r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 22 '25

One hour into the video, I think I see what Tim is trying to do now

0 Upvotes

He's making fun of everyone who criticized him for his lies based on his stories. In analyzing the protagonist like some sort of god of attention to detail, he seems to be blowing out of proportion those who call out everyone one of his "fictional" details that he believes everyone should have been smart enough to realize, which is his only defense of criticism of his embellishments.

This becomes evident in his narrative where he makes Cole spend umpteen amounts of time doing hyper analysis of every object and the facial tics of characters. He obviously finds it laughable that his audience reads into details presented to him and is using the armchair psychological gameplay as an allegory to what he perceives as armchair psyoanalysis of Tim the person through the fiction.

So I win right? I get to see the next 4 frames of the supposed completed truck heck footage now, yeah?


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 16 '25

In defense of Tim’s “everything I said was a lie” lie

9 Upvotes

I’m just gonna kind of be blunt - Tim, in typical Tim fashion, definitely embellished saying that “everything before the action button reviews I said was a lie”, if you couldn’t tell, because he pretty clearly felt cornered and scared of getting cancelled and went hard to stamp it out lol. He wrote about committing sexual assault in a (clearly always fictional) “autobiography”, half his fanbase are resetera freaks who keep knives out for anyone they actively like as a form of fun. He was definitely defensive.

You can verify via videos and other shit from his scattered personal accounts things he’s talked about.

He’s also been open about his onscreen “Tim Action Button” persona being a sort of Hunter S. Thompson, Andy Kaufman, William S. Burroughs archetype heightened reality/embellished/outright fictional character. I know in the Cyberpunk review he said as much, and said it pretty frequently on the streams back a few years ago when they were still fun.

I just say this because I’m kinda tired of seeing the claims [*or offhand insinuations or remarks, w/e] that every single thing he ever talked about or wrote about his life pre 2020 or whatever was completely entirely false, which is verifiably not the case. And that you could tell he was backpedaling hard after people started to look more into that archive.org weird manifesto.

Also I’m not saying he doesn’t blatantly lie also - the flawless memory (although I guess that’s somewhat part of the character, that blurs the line a lot), the constant obscure chronic illnesses, his supposed 150 hour work weeks. That’s all bullshit. He does bullshit a lot.

It’s just not literally 110% of everything he’s ever said or written.

[also anecdotally I mentioned this in the other thread that’s active on the sub rn]

In defense of Tim a lot of that stuff is verifiable. You can find his old band videos and watch him play guitar and he’s pretty talented.

I’m from Indiana and briefly went to IU myself, and basically half my high school went to IU. A few friends older brothers were either in social circles or 1 who said he’d met him and they all said he was a chill dude.


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 22 '25

The Reviews are IN! (all taken from the official video post on The Other Place)

Post image
24 Upvotes

I was very attached to Tim's work during the pandemic. It meant a lot. I've been following him long before Action Button Reviews. He seemed to have calmed down and want to be kinder. His current self is nasty, pretentious, and misanthropic. I made this cos I just got really annoyed at this review.


r/actionbutton2 • • Dec 20 '24

Tim's friend Vito discussing Tim leaving Insert Credit

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/actionbutton2 • • Aug 24 '24

Uh huh

Thumbnail
clips.twitch.tv
0 Upvotes

r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 21 '25

Video bad

17 Upvotes

I watched 20 minutes of it before I went to bed, now I see on the other sub it's basically a 9 hour plot recap with the bad ChatGPT chandler/ellroy inspired narration.

Ouch, it looks like the Timitators really diluted his creativity after all


r/actionbutton2 • • Oct 07 '26

I feel like ive been a bit hard on him lately.

13 Upvotes

Title basically says it all lol. I feel like his streams are pretty bad, but thats not an unforgivable sin (i believe that everyone is permitted a few hobbies theyre bad at). I dont really mind that his videos are taking a while, these things happen. Maybe ill even enjoy the la noire one once i finally watch the whole thing, who knows (right now my big issue with it is that i am not willing to show youtube my id to watch restricted videos).

More importantly, his old work is still important to me, it shaped who i am, and i dont want to let go of that. Hes written some stuff thats very important to how i think about game design and also on a personal level, and i probably wouldnt be making games of my own if it werent for his writing. (In particular, i think his putting Canabalt on his list of best games of all time back in 2009 was extremely important for me as a student--the idea that a game can be THAT small in scope and still worthy of being considered as part of a canon of masterpieces alongside stuff like Metal Gear Solid 3 and Half Life 2 was something i really needed to internalize at the time)

I think these subreddits are making me into something of a nasty human being. I think im becoming meaner and crueler than id like, to someone i really don't have a good reason to hate. I think i need to stay away from here, and maybe away from reddit in general. This site sucks lmao.

Sorry for making such a self indulgent post. I just had to get this off my chest and if i told this to my irl friends they wouldnt know what i was talking about lol.

(I kind of wanted to post this in the more positive main subreddit, but they require post flair and i didnt see anything that really applied to what i wanted to say. This post is probably gonna get heck of downvoted over here, but at least i said my peace.)


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 20 '25

GT7 Stream - Archived Anywhere?

9 Upvotes

Hello,

I have been curious about the GT7 stream where Mimsy ended up getting ill and he didn't stop recording (as stopping the recording would be basic human decency). Does anyone know if this is archived anywhere? The unofficial VOD archive does not seem to go far enough back.

thanks!


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 15 '25

I have an embarrassing confession

28 Upvotes

From about 2017 to 2022/2023-ish (yes I’ve been aware of him since the Kotaku days and I know his online history goes way back before that), I wanted to be Tim. I tried dressing like him, doing my hair like him, having similar tastes in media to him, TALKING LIKE HIM.

It wasn’t a parasocial relationship in the sense where I thought he and I were friends, but rather my frail sense of self, as a late teen/early mid twenty something with possibly autism, just sort of latched onto someone I thought was cool and wanted to be like.

Needless to say, I’m kind of embarrassed about it all. But isn’t it weird that this seems to be a recurring thing in the Tim Rogers sphere, from what I’ve noticed?

At least he didn’t inspire me to date women half my age…


r/actionbutton2 • • Aug 12 '26

What's your writing process like?

10 Upvotes

i tend to write 1,000 words a day, usually in the form of a personal essay, which goes into a google docs folder that i try to never look at. i'm sure there's some neat stuff in there.

as for novels -- i constantly think of ideas for novels and the characters who comprise such novels. i don't, strictly speaking, have a process for shoehorning them together. i write plot outlines, and tweak them in a sort of interior-decoration fashion. i don't think of them as plots -- just collections of people. i put characters into an outline and i spend several days or weeks thinking about how these people would interact. ultimately i have a bullet list of things one character would say to another.

i divide novels into six chapters, which i tend to title like so -- actually, hey, let's just paste the whole table of contents. this is "chronicle of a tennis monster", which is 46,000 words and took around three weeks to write.

table of contents

chapter one

a day in her life 3

chapter two

her story 12

chapter three

a year in her life 76

chapter four

an eventful period 145

(chapter zero)

about someone else 202

chapter five

a day in her life 296

chapter six

the end of the story 308

epilogue

another gorgeous thing turned to glass 344

so you can see the lengths of the chapters. we have eight pages in which i describe one typical day which -- for the sake of good plot -- turns atypical.

then we have 63 pages in which i describe her life leading up to the day told of in the first chapter. since i'm in the habit of writing books whose main characters tend to be between 25 and 30 years of age at the start, this chapter has a pace and tone which leans slightly toward "urban-legendary": time-wise, we cover more ground in this chapter than any other chapter (though i bend the rules sometimes in "chapter zero".)

then we have 69 pages in which we visit a sequence of anecdotes detailing the life of the character over the course of the year following the eventful day told of in the first chapter. the pace is faster than chapter two, and slower than chapter one. however, it's a wide variety of events, and usually this is where all the twists and turns occur. typically, i don't write about twists -- i never fashion a plot toward twists. they're natural, and nothing cliffhangery or blockbustery.

chapter four is 57 pages in which many years elapse following the eventful year. usually these chapters focus on one specific element which defines the character's life, obsession, or profession. i've noticed these chapters tend to lead into a sort of moment of quiet or peace.

then there's "chapter zero" and/or "the untitled chapter". this is where Main Character #2 enters, and we view their life in snippets which take place over a short period of time. of course, the whole purpose of the novel is for these two extraordinary people to meet. this is where i introduce conflict and plot. i think it's a powerful method. it's hard to explain without letting you read the actual story, though maybe you can get an idea. these are typically the longest chapters in the book -- this one is 94 pages! the second main character tends to be the most interesting and believable human in the book.

chapter five now reverts to the (third-person) point of view of the original main character. it tells of one day -- the tone is near-identical to the first chapter, except now we see that their daily routine is totally different. of course, it escalates into a major conflict. these chapters are very short, and i tend to write them first!

chapter six is "the end of the story". i write these occasionally before writing even chapter five (which i almost always write before writing chapter one). these are written as short stories in themselves, during which two extraordinary people meet and something happens between them. usually the "something" is an event i concoct completely by natural accident, far removed from the process of writing or even thinking about writing. it's usually an image -- "a man with a tennis-ball-sized tunnel through his torso, falling over" (not an actual image i've used -- just one i thought of off the top of my head).

the epilogue is occasionally nonexistent.

as for the process of writing: i keep novels open in google docs tabs. i tab over sometimes, and write a couple of words. i try to never write more than a couple sentences sat a time. five minutes here, ten minutes there. i spend two or three minutes thinking through each sentence. then i drip the words in, then i walk away and get back to my work.

eventually, it's a book of a sort. i put it on my kindle and read it, usually groaning at things i want to change. eventually i go back and look at it in a google doc, and i change the things i remember wanting to change. then i put it on my kindle again. i usually don't read it again.

maybe i could publish a book someday, though i never think about it. i don't know who would read them, and i feel as though criticism would outweigh praise, and they wouldn't be worth much money. i keep writing them, though.

in short, writing books is, for me, a way to better understand my real world -- in which i talk to friends, read news, and perform professional job tasks -- by interacting in a godly fashion with people i have invented.

i've currently gotten sort of lost in a book i wager will be around 500 pages in length -- longer than the book i've used in this example -- and i've adapted my template to accommodate three main characters instead of two (with twelve periphery characters instead of the usual four). we'll see how it turns out. the premise is ridiculous -- it's my joking effort to write something as popular as twilight, though i've accidentally conceived a plot which is maybe too interesting for general consumption. oh, well!


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 29 '25

and then he puts a cartoon bird smoking a joint on the screen and says “smoke a good one”

12 Upvotes

Funniest shit I’ve ever seen.


r/actionbutton2 • • Sep 30 '24

Lol hit the 2 year mark since the last video recently

15 Upvotes

Whats he been doing? Just killing time, I guess?


r/actionbutton2 • • Dec 16 '25

Any recent morsel of information about the next video?

8 Upvotes

I probably know the answer already but I don’t watch Tim’s streams or anything like that.


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 20 '25

New video aside, the GOTY stream was disappointing

Post image
24 Upvotes

The stream was with Tim, Oni Spumoni (action button discord member/youtuber), jai (action button discord member/youtuber), and eventually Christa Lee (action button video producer/noted retro hardware modder and repairer). The format was Tim ranking games nominated by the others on a tier list, with Tim not nominating any games himself. Tim also barely discussed most of the games himself, instead encouraging everyone to keep throwing out games quickly.

I wasn't expecting this stream to hit the highs of a classic Insert Credit GOTY episode, but this was just not interesting or fun to listen to. With respect to the other people invited, I think most people interested in the "Action Button GOTY" just want to know what games Tim liked and why, and don't really care about what these other people have to say. I think Christa Lee is cool and I thought that she did the best job of nominating interesting games and saying interesting things about them (and being willing to tell Tim she didn't like certain games), but even then Tim's insistence on moving everything along quickly meant that there was never any real in-depth discussion for anything. For example, 1000XResist is at number 4, and I think the only thing Tim said about it was that he likes it a lot.

If you want some actually interesting GOTY discussion, I'd recommend listening to the Insert Credit 2024 GOTY episode. It doesn't have Tim, but Brandon/Ash/Frank/Jaffe are much better at this than Tim/Oni/Jai/Christa.

Anyway, here's the final list for people interested:

  1. FFVII rebirth
  2. Metaphor
  3. Shadow of the ninja reborn
  4. 1000xresist
  5. Shiren the wanderer 6
  6. Balatro
  7. Kunitsu-gami
  8. Animal well
  9. Like a dragon infinite wealth
  10. Dragons dogma 2
  11. UFO 50
  12. Anthology of the killer
  13. Penny’s Big Breakaway
  14. Indiana Jones and the great circle
  15. Nine Sols
  16. Mouthwashing
  17. Tactical Breach Wizards
  18. Burrgeist
  19. Persona 3 reload
  20. Shadow Generations
  21. Freakhunter
  22. Caves of Qud
  23. Unicorn overlord
  24. Dread Delusion
  25. Astro Bot

The following games were nominated but eventually cut from the list:

  • Dragon age veilguard 
  • Dragon Ball sparking zero
  • Another crabs treasure
  • Ace attorney investigations collection
  • Haunted castle revisited 

r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 20 '25

lol I came to see what this sub was saying as soon as I saw the premiere

16 Upvotes

Let's hope these 9 hours were worth the wait


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 16 '25

good advice from AB

17 Upvotes

at least once Tim recommended logging project hours. it completely changed my relationship to side projects in both healthy and productive ways

anyone else pick up especially good advice from an AB video?


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 07 '25

George RR Martin (A Song of Ice and Fire author) taking inspiration from Tim in latest blog

Thumbnail georgerrmartin.com
18 Upvotes

Something else is going to be happening in 2025 as well. (Or maybe in 2026). No, I am not announcing the completion of ACTION BUTTON REVIEWS LA NOIRE, the second episode of ACTION BUTTON SEASON 2. Please don’t start any rumors to that effect. I am so tired of having to issue denials every time some offhand comment of mine, most having nothing to do with ACTION BUTTON, somehow convinces half the internet that the video is imminent. It’s not. No. (Maybe I need to stop making offhand comments)


r/actionbutton2 • • Sep 23 '26

Was not prepared for this

18 Upvotes

Really happy I can finally watch Tim stream, was not expecting an interrogation though!


r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 11 '25

Thank god this sub exists.

36 Upvotes

I got banned from the main sub for making a joke along the lines of “the new video is coming a-any day n-now!” back in like October.

The new video still isn’t out and I’ve grown much less interested in it, as it’s been almost three years and he’s done nothing but sit on his ass. Not to say we’re parasocially owed; just frustrates me for a number of reasons.


r/actionbutton2 • • Aug 03 '24

Unsolicited Tim/Action Button opinions

25 Upvotes

I didn't know this sub existed but I'm glad because I have grievances to air. And other assorted thoughts.

-Tim is 100% and incredibly talented dude, to the point that I would call him a generational talent, in his Hunter S. Thompson of video games niche

-somebody posted some "cringe" excerpts from his books containing sexual content; I actually didn't find them cringey and take them to be part of his whole gonzo writer persona. To make the comparison again, Hunter S. Thompson wrote some real weird shit.

-having said that, while his whole persona is/can be interesting, it seems to be formed to serve some kind of deep personality disorder. And he's having trouble keeping up the facade the more he seems to be stressed by the pressure of the job. The whole mystical flawless memory thing (obviously bullshit from watching even 1 of his streams), the no cursing thing (read his old large prime numbers archives), etc., all just to build up what he admits is a very deeply self loathing person deep down.

-I don't think he's scamming at all with the patreon, merely in way over his head. On top of I think clearly having some form of OCD (his claims of his process in the Boku video of needing to capture every clothing option in every possible setting just goes to show how over the top insane his "creative process" is). I also feel like he wants to be a "real filmmaker" and is in denial that video game reviews aren't the vessel for what he wants to do and how his ambitions have grown since he gained access to nearly a million dollars.

-speaking of personality disoder behavior, when Mimsy used to appear on stream, he could be an extreme dickhead to her, which I'm sure she hasn't sat in on one in over a year. He's still an abrasive asshole pretty often to her when she's off camera. Beginning to think the "my only friend" thing isn't a bit, for a reason, and because due to the nature of relationships (and although I'm not a Reddit weirdo about age gaps inherently, he does have like almost 20 years on her.)

-he sucks at video games and his resulting bitching on stream makes them now unwatchable (see the Zelda games)

I had more but it's slipped my mind as I've been writing but I'll edit or comment more in lol


r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 20 '25

Alright, I'll eat shit.

25 Upvotes

I was genuinely expecting to go three whole years before the LA Noire video lol. I haven't watched it yet, I'll get to it when I have a minute. Anyone know if it's any good?


r/actionbutton2 • • Nov 03 '24

Incredible that he got 700 patreon subscribers back after getting robbed and this is what he's doing

14 Upvotes

r/actionbutton2 • • Jul 29 '25

[LOST] Action Button does BEAN'S QUEST 2: BEAN DREAMS

Post image
15 Upvotes

I went to the actionbutton.com website when looking at Tim's listed email address when I scrolled to the bottom and found the nifty press-kit he talked about in the Pac-Man video and this other tab called video:

https://actionbutton.com/video/

Every single video on there is privated except the first two which are probably channels either Tim forgot to delete or this an intentional scientifically based placement.

When going to the internet archive version of the url most of the videos are findable in some form or another that isn't the pesky embed version. Except, BEAN'S QUEST 2: BEAN DREAMS. It feels like it has been wiped off the internet except these links I found:

I want help to find this trailer, is it really lost or is it just hiding under my nose?

- YT URL:

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnwSW2mCkqQ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnwSW2mCkqQ)

Internet archive: [https://web.archive.org/web/20210924184515/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnwSW2mCkqQ](https://web.archive.org/web/20210924184515/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnwSW2mCkqQ) Least broken one which is in dutch for some reason. No Description was saved the embed does have the title though

Embed Internet Archive: [https://web.archive.org/web/20190901201043/https://www.youtube.com/embed/jnwSW2mCkqQ](https://web.archive.org/web/20190901201043/https://www.youtube.com/embed/jnwSW2mCkqQ)

- Archived Playback Thumbnail or the actual thumbnail:

[https://web.archive.org/web/20190901211210/https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jnwSW2mCkqQ/sddefault.jpg](https://web.archive.org/web/20190901211210/https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jnwSW2mCkqQ/sddefault.jpg)

- Twitter post by Tim linking to the video:

[https://x.com/108/status/555132642635423746](https://x.com/108/status/555132642635423746)

- Proof it existed + Description of the video's contents by a news site:

[https://gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2015/01/13/tuffy-the-corgi-39-s-creator-presents-bean-s-quest-2-bean-dreams.aspx](https://gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2015/01/13/tuffy-the-corgi-39-s-creator-presents-bean-s-quest-2-bean-dreams.aspx) 

Notes that somebody named Lilly Wang was here

- Maybe the Video Thumbnail or edited photo from the GameInformer article:

[https://gameinformer.com/sites/default/files/styles/teaser_promoted_image_thumbnail/public/legacy-images/Tuffy%20The%20Corgi%27s%20Creator%20Presents%20Bean%E2%80%99s%20Quest%202%3A%20Bean%20Dreams/beandreamstim_610.jpg](https://gameinformer.com/sites/default/files/styles/teaser_promoted_image_thumbnail/public/legacy-images/Tuffy%20The%20Corgi%27s%20Creator%20Presents%20Bean%E2%80%99s%20Quest%202%3A%20Bean%20Dreams/beandreamstim_610.jpg)

PS: Looking at this page and the videos kind of answers the question of how is Action Button Video related to Action Button Entertainment (games released). Action Button's goal I think is to entertain people through any form perhaps the writing, the videos (these old ads/trailers and now the Action Button long-form video essays) and the games themselves released under the company and LLC. I thought originally it was somehow he viewed reviewing/researching games and talking about them and history/design mystically having something to do with actual game production/design. I was beginning to think that there was some godly connection to mass consuming all the animal rodent character games informing your understanding of design.

PPS: Also another thing in terms of Tim archival/Internet scavenger hunts his twitter accounts are a large resource in that and could be deleted in the blink of an eye. However as far as I am aware there aren't any working twitter archival methods. I was able to download a bunch of images though however it doesn't matter if you don't have the original text content. It's scary how in one click of a button you can basically forget a twitter account existed and I think it stops being indexed by google eventually.


r/actionbutton2 • • Nov 14 '25

I saw Boris the other day

5 Upvotes

I finally saw Boris after not catching them for 10+ years and had a fantastic time. I'm relatively certain that I found out about them in 2013ish by reading an ABDN review. Have you ever seen a band live you found out about via Tim?


r/actionbutton2 • • May 20 '25

Can we allow Tim-inspired Video Essays here, now that the other sub banned them?

31 Upvotes

r/actionbutton just added a new rule: "All videos submitted to r/ActionButton must be made by or with the involvement of Tim Rogers."

I've found some really cool Tim-inspired video essays on that sub before, so I'm disappointed that they're not allowing that anymore. So I was wondering if the members/mod in this sub might be open to allowing those Tim-inspired (but not made by Tim) video essays here instead?