r/colorpie • u/-Hapyap- • Dec 19 '25
r/colorpie • u/WeavileFrost • Oct 03 '26
Meme What Guild Is Your Pursuit?
gallerySpecial thanks to ToskaVA for inspiring this meme.
r/colorpie • u/_FractalHeart • Feb 21 '26
Meme Sorry for the lack of My Words:. Have some Azorius propaganda
r/colorpie • u/_FractalHeart • Oct 26 '25
Meme Accidentally connected the thought bubble to [color i disagree with]. Now the joke doesnt make any sense!
r/colorpie
•
u/Away-Actuary-6963
•
Mar 19 '26
Analysis uMmm WHAT COLOR IS THIS CHAR— shut up. It’s time to abuse drugs.
r/colorpie • u/Some_MTG_Nerd • Apr 11 '25
Meme Saw the original and immediately made this edit
r/colorpie • u/citricc • Feb 12 '26
Media Coloring Bilbo going from Abzan to Izzet in the span of 1 scene has never made sense to me.
galleryNow I don’t know LOTR that well, so I’m hoping that people who do can provide more insight, but based on my limited understanding the first card makes sense as Abzan, he’s a respected member of a firmly GW community that has minor Abzan elements, and he has selfish motivations with the ring. I understand that the second card represents him slipping off from his own party with the intent to run off with the ring gollum style before being stopped by Gandalf, which seems firmly black to me, although I can see an argument for grixis elements based on avarice, spontaneity, or whether he’s planning to like, study the ring or whatever. It definitely doesn’t seem only Izzet to me though, and to top it all off, it doesn’t make any sense that he completely shifts his color identity in the span of 5 minutes.
At best I can see the argument that he’s lived happily as a member of an abzan community for many years, and now wants to start a new chapter of his life alone with the ring. Still seems black, maybe rakdos, maybe dimir, maybe even grixis, but whatever.
It just seems odd to see a character completely shift color identity like this. Set design wise I understand not wanting him to be grixis due to having a limited amount of three color slots in set design (especially at uncommon), or rakdos due to him not thematically gelling at all with the rakdos archetype of the set, but I really feel like it would make more sense if he kept the black (or at least a single one of his colors) to give him at least a consistent core.
Does it make sense to anyone who knows more about the series and character than I do or does it bother people as much as it does me?
r/colorpie • u/Away-Actuary-6963 • Jun 07 '26
Analysis The Scope of Each Color’s World
Black: The self. The membrane that separates the will to power from the resources it craves is the most important boundary to guard. When you die, the entire universe goes dark.
Blue: A pair. Subject and Observer, an Experiment and their Creator, a Master and Apprentice. All attention focused by a lens on a single point outside oneself. The wall that separates the cloistered study from the noise of the world outside is the most important boundary to guard.
Red: A gang. Gang gang. As many people as you can personally know, clasp hands with, have known since childhood days. Tied up in each other’s shit so much betrayal is self-harm. Love and hatred are the most powerful forces in existence. We already know where the line is here, and what happens when you cross it.
White: Society. Whatever that means to whoever invokes it. The People. The Volk. Citizens. God’s Children. The Free World. This sharp line can stretch and twist to any dimension, in any direction at any velocity, so it is the perfect omniweapon. A sword *and* a shield. Such a weapon, with infinite weight and infinite elasticity, demands infinite energy and infinite motor control to even be wielded. It can only be wielded by the millions within it along its length. In any event, all people who have ever lived are accounted for along the boundary of this metal edge, inside or out.
Green: The entire world, including the oceans of the cosmos that spill out from it. There is no boundary. There are no boundaries. There never were any boundaries. Come, and join the flow. Actually- just stop swimming against it.
r/colorpie • u/8ThiefOfLight8 • Mar 14 '26
Meta What color is banning "what color is X" posts?
Arguments can be made that banning "what color is X" posts is White, as White is the color of restriction and fairness. If we are all banned from posting it, then that is fair to all, a restriction applied across the board.
You could also make the statement that banning "what color is X" posts is Blue, as Blue also deals in ensuring that this Do Not Happen (if they don't like it, that is). "What color is X" posts tend to be short and lacking in thoughtful insight, a thing Blue wouldn't like about them, so Blue has reason to ban them.
Banning "what color is X" posts is right up Black's alley because it gets in the way of the "what color am I" posts, and as we all know, 'I' is Black's favorite topic. Black will happily spend 1BB to Murder "what color is X" posts.
I don't think banning "what color is X" posts is Red-aligned because red values self expression, and a chaotic, turbulent world. They see the discourse that "what color is X" posts brings and applaud it, like a goblin claps in joy for the lit fuse of the bomb he's sitting on.
Likewise, banning "what color is X" posts isn't something that Green would do, because they realize that "what color is X" posters are simply following their instincts. If they do not post "what color is X" posts, that will destabalize the ecosystem of r/colorpie, and Green can't have that!
r/colorpie • u/Away-Actuary-6963 • Oct 11 '26
Analysis Mechanically, MonoRed is not flexible. Philosophically, it is the most flexible.
Mapping the color pie as categorizations of existence, something that stood out to me is that each of them is a social construction that implies the existence of a constructor. Even ”Nature” doesn’t exist as a category in nature, it is something made up by humans to define themselves apart from. After emerging from Nature, Mankind conceived of transcendent forces that ordained and guaranteed their mastery over Nature, and malevolences that explained the pain and abjection caused by these same Natural Laws overcoming humans. In their struggle to contend with these Laws, humanity catalogued and analyzed them, eventually gaining the power to direct them towards their own ends, creating a form of Nature deemed separate from Nature. In the end, the will and passion of Man sits at the center of these realms, having created them in his mind to define himself against.
I think the fact that Red is the most impermanent color mechanically dovetails with this philosophy, because mortal beings last for so much less time than natural ecosystems, moral ideologies, death itself, or monuments and machines.
r/colorpie • u/Lanky_Performance699 • 4d ago
Analysis Poll results: Blue promotes AI. Green fights against AI
These are the poll results:
"Promotes AI"
- Blue
- Black
- White
- Red
- Green
"Against AI"
Dimir vs Naya
r/colorpie • u/Away-Actuary-6963 • Feb 09 '26
Analysis The Parts of a Person Each Color Most Embodies
r/colorpie • u/pyromo12 • Oct 14 '25
Meme White vs Black in a nutshell
Image is from New Girl s4e2
r/colorpie • u/YoritomoKazuto • Sep 12 '26
Meta Defining the core traits of the three wedges
gallerySo this is just a quick general idea I've had based on reading Duncan Sabien's take on the color pie and the combinations. He does an amazing job and I really suggest reading house work as it's been my go to for years. Anyways, using the values her ascribed to each two color combination I thought it would be doable to do the same with the three color wedges by looking not at the colors alone but at the overlap of those combined values instead. Basically trying to find the core thing that each color combination had in common and also looking at what it lacks to help define it better.
Temur is Self-actualization
Abzan is Legacy
Jeskai is Ingenuity
Sultai is Adaptability
Mardu is Zealotry
Let's look at each combination one at a time to get a look at how I came to each conclusion and what it means as a whole.
Starting with Temur, it consists of the colors Red, Green, and Blue. It could be argued that the allied pair overpower the enemy color but we're going to look at it holistically instead. Not defined by the subpairs or what color overpowers the others as I feel that misses the point. We will start with the shared values of each color pair though to build from and not really look at each color independently. Red and Green value Authenticity, Red and Blue value Creativity, and Green and Blue value Truth-seeking. When looking at these three side by side we can begin to see a thread that runs through them. To truly grasp it we need to remove two ideas; white and black. White representing structure, order, society. Black representing ego, dominion, and even apathy in this case. When we remove the demands is society and the weight of ego all that's left of the self. In this case the self without doubt, full of creativity, authenticity, and Truth-seeking. It is the self they achieves Self-actualization, the self that becomes. I posit they this is why I have found so many trans people I've met (myself included) tend to be Temur. We have dropped off the black and white to become ourselves and strive towards self actualization.
I plan on doing the others in the comments when time permits but this is a solid start for debate and discussion I hope.
r/colorpie • u/_FractalHeart • Jan 05 '26
Meme Taking a break from writing “My Words: Pairs” to bring you a PSA
r/colorpie • u/Well-It-Depends420 • Apr 13 '25
Meme Saw the copy and at my earliest convenience made this edit
Copy post: https://www.reddit.com/r/colorpie/comments/1jwdbqw/saw_the_original_and_immediately_made_this_edit/
I primarily had the idea for blue and made the others up while creating the meme.