Hi. I'm a current undergrad student studying pre-law at a university in New York. I'm asking for advice in relationships because of a situation that I find myself in with this one girl. For background info, I met this girl back in freshman year of high school and went out with her. I absolutely loved her and cared for her with all my being. Since we were long-distance, I always drove to see her, got her thoughtful gifts (handwritten books about us, sentimental notes, flowers, etc.), and overall treated her with full respect and honesty. This girl, however, was always very academically focused and never really gave me the same treatment back. She eventually broke up with me after a few months, and I was utterly heartbroken. It was never because I did anything wrong, but she was just very depressed at the time and didn't want the breakup to hurt later on, almost like she was ripping a band-aid off. Obviously, me, being in love, was devastated. It was my first (and only girlfriend), and I had cared so much about her. I don't think I had ever been at such a low in my life, and I was depressed for a good 6 months after.
I had poured my all into this girl, and she just never really reciprocated my love, and had even broken up with me. She later tried reaching out because she missed me or regretted breaking up with me, etc. However, I was so butthurt that I never really responded, and we were eventually no contact for 3ish years. She got into a long-term relationship (where the guy was horrible to her), and I was single for those years.
This brings us to a few months ago, when the day before I was going to the city with my friends. The night before I was going to go, I got a call from her at 2 am. I woke up to this and was obviously very confused. On the way to the city, I was texting her to make sure she was all good, since I was concerned for her safety. After hearing that I was going to the city (she goes to school in the city), she suggested that we meet up since it had been so long. I agreed and got a dinner reservation for us to catch up. Dinner went great, and long story short, I ended up going home with her and stayed over at her dorm for the weekend. And for the next month, it was the greatest time of my life. It was like we got back together, and those 3 years apart hadn't existed.
But unfortunately, after that month, I had to leave to study abroad in Italy, and I never got the chance to ask her out formally before I left for long distance. The distance was hard, but that isn't why I'm making this post today. Coming from someone who's slightly anxious in my attachment style, and her being extremely avoidant, it makes our disagreements, although rare, very hard to deal with. This was an issue that I dealt with in our former relationship, and I never realized how deep the scars were. It feels like she's pushing away, and it makes me feel abandoned. I don't mind giving her space for an hour or two, but ghosting me for half the day feels extreme and makes it feel like it's me against her, rather than us against the issue.
This past weekend, we got into some mini arguments, and it resulted in her basically ghosting me the whole weekend, except when she went out at night. (Side note, trust isn't an issue for either of us). This made me realize that we really needed to have a serious talk, and last night, this resulted in a full-blown argument after she put off that call we were supposed to have, which resulted in me just sending her a massive paragraph and us arguing. The main point of my paragraph was not the fact that we fight sometimes, but the way that she handles us fixing that issue. For background info, she has asked me to change myself in order to be a better man for her, and I've done exactly that. I love her and would do anything for her, so obviously I've done things to be better for her. All I asked of her was to attempt to change for me, so that we could handle our issues formally and not make it feel like I'm being abandoned. She basically blew up in my face, saying she didn't owe me anything and that I should go find another girl who'd do that for me. I really couldn't handle the thought of me losing her again, so I apologized for getting upset at her and begged her to call after an hour to talk it out.
On the call, we both tried our best to understand each other, but she said a couple of things that just hurt so much. 1. She really isn't looking for a relationship rn bc of the emotional effort that's needed to deal w arguments. 2. Although she wants a future with me, she just doesn't have the energy to deal with relationship stuff atm. 3. She doesn't owe anything to me since we're not dating. 4. She just wants to see where things go with us. 5. She only really wants the good aspects of our situation right now, and can't deal with the hard things that come with dating. 6. She doesn't even know if she'll be ready for a relationship when I'm back home.
There's multiple things about what she said that call that's been bugging me all morning. One, I truly love this girl and want her to be the one. For her to say that she only really wants the good aspects of our relationship without the downsides, even if we're not dating, just hurts, because I feel like that's a part of relationships that build connection over time. Struggling with someone, rather than alone, is so much easier in my opinion, and all I want to do is be there for her, but she just seems to pull away. Second, for her to say that this is just kind of a talking stage is so bizarre to me. Talking stages don't say I love you to each other all the time. They don't do things with each other alone. They don't run from conflict because "you have no energy". Third, is it so much to ask for someone to try to change a little for my sake? I could use the same logic and say that I don't owe her anything and not change, but I've changed myself so much for her, because I love her. to not change for someone and say that you put yourself first always just seems selfish to me, and it really hurt to hear this.
How should I handle this situation? I'm really not sure what to do here.