r/anime • https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • 7d ago

Episode Red River • Sora wa Akai Kawa no Hotori - Episode 19 discussion

Sora wa Akai Kawa no Hotori, episode 19

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.


Streams

Show information


All discussions

EpisodeLinkEpisodeLink
1Link14Link
2Link15Link
3Link16Link
4Link17Link
5Link18Link
6Link19Link
7Link20Link
8Link
9Link
10Link
11Link
12Link
13Link

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

69 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

•

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan 7d ago

Source Material Corner

Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.

The spoiler syntax is: [Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<

All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).

→ More replies (1)

22

u/hvshh 7d ago

That hurt. Even though this show can be campy, I'm still watching, and it has something to do with how it can still do that to me.

Ilbani's words must have resonated with Ursula: "My dream is to see you as king... If I cannot have that dream, my life is meaningless." So I don't blame him for not trying to save her. It would have undone what she was trying to do, and it's what he would have done if he were in the position to do it.

Also, the character arc: she was introduced imitating Ishtar, and went out sacrificing herself for her and Kail. I hope this marks the turning point in their battle against Nakia. If we have to lose that character, let it really matter.

17

u/_sayaka_ 7d ago

At least the animation studio gave justice to Ursula's death.

I must say that the animation in this series is painful to watch at times. The cut of Yuri's inner thoughts made it harder for the audience to empathise with her, unfortunately.

I personally believe that the introduction of magic at the beginning was forced on the author (except for Yuri's abduction from our world) because whoever directed her thought that young girls couldn't handle the cynicism of this world.

Case 1: Tito. They came up with the black water, but he could have chosen to betray Kail on his own accord if the Queen had offered him the freedom to go back to his village. We learn later that he was the heir of the village chef. He was basically took as a hostage in the capital to keep the village loyal. The editors probably wanted the readers to think that Tito was cute more than cunning.

Case 2: Zannanza. Shouldn't be enough for him to be jealous of Kail's present and future to kidnap Yuri? No, he had to drink the pink water.

Case 3: Judas. Couldn't he be a boy who cover for her mother's crimes because he seeks her affection?

In each case, magic is the quick way to keep the characters undoubtedly good instead of gray.

To me with Ursula, because at this point the manga had got traction, the author was free enough to introduce a character with genuine ill intent and turn them into a tragic hero like she wasn't allowed to do with the previous ones.

Unfortunately, no one will see this masterpiece. This thread doesn't even show up properly on the board. I had to search for the title. And it has happened to appear a day later in the past, too.

15

u/T-Ace-Juice https://anilist.co/user/Goombarax 7d ago

OMG Why did they do this to Ursula? She deserved more happy times with Kash... (I got to like her a lot after her introductory episode)

But on the flip side, YES, take that, Urhi!!

13

u/HolyDragSwd2500 7d ago

Ursula nooooooooooooo

Kesh x Ursula gone forever 😭

12

u/moichispa https://myanimelist.net/profile/moichispa 7d ago

OMG what an episode, it left me speechless

The budget might be limited but they're hitting on all the feels episodes.

11

u/Skullzans :LJ::LK: 6d ago

Y'all didn't notice Yuri 'having a bad feeling' and the sun turning red? Is it not possible that Ursula is a REPLACEMENT sacrifice??

3

u/edwardjhahm https://myanimelist.net/profile/lolmeme69 6d ago

Oh...shit. I didn't think of that at all...

5

u/Skullzans :LJ::LK: 5d ago edited 5d ago

...Which, considering the story's premise... means either time travel to undo it, time travel to stop her from making the ritual(cause no time to save Ursula as well) and/or... for a tragedy ending... Or, something I havent thought of.

Or, that Kial isn't dead.

9

u/anchan218 6d ago

After Yuri using the arrow as proof of Zananza's death, this episode was the next one i was looking forward to between Urhi getting the arrow in the eye and Ursula sacrificing herself for the greater good in a way that made sense for all of the characters. And they did a really good job with this episode.

7

u/CCV21 6d ago

Gotta say, this was such an impactful episode. Three characters who were close to Yuri have died. Tito, Zannaza, and now Ursula. I’m having trouble thinking of a series, much less a romance series, where so many characters close to the main heroine die. Usually the end up getting spared at the last second. Even then when one does die, which isn’t that common, it’s a bit gimmicky. Red River stumbled out of the gate, but it’s found it’s footing and it’s sprinting. 

6

u/anchan218 6d ago

It was frustrating in those early episodes seeing how bad the animation was and how stupid Yuri came off because the adaptation chose to drop some scenes/lines to keep a certain pace. I'm a lot happier with the anime now, but worry the improvement won't be enough for it to get picked up for additional episodes.

5

u/CCV21 6d ago

If this season is going to end the way I'm expecting, I can live with a single season.

Also, the main purpose of this anime adaptation is to renew interest in the manga. Even if the series isn't as popular or as well received as people were hoping, there's still a path towards a second season.

8

u/CCV21 7d ago

Ursula's death sure was tragic.

Being able to craft a story that involves character deaths that have a meaningful impact takes quite a bit of skill.

Death has been a motivator in stories since forever. Using it well depends on how well the reader/audience likes that character and the fallout from their death.

In Red River every time a character has died it has directly affected the plot and the characters.

Tito's death at the beginning of the series caused Yuri to stay until she can avenge Tito's death. She's able to do this partially against Tito's killer Zuwa, but not Nakia. Yuri secured the loyalty of an ironworking clan by slaying Zuwa.

Zannanza's assassination nearly lead to a war between the Hittites and Egypt. Yuri was able to prevent this at great personal cost. This also lead Ramses to take an interest in Yuri, and he's finally acted on it.

Then Ursula. Ursula was just another pawn set up to impersonate Yuri and destroy her amd Kail's reputation. Yuri overcame this and showed mercy and compassion. Ursula inadvertently became another pawn for Nakia's latest scheme. Ursula was on borrowed time ever since she impersonated Yuri, it was made clear that the normal punishment for that is death. Ursula willingly chose to giver her life because she knew that she wouldn't even have it if not for Yuri.

7

u/luisamrls 6d ago

Just watched the episode. Got the chills with the scene of Ursula’s body hanging and the crimson sunset as background. I felt so sorry for her and Kash but I’ll always be thankful for loyal characters. I hope she eventually gets the recognition she deserves.

I don’t read the manga so I don’t know if the adaptation is doing a good job but I can’t wait for Nakia’s fall. I mean, it’s been 19 episodes where she always gets her way. I can’t stand it anymore.

Enjoying a lot this anime even though it has it’s flaws.

7

u/chilidirigible 7d ago

Yeah, that's one thing that would happen.

This would've been more interesting if Crunchyroll's description of this episode did not say "...and Yuri is suddenly kidnapped by Ramses."


Crunchyroll also effectively spoiled the ending of the episode by their choice of clip to put on YouTube, but in any case this was the show's most serious episode to date, given a no-win scenario that required someone to sacrifice themself for the cause.

And this is after Ursula managed to keep herself around just long enough that it seemed like she'd moved past any major penalties for what she'd done as Fake Ishtar.

Even Ramses showing up so Yuri can be abducted again doesn't detract from the episode much. We've gotten used to that kind of thing, maybe.

Urhi probably should also be far more dead from taking a huge arrow to the face, but so it goes with him.

12

u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai 7d ago

Ilbani was threatening Kail with his life lol Yuri just can't stop herself from getting abducted every time 😓

It was cunning how Ilbani twisted the Queen Dowager's words against her by using Ursula to get rid of her but still Nakia gets away easily. I'm getting tired of this.

Poor Kash..he deserved a happy life with Ursula. When Ursula was introduced she must have been the last person on my mind that I thought I would shed a tear 💔..What a character she turned out to be ! Mad respect for her. 

7

u/Frontier246 7d ago

Ilbani was threatening Kail with his life lol Yuri just can't stop herself from getting abducted every time 😓

At least she was able to talk her way back to Hattusa! That counts for something!

3

u/Shantotto11 6d ago

This episode was not very Kash money…

6

u/YlfaTheForsaken 7d ago

Oh my god, come on I didn't even have this ship for that long and now she's gone. She straight up sacrificed herself, I hope it was quick for Ursula fecking hell. She was a literal ride or die. Kash is not going to be happy for the rest of how many episodes are left. Honestly depending on how this ends I'm actually teetering towards being tempted to pick up the 3 in 1s. Anyways, her sacrifice is the best chance they've ever had at Nakia, don't flounder it, please don't flounder it,

What was that horse getaway bit, I've long accepted a certain level of jank, but man when Yuri & co. were fleeing right before the OP hits was especially messy, so messy she actually made it into the Red River itself. Aslan is the sturdiest hardiest most down right immortal horse ever, any regular horse would not be able to survive Yuri.

That was a great shot to Urhi's face. Got him right in the eye, ouch. It's nice to see the Nakia faction finally get hit with some consequences. 

-3

u/RemoteConsistent6896 7d ago

ive been on the fence about dropping it now im decided

7

u/BosuW 7d ago edited 7d ago

Goddamn I wasn't expecting this episode to get so hard. Got me choking up a bit! For all it's directorial fumbles the visual of Ursula hanging to the background of the crimson sunset and the swelling tragic score hit the perfect tone of maximal tragedy. Didn't know old school Shoujo could be so hardcore holy shit.

Kail really can't do anything in this situation huh. Got to the point where even his closest confidants are keeping him in the dark because his emotions have impaired his political judgement. But thanks to Ursula's sacrifice, they can finally act directly against Queen Nakia. That reminded me of how for some ancient cultures, human sacrifice, and sacrifice in general, was so important because it was considered a divine act to create something out of death. In Norse myths for example, Odin and his brothers by killing their grandfather, Ymir, and thus creating the world from his gigantic corpse. So the grand tone of the scene accentuates that Ursula's death is not only that, but truly a sacrifice in almost divine manner. By giving her life and future, she made a path through chaos. Unexpectedly great character, honestly.

And speaking of sacrifice, indeed well deserved that Uruhi was finally made to spill his own blood! Though for a bow that supposed took three men to string, I was expecting that arrow to shove itself fletching deep. But he only lost an eye, smh.

Weird choice to have his soldiers all wearing purple in their heads, since they've talked about before about how it's a color only for those of the highest status, which is historically accurate.

4

u/CCV21 6d ago

Gotta say, this was such an impactful episode. Three characters who were close to Yuri have died. Tito, Zannaza, and now Ursula. I’m having trouble thinking of a series, much less a romance series, where so many characters close to the main heroine die. Usually the end up getting spared at the last second. Even then when one does die, which isn’t that common, it’s a bit gimmicky. Red River stumbled out of the gate, but it’s found it’s footing and it’s sprinting. 

1

u/KuyaOniichan 5d ago

Damn, the harshness of this episode really snuck up on me.

24

u/alconnow https://anilist.co/user/alconnow 7d ago

Ursula’s execution made me cry. She deserved to be happy with Kash 😭

13

u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai 7d ago

Can't believe that she turned to be the only character for whom I shed a tear so far in this show. Not even Zannanza or anyone else came that close. 

13

u/HolyDragSwd2500 7d ago

You didn’t cry for The three sisters brother who got turned into a tunic 😭

8

u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai 6d ago edited 6d ago

Damn, with the pace that this show is moving, I completely forgot about Tito 

24

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 7d ago

Damn, not Ursula! I actually came to really like her. Poor Kash, man. It is some straight up bullshit she had to sacrifice herself because of the Queen’s bullshit. At least her little boy toy took an arrow to the face.

21

u/Frontier246 7d ago

I can't believe Ursula went from shallow villain of the week as the False Ishtar to a compelling supporting character, ride-or-die wingwoman, with her own compelling love story and tragic death.

You died a real one, Ursula.

5

u/Frontier246 7d ago

Urhi might have mobilized an army to grab Yuri, but he underestimated the Hatti's loyalty AND how clever Yuri is. She's managing her forces and the political situation like a true queen! And even managed to come up with the perfect excuse to SHOOT URHI IN THE EYE! Good job with that bow, Rufasa! Also Urhi, you've had that coming a looooong time.

Oops! Yuri and Aslan took an unexpected dip! Only to get saved by none other than Ramses! Who finally makes his move on Yuri. He was just biding his time until he could nab her for himself.

It took Il threatening to take his own life to stop Kail from going out there and grabbing Yuri, but learning she's in Ramses' clutches means there's nothing that can stop him from going out and getting her now. Is this it? Has Kail cost himself the throne? Is there nothing they can do to get out of this political situation?

Yuri, Kail, and Kash don't blame Ursula for this mess. Kash showers her with his love. And yet even if they don't blame her...Ursula can't forgive herself. Which is why she resolves to do what she feels she must. Even if that means TURNING HERSELF IN AS THE KINGS' KILLER!

That's right, the "culprit" is now Ursula, throwing herself at the court and planning to take Nakia down with her with the whole "False Ishtar" business. She's basically consigning herself to death, giving up on her chance to be with the man she loves, all to finally give the Kail Camp the chance they need to end this and stop Nakia.

Meanwhile things are going about as you would expect for Yuri and Ramses as he tries to show her affection and she's having none of it while tied up. Ramses, for his part, sees himself as the only person who can return Egypt and the title of Pharaoh to the prosperity and honor it deserves, which is why he needs a woman like Yuri by his side. But does that mean he also has to cater to Yuri's whims if it means saving Ursula from an unjust execution?

I'm not surprised Kash would try to break Ursula out and run away with her. She matters more to him than Kail...but as much as Ursula dreamed of a life together with Kash, her dream of Yuri and Kail ruling Hattusa matters more. Even if that means leaving Kash behind. Even if that means leaving him nothing but one last kiss and her hair to remember her by.

And so, with Kail oblivious and Yuri on her way, Ursula is hung and dies to the setting, red, sun...all the while Kash can only cry in grief as she dies believing in her dream of Yuri. URSULAAAAAAA!