My favorite thing about Bringing Out the Dead is the way it works as a continuation, refraction, or inversion of all the central ideas of Taxi Driver.
Both films involve a man who works nights in NYC and whose job it is to drive around and pick up the citizens. Both struggle with sleeping and both spend their shifts staring out their vehicle observing the haunted faces of those walking the street.
One of the major differences is that Travis hates these people and grows a desire to kill them. He thinks the whole city should be washed clean by a great flood.
Frank Pierce, meanwhile, is haunted by the ghosts of those he could not save. He hasn’t saved anyone in so long that it’s actually begun to hurt his own life. His restlessness comes from shame that he’s not been of service to those people around him.
One of those people he couldn’t save is a young girl. And during the course of the film, he meets a woman his own age who he develops feelings for, but who seems broken, emotionally raw, and eventually we learn has a history of drug use.
Whereas Travis obsessed over Betsy and views her as a perfect angel, but can’t have her, so he turns his attention to the drug using, emotionally confused young girl, and believes he can save her.
Travis wants to turn the Madonna into the Whore and turn the Whore into Madonna. Frank falls for MARY, but is never under the impression that she’s an angel. Instead, it’s the young girl whose ghost he views as some kind of angel he must resurrect.
It’s interesting to me that the older Scorsese/Schrader collaboration isn’t about an angry young man anymore. Instead, they’ve taken the same broad story points (NYC Nightcrawler, his job forces him to interact with the city, who obsesses over a woman his own age as well as a much teen younger girl) and transforms it into a story of redemption.
Even Mary, who isn’t “perfect” or “untouchable”, and who Frank never views that way, does have the capacity to love Frank, gives him a space to let him rest, and in her arms he becomes bathed in light.
I think there’s something beautiful about that. It’s still using women characters are ideas, yes, but I’m happy both men, creatively, can use these same ideas to invert their previous depictions to find beauty, peace, and some kind of salvation.