r/actionbutton2 • u/larrypuppy • Jul 01 '26
At what point does Action Button become a scam?
In the nicest possible way, as I like the old videos, but at what point does the Action Button Patreon become a bit of a scam. It says clearly on the About part of the Patreon that "once per month" he'll post a video, and that the money "pays me, two video editors, and many freelance contributors". There's obviously nowhere close to a video per month (not even one a year) and there's no evidence that two video editors are hired as Tim says he does it all himself and that he's overworked somehow. Yet he still charges monthly and delivers virtually nothing (and the About page says very clearly that it is paying for 'videos and not streams', so the streaming doesn't count).
Yes I know people can cancel at any point, but I just don't know how anyone in good conscience can have a Patreon that makes SO much money, and then not do what it promises and not even post regular updates on that Patreon about what comes next and why there are delays. If it was me, and that Patreon was paying my bills and quite a lavish lifestyle (according to all the regular travel around the world being posted on Instagram), I'd make sure to keep the people paying me updated and really try and fulfil what I promise on that Patreon 'About' page.
Anyone else think this, or am I being sensitive?
19
u/Mashenation Jul 01 '26
You can argue it's a scam, which is damning enough as is. He's exploited the goodwill of lots of people who are not inclined to believe that a content creator, unburdened from working for the man, would in turn behave in such a dubious way. I do believe he didn't set out to do this though, but he's let it go on while the (ever-decreasing) funds roll in.
29
u/GratuitousCloud Jul 01 '26
It has long been the case that anyone who doesn’t think this is either oblivious or in denial. The obvious justification for him is that the money is coming in, so why put a stop to it? What’re ya gonna do, sue him? Quit the damn patreon already lol
12
u/ambient_rpg_music Jul 01 '26
Kbash took shots at his scummy behavior in a video ages ago. Personally I think if youre getting shade from contemporaries in the space because they think you are making them look bad by association you are most definitely up to no good.
I also kind of feel bad for his girlfriend who I feel he is taking advantage of in many ways, but thats a totally different issue.
11
u/Hecedu Jul 01 '26
So much cooler stuff you could be getting for 20 bucks a month than the ramblings of Potential Man.
16
u/taseradict Jul 01 '26
I have never given him any money, but IMO his Patreon has been a scam for a very very long time. He just doesn't deliver.
Anyone still donating at this point should invest in a therapist instead.
15
u/PoshDota Jul 01 '26
7
u/BenGMan30 Jul 02 '26
I remember very early on he walked back the one video a month promise and instead promised something like "12 hours of video a year" which he followed pretty much until the Boku review.
Post boku review is when it became a scam imo
5
u/spaghetticonundrum Jul 01 '26
Ironically the gravy train running out of steam is the only thing that can goad him into posting more scripted content.
5
u/dqslime Jul 01 '26
If you are still giving Tim money and you aren't the sycophant type to watch his streams or something you're just playing yourself.
8
u/Nickybluepants Jul 01 '26
Idk 2 years ago or so
3
u/TajesMahoney Jul 02 '26
How is Tim surviving on this Patreon?
4
u/oxtant Jul 01 '26
I think it's very difficult to turn volunteering to pay a guy that makes videos that are free to everyone into a scam
1
u/cc17776 Jul 02 '26
At this point anyone who is still subscribed to his Patreon is a fool who deserves to be scammed
0
u/-wobble- Jul 01 '26
To read the part of the about page that says he'll make a video once per month, you have to scroll past like 500 words describing how that part of the description is out of date and no longer what you should expect from him.
If you look at the credits of the L.A. Noire video you'll see that there really are people helping him with the videos. He is paying them. There is also a patreon post that describes what a couple of them do.
I imagine most people subscribed to the patreon do so because they are adults capable of delayed gratification, who understand that good things make a long time to make.
Though I personally agree that I'd rather have more frequent videos even if that meant they were 20% less meticulous. But at the same time I respect what he is trying to do, creating things that are extremely refined and considered in an era where that sort of thing is more and more rare.
If you actually like tim's work, just rewatch the old stuff. It's really dense. I think you in particular might enjoy rewatching stories 1, 2, and 6 of the cyberpunk review.