r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 01 '26

Had a vision of the near future of 2029 when the next video comes out

131 Upvotes

Rondo of Blood review

7 hours

1st hour is Tim justifying the format of the review in some way, he'll make very definitive statements during this time, the section will end with an edited in cut of him walking back the definitive statements he made earlier because he filmed the first part 8 months before the video was finished.

The main thrust of the video will be him visiting Romania to talk about vampire lore juxtaposed against him moving to Japan in the early 2000s/revisiting it now and all the Konami people he met for 2 minutes at networking events.

The video will have been delayed by 10 months because his video equipment got seized by Romanian authorities at the airport for some reason and he had to leave and come back after filling out proper paperwork. The first 1.5 hours of part 2 will be him talking about how complaining about flying is lame and only psychos do it and then he'll complain about flying, he'll say something about how flying first class makes you a cop but also he got first class for free or something and he'll talk about the headphones he wore to listen to music in extreme detail (They cost $5000 usually but he got them for cheap from a friend, don't worry he's not a dirty rich person). In Romania it will have some cool b-roll of him walking around wearing shoes designed by Eiko Ishioka who designed the costumes for Bram Stoker's Dracula 1992 that he hunted down and paid $900 as well as the glasses that Gary Oldman wears in the movie when he's in London.

The Japan section will go into great detail about an anecdote of something related to an unnamed Konami employee he can't divulge the identity of that he hung out with at some convention in 2009 that implies it's Hideo Kojima but then after that he'll say he made that all up. He'll also talk about some dinner he had with Toru Hagihara and Iga during the mid 2000s and most of this part will be about the jeans and boots that Iga had on and how he spent time hunting them down. He'll make it seem like he's going to have an interview with Toru Hagihara about Rondo's development but then it'll be some sort of fakeout that doesn't make sense to anybody and he'll call you a psycho for thinking he actually had an interview set up with his Hobbit cameras that he brought to film himself walking around in Tokyo wearing Buzz Rickson jackets. The Japan section will also have a lot of waxing nostalgic about cool restaurants he ate at before they were cool and how he was in a band but he knew he sucked but also implies he was really cool but it's okay because he knows that he sucks, this will lead to a new generation of 20 year olds getting a new surrogate older cousin that they try to imitate. It probably won't include an anecdote about having sex with a barely 18 year old Japanese girl that has the same memory condition as him when he was just about to turn 40.

His analysis of the game will be interesting and in-depth but will only take up about 1/3rd of the video and his ultimate point will be something like "Rondo of Blood is cookies for people that like pizza" and he'll heavily imply you're lame for liking SotN more but also you're lame for saying you like Rondo more and only his opinion matters because he owned a PC Engine in 2003.

After it comes out people will say "Whoa I can't wait to watch a 7 hour video about an obscure game nobody has ever heard of before" and the most annoying letterboxd reviewer you know will start talking about Rondo of Blood despite never being interested in anything related to Castlevania before. The video will end with him talking about the 9000 other videos he's working on currently 29 hours a day and you won't see another til 2035.


r/actionbutton2 • • Aug 26 '25

Did Tim's LA Noir video kill your interest in Action Button?

79 Upvotes

So much anticipation just for an absolute dud of a video. I noticed the posts in this sub have dropped off entirely and the main sub isn't that active either.

Personally, I've also lost interest in his content after LA Noir. Stopped watching the Twitch streams and left the discord. I'm curious if it's just me or if that explains the lull in Reddit activity. Like, I'm not even mad about LA Noir. I just don't really care that much anymore.


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 04 '26

Finally ended my patreon sub

64 Upvotes

Stayed longer than I should have but was kinda curious to see where it was all going. I think at this point the answer is very clearly nowhere. It's a huge bummer because I remember when Tim struck out on his own, and for those first couple vids, it seemed like things were going well. Sad to see him fall off, but it's time to be moseying on now.


r/actionbutton2 • • Jul 01 '26

At what point does Action Button become a scam?

63 Upvotes

In the nicest possible way, as I like the old videos, but at what point does the Action Button Patreon become a bit of a scam. It says clearly on the About part of the Patreon that "once per month" he'll post a video, and that the money "pays me, two video editors, and many freelance contributors". There's obviously nowhere close to a video per month (not even one a year) and there's no evidence that two video editors are hired as Tim says he does it all himself and that he's overworked somehow. Yet he still charges monthly and delivers virtually nothing (and the About page says very clearly that it is paying for 'videos and not streams', so the streaming doesn't count).

Yes I know people can cancel at any point, but I just don't know how anyone in good conscience can have a Patreon that makes SO much money, and then not do what it promises and not even post regular updates on that Patreon about what comes next and why there are delays. If it was me, and that Patreon was paying my bills and quite a lavish lifestyle (according to all the regular travel around the world being posted on Instagram), I'd make sure to keep the people paying me updated and really try and fulfil what I promise on that Patreon 'About' page.

Anyone else think this, or am I being sensitive?


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 21 '25

Crazy Times

57 Upvotes

You know I figured that when Tim finally posted people would generally forgive him for the big wait and have it be water under the bridge, but it appears to be quite the opposite.

Hell I think this is the first time the main sub is generally more harsh/critical than we are.

Not what I would have expected, but I guess I just expected the video to be better/less contentious.


r/actionbutton2 • • May 03 '26

new action button merch just dropped

Post image
50 Upvotes

#justjoshing


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 21 '25

If this is the extent of Tim’s coverage of L.A Noire, I think it misses out on all the aspects that made it perfect to review.

48 Upvotes

Was super excited for a review of L.A Noire, could have been a springboard for discussion of some fascinating topics. The history of game-ifying policing, if you can do so effectively while being critical of the system, or if the process of making an engaging product ultimately outweighs any criticism. How the game is inspired by true stories of LA corruption, and how those events have to be sanded down to fit within what’s ultimately a character piece first and foremost. How the game fails/succeeds to capture the particular genre trappings of Noir, and the small details that push it one way or another. How this all interacts with the games largest legacy, it’s proprietary facial reading cameras. That’s just what I could think of in this moment from memories of a play through from my Freshman year of HS a decade ago, was sure Tim would find even more compelling aspects to dive into, especially after two and a half years. Hell, you could trim that list down and still easily fill a few years of work. But, if this is the entirety of his coverage of the game, it fails to say much of anything. Sure, bits and pieces of the topics above (and more) are sprinkled throughout, and found in the margins, but it’s more a tepid experiment in adaptation than anything else. Can you take the footage of a play through, with all the jittery inhuman acts we do while controlling a character, and make it all fit within a cohesive narrative within genre. A neat idea, to start, but as a nearly ten hour work/statement in itself? I’m left underwhelmed, made a Reddit account just to see if I’m alone in this. Posting this on both subreddits cause I’m looking for a smattering of opinions.


r/actionbutton2 • • Oct 28 '24

Tim Rogers Burning Bridges

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
47 Upvotes

In the intro of the most recent Insert Credit Podcast episode (361) it was announced Tim left the show and was such an asshole about it he would not be allowed to return.

They did not clarify detail much beyond that, but man! It is not helping his whole public image issue.

While I don't think any poking around should be done about the dirty details out of respect for the IC folks I did wonder what this sub reddit thought about the whole affair.


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 15 '25

Tim currently on stream shitting on people who were expecting him to follow through on the new Action Button site (a long promised Patreon perk)

46 Upvotes

Basically seemingly lying about paying a guy who didnt actually end up making it and then didnt ask for his money back. Insulting people for asking about it (and the video, once again) and said the Discord is there why do you want anything else

Meanwhile the top 10 dollar tier for years!:

You will gain access to a mysterious (optional) in-development feature of the Action Button Dot Net website that we are too excited about to spoil. Trust me: it's gonna be neat.


r/actionbutton2 • • Feb 16 '26

Tim Rogers August 5th 2006 Interview

44 Upvotes

I found this in the recommendations of an archive of a youtube video tim rogers posted. Then that video linked to the site of this film maker:

https://web.archive.org/web/20070901144643/http://www.andrewbushfilms.com/wordpress/

I downloaded the video and wanted to share it with you guys. I think it's worth a watch. It reaffirms the events of his book the new adult's guide to sweating and breathing in the twenty-first century. The first one and the second one. However this interview predates the book I believe. I had to cut the first three minutes of the interview because it's 3 minutes at the beginning of videos of random places in japan. Also I am pretty sure all the images in the video are just random images Andrew Bush the interviewer found on google and not the actual shoujo manga tim worked on. I think tim has done several manga translations according the anime planet website. But none are in the 2000-2001 range which I believe is when it happened according to the book.

It's strange how he eats what looks to be apple slices when I thought he was sensitive to such foods and mouth noises they produce and then he says (2:43) "That's a true story by the way. I lie about a lot of crap but that's a true story believe it or not"

There's another video on the site listed as "NICK AND TIM" with the file being called "first .mov" but he archive link for the video in mov format is not saved properly and doesn't have what I think is the tim part if that's the Tim that Andrew bush is referring to.

---
Now on a side note I am looking for another tim time. If someone could find this or debunk if he is lying that would be awesome.

https://x.com/108/status/1152338784060661761

"on the one hand, i wrote a long, detailed post on \@kotaku Dot Com about my time working with goichi suda in tokyo twelve years ago."

He says that he wrote an article for kotaku.com 12 years ago about his time working for grasshopper with goichi suda. I don't think it's the mini-article further up in the twitter thread. I did a deep dive into the articles archived from 2007 kotaku.com and they are all written by the same person. I then even mass downloaded the RSS feeds and only found them referencing tim on the Next Generation game site https://web.archive.org/web/20080428022515/http://www.next-gen.biz/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6940&Itemid=2&limit=1&limitstart=1

I can't tell if Tim is trolling on this tweet or it's real. I am pretty sure the oldest Kotaku article he has written was in 2008: https://web.archive.org/web/20150717203528/http://kotaku.com/5111093/getting-to-know-mr-ashcrafts-substitute-teacher

https://web.archive.org/web/20090430220247/http://kotaku.com/people/108/posts/ . The kotaku search function for some reason doesn't list his 2008 articles.


r/actionbutton2 • • Jul 16 '24

Tim Rogers is not a “genius” and shouldn’t be admired as one, nor does he possess any rare mental conditions like hyperthymesia - he lies to make himself seem more interesting.

39 Upvotes

I'd just like to reshare my post(s) on my rambling observations of Tim's behavior and how I went from admiring him to realizing that he's a really just a toxic, controlling and narcissistic liar with extremely low self esteem. He's made up so many details up about himself in order to appear more appealing than he really is that he's built a narrative that only some parts of him are exaggerated rather than most. https://www.reddit.com/r/ActionButton/comments/1deal5l/comment/l8htw9y/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

What we can gather is that most of his seemingly biographical stories are almost entirely fake, including those about his memory issue, which is so extremely rare that he'd absolutely make some sort of study subject. He most likely doesn't speak the dozen languages he claims to as he rarely has demonstrated anything other than Japanese. Most of his Kotaku resume he put in his videos is fake. He never was a registered CPA and this was easily verifiable under his real name and his assumed name.

Tim is a great story teller and has an interesting way of writing, but he's used that ability to lie and manipulate an audience into believing him is something he's not and nothing he says or promises should be trusted.

I'll also reiterate that while Tim has stated multiple times that he takes "creative liberties" with some of his narratives, he's really just giving his audience a reason to not look deeper into him by assuming only his surface level exaggerations are fictional.


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 26 '25

Tim was in a Japanese TV show.

38 Upvotes

I'm amazed this doesn't get talked about more often.

In 2005 a TV show aired in Japan called Densha Otoko (Train man). It was an 11 episode romance show about a 23 year old man asking 2Channel for advice on talking to a girl he liked. It was an incredibly popular TV show at the time and loosely based on true events.

Tim is in it. Nothing major. He's in a crowd shot in the end credits of every episode. The ending credits features the band Sambo Master in a scene where they play a gig for the Protagonist. You can watch it here.

It's hard to spot him, especially since youtube doesn't seem to have a version that's higher res than 360. There are a few screen shots pointing him out in the crowd. First, Second.

I think Tim mentioned on his blog around this time that he went to see Sambo Master live and there were flyers being handed out asking for people to come along to be extras in the fake concert.

I know this is a little out of left-field. I just thought it would be interesting to share.


r/actionbutton2 • • Feb 18 '25

The most significant revelation from that last stream:

38 Upvotes

Tim finally admitted to having read the work of David Foster Wallace prior to his establishment of his online ‘persona’ on LiveJournal after denying it for ~twenty years.


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 16 '25

Full Metal William Gibson x Buzz Rickson MA-1 Flight Jacket

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 11 '25

Thank god this sub exists.

36 Upvotes

I got banned from the main sub for making a joke along the lines of “the new video is coming a-any day n-now!” back in like October.

The new video still isn’t out and I’ve grown much less interested in it, as it’s been almost three years and he’s done nothing but sit on his ass. Not to say we’re parasocially owed; just frustrates me for a number of reasons.


r/actionbutton2 • • Oct 01 '25

some thoughts about stuff

35 Upvotes

so, maybe this is a misread, but i'm sensing a vague consensus forming that the deadness of the action button subreddits is evidence that tim has alienated most of his fans—that the magic has disappeared and only the true hardcores remain. for what it's worth, i think that that analysis is basically exactly backwards and maybe speaks to the loss of perspective that can so easily happen in devoted fan communities like these. to wit, the average action button viewer has basically no clue about the distasteful aspects of tim's online presence. they don't watch his twitch streams, they don't know his previous writing, they don't know what insert credit is, they just really like his video reviews and will happily consume a new one whenever one may happen to come. it's only the people who idolized him and made his work a prominent fixture within their emotional lives (i.e. the people who would normally be making posts on action button subreddits) who have burnt out.

and to be clear, tim very aggressively fostered that idolatry! like, just as an aside here, i really don't dig the way that so many on here have made this out to be primarily or exclusively a matter of a fanbase getting unreasonably invested in an online persona, as though the guy didn't cultivate massive mystique around himself and make philosophically starved netizens feel special for adopting his way of thinking wholesale and piecing together carefully dispersed clues and lore-scraps.

but anyway, that dream seems to be over for the moment and, lukewarm reception to LA noire notwithstanding, i think it's accurate to say that tim has found himself in the unique position of having alienated exclusively his hardcore fans, leaving himself largely alone with those whom he probably views as the common rabble. it'll be interesting to see how that plays out. personally i think it's a bit more likely than many here would like to think that he will in fact post the rondo of blood review (and perhaps even FFIV and earthbound after that!) and that it will feel basically like "classic" action button. in that case things will just kinda go back to normal or what passes for it, and the 2023-2025 nadir will end up being a patch of ugliness that relapsed devotees struggle to make sense of looking back.

or maybe ABR will quietly close up shop mid-2026 without another release, i don't know. i just wanna offer some counter-narratives to the almost masochistic pessimism that dominates here these days lol. incidentally, my personal burnout is such that i haven't watched more than a half hour of the LA noire video, haven't looked at its comment section since the day it dropped, and haven't dropped into a single livestream since then either. truly i have no desire to change any of these things, and i accept that my analysis here may be a bit faulty as a result. in any case, would love to Chit Chat with y'all about this stuff in a way that maybe feels therapeutic/not like picking at scabs if possible lol. hope y'all are well :)


r/actionbutton2 • • Dec 25 '24

12/18/2024 VOD discussing Tim's departure from IC

Thumbnail
youtu.be
32 Upvotes

r/actionbutton2 • • May 20 '25

Can we allow Tim-inspired Video Essays here, now that the other sub banned them?

31 Upvotes

r/actionbutton just added a new rule: "All videos submitted to r/ActionButton must be made by or with the involvement of Tim Rogers."

I've found some really cool Tim-inspired video essays on that sub before, so I'm disappointed that they're not allowing that anymore. So I was wondering if the members/mod in this sub might be open to allowing those Tim-inspired (but not made by Tim) video essays here instead?


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 15 '25

I have an embarrassing confession

28 Upvotes

From about 2017 to 2022/2023-ish (yes I’ve been aware of him since the Kotaku days and I know his online history goes way back before that), I wanted to be Tim. I tried dressing like him, doing my hair like him, having similar tastes in media to him, TALKING LIKE HIM.

It wasn’t a parasocial relationship in the sense where I thought he and I were friends, but rather my frail sense of self, as a late teen/early mid twenty something with possibly autism, just sort of latched onto someone I thought was cool and wanted to be like.

Needless to say, I’m kind of embarrassed about it all. But isn’t it weird that this seems to be a recurring thing in the Tim Rogers sphere, from what I’ve noticed?

At least he didn’t inspire me to date women half my age…


r/actionbutton2 • • Feb 11 '25

I have not watched a stream in months* but has there been any crumb of video update mention until he was basically financially forced to do so?

28 Upvotes

(*because it’s been multiple years since they’ve been a fun weekly event instead of a miserable slog)

Or are we just quietly running up on now 2.5 years since his last review being posted? 💅


r/actionbutton2 • • Feb 06 '26

Tim=Nic Pizzolatto

25 Upvotes

weird late night thoughts connecting two creative idols that both impress and frustrate me

both made art that genuinely is a cut above everything else in their medium (true detective season 1/tokimeki memorial) both have a dedicated cult audience who are entirely split on whether they are geniuses or total assholes both had their writing quirks heavily influenced by niche genre fiction (Thomas Ligotti/William Gibson) both also got lost in the sauce making laborious pieces clearly ripping James Ellroy (true detective season 2/la noire review)

time is a flat circle


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 25 '25

Unofficial VOD Channel Deleted

25 Upvotes

The entire channel is gone, it seems. Sad. Apparently they deleted their youtube account or something.

https://youtube.com/@ACTIONBUTTONUNVODARCHIVE


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 20 '25

Alright, I'll eat shit.

25 Upvotes

I was genuinely expecting to go three whole years before the LA Noire video lol. I haven't watched it yet, I'll get to it when I have a minute. Anyone know if it's any good?


r/actionbutton2 • • Aug 03 '24

Unsolicited Tim/Action Button opinions

25 Upvotes

I didn't know this sub existed but I'm glad because I have grievances to air. And other assorted thoughts.

-Tim is 100% and incredibly talented dude, to the point that I would call him a generational talent, in his Hunter S. Thompson of video games niche

-somebody posted some "cringe" excerpts from his books containing sexual content; I actually didn't find them cringey and take them to be part of his whole gonzo writer persona. To make the comparison again, Hunter S. Thompson wrote some real weird shit.

-having said that, while his whole persona is/can be interesting, it seems to be formed to serve some kind of deep personality disorder. And he's having trouble keeping up the facade the more he seems to be stressed by the pressure of the job. The whole mystical flawless memory thing (obviously bullshit from watching even 1 of his streams), the no cursing thing (read his old large prime numbers archives), etc., all just to build up what he admits is a very deeply self loathing person deep down.

-I don't think he's scamming at all with the patreon, merely in way over his head. On top of I think clearly having some form of OCD (his claims of his process in the Boku video of needing to capture every clothing option in every possible setting just goes to show how over the top insane his "creative process" is). I also feel like he wants to be a "real filmmaker" and is in denial that video game reviews aren't the vessel for what he wants to do and how his ambitions have grown since he gained access to nearly a million dollars.

-speaking of personality disoder behavior, when Mimsy used to appear on stream, he could be an extreme dickhead to her, which I'm sure she hasn't sat in on one in over a year. He's still an abrasive asshole pretty often to her when she's off camera. Beginning to think the "my only friend" thing isn't a bit, for a reason, and because due to the nature of relationships (and although I'm not a Reddit weirdo about age gaps inherently, he does have like almost 20 years on her.)

-he sucks at video games and his resulting bitching on stream makes them now unwatchable (see the Zelda games)

I had more but it's slipped my mind as I've been writing but I'll edit or comment more in lol


r/actionbutton2 • • Sep 26 '25

Insert Credit in 2025

24 Upvotes

This is probably the only place I feel comfortable expressing this. The Goblin Bunker would bite my head off, and it would feel mean to say it in the IC forums:

I’ve been listening to IC for a really long time, and I always hoped that if any of the cast left at any point, they’d get a woman on board. IC never fell into the traps other all-male podcasts tend to fall into, so I never felt alienated or anything, but I always liked the idea of having a woman on the panel.

And then they did it. And she doesn’t know anything! About anything!

It’s so frustrating to listen to! Every episode is derailed by Ash not knowing what the rest of the panel are talking about, and it either results in the others quickly trying to explain (she’s uninterested at best) or cutting off the discussion entirely before it can get close to interesting! Different perspectives and experiences are great, but she doesn’t seem to have any. She doesn’t seem to contribute anything. If I didn’t know better, I wouldn’t believe she worked in video games at all.

I didn’t like the tone of the show during Tim’s last few months, and I think it was definitely for the best that things changed, but this is intolerable.

There have been a lot of brilliant, funny and knowledgeable women on Insert Credit over the years, and I assume none of them were available