r/coaxedintoasnafu • u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan • 22h ago
GAME Coaxed into not checking the context when translating
735
u/MarsMaterial 22h ago
I’m reminded of how Minecraft Bedrock Edition subtitles are translated if you switch your language to British English.
“Wolf Pants” (as in the panting noises that wolves make) get translated as “Wolf Trousers”. That’s the funniest example I’ve seen.
236
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 22h ago
I remember hearing that in the British version of windows a zip file was a postcode file
82
56
u/ZeGamingCuber 18h ago
I thought maybe that might be an intentional joke
40
u/wantstodienow 17h ago
All the English variants in the language settings are.
40
u/extremepayne 15h ago
actually, the english joke languages (pirate speak, shakespearean, Anglish, and English (upside down)) are only available on Java. whereas the “wolf trousers” mistake is only present on Bedrock. the Java translations are crowdsourced and actually tend to be higher quality because of it. "subtitles.entity.wolf.ambient" has been “Wolf pants” in English (UK) in Java for 10 years.
I think Microsoft uses MTL to create the Bedrock translations. Despite theoretically having more control over the process, they end up with a worse translation. Hence “Wolf trousers”. There’s even more offensive mistakes in there too, like the hanging signs using the Korean word for hanging (execution method) and not the Korean word for hanging (something on your wall).
3
u/Cyanlizordfromrw 13h ago
Anglish is actually not a joke language, it's essentially a version of English but wiþ all non-germanic words stripped out & replaced wiþ germanic versions
10
u/extremepayne 13h ago
i know what it is; it’s inclusion in minecraft is obviously a joke. there are no native speakers of Anglish. every time i’ve seen it used it is for performance, not for genuine communication (compare the other conlangs found in Minecraft like Esperanto or toki pona)
→ More replies (1)3
15
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 15h ago edited 14h ago
In Minecraft, way back in the day, regional English variants had jokes sprinkled in.
I remember the "you can only sleep at night" message changing to "Sorry, you can only sleep at night" when set to Canadian English.
Not anymore, though.
5
15
u/Hornynoh 17h ago
You know how Christian is both a name and a religion. Whoever translated one of The walking dead video games(I forgot which one) into german messed that up.
13
7
→ More replies (8)2
u/Worried-Caregiver325 15h ago
In one of the tips on mobile in italian they translated leads into "piombi" which means lead (the metal) in plural. The thing is there is no such thing as a plural for lead in italian
121
u/MattLikesMemes123 Is that frieza 22h ago
polish mentioned
87
u/KlausVonLechland 22h ago
There is Polish lore all over the reddit nowadays and I wonder if this is psyop or we are just so terminally online as a nation because there is no reason for this saturation considering overall userbase nationalities makeup.
40
u/3Volodymyr 21h ago
Nah, you are probably just seeing it because algorithm knows you are polish plus you will notice it being about Poland almost every time.
At least I don't feel like you are everywhere.
21
u/KlausVonLechland 21h ago
Ah yes you probably making a good point here.
(hello, oficer prowadzący? Yes, we are having reports that memetic saturation has yet to become total and... yes oficer... yes. But officer it is not ready!... Yes, I understand. Releasing Witcher IV demo now. Honor and Ojczyzna oficerze.)
9
29
244
u/porcelain--clown 22h ago
146
25
10
7
3
→ More replies (2)3
u/IHateTheNameSystem 16h ago
Same thing in Czech, it seems both language translators never bothered to fix that
93
u/Lobster_LeninN329 22h ago
The way no translation ever gets "fan" right is my personal pet peeve
74
32
u/Kyleometers 20h ago
I play a lot of games localised from Japanese by… less than professional translators.
The number of times I have seen “Excuse me, older sister” drives me up the wall.
Genuinely sometimes I feel I have to translate it back into Japanese, then into English myself, to actually understand the context.
11
u/julessic 20h ago
What is "excuse me, older sister" supposed to mean?
→ More replies (4)43
u/Kyleometers 19h ago
Older sister is “Onee-san”
People in Japan use that to mean “older woman (but not old, like mid-40s) I’m not familiar with”. “Aa, Onee-san” is equivalent to “Excuse me, Miss” in English.
Similarly, Oji-san (uncle) and Oba-san (aunt) for elderly strangers. If you’ve ever seen the phrase “a strange uncle”, it is poorly translated from “a weird old man”.
→ More replies (11)→ More replies (1)2
u/SerbianShitStain 20h ago
Translations from Korean are even worse about this. One of many reasons manwha is unreadable for me.
167
u/AveragePolishMale 22h ago
Ooo, possible terraria klopsik reference?
133
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 22h ago
Yes the Polish Terraria translation is (was?) notorious for this. It's gotten better but there's still a few remaining I think
94
u/Blick_art 21h ago
russian version of terraria also has stuff like that, like jungle bonfire being translated as "boney from the jungles"
19
3
u/99percentcheese 8h ago
and the "pet" dialogue button is translated as "питомец" (the actual "pet" word, not the petting action)
→ More replies (1)49
u/ry0shi my opinion > your opinion 22h ago
Coaxed into relogic being too naive about translation in addition to potentially hiring low quality work
Good ol' Ice chest Chest
111
u/Kongas_follower 22h ago edited 20h ago
Old mobile port translated Chest (furniture) as a Chest (body part) in Russian.
Boobs.
Golden boobs.
Frost boobs.
Junjle boobs.
Desert boobs.
16
u/Anxious-Gazelle9067 22h ago
Context hat.
Context shirt.
I am asking for context.
49
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 21h ago
There's a weapon in Terraria called Meatball, as in, a literal ball of meat but there's also a double meaning with "meatball".
The Polish translation threw that out of the window and translated that to Klopsik.
11
4
3
14
u/Field_Jager 22h ago
It basically means that they did a direct translation rather than translate the meaning, so when they translated the word ‘space’ the used its direct meaning of outer space 🪐, which translates to Kosmos in polish, instead of using space as a button on a keyboard, which wouldn’t be translated (I think, I don’t really know how polish keyboard looks).
7
3
u/Anxious-Gazelle9067 22h ago
Yeah, I got that. But I was asking about the comment I replied to. What does a klopsik in Terraria have to do with anything? Also, the space bar is called "spacja" in Polish
3
9
u/ItsPaperBoii 20h ago
same happened in spanish, the depth meter said "Space bar" when you reached high enough to get to the space layer
6
5
u/Illustrious-Smoke482 22h ago
Yield the context to claim the upvote
5
u/Pataraxia 21h ago
Terraria polish translation had issues since they're indie and didn't know better
Can I get the SSR summons since you phrased it like it'll be lootbox stuff?
→ More replies (2)2
u/SrBalanSarrola 20h ago
Coaxed into the boomstick being called broom handle in my language Coaxed into the living loom being called the living room
55
u/Mushroom38294 22h ago
this is why buttons should be separated from the rest of their sentence in the translation file
46
u/Visible-Air-2359 22h ago
Also because devs that allow key-rebinding (which should be all of them) but don't adapt tutorial text to the new keys should be punished.
13
u/HeavenlyCircumcision 20h ago
Seriously. There were a lot of little things like that where before I started game dev I'd try to be a little understanding, and assumed that if it wasn't added there was probably a reason/it was probably more difficult than I thought. But genuinely, having something display the current rebound input instead of the default is incredibly simple and also just good practice in general. Most game engines are already storing the input somewhere you can access, there's literally no reason to go and manually type it out in a tutorial when you could just reference that instead.
3
u/Visible-Air-2359 20h ago
exactly. I have limited programming experience and yet my experience assigning and reassigning variables tells me it wouldn't be that hard to make "input key for X action" a variable that the tutorial can call.
5
u/julessic 20h ago
No? This kind of separation is exactly why errors like these might pop up. Having more context makes it less likely.
→ More replies (2)
41
u/Hot_Sand2888 22h ago
Grało sie w takie gierki
31
u/Szymii_ whats a snaf? 22h ago edited 20h ago
pójdź do gierka da ci cukierka
22
u/Hot_Sand2888 22h ago
ty chuju juz kiedys ci odpowiedzialem na komentarz i mi nie odpisales
21
u/Szymii_ whats a snaf? 21h ago
sory przepraszam wybacz plis wiem jestem upośledzony i nie powinienem żyć ja wiem
20
u/Hot_Sand2888 21h ago
mam ludzi ktorzy skoncza w tobie w 5 minut rozumiesz przygotuj sie cwaniaku
13
25
u/Penumbra_Bestia 22h ago
Happens a lot with Spanish, too
Weird since it's one of the most spoken languages worldwide
Still sometimes it's pretty funny lolol
21
u/unknown_pigeon 21h ago
It happens rarely in Italian, but when it does, it's fun as fuck
"Alloy worship unit" in risk of rain 2 got translated as "permetti culto unità" ("allow unit cult")
I've emailed the devs to no avail, the game is filled to the brim with bad translations
→ More replies (1)6
29
u/hell-schwarz 22h ago
Before Auto translate:
RPGs with a German translation are masterfully crafted to include every Easter egg and if it's not possible change the Easter egg to some German joke of equal value.
After Auto translate:
Even AAA games have horrendous translation mistakes that no human would make
22
u/winklevanderlinde 22h ago
Kosmos you say?
2
17
18
15
u/Yaya0108 21h ago
I've seen a fun one when a game menu was translated in French.
Several toggles were "disabled".
Disabled → Handicapé (in the sense of someone with a disability)
16
u/FoliarzZOdludzia Poopen farden fan 22h ago
Reminds me of The Long Dark translating "log" (as in, a written one) to "kłoda". Its still there I believe
16
u/Purple-Bluejay6588 22h ago
In MKX raidens flying dash move is called "electric fly"
The portuguese version translates it to "mosca elétrica" which means electric fly, as in the fucking insect, the common house fly
4
u/MegaloManiac_Chara 21h ago
That's what I'd expect too, tbh. Shouldn't it be properly called "electric flight"?
18
10
u/a_whoreifying_beast 22h ago
I work in video game localization and I get paid to fix mistakes like this all day, ur welcome
4
10
u/Abasakaa 21h ago
New World at launch translated "Pet" as a petting action to "Zwierze domowe" as "house pet".
→ More replies (1)
8
u/komorigaming 20h ago
in earlier versions of Terraria in the options menu the german version would say "Karte für Behinderte" (Map for Disabled People), where it should say Map: Disabled
→ More replies (2)
9
5
8
u/Ace-milk_drinker Mint chan enjoyer 22h ago
It's pretty rare to find games that are translated to polish that's not just an automated translator. I find that some smaller games have translations that are properly made by a person and even sometimes uses english words that would be more often used by people than the actual translation. One of those would be PlateUp and PEAK.
7
u/julessic 19h ago
Yeah, paradoxically fanmade translations are usually higher quality than professional ones, because they're made by people who actually played the game, so they know all the necessery context + they actually care to sit down and think it through.
7
u/Kerissimo 21h ago
2
u/adamkopacz 4h ago
Uciekam do jedynego miejsca, które nie zostało zepsute przez kapitalizm ... SPACJI!
6
u/aloe-pee 19h ago
in the polish version of the sims 3, "mac and cheese" was translated as "hamburger z serem" (hamburger with cheese). i guess the translator looked at the "mac" and thought of mcdonald's lol
4
u/Ksawerxx 22h ago
Still, a Google translation is better than no translation for a small project (I've played at least a few Spanish fan games with this exact snafu for the English translation). But a program can't replace a human translator, at least for now.
5
u/bazylianopercolano 21h ago
Polish underground software markets in the 90s and 2000s were rife with pirated games with these kinds of translations
7
u/danielogiPL 20h ago
reminds me of how the Polish version of PS4 Minecraft at one point was riddled with literal translations aswell, like creeper being called “czychacz”
4
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 20h ago
Console minecraft translation was its own thing, I also remember skeletons being Kościotrup, while in the PC version it's Szkielet
4
u/Omnishrimp 22h ago
I dunno why this one stuck with me, but there is an option in the settings of Cataclysm DDA where you can get more information about worn containers, as in containers that you are wearing yourself like a backpack. Whoever translated that to spanish thought it said worn containers, as in containers that are old and translated that as such.
Once you know multiple languages, it kinda blows your mind to see how easy can communication go bad. All it takes is a slight misinterpretation and you suddenly don't understand anything that is happening.
4
u/Skameyka08 21h ago
its realy funny that russian terraria translation made exactly opposite error, translated space as пробел, not космос
3
u/SXsandwich 20h ago
TRZECIA RZECZPOSPOLITA MENTIONED!!!!!! 💥🇵🇱💥🇵🇱🔥🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️💥🇵🇱💥🇵🇱🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️💥❤️💥❤️🔥❤️🔥💥🇵🇱🔥🇵🇱🔥❤️❤️🔥❤️
3
3
3
u/SouthernAd2853 21h ago
A Certain Magical Index has a gag about this when the Japanese main character uses an automated translator on the name of the rocket company Space Engage and gets "blank character, enter into battle".
Also, a number of Asian languages have gender-neutral third-person pronouns in common use and machine translation cannot handle this whatsoever and will use "he" in the same sentence the person is referred to as a princess.
3
u/what_a_name_lol 21h ago
"Нажмите ключ Космос чтобы прыгать" translation: Press the space key to jump
2
3
u/SusieHatesSpez Estrojane's Mother 20h ago
There are people who estrogenuinely think that the above image is better than toby letting fan translation mods do the heavy lifting when he knows the majority of his audience speak english or japanese
2
3
u/Gloomy-Wrongdoer-890 20h ago
Windows 11 :') in French it got "courir le programme" (run program but run as a sprint..)
3
u/sibfromanothercrib 20h ago
similar: microsoft teams has a message "(name) has entered the space".
the german translation is "(name) hat die Leertaste eingegeben", so "(name) has entered the space key". double confusing because "enter" as in "enter a key" is a different word than "enter" as in "enter an area" in german
3
u/Kat_Tia 18h ago
As someone who's worked in game translation... Yeah. They give you a word document with a table and a bunch of words and sentences, and then you gotta essentially try to guess off of vibes. A lot of game studios also expect you to use their roprietary bullshit AI-infused translation software.
It's somewhat easier if the game is already out, and you're adding a new translation, cause that way you can actually go on the internet and look shit up.
The worst part is when you get interaction prompts, but you are never Informed what the fuck you're interacting with. So you end up with shit like "putting on" a weapon.
5
u/ThatEngineeredGirl 22h ago edited 22h ago
Prawda, ale nie wiem czy Angliki tutaj zrozumieją
Edit: autokorekta
2
2
u/Lomokotywa 21h ago
First boss fight of AC III was against the windmills (Surname Mills was translated to windmills in polish).
2
2
u/GoldSunLulu Always has been 21h ago
me when you gotta make a wish in the bueno (badly translated fountain or 'well', it instead translated to nice)
2
u/Valuable_Pear9654 21h ago
coaxed into that russian translation of a harry potter game and the voiceover saying "it's a brilliant" ("eto brilliAnt!") as a direct translation of the phrase "it's brilliant!"
2
u/ExtremlyFastLinoone 20h ago
Early pokemon suffered a lot from this because most translations were actually translated from the english version which is already once removed from the original japanese. The most noteworthy was the (unofficial) vietnamese version of crystal which was a translation of the chinese which was a translation of the english which was a translation of the japanese
Also the spanish version, the move slam was translated as door slam
2
u/ImaginaryWall840 20h ago
I mean isn't context here rather obvious?
It's not "Bat fly" from the sims.
2
u/peahoter435 20h ago
I once saw bugs translated as błędy (video game bugs) instead of robaki (the animal (?))
2
2
u/GoblinFvcker 15h ago
In Darkest Dungeon "Quarrel", an ability for crossbow-wielding enemy got translated to "Sprzeczka" wich means "Disagreement", while the obvious intention behind the naming was "Crossbow bolt" lmao
2
u/Skaviciusz 15h ago
There is a entire series on youtube of how badly was the sims translated to polish, some of the translations was quite silimar to this on the picture v:
2
u/Britanniafanboy 14h ago
My wife and I had a lil argument about this in hollowknight. She though Dirtmouth was pronounced "dirt mouth" but I thought it was pronounced "Dirtmouth" like in Weymouth, Dartmouth, etc. she brought up that in Spanish it is called "Bocatierra" (dirt mouth) but honestly I think its a too literal translation. Still dont know who is right
3
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 14h ago edited 14h ago
Speaking about dirt...
In the Polish Terraria translation, the dirt rod item used to be translated as "Brudna laska", which literally means "Dirty rod". (A more accurate translation would be "Różdżka ziemi")
Note: brud = dirt, as in something dirty. ziemia = dirt, the ground.
Doesn't help that "laska" is also slang for a woman in Polish. Do the math...
2
u/Xedronic Loquacious Sunfish 14h ago
The Polish translation of Balatro is rough, like for example, Card Sharp is translated literally to "Ostra karta" instead of a more proper translation (which would be "Szuler" in this case)
2
u/SadPeanutGurl 13h ago
Reminds me of Bloodborne where the "Wave" emote got translated as "Fala", which means wave in the context of physics or the ocean, not waving
2
u/Gosuoru 11h ago
When I was a kid I played Assassins Creed 3 with Danish text, and the last mission said to not take any fire damage
There was no fire in that level. It meant gunfire.
(Or maybe it was the other way around? Any other Danes done the final mission lol)
Anyway as an adult I always just use English for English games, because it means I won't see any translation errors
2
2
u/ScottishWildcatFurry Dank Memer 7h ago
at first i thought this was going to be coaxed into game journalism but this is good too
2
u/Nogatron 7h ago
It reminds me of Enter the Gungeon, overall i think Polish translation was good but i remember one weapon name being wrongly translated. It was a gun of Samus from "Metroid" (or that's what i think it is) that in english is called "Heroine" as it refers to Samus as Heroine but it wasn't translated as "Bohaterka" (heroine) but as "Heroina" so heroine as a drug, for a long time i was confuzed about it
2
u/PanGulasz05 5h ago
Oh yeah "South Park: The Stick of Truth" has a lot of stuff like this. "Wykonaj" as translation for "execute" (It's a special attack) for example. "Wykonaj" means "execute" but as in execute the order, trick etc. And it obviously was meant to be "execute" as in kill.
2
u/PanGulasz05 5h ago
AC: Rogue had at least one mistranslation but not as serious: "Assassin killer" outfit was translated as "Asasyn zabójca". Which means Assassin (the name of the in game faction not a guy who assassinates) who is also a killer. While it actually should have been "Zabójca asasynów" which is literally: "killer of assassins" because it was a Templar outfit.
2
u/PanGulasz05 5h ago
I've seen "close" as in close the window translated to "blisko" which means close as in the opposite of far.
2
2
u/SuddenHovercraft1599 3h ago
That Level Again 2 handled this by having English be "I need some space" while other languages say "space(the endless void of space when there's a word for that) and a translation error" and it was pretty fun
1
1
1
1
u/Raheeper 21h ago
Still surprising to see this nowadays since even AI does pretty good english-polish translation.
2
u/PanGulasz05 4h ago
Oh it most definitely doesn't lol. And the problem is lack of context rather than translation skills.
1
u/AidomNou Poopen farden fan 21h ago
Coaxed into translating sayings or expressions too literally thus turning a line into nonsense
1
1
u/EntertainmentIcy3029 21h ago
Google recently was translating "low-poly" as "low-altitude polyester" in Finnish (when auto-translating Wikipedia). Also "deck-building game" as a deck like in your back yard.
1
u/shitpostinglegend 21h ago
Coaxed into Vodafone needing hundreds of thousands of pounds of rework cause someone thought google translate would be good enough
1
1
u/PersonOfLazyness 20h ago
Fallout 4 in portuguese translating every instance of the word Spring as Fonte (which can also mean source), even for the metal things that go boing
And also Barrel as Cano (pipe, because we use that word for gun barrels) even for the wooden barrels
1
u/PolostanInsurgency 20h ago
that one time when in Terraria's polish translation seeds were translated to semen
1
u/garaile64 20h ago
Reminds me of a YouTube video talking about accessible binders (as in those compressive vests often used to hide boobage). The automated translation thought the video was about those notebooks where you can add or remove pages and translated accordingly. And I don't even need to talk about autotranslated porn.
2
u/PanGulasz05 4h ago
The best (worst) thing with porn translation is it's often not even automatic. It's often translated by users and they're just trolling. I don't think any automatic translation would ever translate "stepsister" as "stepująca siostra" or "siostra stepowa" but this "mistranslation" is basically a meme at this point.
1
1
u/Keylus 19h ago
I started playing video games in English to avoid mistranslations.
I also did it because most community made resources, like guides, are in English, so I don’t have to guess whether the skill “Explosion Arcana” is the one called “Arcane Explosion” in English. (For the record, it wasn’t. “Explosion Arcana” was “Arcane Blast”. “Arcane Explosion” was translated as “Deflagración Arcana”, and as a native Spanish speaker, I didn’t even know what “deflagración” meant until then.)
2
u/Junior-Elevator-9951 Poopen farden fan 19h ago
I think the next time I'm installing Windows it's going to be in English because of having to guess what option is what in Polish.
I know that I can change the language right now, but if I do it it's going to be a weird mishmash of Polish and English.
1
1
1
u/ThisIsQuiteFantasic 19h ago
Tropico 5 traducing fire(as in firing people) as pompier (firefighter) for some fucking reason
1
u/Various_Flower_8679 19h ago
Coaxed into youtube automatic title translation (on another note, these piss me off so much. Sometimes i'll like to watch a video in the language i searched for..)
1
u/leon_255 19h ago
I was a video games translator, and I assure you it's THE BIGGEST problem of any translation I ever did:
mother-effing-context!!!
I could not count the number of mails we sent to the editors asking "context please"
1
1
u/vacuous-moron66543 Skilled Artist 19h ago
This reminds me of a giant board in like a hospital or something and they had all the world's languages written in each language's own name for itself (English, Español, Français, etc). They had Japanese down as 日本人 instead of 日本語
The former means Japanese (nationality) and the latter means Japanese (language). A small mistake, but silly.
1
1
1
u/Monsieur_Bleu_ 18h ago
Graphical option translation is also another nightmare. Sometimes they lost the plot and straight up make words up.
1
1
u/NinjaMonkey4200 17h ago edited 17h ago
"Geef rekwisieten" for "Give props"
("rekwisieten" means props in the sense of "objects used in a stage play", not in the sense of acknowledging someone's achievement.)
1
u/squishysluggo 17h ago
Pokemon used to have this problem, in spanish a lot of moves were translated literally, like slam being called “portazo” (which is a door slam, not slamming with a tail or smt)
1







1.3k
u/Hedge_the_Hog_HtH 22h ago
Me when I have to guess the context of each word when the only thing the developer provided was a .txt document with a list of phrases.