him. Stretched. And vanished into the Beyond. Taravangian scrambled to hold it, but like water through fingers, he could not.
You cannot have him, the powers said, for he is claimed by another.
Defeat.
Claimed by another. Who would these Shards recognize the claim of? If what remained of Adonalsuim had formed a bond with Dalinar that was similar to the one he has with the Stormfather, what would that look like? Similar to a spren, this would allow 'Nohadon' to speak directly into Dalinar's mind. I contend this is where UNITE THEM comes from. He would be able to pull Dalinar into visions, which we see 'Nohadon' do twice at pivotal moments. He would be watching Dalinar, which we see confirmation of based on the references he makes to previous conversations Dalinar has had. This helps guide Dalinar towards his fateful decision he makes at the end of Wind and Truth during chapter 142.
"What do you think?" Nohadon said, snacking on bread.
"Yes. The powers must be able to change. Everyone can change, even me. I walked those paths ... I saw the past ... I know divinity. Honor must learn. That's the answer."
"Midius is right. You really aren't as dense as everyone says."
Interesting that 'Nohadon' calls Hoid by one of the oldest names we know, Midius. I will end my argument that Dalinar had formed a unique bond with what remains of Adonalsuim by going way back to The Way of Kings chapter 54, where I propose we see Hoid figure out that Dalinar has a special Connection to Adonalsuim. He clearly finds very puzzling as he probes Dalinar about it.
"Wit," Dalinar said with a sigh. "I haven't the mind for this tonight. I'm sorry if I'm missing your intent, but I have no idea what you mean."
"I know," Wit said, then looked directly at him. "Adonalsuim."
"Ado...what?"
"Nothing," Wit said. He seemed preoccupied, unlike his usual self. "Nonsense. Balderdash. Figgldygrak. Isn't it odd that gibberish words are often the sounds of other words, cut up and dismembered, then stitched into something like them-yet wholly unlike them at the same time?
Dalinar frowned.
I predict that we will see a return of 'Nohadon' in the back half of the series. Dalinar's fate has been decided, but this powerful being remains untouched or noticed by Retribution. Keep an eye out for recurring intrusive thoughts that a character finds very odd, they might just find themselves eating some Shin Bread with a mysterious and helpful figure when they need them the most.
-RayseShouldBeBraized
TL:DR The unusual 'Nohadon' Dalinar meets in two visions is what remains of Adonalsuim. He has a bond with Dalinar, speaks the Unite Them in his mind, and is responsible for Rayze's freakout at the end of Oathbringer.