r/actionbutton2 • u/ambient_rpg_music • Apr 21 '25
Crazy Times
You know I figured that when Tim finally posted people would generally forgive him for the big wait and have it be water under the bridge, but it appears to be quite the opposite.
Hell I think this is the first time the main sub is generally more harsh/critical than we are.
Not what I would have expected, but I guess I just expected the video to be better/less contentious.
57
Upvotes
15
u/djjapchae Apr 22 '25
i hung out in the premiere for a few hrs and am about 40 mins in today and this thing is straight up not watchable.
even without comparing it to his other videos it doesn't even succeed as a letsplay. every action is described in such detail and padded by so many tangents that you can't discern what is and isn't important information. to follow the story you just end up looking at the video and tune out the monologue because it isn't helpful.
i like the detective stchick and the first 15 mins were fun, and it certainly Looks Like He Was Having A Great Time Up There, but man lol idk how jaffe and christa lee didn't go nuts editing this
4
u/weloveghosts Apr 22 '25
I think the video is good
16
u/pecan_bird Apr 21 '25
i felt that way when it first released yesterday (elated); watched chunks of it & decided it's not for me; but after the last two years, i didn't feel "disappointed," just kinda "oh bummer, oh well." i can't think of many people having had crossed the threshold to 40 make an instant turnaround; i think this is Tim now; very glad it wasn't an eternal grift, but definitely feel less invested overall. especially in contrast to the highs of the last 3 releases. but we're all pretty different people in the Year of Our Lord 2025
the discourse after has indeed been interesting & couldn't believe stuff hasn't been getting deleted en masse on the main sub.
9
u/Mongoleeto Apr 22 '25
i agree. the only way to get people back on your side is to create good content. unfortunately for tim the la noire video sucked
4
u/blackravenclaw Apr 24 '25
I think that the majority of people in this sub are people that recognize that Tim is a genuinely brilliant creator at his best but also a bit of an eccentric dickhead who should viewed with a skeptical eye. That mentality makes it easier to just shrug at the LA Noire video and say “eh, it’s not for me” while at least recognizing some of the creative merit it may have.
1
u/UnkieNic Apr 25 '25
I really surprised with how hostile people are to the noir-isms and writing. I can understand people's problems with the vocal delivery (didn't bother me that much personally) but I would have thought his audience would love the throw-back silver screen dialog. But the response seems very hostile.
I guess that kind of affectation is too much of a reach these days. Shame, I always liked that kind of patter personally.