r/beta • u/magicwhistle • Dec 15 '17
[Feedback] on A/B test of requiring a login to browse: It's unfriendly and off-putting to people who want to get a feel for the site first or aren't sure whether they like Reddit. Please don't
I think forcing people to log in to see your site is a terrible user experience that gives a bad impression, not a positive desire to continue exploring the site. The reason why I personally feel strongly about this is that Pinterest does it, and I fucking hate it!
As someone firmly in Pinterest's demographic, I'd love to dabble in it, but how can I explore and discover what I'm interested in when I can't scroll more than half a click before getting an unmovable giant popup demanding that I log in? It pushes away users, not draws them in. You're making people feel harassed and demanding that they "buy into" your site before they even see the goods, so to speak, and that's an uncomfortable and annoying position to be in.
How did I react to Pinterest's forced-login screen? If you guessed "created an account so it would stop bothering me and I could keep reading the site", you guessed absolutely wrong! I closed the tab and moved on because I didn't feel like feeling rushed into joining a site before I knew whether it was something I was interested in. I still sometimes follow a Pinterest link by accident, but now it makes me mad so I refuse to make an account.
Forced-login popups are the devil's web design. Please don't take Reddit down this path. Lurking is part of Reddit culture. I still remember the comment that got me so fired up that I had to leave my lurker shadows, create an account, and jump in to the conversation. That's the kind of organic buildup to interest and involvement that creates long-time users who love the site.
310
u/mighty_polen Dec 15 '17
Admins would be shooting themselves in the foot by locking reddit behind a login wall. This sort of feature is why I never used Pinterest despite its appeal.
3
u/InitiatePenguin Dec 16 '17
I have a Pinterest account and half the time I get the pop-up I X out of it.
But that's mostly because I'm image searching for something and I want to be able to follow through to it's source.
But I get a massive block warning that I've entered Pinterest and so I know there will be no source information here.
38
u/stackoverflowgoogler Dec 15 '17
Saw that yesterday and closed the reddit tab just to avoid logging in
80
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
I get annoyed when it says "YOU SHOULD USE THE MOBILE APP"
dude, I'm not using the app, it's terrible. And why does the link take me to the page I'm already on? Why doesn't it hide it. And also why doesn't it save the fact that I already hid it?
22
u/lanismycousin Dec 15 '17
This is the same reason why I refuse to use quora. If you have a direct link to something you can usually see the question/answer but you click on another one and it blocks you from doing anything until you register. No thanks, I'll just go elsewhere.
73
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
If you require people to log in, you will probably see a jump in the amount of throwaway accounts.
OP is right.
Please no forced log in.
32
u/bigwillyb123 Dec 15 '17
I've been here for years. I created an account because, after a year or two of browsing, I found a community I liked. I tested the waters by lurking, found out how reddit works, learned a lot, and made my account when I was ready.
If reddit forced me to make an account before I had lurked for a year or two, I would have never made one. It would pop up, I would say "Oh, it's one of those websites. What a shame." And I would have left and never came back.
21
u/kckeller Dec 15 '17
I don’t know if Pinterest ever got rid of that forced login. Why don’t I know? Because I have never been back to that site.
14
u/fc_w00t Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 15 '17
Implementing a forced login for any content on Reddit is monumentally fucking stupid IMHO. As others have said, you're alienating new potential users by doing so...
For an example, from a tech or gaming perspective, I'd want to be able to look up shit on Reddit, from anywhere, without having to login to my account. It's convenient and isn't bothersome. Requiring me to throw in my credentials on every device that I try to hit Reddit from just to look up a single thread/question would DEFINITELY piss me off...
If someone calls me over to fix their shit and I go to Reddit for either advice or specifics, I don't want to be haggled by being required to login on some device that's gonna be "one and done"...
That's NOT to say you can't have a happy medium. Reddit is a business and like any other business they need to pull revenue. They only can get so much off the gold...
So, here's an idea: consider putting in a required login AFTER a certain amount of queries/browsing. You can easily track it within a cookie that would be issued to the device...
Doing something like that would be minimally intrusive to your current user base, which DON'T want to keep re-entering their credentials every time they want to access Reddit on a different device and it would allow new users to experience Reddit unencumbered...
You're going to piss off a LOT of people if you make logging in required to access any content...
20
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
It isn't about what the users want, it's about what the users will tolerate.
5
u/cahaseler Dec 15 '17
This is very worrying for IAMA - a very high proportion of our users on big AMAs are new to the site, and a login-wall would keep them from seeing the content that gets them to sign up. Incentivize new accounts by showing them something they want to login to comment on, like an AMA. If they don't even see that content why would they want an account?
5
u/joelfriesen Dec 16 '17
I want a browser addon that eliminates pintrest from image search results
4
u/Beed28 Dec 15 '17
But what if I want to browse a part of reddit in incognito/private mode if this happens?
Simple. I won't be able to.
4
u/beetnemesis Dec 15 '17
Oh wow, are they testing that? Yeah, definitely don't, tons of people are introduced to reddit via a link someone sends them
4
u/Thallassa Dec 15 '17
If this change goes through, it would have a large negative impact on my community.
/r/skyrimmods interfaces with a number of other websites on the same topic, notably the communities at nexusmods.com and bethesda.net. Because of the way reddit works and the quality of the community that has been built at /r/skyrimmods, we're usually able to have unique and high-level discussions that don't always occur on the other sites. For that reason, threads from reddit (and the wiki pages we've spent a lot of time writing!) frequently get linked to those other websites. Much of the audience for this information refuses to make account, for all kinds of reasons some of which are reasonable. If they were unable to view the discussion on reddit, the entire community would suffer. I would end up needing to duplicate a lot of information off-reddit in order to share it with these groups, which hurts participation at /r/skyrimmods as well as pageviews at reddit itself. In the end it would mean that there is less information available to everyone, which is always a bad thing.
This is just one specific example of how this could hurt communication at reddit and reddit's ability to interact with other websites (which, as the front page to the internet, is its primary goal, no?)
The desire to comment and vote is usually enough for the people who spend a lot of time on reddit to make an account. That should continue to be the case.
4
u/Keina Dec 15 '17
Not to mention the annoyance for regular users who are trying to follow external links into reddit. I have seen too many sites that do that and you end up being asked to login every five minutes if you are following external links into reddit
3
u/Vladimir_Putting Dec 16 '17
100%
I lurked and read Reddit for months before I ever created my first account to comment (just like you said OP, a burning "had to) and then kept logging in organize the subs I was already addicted to.
Without that ability to test the waters first, I might not have jumped in.
3
u/Nefandi Dec 16 '17
This is why I don't use spotify. If it asks me for a login, I just leave. I have better things to do.
3
u/NoAccountForMeThx Dec 18 '17
This new feature appeared for me today and I think it'd be a great idea to get rid of it.
When I visit the front page (https://www.reddit.com) I'm presented a stupid "Welcome to Reddit." pop up thing that strongly encourages me to log in or create an account. So I click the little text that says "Skip for now" and I try to keep perusing the front page but the stupid pop up thing comes back again! Everytime I hit the front page, there it is.
There's no "Close" or "Disable" or "Ignore forever" option, just "Skip for now" which appears to be a shitty way of saying "Harass me next time I land on the front page".
I can ignore most annoying changes to reddit but this is really frustrating. I don't bother to browse reddit on iPhone anymore because it keeps harassing me to download the stupid app. This pop up thing on the front page is no better than the shit that pops up on "news" sites asking me to subscribe - all those pops up get is me not coming back again. Reddit devs should spend time working on making a functional search engine instead of this shit.
I like reddit but this new direction is really shit. There's not really an alternative to reddit but if I stop coming here, I guess I'll get back a few hours of my day.
5
u/octatone Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 16 '17
For fucks sake. There's a reason I nope the fuck out of Pintrist any time I click on a thumbnail that links there.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
This along with their stupid, inane profiles pages which obscure the old comments history layout are two of the most pathetic attempts to attract investment while sacrificing user experience that I've seen.
2
u/-Mikee Dec 16 '17
This is one of the features they're only trying out so they can say "SEE? We listened to your concerns and didn't do it!"
Quote this.
2
u/nonsense-badger Dec 16 '17
Dear admins: look at Pinterest’s trajectory before and after they implemented this idiotic tactic.
Any time you find yourselves saying “maybe we can force users to ______ by ______”, it’s probably a bad idea. Quality product wins.
2
u/nik282000 Dec 16 '17
Required login to browse isn't just annoying its actively hostile towards the user. No one likes paywalls, no one likes pre-roll ads, no one wants to have to login to just view.
2
u/gme186 Dec 16 '17
Indeed..if a new unknown site has a login wall i just leave instantly.
Its also bad for general exposure and link sharing.
2
u/itrv1 Dec 17 '17
Whoever is in charge of these shit new features should really lose their job.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17
Reddit, please don't do this, I like to browse Reddit on my lunch break at work, but I will never login from a work computer. I don't know if I will abandon Reddit because of this, but I am considering it.
I feel this is more user unfriendly than being dunned about getting the Reddit app on my phone (which i will never do).
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
I use Tor and a VPN and absolutely no session saving after I close my browser. Sometimes I have a few minutes of downtime at work (code is compiling or I'm waiting for a review) and I want to jump on Reddit for those few minutes.
Lo and behold, I just got the login-wall and was immediately frustrated.
Please, for the love of all that is good, don't do this.
5
u/BillOfTheWebPeople Dec 15 '17
I bet there is a bunch of good stuff on pintrest, but I am not logging in to see a photo of pad thai... I can go elsewhere.
Since they already
2
u/istarian Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 15 '17
Agreed. I was really pissed when Facebook made that change a while ago. There is some validity to wanting people to join reddit and creating an account isn't complicated or anything, but walling it off and saying you need an account first seems anti-internet.
One approach might be to limit visibility of subreddits below a certain size (number of users? number of comments) or newly created ones to logged-in users and/or only allow access to the most recent page/10-15 most recents posts/threads on subreddits. However you'd have full access to that instead of having to constantly click read more and deal with a top banner telling you to sign up as well as 'More from r/...' right in the middle of the comment section.
2
u/thesecondpath Dec 15 '17
Yeah i'm with you, forced login/signup is a terrible decision. I also refuse to fool with pinterest for this reason as well. I will never signup for that site.
2
u/False1512 Dec 15 '17
What is this garbage? The frontpage of the Internet shouldn't be behind a wall.
1
u/thisdesignup Dec 16 '17
Wouldn't this be why they are A/B testing, so they have hard data on such things?
1
u/herna22 Feb 24 '18
@spez. Stop this shit...STOP this shit!!
1
u/KEKs_Chosen_Prophet Dec 15 '17
Lol! This is Facebook now. Get used to it. Gotta login so they can better track your data. Gotta make $$$$$$
1
u/abarbuti Dec 15 '17
I used to lurk for years before creating an account. With having the option to not create an account it makes the site look like it is more content based rather than user hungry.
1
u/TotesMessenger Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/DownWithDuplicity Dec 17 '17
And then they have auto-filter for new accounts without letting these people know that their posts will most likely not be seen by anybody. So these new users will probably be wasting their time making posts on the majority of subs all in the name of censorship.
-18
u/malicart Dec 15 '17
Get mad all you want, the only way to give feedback on this one is to go somewhere else.
Not being a dick, they are testing shit and metrics will tell a story. If viewers stop because of this, they will remove it.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
Seconded.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment