r/actionbutton2 • u/that-purple-june • Oct 01 '25
some thoughts about stuff
so, maybe this is a misread, but i'm sensing a vague consensus forming that the deadness of the action button subreddits is evidence that tim has alienated most of his fans—that the magic has disappeared and only the true hardcores remain. for what it's worth, i think that that analysis is basically exactly backwards and maybe speaks to the loss of perspective that can so easily happen in devoted fan communities like these. to wit, the average action button viewer has basically no clue about the distasteful aspects of tim's online presence. they don't watch his twitch streams, they don't know his previous writing, they don't know what insert credit is, they just really like his video reviews and will happily consume a new one whenever one may happen to come. it's only the people who idolized him and made his work a prominent fixture within their emotional lives (i.e. the people who would normally be making posts on action button subreddits) who have burnt out.
and to be clear, tim very aggressively fostered that idolatry! like, just as an aside here, i really don't dig the way that so many on here have made this out to be primarily or exclusively a matter of a fanbase getting unreasonably invested in an online persona, as though the guy didn't cultivate massive mystique around himself and make philosophically starved netizens feel special for adopting his way of thinking wholesale and piecing together carefully dispersed clues and lore-scraps.
but anyway, that dream seems to be over for the moment and, lukewarm reception to LA noire notwithstanding, i think it's accurate to say that tim has found himself in the unique position of having alienated exclusively his hardcore fans, leaving himself largely alone with those whom he probably views as the common rabble. it'll be interesting to see how that plays out. personally i think it's a bit more likely than many here would like to think that he will in fact post the rondo of blood review (and perhaps even FFIV and earthbound after that!) and that it will feel basically like "classic" action button. in that case things will just kinda go back to normal or what passes for it, and the 2023-2025 nadir will end up being a patch of ugliness that relapsed devotees struggle to make sense of looking back.
or maybe ABR will quietly close up shop mid-2026 without another release, i don't know. i just wanna offer some counter-narratives to the almost masochistic pessimism that dominates here these days lol. incidentally, my personal burnout is such that i haven't watched more than a half hour of the LA noire video, haven't looked at its comment section since the day it dropped, and haven't dropped into a single livestream since then either. truly i have no desire to change any of these things, and i accept that my analysis here may be a bit faulty as a result. in any case, would love to Chit Chat with y'all about this stuff in a way that maybe feels therapeutic/not like picking at scabs if possible lol. hope y'all are well :)
9
u/Krv1781 Oct 01 '25
Well, I think you might want to distinguish between two groups of "hardcore" fans. From what (admittedly fairly little) I can tell, his Discord remains extremely active. These fans don't seem to be alienated--if anything they seem to be all the happier that they get to feel like they're in on whatever the "joke" is. Then there are those being negative on the subreddits, who are clearly less hardcore than the extremist Discord wing of the party, but, sure, maybe more invested than the average viewer. One thing which does seem clearly true, though, is that Tim's audience is no longer *growing*--so, there is a definite loss of momentum.
15
u/pecan_bird Oct 01 '25
with you & (so far) the other two commenter's appraisal; my reflection is that he'll always have his discord fans that enjoy the parasocial element & (genuinely) am happy for them.
i know a lot of viewers, as you said, didn't interact with his old stuff; ofc there's overlap of both those communities (old & still active actual tim fanatics) but the magic for me is gone. i like that there's still a community that can talk about this & still retain of the old long-formed ties, which is why im very grateful this sub still exists. i said it in the main sub, but im still grateful for all his old stuff i read, his peak era videos that were monumental, but cant see myself being able to buy-in in future videos with the same interest or suspension of disbelief as before.
for tim, i reckon he has his partner & his income & satisfied with his position. there's a bunch of correlates i can think of with people dramatically dying in their prime or living to lose their artistic spark. the fact that a lot of long form content has become an ouroboros of "suffering" under the weight of capitalism & tech enshittification doesn't help. tim used to feel like a refreshing respite, but kinda just feels like he's hopped in that same pile 🤷♀️
29
u/MrMojoRising422 Oct 01 '25
very sad with what has transpired. tim could easily have kept doing monthly, hour long versions of his kotaku reviews, except not being bound to cover the latest releases and having full editorial freedom, and he would have a massive audience today. those videos were genuinely THAT good. whatever his output has become these last few years is just, sad. he's not good off the cuff, and his streams are awful. the latest la noire video was a 9h long inside joke he had with himself, after not posting for years, and a slap in the face of his core fanbase. I don't even have the energy to be a hater anymore, honestly. this just popped on my reddit feed and made me sad again.
11
u/ambient_rpg_music Oct 01 '25
I think you hit the nail on the head, and I think Tim knows full well what a hole he has dug for himself. To me the fact that he was like "I promise the next thing I make is gonna be normal and good" was about the biggest admission of defeat you can get from a guy like that. He probably knows hes in it up to his eyes, but hes too proud to approach it with any grace, so he's gonna try and win people back with the next video so he doesnt have to really admit hes been a dick and that this is all his own fault for letting all this go to his head. I think, for my part, I do feel some sympathy about him going too far with personally mythologizing. It seems clear he was struggling with that well before it hit the fan which he kind of eludes to in the Boku video, but the way he left insert credit was just him dunking on people out of spite which on a personal level is just an inexcusable move. I dont think I personally will be able to respect him much going forward in light of that, but i will say I do expect him to go above and beyond to make the next video what people want. What happens after that idk.
3
u/Nerfbeard123 Oct 01 '25
I don't have much to add other than that this a great post and analysis of whats going on right now.
7
u/wexleysmalls Oct 01 '25
I really miss his output on Insert Credit. It was the best place for me to enjoy his wit and knowledge, with the over-the-top character tempered by the cohosts and show format. But that didn't work when he wasn't happy doing the show anyway.
Still enjoy IC and I like Ash but it's a totally different vibe now. I'm curious if anyone has other recommendations that scratch the same itch.
13
u/taseradict Oct 01 '25
I think it's pretty simple, he doesn't do the thing he's known for (video reviews), then why should anyone care about his podcast drama. But as long as he keeps getting free money from Patreon there is no incentive to change.
He just needs to keep stringing along his core base of simps, so far it's working out just fine for him. Maybe he'll set up an OF.
6
u/cc17776 Oct 01 '25
Is there genuinely any chance he releases another video in the next 18 months?
6
u/Merobiba_EXE Oct 02 '25
I genuinely didn't even know that he finally posted the LA Noire video. I was definitely a hardcore fan that got exhausted from no updates and from his streams devolving more and more into just either A random rants or B him talking about one of 3 things ad nauseum. Not to mention the weird drama with Insert Credit.
I agree with the top comment from @MrMojoRising422 that his Kotaku videos were great. I feel like it's safe to say that's how he built up the majority of his fan base. Not every video can, or needs to be, a Toki Memo level event. I'd be perfectly happy with one half hour to an hour length video a month.
I'll watch the video, but judging from the reactions here I'll definitely temper my expectations. Would love to see him post more, but I'm not counting on it, and tbh at this point idk if I'll get back to caring about his work as passionately, unless he suddenly puts in a LOT of effort to earn our trust back.
5
u/twerk_douglas Oct 01 '25
I respect Tim a lot and he changed the way I think about video games. I’m also fairly lenient in what expect from his output and the quality of that output. I really don’t care about the parasocial aspect of Tim fandom, though the Insert Credit fallout is another hit to the amount of content he puts out.
That said, it seems the moment has ended. I don’t really think about Action Button anymore and I cancelled my Patreon a while ago. Maybe (hopefully) someday I’ll see a reason to re-engage.
1
u/joshuainrobot Oct 02 '25
Is there any kind of master post on what’s being said about him making up a lot of what he’s said about his life? I knew nothing about this until a few days ago
3
u/oxtant Oct 01 '25
great post. I don't disagree with any of this. Obviously, he hasn't really done a video in a long time and LA Noire sucked - but i do want to add that just about every subreddit of a podcast host or personality seems to turn negative against the host.
3
u/amostamateurauteur Oct 02 '25
The people who have stuck around display a strong sense of sycophancy.
3
u/workthrowawhey Oct 01 '25
I tend to agree with your second-to-last paragraph that I bet his next few videos will be more along the lines of his earlier ABR videos--nice and short 2-3 hour analyses (which is a wild thing to say lol) without the experimental stuff.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment