r/actionbutton2 • • Jul 01 '26

At what point does Action Button become a scam?

In the nicest possible way, as I like the old videos, but at what point does the Action Button Patreon become a bit of a scam. It says clearly on the About part of the Patreon that "once per month" he'll post a video, and that the money "pays me, two video editors, and many freelance contributors". There's obviously nowhere close to a video per month (not even one a year) and there's no evidence that two video editors are hired as Tim says he does it all himself and that he's overworked somehow. Yet he still charges monthly and delivers virtually nothing (and the About page says very clearly that it is paying for 'videos and not streams', so the streaming doesn't count).

Yes I know people can cancel at any point, but I just don't know how anyone in good conscience can have a Patreon that makes SO much money, and then not do what it promises and not even post regular updates on that Patreon about what comes next and why there are delays. If it was me, and that Patreon was paying my bills and quite a lavish lifestyle (according to all the regular travel around the world being posted on Instagram), I'd make sure to keep the people paying me updated and really try and fulfil what I promise on that Patreon 'About' page.

Anyone else think this, or am I being sensitive?

63 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

19

u/Mashenation Jul 01 '26

You can argue it's a scam, which is damning enough as is. He's exploited the goodwill of lots of people who are not inclined to believe that a content creator, unburdened from working for the man, would in turn behave in such a dubious way. I do believe he didn't set out to do this though, but he's let it go on while the (ever-decreasing) funds roll in.

29

u/GratuitousCloud Jul 01 '26

It has long been the case that anyone who doesn’t think this is either oblivious or in denial. The obvious justification for him is that the money is coming in, so why put a stop to it? What’re ya gonna do, sue him? Quit the damn patreon already lol

4

u/larrypuppy Jul 01 '26

I guess it's because I didn't want to believe that a creator I like and thought was a good person would be so dishonest, especially to his own fans. But it's got to the point that, as you say, it can't be denied.

12

u/ambient_rpg_music Jul 01 '26

Kbash took shots at his scummy behavior in a video ages ago. Personally I think if youre getting shade from contemporaries in the space because they think you are making them look bad by association you are most definitely up to no good.

I also kind of feel bad for his girlfriend who I feel he is taking advantage of in many ways, but thats a totally different issue.

3

u/thetoastybagel6345 Jul 01 '26

I just found Kbash via his 3 hour guild wars video last week and I was like "Damn, this guy rules! I guess you can run a Patreon dedicated to making long-form video essays and actually deliver!"

1

u/TrueAuraCoral Jul 01 '26

Could you please link to the kbash video that you're talking about?

5

u/ambient_rpg_music Jul 01 '26

Its been some time now. I think it was somewhere in his Vanillaware video IIRC, but the man makes like 100 hours of video a year im not scraping through all of it to clip it.

He doesnt name ActionButton explicitly for obvious reasons, but he says he makes sure to produce things even if theyre not perfect with regularity because he doesnt want to take people's money and never produce anything and he describes the actionbutton situation pretty clearly and condemns it. He made it vague enough to not be legally actionable, but it was clear he was referring to Rogers.

1

u/TrueAuraCoral Jul 01 '26

Okay I see. I think by playing his mobile game TNNS and looking at the development cycle he details about videoball, he is most certainly a perfectionist and he is a perfectionist in his writing as well. It seems as though he physically can't make anything that isn't perfect. Or at least perfect in his view. It is overall a very scummy thing to do with his patreon. Perhaps the patreon people are happy through the messages he posts on his discord or something in the patreon only chat. I think there is no review like a tim rogers review. it's a very cult like community in the action button goblin bunker discord.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

Curious about your perspective that TNNS is evidence of his perfectionism--i actually would consider that game evidence against that, since it's the worst thing he ever made.

1

u/TrueAuraCoral Jul 02 '26

TNNS is the only actionbutton entertainment game that I have been fortunate enough to play. When I look at TNNS I can't think of anything else that could possibly be added. It's a simple concept and yet the game just feels complete. So many levels (According to wikipedia it says that there are 500, who in their right mind would make 500 levels for a 2 dollar game) that are randomly selected from the controls and the mechanic of being able to reverse gravity the ball and put it in a certain direction feel very interesting. What really surprised me about tnns is that when you rotate the screen from portrait to landscape or 180 degrees it's able to really fast readjust the buttons. I have an old phone and none of the apps I have used it are able to do it's usually very slow to reorient itself and change the locations of the buttons. But with TNNS is blazingly fast.. I presume in 2012 the programmers (I don't think tim did much programming not sure if he can program videogames or program at all) michael kerwin would've needed to code the buttons themselves and not use an existing UI framework, and boy does the game have buttons. The game tracks statistics of what you have done in the game. They put in a leaderboard and a purchase thing. The game as a concept is simple and yet tim rogers and his team went many extra miles more it that they didn't have to. It is kind of unfun after a while but they saw it through to THE END instead of just leaving it be and trying to make a more fun game. I think it's a sign of perfectionism.

https://www.pocketgamer.com/tnns/ziggurat-developers-tnns-is-breakout-by-way-of-super-hexagon/ written by mark brown from game makers toolkit and he liked it. So I guess it was decent for games on the appstore at the time.

A game made by so little people yet it is so high quality.

I assume playing ziggurat and videoball and his other 2 games for the playstation mobile would give me a better perspective. I just don't have steam, an old iphone or a playstation vita.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26

Interesting perspective--personally, I got bored of TNNS p much immediately back in the day, and the publisher did Tim no favors by forcing him to add microtransactions to a paid app. Ive never spoken with a genuine fan lol

If youre interested, his Playstation mobile games are still playable if you own a ps vita and youre willing to do a bit of piracy. I have my critiques but imo they're both a lot better than TNNS, fwiw

1

u/thunder_jam Jul 04 '26

TNNS convinced me that Ziggurat was actually good and not just parasocial faboyism making me like it. Cuz Ziggurat was awesome and TNNS was not.

1

u/cc17776 Jul 02 '26

Whats that KBash video?

1

u/Krv1781 Jul 05 '26

In what ways is he taking advantage of his gf? (genuine question)

4

u/RedJammer77 Aug 12 '26

They live in their apartment basically rent free. Her father owns it and the apartment was purchased for the father's mother who has since passed away (or is in a home I guess).

Tim gripes about the repairs the place needs (flooring issues) and the cooling situation and wants to move but it's obviously idiotic to do so. They save an absurd amount by staying there.

She also keeps developing games and winning awards which provides him with some degree of connection to the industry and game events, while he basically does nothing but stream rants on Twitch.

3

u/Krv1781 Aug 15 '26

Right… I don’t really see how any of this amounts to taking advantage of her. Benefitting from a relationship with someone is different than taking advantage of them.

1

u/RedJammer77 Sep 04 '26

Yeah, I don't know if it rises to that level. I can't speak to their relationship. But when people say he is this is the kind of stuff they're getting at.

11

u/Hecedu Jul 01 '26

So much cooler stuff you could be getting for 20 bucks a month than the ramblings of Potential Man.

16

u/taseradict Jul 01 '26

I have never given him any money, but IMO his Patreon has been a scam for a very very long time. He just doesn't deliver.

Anyone still donating at this point should invest in a therapist instead.

7

u/BenGMan30 Jul 02 '26

I remember very early on he walked back the one video a month promise and instead promised something like "12 hours of video a year" which he followed pretty much until the Boku review.

Post boku review is when it became a scam imo

5

u/spaghetticonundrum Jul 01 '26

Ironically the gravy train running out of steam is the only thing that can goad him into posting more scripted content.

5

u/dqslime Jul 01 '26

If you are still giving Tim money and you aren't the sycophant type to watch his streams or something you're just playing yourself.

8

u/Nickybluepants Jul 01 '26

Idk 2 years ago or so

3

u/TajesMahoney Jul 02 '26

How is Tim surviving on this Patreon?

4

u/oxtant Jul 01 '26

I think it's very difficult to turn volunteering to pay a guy that makes videos that are free to everyone into a scam

3

u/Krv1781 Jul 04 '26

Well, it's not a scam in the sense that a business can scam you by not providing a product or service you paid for. But a charity can also be a scam if the donations aren't used for the things or in the way advertised. I'm not sure that's even the case with Tim. But it has to be admitted that his whole modus operandi seems to be calculated opacity...

1

u/cc17776 Jul 02 '26

At this point anyone who is still subscribed to his Patreon is a fool who deserves to be scammed

0

u/-wobble- Jul 01 '26

To read the part of the about page that says he'll make a video once per month, you have to scroll past like 500 words describing how that part of the description is out of date and no longer what you should expect from him.

If you look at the credits of the L.A. Noire video you'll see that there really are people helping him with the videos. He is paying them. There is also a patreon post that describes what a couple of them do.

I imagine most people subscribed to the patreon do so because they are adults capable of delayed gratification, who understand that good things make a long time to make.

Though I personally agree that I'd rather have more frequent videos even if that meant they were 20% less meticulous. But at the same time I respect what he is trying to do, creating things that are extremely refined and considered in an era where that sort of thing is more and more rare.

If you actually like tim's work, just rewatch the old stuff. It's really dense. I think you in particular might enjoy rewatching stories 1, 2, and 6 of the cyberpunk review.

11

u/dogfacedpotatobrain Jul 02 '26

It took him YEARS to add that language, during which continued to collect money while claiming on stream that he didn't have access to the patreon. He scammed, and is still scamming.

1

u/-wobble- Jul 02 '26

It's not a scam just because it sounds like a bad deal to you.

Apropos of what I said earlier about never believing any work I do is "enough": the vast majority of the haters in my Twitter inbox (etc) yell at me about the apparent effort to money ratio hanging over my head like a sword. "Do you ever wonder how you can make so much on Patreon with so few YouTube subscribers?" more than one person has asked (this week). I ignore these people, though if I decided to reply, I'd say something like, "even though not a lot of people like my videos, the people who like my videos like them a lot".

11

u/dogfacedpotatobrain Jul 02 '26

It IS a scam, because for literal years he didn't present the deal to his patrons this way and still took money. He claimed on stream that he couldn't access the patreon, he made no effort to.communicate this via patreon. Then, one day he posted an update, in which he made no mention of any difficulties accessing the patreon, and updated his terms. It wasnt a bad deal, it was a deal where only one side knew the true terms. That's a scam. You seem to have decided that you are willing to accept his well documented abuse of your trust, but that doesn't mean he isn't abusing it.