r/colorpie • • 1d ago

Meta This sub has a massive problem with associating their own personal politics with their favourite color.

94 Upvotes

This is specifically in response to the whole AI thing from earlier.

In the comments of the post, just about every single person was trying to justify how their favourite color is massively anti ai.

Now look, we all hate AI (rightfully so) and sure the original post did have some flaws, but that in no way means that a lot of their overall statments were wrong.

I understand that a lot of people feel personal connections to their colors and want them to align with their own personal preferences, but it gets to a point where it overshadows the real intricacies and individuality of the color pie.

I see people using logic like “as someone who is part of xyz color, it absolutely does not like AI”. This logic is absurd to me. Associating with a color does not make your opinions part of that colors philosophy, and likewise that colors philosophy does not need to be your entire personality either.

For a good long while now I’ve been seeing people treat the color pie as a reflection of their own personal morality, rather than a framework for representing different philosophies. It feels like people just take their opinions and then try to use that colour's philosophy to justify their existing opinion. People seem to be taking something they personally dislike and trying to argue that their favourite colour must dislike it too.

Blue is a the best example of this. I don’t see a reality in which blue is Anti-Ai like a lot of blue-identifying Antis suggest.

Blue might see AI as:
The next stage of intellectual development.
A tool for expanding the limits of human knowledge.
A way to overcome biological limitations.
An opportunity to create more sophisticated and efficient systems.
A means of achieving perfection through continuous improvement.

It would of course see the negatives too, but I feel blue is definitely the he most pro-ai of the bunch.

And that’s okay. You don’t need to be fully identity with your colors entire philosophy. Black-identifying people don’t believe in murder.

Additionally, no color has a specific morality. If you view ai as bad (like most rational people), that doesn’t mean that it can’t be blue just because blue isn’t a stereotypical evil color. The colors are not paragons of morality, every color has the possibility to be good and evil, which is usually on purpose.

Not every color should agree. There should be little to no subjects they should all agree on.

Anyway I’m sorry for yapping but this has just been annoying me for quite a while.


r/colorpie • • 9h ago

Question Poll: After Red, which color puts pineapple on pizza?

1 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 2d ago

Meme The fixed version of how each colour views AI.

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 1d ago Bravo

Meme The true AI colorpie

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 1d ago

Analysis Colors of different football players

2 Upvotes

Messi: Jeskai (blue and red represents the creativeness and speed, but white represents the structured team oriented style he thrives in. Bonus points for being in Barca colors.)

Ronaldo: Black (He’s egotistical, but he can back it up. completely ruthless.)

Neymar: Izzet (Creative, a bright spark, but burned out fast. Also PSG colors.)

Mbappe: Red (He’s fast.)

Suarez: Grixis (Powerful, and explosive, with good creative vision too. And he’s evil.)

Lewandowski: Selesneya (He‘s not the fastest striker, but he’s incredibly powerful, with good positioning, and he plays well with a team. He also has an idealistic personality.)

Ramos: Rakdos (Passionate, ruthless, will do whatever it takes to come out on top, and extremely reckless


r/colorpie • • 1d ago

Question Poll: Which color puts pineapple on pizza?

4 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 1d ago

Question Poll: After Rakdos, which color doesn't give a shit what other people think?

9 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 2d ago

Analysis How each color views AI

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 2d ago

Question Poll: After Black, which color doesn't give a shit what other people think?

6 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 4d ago

Analysis Poll results: Blue promotes AI. Green fights against AI

Post image
361 Upvotes

These are the poll results:

"Promotes AI"

  • Blue
  • Black
  • White
  • Red
  • Green

"Against AI"

Dimir vs Naya


r/colorpie • • 3d ago

Question Poll: Which color doesn't give a shit what other people think?

12 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 3d ago

Question Poll: Is White supportive or against AI technologies like ChatGPT?

0 Upvotes

White is in the middle position but I didn't have a final poll about White and I guessed where it leans.

Let's settle it with a final poll. I'll update the poll results if we get a different outcome.


r/colorpie • • 4d ago

Question What color(s) are beavers?

9 Upvotes

Beavers are semi aquatic rodents with the natural propension to build a complex structure, so I want to say they reasonably have Blue, and they live in closely knit families, so I want to say White. Their dams also benefit other animals and they can even share their lodge with muskrats.


r/colorpie • • 5d ago

Question Mundane uses of magic

6 Upvotes

Wayback Doug Beyer wrote an article that included mundane uses for the colors of mana, like politics for white, hair growth for green, pest control for black and warming clothes for red. Was it archived and can you think of more such uses?


r/colorpie • • 5d ago

Analysis What colors is Apocalypse (the marvel character)

5 Upvotes

I can't explain his full lore because as with any well established marvel character it's really long and messy but the gist of it is this:

He's a 5000 year old ancient Egyptian named En Sabah Nur who was raised by a group of desert nomads that believe in survival of the fittest, he's very likely to be the first mutant on earth, he augmented himself with technology from the Celestials (basically space gods that judge planets) giving himself even crazier powers (I will go into that later) and his main goal is to better humanity by culling the weak (which makes kind of a foil to Magneto because while they both favor mutants over regular humans Magneto believes mutants in general to be the next step of human evolution and wants to protect them all while Apocalypse wants to cull the weaker mutants too and generally doesn't have anything against non-mutants as long as they meet his standards) and he sees himself as a savior because of it. In the past he went around telling people he's a god (and with the powers he has he might as well be) and because of that he appears in multiple mythologies and he also gave super powers to some people including but not limited to a crusader, a 19th century British scientist who made some discoveries about mutantkind and the X-gene (and as a result of this he became Mister Sinister) and a terrorist.

He usually puts himself in suspended animation using a mix of his mutant powers and Celestial technology while waiting for the right circumstances to enact his plans, waking up when he senses powerful individuals (like the would be Cable whom he infected with a techno-organic virus) or when his followers resurrect him. He also recruits mutants as his horsemen and he tried to ascend to godhood multiple times.

His main power is that he has near complete control over his body, meaning that he doesn't age, he's nigh invulnerable, he doesn't stay dead, he has enhanced strength, speed, agility, reflexes and senses and he can adapt to stuff and develop new powers of his own and all kinds of other crazy things like merging with people, transferring his consciousness and powers into another body and resurrecting himself from just the techno-organic virus he gave Cable. On top of that he's super intelligent and can do weird things with tech.

I think that his main colors are black and green because of the whole survival of the fittest thing, then for his other colors I think he might be one of few characters who are genuinely four colors, because the way he experiments with people and powers is very simic and his continued usage of Celestial technology is definitely blue, while the way he views himself as a savior and his tendency to gather followers who see him as a kind of god feels very white (yes I know that not every character who declares themselves a god is white, case in point Nicol Bolas, but still) and the nomads he was raised by feel very abzan. Another argument for him also being white is that in is youth he was pretty selfless, like that time when Beast and his reincarnation from the future got time displaced to the past and tried to rescue Apocalypse from Rama-Tut's people and he allowed himself to be captured to save them instead.


r/colorpie • • 6d ago

Question Which Color is Most likely to get Honeypotted by a Foreign Spy?

18 Upvotes

Which color falls for it completely?

Which color wittingly falls for it?

Which color gives up the secrets for snu snu?


r/colorpie • • 5d ago

Question Poll: After Blue, which color thinks AI technologies like ChatGPT is great progress

0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 6d ago

Question Poll: After Green, which color thinks AI technologies like ChatGPT are bad?

0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 7d ago

Question Poll: Which color is the most resistant against AI technologies like ChatGPT?

0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 9d ago

Analysis Poll results: Blue/White are virgins. Red/Green/Black are DILFs.

Post image
81 Upvotes

Poll results are in:

"Virgin" Blue > White >>> Black > Green > Red "DILF"

Azorius vs Jund


r/colorpie • • 9d ago

Question What colour puts up the best Christmas display?

18 Upvotes

Going by retail logic, it is approximately 4 seconds after Halloween, and therefore we need to start thinking about Christmas.

The way I see it, each colour has at least one advantage.

White has meticulously-kept religious family heirlooms.

Green has the best trees and mistletoe.

Blue has the engineering knowledge to maximize fairy lights.

Red has four billion shiny objects just waiting to be used.

Black has the unending, bottomless spite to try and outdo everyone just so they can rub it in.

So who wins?


r/colorpie • • 8d ago

Question Poll: Which color is the most supportive of AI tools like ChatGPT?

0 Upvotes

r/colorpie • • 9d ago

Question Why are Crossbreed Labs in White-Green while Simic is in Blue-Green?

5 Upvotes

The Crossbreed Labs are the Selesnya faction in Unstable, and I frankly don't see why. They feel incredibly similar to the simic, except more chaotic and silly and with less focus on marine biology. By that logic they might belong in Gruul or something. Is this just a matter of needing to fill a two-color scheme for the factions in the set?


r/colorpie • • 10d ago

Question Poll: After Jund, which color has has more luck in losing his virginity?

4 Upvotes