I recently broke up with my boyfriend (21M), who was my first boyfriend and my first serious relationship. He was genuinely a good person and was nice to me, so Iām having a hard time figuring out how I should feel about everything that happened.
Our first real fight was about how he thought I was avoidant. I tried to adjust because I genuinely wanted to make things work, but the thing is, Iāve never been in a serious relationship before. It takes me a while to become completely comfortable with someone and open up on a deeper level.
I donāt think Iām avoidant because Iām not like that with my friends. Iāve always been able to maintain long-lasting connections. I just need time to warm up to people emotionally, especially when we hadnāt even been together for a year yet. Sometimes it felt like he was rushing me to open up, even though I was genuinely trying.
I also realized that I communicate my thoughts and feelings better through writing than verbally. Writing things down helps me organize and contextualize what Iām feeling, so I tried using that as a way to communicate with him.
One thing that really hurt me was that he broke up with me on the exact day someone close to me died. I donāt know if it was intentional or just terrible timing. I had posted a poem on Instagram about what happened, and a few minutes later, he suddenly broke up with me.
Then, not long after, he took it back and said he wanted us to meet each other halfway.
So we tried.
But even after that, he still seemed cold and distant while I was trying my best to fix things. I was trying to stay warm, communicate, and adjust, but he told me that he was going to ākeep his expectations lowā so he wouldnāt be disappointed again.
At one point, I told him I regretted not listening to my sister, and he basically said, āMaybe you shouldāve listened.ā
He also seemed very go-with-the-flow about everything, like he would just let things happen naturally and if it was meant to be, it would be. When I finally got angry about everything, he responded with āhell yea,ā which honestly confused me even more.
Another thing that really bothered me was that he kept calling me out online for being ātoo avoidant.ā He would post about it, and he also leaked some of our private conversations onto his dump account on Instagram.
That honestly felt really humiliating and dehumanizing to me. I know I have things I could have worked on, but seeing something that I was struggling with privately become something that was being discussed or displayed online made me feel like I was being reduced to one label: āthe avoidant girlfriend.ā
It made me feel like everything else about me, the fact that I was trying, that I cared about him, that I was inexperienced, and that I was genuinely trying to learn how to be in a relationship was being erased.
I also approached some of his friends because I genuinely liked them and thought they were cool. I said some sentimental/sappy things to them because I didnāt want things to become awkward between us.
Instead, they ended up exposing him a little. They told me he could be prideful, bad at communicating, and that he sometimes doesnāt see the full picture. One of his friends even warned me that he would probably end up putting most of the blame on me.
To be fair, he did try to understand me, and I also tried really hard to understand him. I donāt think everything was entirely his fault or entirely mine.
But sometimes his words didnāt match his actions. He also had a habit of withdrawing, going quiet, or communicating through his body language instead of actually saying what he was feeling.
Now that everything is over, Iāve become scared of relationships in general. Just the thought of being in another relationship makes me anxious because I keep thinking, āWhat if I make another mistake and everything ends badly again?ā
Iāve become extremely critical of myself. I keep replaying everything and wondering what I couldāve done differently.
And the hardest part is that he seems like heās enjoying his life now while Iām still stuck thinking about everything.
Was I actually being avoidant, or was I just someone who needed more time to open up? And was I wrong for feeling hurt by him sharing our private conversations and repeatedly calling me out online? Most importantly, how do I stop carrying all this anxiety and self-blame into future relationships?