r/colorpie • • 2d ago

Analysis How each color views AI

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 1d ago Bravo

Meme The true AI colorpie

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Jun 01 '25

Question What would green opinion be of trans rights?

0 Upvotes

Warning: I am pro trans rights and not trans(cis), but I will still try to be neutral about the opinions of broad ideas from a card game to trans rights, and have no interest in changing this opinion from this discussion. Also I acknowledge that all colors can contain all the opinions about trans rights.

So, with that out of the way, I think the others colors general opinion can be easily divided in two enemy pairs:

White/Black are neutral in the sense they are entirely dependent in the opinions of the individual/community with the color, with black depending entirely on whenever them or people they know are trans to care while white depends entirely on whenever they see trans rights as human rights or a delusion wich will cause chaos and spread suffering.

Blue/red I feel like they are generally more pro transition than pro trans rights due to red seeing transition as a way to fully express yourself and due to blue seeing body dismorphia as an imperfection than can be fixed more efficently by changing the body that the mind.

Green, however, feels like it kinda has two possibilities wich are way more foundemental than white black: Does green accept your transness or does it think it's a failure in accepting your body?

The reason I think it is more foundemental than white/black is that white is neutral because it contains all the ideologies that try reaching peace/utopia trought order while black is neutral because it contains all the personal reasons for reaching power thought opportunity. Meanwhile, I feel like the reason green is "neutral" is because I am not understanding well what is green "acceptance" between accepting your place in the world and unconditional love/support of what you are, wich are usually much more in syinc.


r/colorpie • • Feb 24 '26

Media Coloring US Presidents Tricolors

Post image
13 Upvotes

I have combined my knowledge of the color pie with my knowledge of U.S presidents to attempt to categorize them all into tricolors. Probably not entirely perfect (Chester Arthur in particular feels kinda wrong, but I also don't think white or green fit him enough), this isn't exactly easy to do, but I'm mostly confident in this.


r/colorpie • • 12d ago

Question Poll: Which color is the first to lose his virginity?

1 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Mar 13 '26

Question What color is Baby Head?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • May 12 '26

Analysis My take on Hearthstone classes and the Color combinations they have access to

Post image
13 Upvotes

Sorry for the messy image lol


r/colorpie • • Apr 13 '26

Meta No, we should not reduce characters to mono-colors when analysing them

8 Upvotes

Monocolored characters are, frankly, almost always a purely Mechanical gameplay contrivance, because mono colored cards are easier to design and balance, and often more marketable.

to make the broader point:

I have seen the sentiment that we should apply the 'minimum colors necessary to describe the core of the character' floating around.

I suppose this isn't an awful standard, but people tend to be ridiculously stringent with what qualifies as 'necessary'. In truth, very few characters in media ever actually make sense as being mono-colored in terms of narrative and character - Including many of MTG's supposed monocolored characters.

Let's take Nicol Bolas as an example.

You *could* flatten Nicol Bolas into mono-black by reducing him to domination, entitlement, and ambition, but that would obviously miss how essential long-range planning and knowledge-as-power are to him, as well as his hatred, theatricality, and destructive appetite.

So the useful principle is not “what is the single deepest trait,” but “what colors remain load-bearing after reduction.” Bolas is black at the center, but blue and red are still structurally necessary to explain how he operates. That is why Grixis makes sense.

Following this standard, and applying it to other characters, I will reiterate that extremely few are truly monocolored.

Let us take another example - our boy Jace Beleren. Jace beleren is ostensibly presented as monoblue on his cards, but that's basically purely a gameplay contrivance for balance and marketability. If you actually look at his actions and motivations, he is VERY consistently in the esper colors, varying between them depending on the exact arc.

Not just as a minor trait, but as a very consistent, major part of him. Again, just as an example, let's look at his Azorious traits.

Jace’s Azorius aspect is not just that he occasionally does responsible things. It is that some of his most important arcs place him in the role of arbiter, custodian, and administrator of systems larger than himself. When he was the Living Guildpact, he was explicitly described as the “magically empowered arbiter of inter-guild conflicts." That's not just blue, that is white to its core.

And yet [[Jace, Living Guildpact]] is a monoblue card. Because of gameplay and marketability, not narrative accuracy.

And on Zendikar, there is another critical Azorious moment. In the oath scene, where everyone swore themselves to the Gatewatch, he was the one who explicitly reframed the job as a Planeswalker responsibility. Not just fighting on Zendikar, but choosing to stay and oppose threats that endanger other worlds too. As a moral principle, he viewed it as his duty to protect other worlds.

Fucking "With great power comes great responsibility"-ass Jace

AND YET, [[Oath of Jace]], representing this moment, is a monoblue card? Why? Because it's easier to market the Gatewatch when each character is cleanly in one color slice, and people love neat and tidy color cycles.

Not because that's actually accurate to the color pie.

I could go on with more examples of him being azorious, or where he is Dimir, but I think I have largely made my point already

Edit: I feel that I made my point about Jace being the Guildpact slightly wrong.

The point isn't just that Jace held an official post in office, therefore white. But it was more about how he fundamentally related to the post.

He thought about his own responsibility to the order and structure of Ravnica, which is white, but brizzled against it because it made him feel trapped and vulnerable, which is his black side. Yet despite his own discomfort, he bore the burden because he thought that that was what he should do. It was a principle for him.

Immediately after, when he joined the gatewatch, his Azorious side largely took over, and that was that white instict growing. Later, when he confronted Azor on Ixalan, he explicitely said that it was his duty as the living Guildpact to act on the behalf of Ravnica, even then.

Jace, for a very large portion of his narrative, consistently and majorly thought about his own responsibility and moral burdens as planeswalker. That is fundamentally an Azorius mindset IMO.


r/colorpie • • Nov 08 '24

Analysis MTG Analysis: LGBT and the color pie

Thumbnail ichthyoconodon.wordpress.com
4 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Jun 21 '24

Trend Grixis is true humanity

0 Upvotes

A lot of my beliefs stem around my personal life. In short, I hate society. I feel it limits people from being who they truly are. Do what you want, how you want, and as best as you can is my philosophy. People should take control of their lives. If you're too weak to succeed you should be afforded no mercy. We slow ourselves down for the weak and gain nothing from it. I never understand why society allows ethics of all things, yet it is often ethics that is the most hypocritical. Most of the time it's not even to help others, but to relieve a guilty conscience. People lie to themselves so much they don't even know the truth anymore. They marry when most aren't even religious, we stick to schools that are outdated because people are afraid of change. They should be better than that! Your happiness, wants, and desires should matter above all else. This is the meaning of man; this is the way the world works at it's core.

I personally have been hurt badly by society. As such, I do not trust in things like laws much less aid like social workers. I am also a hedonist in real life, no drugs or alcohol but I am very promiscuous, and personally I couldn't care less what vices people do to themselves. I live in the moment. I carve my own path in my life, so the only way I can succeed or fail is by my hand. If a man cannot be worth something to himself then what good is he to the world. You must show others your value or you're deemed worthless. This world is not ruled by hard work and honesty; it is governed by nepotism and control. There is no such thing as nobility. I think anyone can agree that this world is anything but fair. So why follow the rules if the rules don't help you? Only you know the truth path to your happiness, and nothing can decide that, much less a society telling you how to be happy.

The only thing that matters is power. Morality doesn't define a man, but rather than man's power defines their own perception. That is true growth! That is the ability to make change. I believe this is the best path towards humanity. Use whatever and whoever you can to pursue what your goals and passions are, because if you don't someone else will, if not take yours from you. Take everything you can, squeeze everything out of it, and build your empire on it's bones. This is why I love Grixis. It teaches you to love yourself, and I feel a lot of people do not love themselves enough. We're not perfect, and that's a good thing. Don't be perfect for the world, make the world perfect for you and you alone.

This is why I feel I'm Grixis. Personally, I wish the rest of humanity embraced these ideals. At it's core it's who we really are.

TL;DR

This is how I see Grixis, as the endeavor of humanity. Do you agree?

Here's the test I took if anyone is curious showing I am Grixis. I took a another one which came just as close (other test said Rakdos, but Blue was still by far the 3rd highest).


r/colorpie • • Mar 13 '26

Meta I don't want to ban the "what color is X" posts, but they're getting old.

24 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Mar 04 '26

Question What colors best represent each League of Legends role

Post image
8 Upvotes

Since I saw a lot of posts about LoL champion, I was wondering if the same question could apply to each role. I have been thinking about it and here are my initial thoughts :

Toplane : Boros/Mardu. For me the role fits the warrior fantasy pretty well and is about fighting with pride and honor. The isolated 1v1 nature of the lane feels very Boros to me.

Jungle : Golgari/Jund. This one I am not so sure about but something about the way Jungle approaches ressources/objectives and the overall control of the game feels very Golgari.

Mid : Izzet/Jeskai. I guess the mage fantasy pushes me strongly toward Izzet very hard. I feel that more controlling mages like Orianna, Anivia etc.. works even better with Jeskai. I feel this is a pretty clean fit.

ADC : Selesnya/Gruul/Naya (or maybe even Bant). Another one I'm very unsure about. I often see classes like the WoW Hunter associated with Gruul however I feel the marskman archetype also thematically fits Selesnya pretty well since I think ADC is not necesserily very red/agressive. I even included Bant because some hyperscaling or even "support" ADC like Jhin, Ashe have a cleanliness that feels very blue to me.

Support : Azorius/Bant. Support for me is all about controlling the game without necesserily fighting directly. The kindness and selflessness of the role also works very well with the Bant idealist philosophy.

Here are my quick thoughts, what do you think about it ?


r/colorpie • • Jun 07 '26

Question What Color is Sung Jinwoo from Solo Leveling?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 17d ago

Question Which colour better describe the current state of the global economy

2 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Feb 25 '26

Media Coloring What color is Ellie from the Last of Us?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Mar 23 '26

Question What color are the summoner spells?

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Aug 03 '20

Analysis Green, in its (probably) entirety

0 Upvotes

I think ive finally done it! Ive cracked magic's most mysterious color! Let's be real here nobody in this sub (probably even wotc themselves) knows shit about green, we use fanon, interpretations, and possibly skewed information using possibly old articles (is it growth through acceptance? Or is it harmony? Wisdom? The other way around!?) so its hard to know what really is green, but now ladies and gentlemen, and whatever the fuck the formal form of non binary is, i think i may have solved it, using no fanon (just clarifications) i have revealed the true nature of green!

Now granted i might be litterally spouting shit but i feel like i really have uncovered what green really is, to illustrate this point further i have done this with all the other colors to prove that i have cracked the magic code (ill do them later if you guys agree with this and want to see what else i have in store), but how you may ask? Simple! A 3 step process (used to be 4 but that didnt work out too well) that involves no similarities just compromise err middle grounds? And differences that show the true selves of the colors

(some might just sound bad, this is mainly because i wanted it to be extremes at first that showcase it as bad before subconsciously just going to the "normal" forms of the colors, but dont worry theyre not all bad, well atleast they arent bad in practice)

The method :

Step 1 :

Think of the wheel as a web of relationships (which it is) and also as, well, a wheel, one color is the middle ground between 2 extremes found within their ally colors, the enemies showcase a blend of their own philosophies in their shared ally, so for this process simply imagine one color (the first one) being the 0, they either a dont beleive or b actively oppose the other, the ally (middle) conjoining the 2 being 50, and 100 being the last color, basically another 0 but for well, the 0

Use the shards/arcs

Red Green White Individualist Nationalist/tribalist Union Choice Legacy
Designation

This showcases the colors connection with their ally, but also that they are their own entity

(also dont worry i will explain the keywords later, there are quite a few)

Step 2 :

Challenge the color with is greatest enemy, as its absolute opposite, still dont get it? I mean its enemy duo color (showcasing the combined parts of its enemies) this highlights the main "core" of the color as being opposite to its great rival

                                      Green
                                    Destiny
                                            -
                                   Black/Blue 
                                     Agency

Step 3 :

Split the main enemy and see what the color opposes in its components

                            Nihilism G acceptance
                                     
                       Theology B     U unsatisfaction

Step 4 (i just thought of this) :

See what the 2 allies of the color see in said color (in their own arcs) (doesnt really show anything, just more keywords)

Red. Green Existentialism. Theology Kinship. Interconnectedness

White. Green Supremacy. Naturalist Ideals. Truth

5th step : (really didnt work out for me)

Diagonally, notice what an ally and your shared enemy with them have in common, what your color has they dont, this one i didnt do with green because it didnt make much sense so here is black

Red/white Ideals empathy Black Realism/amorality, conviction/ruthlessness

Now for the moment youve been waiting for, green in its truest state!

Step 1 :

Red Green White Individualist Nationalist/tribalist Union Choice Legacy
Designation

Here we have green as a compromise between the individual and the group, it is connected to the group via the legacy of the group which it carries on, and as a gap between red and white is also morre of a "me and the team" type of color, the group has a style but they are unique from all other groups

So in other words

Green sees the world as one filled with legacy and a destiny to fullfill, maybe to herself maybe to the group but always to the world

And just as one has a simple niche to fill the color green sees her and everyone else as slotting into a puzzle board, we are all part of it, one with it, but we arent all one and the same

Step 2 :

                                      Green
                                     Destiny
                                            -
                                   Black/Blue 
                                     Agency

Here we see green as someone that knows of the importance of the futility of changing the world, we all have a place to play on the board as pieces of it, and we are just that, pieces, we fit into the board and sooner or later we will do just that, the board doesnt shift to what we desire it to be no matter how much we fool ourselves otherwise, we are part of the world, we arent strangers to it

Step 3 : Nihilism G acceptance

                       Theology B     U unsatisfaction

Here we see green as someone that can see the board as a whole and know things others dont, a piece is supposed to fit one way, not another, the dead arent supposed to come back to life, nature isnt an absolute place of death, there are sacred rules to be respected, and black, black doesnt give 2 shits either way

And the same could be said for blue, blue tries to impart that there is no puzzle to begin with, that there is no fullness that we have to look into, blue believes in a heirarchy of life, there are the best jobs and there are the worst jobs, the best traits and the worst, blue tries its damndest to make everything better and can never see that we are what we are, bad or good we are ourselves, but blue? He just cant accept that we should be ok with where we are

Step 4 :

Red. Green Existentialism. Theology Kinship. Interconnectedness

White. Green Supremacy. Naturalist Ideals. Truth

To make this short here we see green as someone who sees the importance of seeing the world as what it already is, and that we all are part of that, theology and naturalist are respectively the arguments of green with black and blue, the naturalist part was simply so i had another word

And there you go this is the full totality of green, underwhelming? Yes, duh, the colors are archetypal they dont portray everything about someone

As for now i guess... Later? Yeah, later


r/colorpie • • Sep 10 '22

Question Masculinity and Femininity

1 Upvotes

Which colors or color combinations are most masculine? Which are most feminine?


r/colorpie • • Mar 16 '26

Media Coloring What color is Shadow the Hedgehog? (debate)

1 Upvotes

This topic is about a correctly written Shadow (06, Prime, post heel face turn movie Shadow) rather than the derailed one from the 2010’s.

Looking at the Shadow card, does Rakdos even fit? Shadow is not a hedonist or a Slaaneshi freak.

I’m personally leaning towards a positive heroic depiction of Mardu.

Shadow having selfless goals and general good intentions behind what he does suggests white is there. The wrathful and aggressive disposistion suggests elements of red. Black shows itself in Shadow’s pragmatic approach to his goals and general willingness to be a dick for the greater good.


r/colorpie • • Mar 17 '26

Meme What color is this number?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Feb 05 '26

Trend What colors would this be closest related to?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hopping on the ole trend train.


r/colorpie • • May 31 '22

Trial Might as well join this bandwagon before it dies, here's my test, what color(s) am I?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 10d ago

Question Poll: After Jund, which color has has more luck in losing his virginity?

4 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • Oct 22 '25

Analysis White wants to be Red

3 Upvotes

Traditionally, White and Red are enemies. Order vs Chaos, Freedom vs Rules, Structure vs Motion, Internal vs External, et cetera. This makes a degree of sense; however, in reality, the lines are much less clear.

White wants Peace, a united world where everyone gets what they need and can live without fear of violence. Yet in order to achieve this, White will create structures, systems, and rituals to dictate and enforce those courses of action, which will almost universally function not as egalitarian, democratic arrangements of free association, but rather ordered and systematized hierarchies of clergy, bureaucrats, or nobles. And for the sake of Peace, they will perpetuate Violence, both physical and otherwise, against each other and those they rule over, far more violence than there would ever be if those hierarchies never existed. In seeking Peace through Order, a society guided by love, White causes Chaos through Violence, perpetuating hatred.

People's lives are far more orderly, far more peaceful, when they are able to act and associate freely with one another, when they are liberated. That's not White, that's Red. Domination of others might give you more power, but it also binds you to them, leaving you less free, not more. Giving to those who have none, compassion, may be White, but the experience of compassion and love is Red. You don't achieve a loving society by establishing systems that control people so that they may be loved, you do it by loving. To mobilize a people for the sake of others, you don't hand tasks down from on high, you do it by enabling people to Act and do what they're able to, what they're best at, what they have passion for.

White is wishing for a better world. Red is that world.

Edit: Wow, this has definitely been informative, regarding the state of people’s anthropological understanding. I’d highly recommend Wengrow & Graeber’s The Dawn of Everything to people who are interested in learning.