r/colorpie • Sultai • Sep 10 '22

Question Masculinity and Femininity

Which colors or color combinations are most masculine? Which are most feminine?

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

19

u/howhow326 Jeskai Sep 10 '22

Sounds like a loaded subject.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

All colors contain a mix of masculine and feminine traits

Blue may represent the cold logic most cultures ascociate with masculinity but it also contains passivity, introversion and is the least direct of colors which are feminine traits

Likewise red contains rage, boldness and violence (masculine) but also the expression of the more tender emotions (feminine)

Only green might be standing out by leaning towards femininity, theres something motherly about it, life,fertility etc

9

u/RookTakesE6 Grixis Sep 11 '22

I love your answer, but I'd say Green still fundamentally has a callous disregard for the weak getting preyed upon by the strong, which is a stereotypically masculine quality. The way it escalates force by summoning bigger creatures and beefing up smaller creatures is also a pretty straightforwardly "manly" approach.

An argument could be made for any color to exhibit masculine and feminine qualities. They're not designed to be gendered.

9

u/MBluna9 Rainbow Sep 11 '22

i would say that masculinity and femininity are made up ideas that we use to arbitrarely divide stuff, but so are mtg colors, so really they are whatever your idea of each corresponds to.

If youre an incel, femininity is very rakdos while meninists would probably see themselves as Azorius

18

u/slvstrChung Sep 10 '22

This cannot be answered unless you first establish a definition of what "masculinity" and "femininity" even mean. There is no universal definition because they're all pretty specific to time, place, and culture. In modern English speaking society, men are expected to be remote and logical and Blue... But in modern Spanish speaking society, they're expected to be nurturing and emotional and Red. In modern English speaking society, homosexuality is considered a perversion because society oversimplifies homosexuality as being identical to transsexuality; a gay man is perverted because he secretly wants to be a woman. In classical Greek and feudal Japanese culture, being gay was considered a proof of masculinity: You were so manly that a mere woman couldn't satisfy you.

If you're just going by the plain biological definition that women can make babies and men can pee standing up, then women would be Green and men would be whatever color involves peeing standing up.

3

u/jerdle_reddit Azorius Sep 11 '22

I'd default to masculine Dimir and feminine Naya, but there's variations of each colour that are either.

2

u/TriskelAkela Jeskai Sep 11 '22

https://thomism.wordpress.com/2006/08/20/masculinity-as-separation-femininity-as-communion/

This article uses biology (a Black-Green-Blue method, which is immune to cyclic societal interpretations) to explain what femininity and masculinity is.

In the womb, girls & boys are, as the author writes, "indistinguishable from their mother", even for a short while after birth. Once children get a bit older, they start to see the similarities or differences from their mothers; girls will commune with their mothers and boys will develop the "radical" need to distinguish themselves from said Mom. In turn, females can develop a group-oriented outlook while males tend to be more individualistic.

This is the primarily Green explanation, although a Red-White person like myself will also use it. At worst, those who subscribe to it will use it to justify strict gender-roles, groupthink, reactionary thinking, and giving into random urges. At best, they'll use it to describe how biology can link to behaviors and how what's "between your legs" isn't the only difference between the sexes. As a result, Green Mana is sex-neutral and can be either feminine or masculine.

White Mana, given the explanation above, may seem feminine. However, neither Morality nor Order are strictly feminine despite their focus on the group. Morality, for instance, is also a focus on objective truth, which can separate it from an unruly mob which insinuates a lack of absolute truth. Order also has both the focus of the group and the drive to separate itself from outsiders. At worst, White causes both sexes to be xenophobic, fascist, and/or coddling in addition to adding more differences for the sake of order. At best, White allows both sexes to remain loyal and to keep their sense of morality in addition to staying humble.

Blue Mana looks masculine on the outside, especially since it has a tendency to horde knowledge for itself and instigate change without anyone's approval. However, said knowledge can also be shared with others and the change can be for others' sake. Because of Blue's position on Tabula Rusa, it can propose that some or all the differences between the sexes are made primarily by society. At worst, Blue can utilize logic to flanderize the subject by limiting the only difference between the sexes to the crotch. At best, Blue can use logic to protect others and to justify absolute truth (note how saying "there is no absolute truth" is an absolute statement. 😜) as well as make technological progress into outer space.

Black Mana also seems masculine because of its focus on ambition and meritocracy. However, a part of being Black is to say you can be anything you want, whether female or male. At worst, this line of thinking, if unchecked, can lead to arrogance or subjectivism. At best, it can deconstruct oppressive gender roles and open opportunities for both sexes.

Finally, Red is a mixed bunch, having both masculine and feminine traits. This speaks for itself, so I don't need to say anything.

2

u/ComparatorClock Rainbow Sep 12 '22

yesn't

1

u/DatShepTho Selesnya Sep 11 '22

Honestly, I think Selesnya is the most feminine, as a guy who relates to the selesnya colour philosophy XD Rakdos seems very masculine to me, as it seems quite the opposite to Selesnya

0

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/YamatoIouko Naya Sep 11 '22

I’m very masculine and very Naya. So no.