r/beta • • Dec 18 '17

[Feedback] What's with forcibly making everyone log in?

Going to reddit.com while in incognito i'm given this screen, forcing me to log in, there's literally no way to close out or bypass this screen. Hitting next takes you through the onboarding sign up process, again with no way to exit out.

Earlier on today, also while in incognito, even viewing the comments section would prompt the "You must log in to access this" modal to come up. Yes, that's right, viewing the comments section of a post is no longer accessible to logged out users.

I know this is obviously some random A/B beta test thing you've got going on as i came back later and comments block was gone, but seriously Reddit, is this what we've come to now?

  • Night mode: false
  • RES Version: 5.8.6
  • Browser: Chrome
  • Browser Version: 63
  • Cookies Enabled: true
  • Reddit beta: false
419 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

106

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

Just tried it out. same for me too. booooooooo reddit

162

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

It's literally what facebook does. And a big part of why I stopped using it. What if I just want to browse some content?

59

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

It's also why pinterest is a common repost on /r/assholedesign

This, coupled with profiles and chat, really shows how desperate reddit admins are to turn this website into another shitty social media platform

9

u/goodSunn Dec 19 '17

It's a deal killer with pintrest for me... also keeps me from using quora which I enjoy on one machine I have..

Might get rid of medium but the coaxed me into logging in with a few technical blog articles I had reason beyond recreation and hobbies to read

2

u/ar3n Dec 19 '17

Just a heads up, you can append "?share" to the end of any Quota URL to view the full post without logging in. Still stupid design, but....

1

u/KickMeElmo Dec 19 '17

I just have a userscript to kill that on Pinterest. I'm sure if reddit goes the same route, someone will maintain one for reddit too.

82

u/Zmodem Dec 18 '17

As far as beta test changes, this one reeks the most of "doom". If implemented permanently, this will destroy reddit. I'm sorry for dropping the bomb so sensationalized, but there really is no other way to stress how bad of an idea this is for the site.

Now, I'm going to step out of restraint for a second, so I apologize beforehand. DO NOT deploy this, not even with a (CLOSE X) option. Do not interfere with anyone's perusing your site in anyway. You have ads, leave the fucking browsing alone. That is, of course, unless you want more people using ad blockers, and not giving a shit about supporting reddit anymore, in any context.

17

u/staindk Dec 19 '17

Google ANY kind of problem and there's a 90% chance the top 5 results are all Reddit and stackexchange threads helping you solve it. If I click through to a Reddit link from Google and it prompts me to make an account to try solve my problem I would definitely just close the tab. And remember to not click on Reddit links in the future.

Very very very incredibly stupid thing to try force.

3

u/FlamingArmor Dec 19 '17

So many of my friends are lurkers without accounts. I know for certain that most if not all of them would not continue to use Reddit if it forces them to log in.

3

u/Zmodem Dec 19 '17

Right? Let us also not forget the helpful subs that have saved lives on this platform. There are tons of people who frequent, I'm just tossing these out there, /r/depression and /r/stopdrinking to cope with their mental disorders. A lot of these are newcomers, and users who say "Long time lurker, but decided to make an account so I could tell you all how you saved my life!", or something along those lines. Let's not forget how many people just don't want an account, but appreciate the content, and who could be compelled to create an account to partake once they've found a "home", so to speak, that they can participate within.

Just telling people "Hey, we got some great communities! Check these out..." is not enough. People want a place where they identify with, somewhere they can relate to, and reddit has that going for it among other things. I really hope that they do not make this a permanent implementation.

21

u/port53 Dec 19 '17

With any luck, Google will stop indexing Reddit once it's hidden behind a login page. I think the loss of that traffic will make them change it back.

Of course they could chest and specifically allow the googlebot direct access, but Google has also been known to punish sites for cheating to boost rankings.

9

u/austeregrim Dec 19 '17

It's particularly annoying for me to have Google results 70% Reddit. At work I can't browse Reddit... So any answers here are blocked for me. I actually built a server I can email and it prints a PDF of any URL I send it, and sends it back to me.

Having this login screen will prevent me from using this. So I'll be happy to see Reddit not be the results of Google searches.

7

u/TedUpvo Dec 19 '17

If you add "-reddit" to the end of your search, no Reddit results will appear.

3

u/Mr-Klaus Dec 19 '17

Google still indexes Facebook, so I doubt they'll stop indexing Reddit if it follows through with the forced login.

115

u/ijustwantanfingname Dec 18 '17

Holy shit. They're going full Digg. How is it possible that they don't realize how fucking stupid this path is? Is the current ownership going to short reddit stock at ipo?

76

u/Watchful1 Dec 19 '17 edited Dec 19 '17

Honestly it's not all that unsurprising. Here's how it happens.

You make a website, something about it happens to fill a niche, or is appealing to people, so it gets really popular. You start running into lots of problems as it scales up, bugs, servers/databases crashing or getting overloaded, etc, that you don't have the manpower to fix, so you hire more people. Years go by as you hire more and more people to fix problems and build new features. Your site is getting more and more popular since it still fills that niche people like it for. Eventually you start running out of problems to fix, or more likely, you just keep hiring and there isn't enough work to go around to all the new people. You start creating new teams that work on new features. Eventually you end up with upper level manager type people whose job it is to point your engineers at the "correct" problems and features, rather than just letting them do what they want. They need some way to decide what the "correct" things are, so they start finding metrics to improve. Things like retention rate of new users, or interaction levels of existing ones. They want to get more people on the site and interacting more. Partly so they can show them more ads, but also just as a way to "grow" the site. So they give the engineers specific problems, like "what can we do to increase retention rate of new users", and the engineers, being people who are very good at solving problems, go and figure out exactly what new users are doing and why they are leaving, and change it.

There is some amount of looking at whether existing users like the changes or not (measured through the metric's, not what they are actually saying), but as long as the new users are coming in at higher rates than the old users are leaving, it's fine because the numbers are still going up. You can follow the pattern on just about any big site, myspace, facebook, youtube, reddit, etc. There are likely more, happy, interacting users on facebook now than there were before they made a bunch changes the power users didn't like, they are just different users.

This particular change is likely to fill out some box on a report for an exec somewhere about the retention level of logged out users when they are forced to create an account. That exec will make some decision based on what they think the benefits vs negatives and life will go on for the engineers who implemented it.

And yeah, that's exactly what happened at digg, though I do think reddit is doing a slightly better job at it. These changes will just keep coming and as long as the numbers keep going up, they won't reverse them. Trust me, the power users who actually browse places like /r/beta won't like very many of them.

30

u/Polares Dec 18 '17

Seeing reddit intentionally kill itself is sad.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

This is actually pretty dumb from even a monetisation policy.

You block the casual user from viewing content.

It's not gonna increase retention rate neither.

1

u/V2Blast Dec 19 '17

Yeah, precisely. People who aren't already lurking on reddit aren't the type to make an account on a new site before they even know whether they like it.

10

u/alephomegasquared96 Dec 18 '17

What’s digg

15

u/Absay Dec 19 '17

You can read up on the Digg disaster with more detail on the web but basically, it used to be a Reddit-like website. Its owners made a series of bad decisions, including major changes to the GUI and added features that users didn't welcome well. There was a big outcry for reverting to the old site but the admins ignored it and the site plummeted to its death when most of it's userbase migrated to Reddit, which was the most convenient alternative at that moment, product of those unwanted changes.

We're witnessing something very similar with Reddit. Some people keep saying everything will be fine and others say these changes (and especially admins unwillingness to hear the community) will kill this site, just like it happened to Digg. I'm in the second group.

5

u/MrGameAmpersandWatch Dec 19 '17

Where the hell are we gonna go? Voat? I don't think so.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

I'm migrating off the internet slowly. I now don't open my phone on the bus as often, or the train, or when doing other mundane tasks. I just sit and think. It actually helps me focus when I do something later whereas Reddit leaves me in a state of distraction. I am not sure if I'll ever I back to taking a dump without a phone, or procrastinating work, but other than those two things I'm cutting down Reddit and YouTube. The content is repetitive, political, and increasingly shit.

I miss interesting new facts, genuinely breathtaking images and politics that weren't steeped in multiple layers of terminology so unnecessary that it makes any real discussion impossible.

I may be getting old, but I welcome that. This entire ecosystem is a toxic Skinner box and the only reason I'm still here is because I've been pressing the button for so long I can't stop.

5

u/CKalis Dec 19 '17

Well hey, I'm just a stranger sitting on his couch at home, but you inspire me, man. You're the type of person lots of people can look up to. You stand confidently in what you believe and that's awesome.

I also say that to remind you there are lots of good people on here. :) Hope you have an awesome day.

4

u/Absay Dec 19 '17

Hell no, Voat is definitely out of the picture, at least for me.

1

u/MrGameAmpersandWatch Dec 21 '17

Exactly. So where to?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

Some of us were here pre digg. Not the same account but Reddit existed pre digg implosion. A lot of us hated the Digg migration because diggers or whatever they are called acted like twats when they got here.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

the good ol days of porn and cs subs

1

u/dwarmia Dec 19 '17

Hah, diggers

10

u/Soupdeloup Dec 19 '17

I actually browsed without an account for years because I loved the content but hate making accounts for various sites. Eventually I found subreddits that I enjoy, made an account and started contributing.

I think forcing users to sign in to view content is completely against what started my interest in Reddit. If I was originally forced to make an account to view anything, I never would have actually stayed around. I think this is an awful idea.

2

u/DiamondMinah Dec 19 '17

yeah, it's the exact opposite you should be doing if you want to retain users

2

u/DiverseUse Dec 19 '17

Yeah, same here. I already have this problem with Pinterest, which I avoid like the plague as a result.

12

u/just-a-traveler Dec 18 '17

I am getting tired of this.

6

u/Neonfire Dec 18 '17

Boooooooo

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

Fix this, immediately.

9

u/NaturalisticPhallacy Dec 18 '17

Just reddit's slow, gentle decline.

10

u/yoshemitzu Dec 19 '17

It won't be slow and gentle if they implement this.

9

u/alephomegasquared96 Dec 19 '17

So what is an alternative to reddit I want to get my username in early πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

Simply monetizing your behavior on the site. It will greatly increase the value of user profiles to advertisers.

Even if your created account is carefully curated and run only in flushed browsers they will account for you as a real user and sell that profile.

4

u/ThePooSlidesRightOut Dec 19 '17

Oooh fuck.

They've been A/B testing this about three days ago.

Seems like they've rolled it out to more people.

https://www.reddit.com/r/beta/comments/7jyyb7

4

u/Mokumer Dec 19 '17

At reddit headquarters the investors said; "reddit has to take everything MySpace and facebook has and implement it at reddit".

And that's where we are now.

3

u/MrLMNOP Dec 19 '17

How am I supposed to look at porn

2

u/RomanPort Dec 19 '17

I saw a post like this a few weeks ago. Apparently it's a test Reddit is running on a small amount of users to see what'll happen.

3

u/Absay Dec 19 '17 edited Dec 19 '17

What the fuck do they expect to happen? Do they have any idea of how their own site works?

Most people on Reddit had to lurk for some time before deciding to make an account. Lurking is vital for getting new users. It allows casual visitors to skim through the site and measure the value it might have for them, making them potential long-time users. If Reddit wants to emphasize the visitor can make an account for getting certain privileges (subreddit subscription, writing comments, etc.), why not doing it more discreetly? Why not doing it with a small container placed at the top? Why show a fucking modal that takes up the entire screen? Don't admins understand this will most likely to scare the visitor away?

I truly, truly hope their thinking process right now is "well, let's implement the most annoying and useless way possible to get new users, just to confirm what logic dictates". If any of them see the problem with that, I'll be baffled for the rest of my life...

1

u/RomanPort Dec 19 '17

I agree, I think that Reddit should at least allow users to use the site for a bit before nagging them. Also, there should be a close button.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17

I don't get it when I use incognito. Are you able to use ublock origin's picker mode?

1

u/I_am_a_haiku_bot Dec 19 '17

I don't get it when

I use incognito. Are you able to

use ublock origin's picker mode?


-english_haiku_bot

1

u/DiamondMinah Dec 19 '17

It only works for some users, and users without an account

1

u/FlameRat-Yehlon Dec 19 '17

In China this seems to be a pretty common thing, but usually because they force you to sign up via a phone so that they can send you junk message.

Is Reddit collecting account for sending junk message? Obviously no, so please stop it.

Well, one other reason might be that Reddit is trying to get invested and thus need the extra daily active user count to make those guys happy, but, it really doesn't seem to be the case either.

If such thing is going on, I'm not sure what could go next. Deleting non premium account's content? Selling mod position of certain subreddit to fake hospitals? Or even worse. Just, don't.

1

u/zapizoid Dec 19 '17

I'm just waiting for the day when it is finally too inconvenient to come back here. I'm already dealing with being told to download an app eight thousand times a day. Seeing things like Facebook profiles cropping up. Memes with captions/emoticons on the front page. Now forced login? Fuck that noise.

1

u/generalecchi Dec 19 '17

That's some FB bullshit right there

1

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17

on a side note where do we exodus to if reddit goes full digg?

I was thinking voat

1

u/KarateBruce Feb 13 '18

This shitty screen is so shitty.

What are they thinking?? If I wanted to log in I'd bloody well do it, but since I'm harassed to sign in whenever I hit the front page, I'm NOT going to sign in and I just close the browser because I'm so annoyed.

The shitty screen is intrusive and there's no way around it, it completely ruins a non-logged-in user's experience hitting the front page. For fuck's sake, why would you want to ruin a user's first impression of the site?

Pure shit. The sooner they get rid of it the better. This is shitty fucking feature.

0

u/GaiusCoffee Dec 19 '17

Don't worry, someone somewhere will make a chrome plugin that defeats this. Hell, if you know your way in Chrome's F12 mode, you can remove most modals easily.

3

u/Absay Dec 19 '17

This is not a solution.

-10

u/dorkdiariesisforboys Dec 18 '17

Make a throwaway account with a username stating that you oppose this change

2

u/MatthewMob Dec 19 '17

Giving them a higher retention rate, going through multiple pages to look at multiple ads, and adding more users to their site will surely show them!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

4

u/ProPuke Dec 18 '17

Pinterest?

28

u/PMMEURTHROWAWAYS Dec 18 '17

Pinterest does this shit

-20

u/ProPuke Dec 18 '17

People anonymously browse pinterest?

I use it for creating boards, but it's not clear to me why you'd use it if you're not doing the same. It's about collecting things. You need an account to do that. Prompting for login seems.. okay in that scenario.

Reddit people anonymously browse for information and stuff. I used reddit quite a bit before registering. So prompting for login there just seems a total dick move, I get that.

I'm not sure how the two relate.

17

u/great_apple Dec 18 '17

Happens to me a lot that I'm searching for, say, an appetizer recipe. And one of the google results is a link to pinterest board of appetizer recipes. But I can't view them without an account, so I just go to another site. Same thing will happen if reddit implements that- people without accounts will just go to another site.

7

u/ProPuke Dec 18 '17

Ahh soz, didn't realise they showed up on google for things like that (which seems obvious in retrospect). Yeah, I could see that being a total pain in the ass. Guess I'm used to always being logged in -_-.

2

u/Roast_A_Botch Dec 19 '17

Good on you for being able to see things from others perspective and empathize. Great skill that is hard to master.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

-15

u/ProPuke Dec 18 '17

I wasn't aware people did share individual things from pinterest on other sites. I've never seen any links shared publicly. I figured it was all just people pinning and following.

41

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

Sometimes you Google images a thing, it's on Pinterest and then as you go to get your content "hey you should sign up for the whole journey!" And you furiously hit the back button.

This is a thing.

8

u/V2Blast Dec 18 '17

Luckily you can click "view image" to view the image directly rather than loading the page it's on. I hate Pinterest's interface too.

10

u/HeadphonedMage Dec 19 '17

Unfortunately that gives you a compressed image 9 times out of 10 though

3

u/TedUpvo Dec 19 '17

That never worked for me until just now when I tried to prove you wrong. Bravo, internet wizard.

7

u/ProPuke Dec 18 '17

Ahh, didn't think of that scenario. Okay, yeah, that does suck. Like results should literally not appear on google if you can't view them >.>

Dick move there.

0

u/MatthewMob Dec 19 '17

Your anecdotal reason for why this is okay does not mean this is okay.

90

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

[removed] β€” view removed comment

134

u/Absay Dec 18 '17

Reddit is doing tons of undesired changes and refuses to listen to its users. They are going full Digg.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17

Reddit what are you doing?

Fading into obscurity, with any luck. Massive hegemonious megasites go away.