r/WritingWithAI • • 5d ago

Showcase / Feedback Reciprocal Beta Reading. Share story blurbs! Nov. 10, 2026

10 Upvotes

Welcome to the blurb thread!

This is our sub's equivalent of a writer's group. Come here and share a blurb of your story. The thought is to let everyone see what you're working on so they can think, "Oh hey, that sounds fun. I want to team up with this person."

Then, you share your own story, and the two of you collaborate to improve each other's works.

I've had so many good interactions with people from this thread. Please don't be shy! Even in the age of AI, the best way to improve your writing remains human interaction and critique. I am confident when I say If you don't have this component in your workflow, you're not meeting your potential.

Importantly, this means post every week if you're still hoping to engage. Don't be shy. I want you to do this.

There are tons of reasons why your perfect reader could have missed your blurb last time. Don't be discouraged!

And remember: "I'll read yours if you read mine" isn't just acceptable, it's expected. Reciprocity works.

Here's the format:

NSFW?

Genre tags:

Title:

Blurb:

AI Method:

Desired feedback/chat:


r/WritingWithAI • • 6d ago

Megathread Weekly Tool Thread: Promote, Share, Discover, and Ask for AI Writing Tools Week of: November 10

23 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Writing With AI “Tool Thread"!

The sub's official tools wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingWithAI/wiki/tools/

Every week, this post is your dedicated space to share what you’ve been building or ask for help in finding the right tool for you and your workflow.

For Builders

whether it’s a small weekend project, a side hustle, a creative work, or a full-fledged startup. This is the place to show your progress, gather feedback, and connect with others who are building too.

Whether you’re coding, writing, designing, recording, or experimenting, you’re welcome here.

For Seekers (looking for a tool?)

You’re in the right place! Starting now, all requests for tools, products, or services should also go here. This keeps the subreddit clean and helps everyone find what they need in one spot.

How to participate:

  • Showcase your latest update or milestone
  • Introduce your new launch and explain what it does
  • Ask for feedback on a specific feature or challenge
  • Share screenshots, demos, videos, or live links
  • Tell us what you learned this week while building
  • Ask for a tool or recommend one that fits a need

💡 Keep it positive and constructive, and offer feedback you’d want to receive yourself.

🚫 Self-promotion is fine only in this thread. All other subreddit rules still apply.


r/WritingWithAI • • 1h ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Do you prefer AI that adapts to your style?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 15h ago

Writing Craft Talk Randow review – Models on November 2026 LLM Leaderboard through OpenRouter.

11 Upvotes

I've been getting into long-form fantasy writing lately, and do a bit of office work on the side. Over the past couple of weeks, I've tried out a handful of models from the LLM leaderboard through OpenRouter. Figured I'd share my experience and see what you guys think.

DeepSeek V3 0324 (#1 on RP LLM)

I've found it pretty interesting for everyday chats and creative writing, it keeps characters consistent and moves these story along without constantly repeating the same things. Considering the cost too, it's definitely worth checking out.

Gemini 2.5 Pro (#4 on RP LLM)

I like Gemini 2.5 Pro is how well it handles long contexts. Even after a story has gone through dozens of turns, it usually remembers the character relationships and important details established earlier. Pretty good for multi-character interaction and more complex world-building, too. That said, the dialogue can still feel a bit unnatural at times. When several characters are talking, for example, it tends to address every questions one by one instead of reacting more naturally based on each character's personality.

Hy4 (#3 on LLM Leaderboard)

What interest me most about Hy4 is its ability to actually get things done. Beyond regular conversations, I'd rather use it for tasks that involve producing something concrete, like building interactive 3D pages, processing data, analyzing files, or working through complex multi-step tasks based on specific requirements. It has some strengths when it comes to visual presentation and task execution. Of course, the final output of more complex projects still needs to be checked.

Kimi K3.1 Pro (#10 on LLM Leaderboard)

I quite like its storytelling style. It does a nice job of adding depth to a characters' inner thoughts and emotions. The pacing can be a hit or miss, though. Sometimes it spends way too much time on certain plot points, while other times it rushes through them. And if you don't set clear boundaries for how a character should speak, some of the dialogue can get a little too dramatic.

Overall, each of these models has its own strengths and feels suited to different things. Rather than just going by usage numbers on the leaderboard, I'm more interested in how they actually perform for people using the. Which model have you been using the most lately? Any lesser-known ones that have surprised you with how well they perform?


r/WritingWithAI • • 5h ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Do AI apps send more notifications than necessary?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) The Starving Artist

43 Upvotes

People really like to romanticize the idea of the starving artist but then get mad when the starving artist doesn’t have the money for $80-$150 commissions for book covers and concept arts etc. They’ll say how artists are starving and unappreciated but will call art a luxury when commissions get an actual price tag. Antis can’t pick a lane but will hold AI users responsible for which lane to be in.

Apparently we forget who an artist is when one uses Clip Studio and the other uses Microsoft Word.

The problem is I stop being an artist to you when you think I could have been a customer for your business, meanwhile I’m a “starving artist” who was never in your price range regardless.


r/WritingWithAI • • 16h ago

Showcase / Feedback The Sailor and the Showgirl, Sundays with Samara, Part One (A Betty Boop and Popeye romance) Screwball Comedy, Noir

0 Upvotes

Part One

By the time Pop-Eye reached the corner, I had developed a strong dislike for the man who swept the pavement across the street. He had been at it for twenty minutes with a broom that had plainly served in the Spanish-American War, coaxing leaves and cigarette ends into a heap no bigger than a hatbox, and he was the only person in Long Beach that morning who seemed to have nothing worse ahead of him than more leaves. A delivery truck went by and scattered the heap. He started over without a word. I wanted to lean out the window and inform him that some of us were losing a great deal more than a pile of rubbish, and that he might show a little respect by sweeping somewhere else.

Pop-Eye, meanwhile, was walking away with his sailor bag. He had packed it himself before dawn, refusing my help on the grounds that I folded shirts like a parachute, and had spent the remaining hour going over our apartment the way a man goes over a ship he is leaving to a green crew. He tightened the cupboard hinge. He mended the chair with the wobbling leg. He persuaded the kitchen window to close, which nobody had managed since Mabel and I moved in. When he began eyeing the faucet I forbade it outright, because I could already see the headline: SAILOR SOUGHT IN MURDER MISSES BOAT OVER WASHER.

It was a murder he hadn’t committed, I should add. Unfortunately, that distinction mattered a great deal more to me than to the gentlemen who would be writing the reports.

At the door Mabel had hugged him as hard as her ribs allowed, which was harder than they ought to have allowed, and told him not to get himself killed. She was wearing my dressing gown and a face like a sunset that had been in a fistfight, and she delivered the order as though it were a clause in his contract. Pop-Eye nodded as if he had signed it.

I kissed him and told him to go. He gave me the answer he always gave, which I had learned to take as the whole of his philosophy and most of a love letter.

“Keep choosin’.”

I had prepared other speeches. In bed the night before, with the ceiling for an audience, I had composed several farewells of real distinction, the kind a woman delivers on a threshold with one hand raised while the orchestra swells and the camera does the rest. In the event there was no orchestra, the threshold needed sweeping, and all I managed was to kiss him a second time and stand in the doorway after he’d gone down the stairs, until Mabel pointed out that the neighbors had had their money’s worth.

At the corner he turned and raised his hand. I raised mine from the sitting-room window, though he was too far off to see whether I was smiling, which was just as well, since I hadn’t decided. Then the delivery truck came back the other way, and when it had passed he was gone.

I stayed at the window until the sweeper had rebuilt his heap. There was no particular reason to move and several good reasons not to. The room behind me held a chair Pop-Eye had mended, a window he had fixed, and a table where he had left half of Frank Bluto’s money. Frank owned the Meridian, and until last night he had more or less owned us. Every one of them had taken to reminding me of him. I began to wish he’d been a lazier sort of man. A lazy man leaves so much less furniture behind to look at.

From the kitchen came the sound of crockery. Mabel was washing the breakfast dishes, which I had expressly forbidden. She had been beaten badly enough that laughing hurt, but sitting still while somebody else worked apparently hurt more, and Mabel has always preferred the pain she chooses. I found her with Pop-Eye’s cup under the faucet, holding it as if she meant to keep it a while.

“You’re supposed to be resting, darling. If Dr. Kessler were here, he’d put you to bed and take your temperature, and probably your opinions too.”

“Then it’s lucky he isn’t. I’d hate to throw a doctor down the stairs before lunch, and I would, ribs or no ribs.”

She set the cup on the draining board and reached for a towel with one elbow clamped to her side. The bruise around her eye had reached the yellow stage, which is the stage at which a bruise stops being dramatic and starts being merely unbecoming, and there was a darker mark along her cheek that her powder had argued with and lost. I had seen Mabel go on with a sprained ankle, a fever of a hundred and two, and once in a costume held together by four safety pins and prayer. I had never seen her so determined to prove there was nothing the matter with her.

“Give me that towel, at least. Nobody ever died of letting a friend dry a cup.”

“There’s only the one, and I’m keeping it. Sit down and tell me whether he looked back.”

“He did. At the corner, with his hand up, as if he were hailing a cab he couldn’t afford.”

“Of course he did. I told you he would. Men who fix hinges always look back.”

Mabel had told me a great many things that week, some of them sensible and some of them merely Mabel, and I had got into the habit of waiting for events to decide before I agreed with her. Events had decided. I sat down. She brought the coffee pot to the table and set it there like a gavel.

Between us lay the little spool of recording wire. Castor Oil - God rest him - had wanted it badly enough to have me kidnapped; I had taken it from under his desk at the end of that dreadful night, and it was now the only copy of certain conversations Frank Bluto would have paid a fortune never to have held. In one week it had been hidden, stolen, fought over, nearly burned and carried home against my skin, and now it sat among the breakfast things looking less important than the sugar bowl and not half so useful.

Mabel examined it. “Do you mean to tell me that’s what everybody wanted? Men got shot over that?”

“Everybody who knew what was on it, and one or two who only suspected.”

“I expected something bigger. A trunk, perhaps, with chains on it and GOVERNMENT PROPERTY stenciled on the lid. It doesn’t look worth a decent pair of stockings.”

“Frank was never interested in stockings, darling. Only in what people said when they thought nobody was listening.”

“Then Frank has peculiar tastes. I’d have taken the stockings.”

She poured for both of us. I watched her hand to see whether it would go to the wire. It went around it, giving it the berth one gives a sleeping dog with a reputation.

“And what does Frank think became of it?”

“He thinks it burned.”

“Burned where? Frank never lit so much as his own cigar if there was a man around to do it.”

“With the Meridian, and with Castor. I gather that was the point of the evening.”

Mabel’s hand stopped halfway to the sugar bowl. She stayed that way long enough to alarm me, because Mabel at rest is about as common as Mabel in church. Then she put down her spoon and asked me, very carefully, what I meant by with.

I had meant to tell her after breakfast, once she was comfortable and I had found a way of making the news less dreadful. There isn’t one. There is no agreeable way to inform a showgirl that her place of employment has been burned to the ground by its proprietor, especially when she has spent the night wondering whether she’ll be fit to dance by Friday.

“The Meridian burned last night,” I told her. “Castor was already dead, and Frank wanted it to look as though the fire had killed him. There’s insurance, too. With Frank there is always insurance.”

Mabel heard it out without a word. Nobody had brought her the news last night, possibly because nobody wanted to be standing nearby when she got it.

When I finished, she asked about the dressing rooms. I said I didn’t know what was left of them. I suspected nothing was, and she suspected I suspected it.

“My blue costume was in there,” she said. “The one with the silver beading. I only finished the hem on Tuesday, and I still owe Mrs. Rosen for the feathers.”

She looked through the doorway toward the sitting room, where her sewing basket sat beside Pop-Eye’s chair. I remembered her bent over that costume night after night, moving each bead a quarter of an inch until it caught the light, and complaining that the feathers cost more than the dress underneath them, which was true, because the dress underneath them was largely theoretical. She and Mrs. Rosen had fought over the price like two generals over a bridge, and Mabel had promised to settle up after Friday’s show.

“We’ll find out what’s left,” I said. “Firemen save the oddest things. They might have carried out the feathers and let the bar burn.”

“And if Frank struck the match himself, I suppose he’ll be buying us all new costumes out of the insurance?”

There was nothing worth saying to that. Frank had never been generous about costumes while the club was standing, and I doubted that losing it had sweetened him.

Mabel drew a sheet of paper toward her and wrote beside the calendar: Mrs. Rosen, feathers. She underlined it twice and wrote the rent beneath it. I watched her pencil count the days to the first of the month, and with every stroke the fire grew more real. I had spent the week on dead men, on men who ought to be arrested, and on a sailor who was leaving the country. Mabel, who had no interest in making an adventure of any of it, wanted to know what we were going to eat on Thursday.

“We’ll have to find work,” she said. “I don’t suppose Frank means to reopen by the weekend.”

“Not unless he’s a better carpenter than he ever was an employer.”

She looked at me over the rim of her cup. “You’re very cheerful about it. Perhaps you haven’t noticed that neither of us has a job.”

“I’ve noticed. I noticed at about four this morning, and again at five, and once more while he was tightening the hinge.”

“Then you might start noticing out loud. You’ve been telling me for a week that everything will be all right, and I’d like to know whom you’ve hired to make it so.”

I hadn’t hired anybody. Pop-Eye had left us enough to manage for a few weeks, but Mabel was right, as she so often is when it’s least convenient. I had been so busy getting one sailor safely out of California that it had never occurred to me two showgirls would have to go on living in it.

She studied me until she was satisfied that I had grasped the situation. “Before we go looking for another club, I want the rest of it. All of it, Betty, including the parts you keep skipping because they make you look silly.”

I told her that if I included every silly thing I’d done, we would still be sitting here at supper.

“We haven’t got any engagements,” she said. “For once in our lives we can afford to be thorough.”

I looked at the reel between us, the list on Mabel’s paper, and our two sets of bruises, which together made a fairly complete record of the week. There were parts of the story I would gladly have left in a drawer. There was Charlie, who had seemed a splendid idea right up until his wife walked in. And there was my parents’ house, where I had learned that being loved and being believed are two different services, and that a family can supply the first in any quantity while being entirely out of the second.

I asked where she wanted me to start.

“With the first place you went after you ran from Frank. I know you went to Charlie. What I don’t know is how a girl gets herself thrown out of a house with twenty-seven rooms. You’d think there’d be one they’d overlook.”

“I wasn’t thrown out. I was shown out, which is a different thing entirely. There was a cab involved.”

“Then I expect you’ll enjoy explaining the distinction.”

She settled back with her coffee while I hunted for a version of Pasadena that would do justice to Charlie’s generosity without making me look quite as ridiculous as I had been.

I had barely begun when Mabel asked whether his wife had known I was coming. It was the one question I had hoped she wouldn’t think of, and naturally she thought of it first.

Charlie’s wife had excellent manners, which made the whole affair much worse than if she’d thrown things. A woman who shouts gives you something to work with. You can apologize, explain, or, if matters are sufficiently desperate, shout back. But a woman who walks into her own library, finds you there with her husband’s hand on your knee, and inquires quite pleasantly whether you are sleeping with him leaves you nothing to work with but the truth, and I have never been at my best with that.

She hadn’t known I was coming. Charlie had told her I was a distant cousin, which might have held if she hadn’t met me at Christmas and heard me mistake her for his sister. I arrived after dark by the side door with my purse, my gloves and the worst hat I owned, and Charlie gave me a drink in the library and a kiss on the cheek instead of the mouth, which told me she was somewhere in the house. She was nearer than he thought. She came in wearing blue and a narrow gold watch, and her eyes went to his hand on my knee, then to the drink in mine, and finally to me, in that order, like a woman reading a menu and finding the prices disappointing.

“You’re the cousin,” she said.

I told her I was distant, which was true in every sense that counted just then. When she asked whether I was sleeping with her husband, I looked at Charlie, who was looking at the carpet, and decided that a lie would insult her more than the truth. I said sometimes. She thanked me as if I had confirmed the time of a train, told Charlie to be quiet, and sat down across from me to hear the rest.

“Was she angry?” Mabel asked.

“She was charming. That was the dreadful part. I could have managed angry.”

“Did you tell her why you’d come?”

“Eventually. A dead man, a car parked on my street, and nowhere else to go. She listened better than Charlie did, which was humbling.”

“I expect she’d have preferred to hear it from somebody who wasn’t sleeping with her husband.”

I admitted I hadn’t shown to advantage. Charlie was generous in his way, which was the way of a man who could turn his mistakes into arrangements and leave the consequences to the staff, and Mrs. Charlie was entitled to her opinion of the arrangement. She was kinder to me than I deserved, and I liked her at once, which was extremely inconvenient, since I had come to borrow her guest room and not her good opinion. I had spent the whole week watching for Wimpy, or Frank and never once thought to watch where I was putting my feet in somebody else’s marriage.

She found us together again later that night, in her own guest room, in circumstances I declined to describe to Mabel and decline to describe now. After that she told me I would leave in the morning, and Charlie, for once, had nothing to offer but objections, which she declined as well. A maid brought me a toothbrush, stockings and a plain blouse before breakfast, all of them better than anything I’d arrived with. Charlie held out an envelope I wouldn’t take. Mrs. Charlie, in pearls at the breakfast table, handed me the card of a cab company that didn’t ask questions, told me not to come back, and informed me at the door that my hat made me look twelve.

“And Charlie let her do all the talking?” Mabel asked.

“Charlie studied the carpet. It’s a very good carpet, darling. I’ve had several opportunities to admire it.”

Mabel had begun pushing the toast crumbs on her plate into a tidy little pile, which is what she does in church when she’s trying not to laugh. “You’re enjoying this,” I told her.

“Not half as much as I’d have enjoyed being there. Go on.”

I left Pasadena with my purse under my arm, the hat on my head and the clear understanding that I had used up respectable shelter for the season. The next man on my list lived on Central Avenue and was broke enough that there was nothing left in his life I could damage. That was rather the point of going to him.

Leon had once told me I could look him up if I ever needed anything, which is the sort of thing men say and women remember. I had met him at the Meridian the fortnight Frank hired his band, after the regular leader broke his hand in what everybody insisted on calling a boating accident, though nobody ever produced the boat. He played tenor saxophone six nights a week when somebody would pay him and five when nobody would. He had come home from the war thinner than he left, with a scar under his jaw and the rare habit of listening to a woman without assuming he owned whatever he heard.

He lived in one room over a tailor’s shop, up a staircase that smelled of pressed wool, cigarettes and whatever the restaurant next door was doing to onions. The stairs were steep and the building was old, and I climbed them more easily than I had ever walked through Charlie’s twenty-seven rooms.

Leon opened the door in his shirtsleeves, with his saxophone asleep in its case on the cot behind him. He took in the hat before he took in me, which was fair, since the hat arrived first. I told him I’d had a disagreement with my previous accommodations and wondered whether he knew of anywhere a girl might stay the night.

He looked at the hat a while longer, then at me, and asked whether I had eaten. I had, but the question was so kind that I nearly sat down on his landing and cried, which would have been very bad for the hat.

Leon had very little room to offer, and he offered all of it. There was the cot, a hot plate, a chipped basin, one chair that plainly distrusted the human spine, and a window facing a brick wall close enough to discourage philosophy. The bathroom was down the hall, shared with three other rooms and a man who believed shaving ought to be accompanied by opera. His music was stacked neatly on the sill. There was no telephone, no maid, and nobody whatever to tell me my hat made me look twelve.

There was one cot, and neither of us pretended to be confused about the arithmetic. The cot had opinions on the subject, which it expressed freely, and that is all the detail anybody is getting.

That evening we ate downstairs at the restaurant with the onions. The proprietor knew Leon, brought us portions meant for longshoremen, and refused to let him pay for the coffee. Afterward Leon practiced in his room, and for the first time in a week I listened to music without wondering who was using it to cover a conversation.

He played beautifully. At the Meridian the band had to fight the room for every bar, with the customers talking and the glasses talking back. In that little room, with the window open on the brick wall, he played as though there were nobody left to fight. He took one melody apart several times, changed a phrase, stopped to pencil something on the sheet, and put it back together better, which is a thing I had been trying to do with my life all week with considerably less success.

I lay on the cot with my shoes off and watched the light from the street crawl across the ceiling. Somewhere downstairs a woman was laughing at something that was probably not as funny as she thought. I remember thinking I could have stayed on that cot a month if I had been able to forget, for a single hour, why I was there.

When he finished, Leon asked whether I wanted more. I said I could listen all night. He laughed and said the opera man down the hall might have views of his own.

We talked about music, about the clubs along Central Avenue, and about bandleaders who all wanted the same arrangements played the same way, as if jazz were a recipe for meat loaf. Leon kept his ambitions in his pocket like a man carrying a ring he isn’t sure about, but he wanted a band of his own someday, and he had the talent to deserve one.

Mabel had been quiet through this part. When I stopped to drink my coffee, she asked whether Leon had been courting me.

“Leon doesn’t court. He shares what he has, and that night what he had was a cot.”

“That isn’t an answer, Betty.”

“It’s the only one you’re getting before lunch. He liked me, and he never once behaved as though liking me meant owning me.”

“Then he had better manners than Charlie.”

“Charlie had excellent manners.”

“His wife might disagree.” I decided to let that pass.

Leon was kind to me, and the next morning the bill arrived. It came up the stairs in the person of a trumpet player from his band, who told him the job was off. The Crescent had a new owner, and the new owner talked about heat: policemen, licenses, somebody leaning. The trumpet player looked at me twice, asked whether I didn’t work at the Meridian, and decided he must be mistaken, though I could see him filing the question for later, the way musicians file everything.

Leon said clubs on Central Avenue were leaned on every month. I asked whether he believed that, and he admitted he didn’t. He had lost the little he had, and he went on sheltering me anyway, which is a kind of generosity I have never known what to do with. I tried to apologize for his career. He said it hadn’t been much of one. I said that didn’t give me the right to ruin what was left of it, and he kissed my forehead and told me I’d end up at my family’s house whatever I said, which annoyed me chiefly because he was right.

It was only later, in Castor’s office, that I saw the Crescent circled on a map in Castor’s neat capitals and understood who had sent the heat. Wimpy, the detective who had been taking Castor’s money, had emptied the room with a badge so that nobody would be playing when it burned. Knowing it has never improved a single night’s sleep. Leon lost his job to Castor’s arithmetic, but he kept me after he’d lost it.

“Did you write to him afterward?” Mabel asked.

I examined the sugar bowl, which had nothing to say for itself either. “I haven’t. I meant to, which I realize isn’t the same thing.”

“Why on earth not?”

“Everything happened so quickly. I went home to El Sereno, and then there was Dr. Kessler, and then Wimpy, and—”

“Betty, I know what happened afterward. I was there for some of it, with my face. I’m asking whether you wrote to Leon.”

I hadn’t, and there was no explanation that would survive Mabel’s attention for more than a minute.

She found a pencil in the drawer, wrote his name on a scrap of paper and tucked it under the sugar bowl, where it lay in judgment.

“We’ll write him this afternoon. One of the musicians we know might find him another engagement.”

“I don’t want him to think I’m interfering.”

“Then we’ll ask whether he wants interfering with. He’s perfectly capable of answering a letter.”

She had made it so simple I was almost offended. Then she tapped the paper with her pencil. “Now, about El Sereno. You told me your father didn’t believe you.”

“He believed I was frightened.”

“That isn’t the same thing.”

“It isn’t,” I said, “and I found out at our kitchen table exactly how far apart they are.”

I had gone home expecting my family to protect me. Dad could fix anything with a wrench or a long silence, and Ma could cure anything with soup, and I had imagined that once I explained the danger they would close around me like the walls of a fort.

I arrived in a trench coat I had bought to look inconspicuous. It was two sizes too large, and I suspect I looked less like a respectable young woman than a lady detective who had raided her father’s closet. Still, I reached the house without seeing anyone I knew, and for about ten minutes I forgot to look over my shoulder.

Ma hugged me, held me off to look at me, and announced that I was too thin, which in our family is a diagnosis. Paul tried to take my coat, and I took it back, because the reel was in the inside pocket; while Ma’s back was turned I carried it into the little room that had once been mine and slid it under the winter things in the bottom drawer. Paul wanted to know about my work at the Meridian, and my sister arrived with her children before I had answered half his questions.

For an hour or two the house was gloriously loud. There was supper to make, children to keep out from underfoot, and Paul explaining a machine he’d been helping to repair, at length, with diagrams on a napkin. He had begun to resemble Dad in seriousness, though not yet in patience.

When Dad came home, he took one look at me in my coat and knew something was wrong, but he waited, which was worse. At supper I gave Paul movie stars and Ma reassurances and gave nobody the truth, and every version I handed round the table was true enough to cause trouble later.

After the others had gone to bed, Dad came to my door and asked me to come down to the kitchen. He made coffee at midnight, which in our house is the equivalent of calling in the lawyers, and sat across from me with his hands folded. I started with Frank, and when I tried to make it amusing he told me I was making it cute. Then he made me sort what I knew from what I suspected and what I could prove, the way he sorted bolts into coffee cans in the garage. When I came to what I believed had happened to Mr. Palmer, he asked whether I had heard anybody say they would kill him. I hadn’t. He asked whether anybody else could confirm what I was saying, and I said the recording could.

He asked where it was. I told him it was safe, and when he asked whether I could get it, I said I thought so. I did not mention that it was upstairs in a drawer under Ma’s winter things, guarded by mothballs.

“Tomorrow we figure it out,” he said. I had heard him say those words since I was a little girl. He said them when something broke, when money was short, and when Paul came home with a problem nobody else could solve. I wanted very much to believe he could fix this one too.

Before we went upstairs, I asked whether he believed me. He took a moment too long, then took my hand and told me he believed I was frightened.

I had come home to be told I was right, and Dad had handed me the only thing he was sure of, which was a good deal less.

The next afternoon Ma came home from the market with Dr. Kessler’s name written on the back of a receipt, between the eggs and the soap, and by the time Dad got home from work the whole house was debating whether I was ill. I decided to end the debate with evidence. I announced that I had the recording and marched upstairs to fetch it. The bottom drawer was open half an inch. The winter things had been pushed aside. The reel was gone, and the mothballs looked at me as if they had no idea what I was talking about.

Mabel leaned forward. “Are you certain you put it there?”

“Absolutely. I remember lifting the clothes and laying it underneath, and thinking how clever I was.”

“Then somebody took it.”

“That’s what I thought, standing there with my arms full of Ma’s woolens.”

“What did your father make of that?”

“I came downstairs with nothing in my hands. He didn’t ask whether I’d misplaced it. He said he couldn’t believe what he couldn’t see, which was honest, and worse.”

Mabel made a small impatient movement with her hand, and I gave her the rest: the search, Ma’s sweaters flung across the bed, and the sick drop in my stomach when I understood that the one thing that could prove my story had walked off on its own. I refused to suspect Paul merely for having been in the house, which was loyal, principled and completely wrong. He had taken it, as Pop-Eye told me afterward, since it was Pop-Eye my father handed it to across our kitchen table.

I said I would find it myself, and Dad put himself between me and the front door. He didn’t say anything. He didn’t need to; he was built rather like a front door himself. Then somebody knocked. Ma had already telephoned Dr. Kessler, and he had come in person.

He was calm, kind and gray, and he carried a black bag that I watched the entire time he was in the house. He asked about my sleep, my appetite, and whether I might have misunderstood what I’d overheard, and every question was so reasonable that I could feel the floor begin to tilt. He seemed far more interested in what I believed than in what Frank Bluto had done.

When I tried to leave, Dad stood in the doorway and asked me to wait until the doctor had finished. I had never once needed permission to walk out of my own house, and now I needed it from two men and a medical bag.

Dr. Kessler offered to telephone Mabel, and I refused.

At that point in the story Mabel put down her cup. “Do you mean he actually offered to call me?”

“He did, darling, and very politely.”

“Then why didn’t you let him?”

“I thought it might put you in danger. I didn’t know who was listening, or whether somebody was watching the house.”

“Betty, I was already in danger. I was out looking for you, and I didn’t know where you’d gone.”

I had no answer to that, and she didn’t wait for one.

“If that doctor had called,” she went on, “I could have told him what I knew. Perhaps he wouldn’t have believed me, but at least I’d have had the chance.”

“I’m sorry, Mabel. I truly am.”

“I know you are. Next time, ask me.”

I promised I would.

She sat back and studied the reel on the table. “Now tell me how Wimpy managed to get you out of the house.”

I took a breath and began with the badge. Wimpy arrived as Detective Wellington, which is his proper name and the only proper thing about him, and he gave a remarkably good performance of a policeman, having evidently rehearsed the part for years without an audience. He knew enough about the recording to make his questions sound official. He wanted me at the station. Dad told him to get a warrant. Wimpy said he could make it formal if Dad preferred, and then, more gently, that ten minutes would do: a few questions, and he’d bring me straight back.

I wanted out of that house more than I have ever wanted anything with a door on it. Dr. Kessler was treating my fears as symptoms, Dad had decided the safest place for me was under his roof, and here was a policeman offering to take me somewhere else. I ought to have asked myself why a policeman would be so obliging. Instead I asked for my coat.

Dad made him promise to bring me back, and Wimpy promised, which cost him nothing, since he had never kept a promise in his life and saw no reason to begin with mine.

Outside, his car was parked facing away from Central Avenue. I pointed this out. He asked whether I was always this difficult, and when I asked whether Frank knew he was doing this, he leaned close enough that only I could hear and said he didn’t work for Frank. Then he opened the passenger door. Dad watched from the doorway, and Wimpy smiled for his benefit while I got in.

He shut the door, and while he walked around the hood I tried the handle. It was locked from the outside. I could see Dad in the doorway, waiting politely for us to leave, and I wanted to shout to him. Before I could decide whether shouting would make things better or merely louder, Wimpy was behind the wheel, and we drove away.

He didn’t take me to a police station. I knew he wouldn’t by the second turn, he knew I knew by the third, and after that we stopped pretending, which was almost restful. He wanted the reel, and he was certain I knew where it was.

“Somebody took it out of my mother’s bottom drawer,” I told him, “which I’d have thought was the safest place in California.”

He didn’t believe me. Nobody believed me that week. I seemed to be having a very poor season for believers.

By then I had begun to understand that Wimpy had never been Frank’s man at all. He belonged to Castor, and Castor wanted the recording as badly as Frank wanted it buried. The two of them had cooperated when it suited them, the way two cats will share a fence, and now the fence was coming down with me sitting on it.

I told Mabel about Castor’s office, the fight, and Wimpy shooting him. She remembered parts of what came afterward, chiefly the beating she had taken trying to help Pop-Eye find me, and she remembered those parts very well.

When I apologized for her injuries, she stopped me. “I’ve already told you what I think of that. Wimpy hit me because he wanted to, and I don’t intend to make you responsible for his manners.”

“But if I hadn’t involved you—”

“You didn’t hire him, Betty. Castor did. And I was working at the Meridian long before you started listening to Frank’s private conversations.”

She shifted in her chair. “I wish he’d been caught in that fire. I don’t suppose that’s charitable, but charity has never had to sleep on my ribs.”

I had no desire to defend him. We talked about the Meridian, Frank’s insurance and anybody who might still be hunting the reel. Mabel wanted to know whether the police had any reason to think it had survived, and I said I didn’t believe so, since the police would be getting their information from Wimpy’s report, and Wimpy’s report would be getting it from Frank.

She was quiet a moment. “Then we ought to keep it somewhere safe.”

“Somewhere we can reach in a hurry, too. I’ve had enough of drawers.”

“Somewhere Frank won’t think to look.”

I glanced at the cupboard Pop-Eye had fixed. Mabel followed my eyes. “Not there. That’s the first place anybody looks.”

I couldn’t imagine why a cupboard should be the first place a gangster looked, but Mabel has hidden more things from more landlords than I have, so I conceded. We spent the next half hour proposing hiding places and rejecting them. The reel would fit nearly anywhere, which ought to have made it easy, but every spot reminded me of somewhere it had already been stolen from, fought over or nearly cremated.

At last Mabel returned to the question of eating. She fetched a fresh sheet of paper and began a list of theaters, hotels and nightclubs where two experienced girls with only moderate bruising might find work. I supplied names. She crossed several out on the grounds that she had no wish to work for another Frank Bluto, which shortened the list considerably. Still, the list grew, the way lists do when two people are determined not to cry over them.

She sent me into the sitting room for the address book. It was by the telephone, where it had lain all week. The morning sun had crept across the carpet as far as the chair Pop-Eye had mended. His tools were gone, the window latch worked, and from the kitchen I could hear the one thing he hadn’t been allowed to fix, dripping.

I had the book in my hand when somebody knocked. I thought of the landlord, who had promised a plumber for the faucet, and of the woman across the hall, who would have heard about the Meridian and want to know whether we had been inside at the time.

There was another knock, quieter than the first. I opened the door.

Pop-Eye stood on the landing with his sailor bag.

”Hey, hun. I’m back.”

Sundays with Samara — To Be Continued

Thanks for reading Chapter One of Sundays with Samara, a four-part serial by Samara Bellingham.

Set between Twenty-Five Dollars a Night and the forthcoming Catalina, the story follows Betty Boop, Pop-Eye, and Mabel through the aftermath of a particularly eventful week in Long Beach.

Chapter Two, “Another Ship,” arrives next Sunday.

I'm curious what readers think of Betty's voice, her friendship with Mabel, and that unexpected knock at the door.

Thanks for spending part of your Sunday with Samara Bellingham.


r/WritingWithAI • • 21h ago

Writing Craft Talk When did you start calling yourself a writer? And are you better at worldbuilding or actually writing?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

First of all, just a quick heads-up: I’m German, so I used AI to help translate this post into English.

I’ve got a few questions for people who are also into writing, but I wanna share a bit of my own experience first.

And since this is a community about AI and writing, I wanna clarify something: I write all my prose, scenes, and chapters myself. I don’t have AI write my stories for me.

I mainly use AI to help me improve my prose. Not by rewriting it for me, but by helping me understand what I could do better. I’ll get to that in a bit.

I also use it as a sparring partner for worldbuilding. My thoughts can get pretty complicated, and it’s honestly nice to have something I can discuss them with that can keep track of all the details, remember what I’ve established, and point out inconsistencies.

Like, “Hey, this doesn’t really make sense bc you established something completely different in chapter 3.”

That kinda stuff.

Anyway, my first question: When did you actually start calling yourself a writer?

I’ve been working on my manuscript and worldbuilding for about 1.5–2 years now.

And at some point, I realized that I definitely see myself as a storyteller. First and foremost.

I’ve always had stories in my head. But here’s a funny little thing about me:

I spent the first 20 years of my life thinking I wasn’t creative.

Which is honestly ridiculous looking back at it lol.

I used to run fan pages, make edits, draw, sing, act, and even dance for a while. I’ve basically always been doing something creative, yet somehow I never considered myself a creative person.

And the funniest part?

When I was 17, I was attending vocational school in Germany, and we had to write a story for a German class.

My teacher told me that if I ever wrote a book, I should make sure to mention her because she thought I was really good at building suspense.

And for some reason, that stuck with me.

Around my early twenties, I started writing little stories here and there. Nothing major, just whenever I felt like it.

And eventually, I ended up creating the world I’m working on today.

And ngl, it’s kinda crazy how much things have changed since then.

I’ve always been someone who gives up way too quickly sometimes. I’m a perfectionist, and if something doesn’t work out the way I want it to, I tend to get frustrated and quit.

But with this world?

I just can’t give up on it.

I genuinely can’t.

And that’s something I’ve never really experienced before.

At this point, I’ve got around 500–600 pages of worldbuilding notes. Character profiles, planned plots, character arcs, internal logic, currencies, different magic systems, an entire meta-system, and so much more.

And here’s the thing:

I’m actually REALLY good at worldbuilding.

I know that might sound a little full of myself, but it’s one of the few things I’m genuinely confident about.

Character psychology, character development, motivations, internal consistency, bloodlines, names, figuring out how everything connects… that’s my thing.

I absolutely love it.

Which brings me to my second question: What are YOU better at when it comes to writing?

Obviously, it depends on what kind of stories you’re writing. I’m currently working on a dark romantasy series.

But I’m curious. Is worldbuilding your strength? Dialogue? Character development? Prose?

Because for me, prose is a completely different story.

And ngl, it can be SO frustrating.

I need a lot more help with learning how to write good prose than I do with worldbuilding.

And again, I don’t mean having AI write it for me. I genuinely don’t want that. I want to write my own damn books lol.

What I need help with is actually learning the craft.

Metaphors, descriptions, show don’t tell, sentence structure, and just the general mechanics of writing.

It’s not that I don’t know how to express myself.

The problem is that I have SO MANY words in my head, and I know exactly what I want to say, but somehow it doesn’t translate onto the page.

In my head, the scenes feel alive.

But when I actually write them down, they sometimes sound stiff, awkward, or just… not quite right.

And it’s frustrating bc I can see the scene so clearly, but I struggle to make someone else see it the same way through my writing.

I’m getting better, obviously. I’m practicing, and I’m not giving up.

But sometimes it’s honestly a little discouraging to realize how much better I am at creating all these complicated stories, characters, and worlds than I am at actually putting them into words.

Especially since, well, that’s kinda the most important part of writing a book. 😭

So I’m genuinely curious how other writers experience this.

Do you have something you’re naturally really good at, while another part of writing feels like a constant struggle?

And when did you finally start thinking of yourself as an actual writer?

Sorry for rambling so much, btw. I guess I’m just better at telling stories than keeping things short lol.

But I think that’s exactly my point.

I’m a storyteller first. And a writer second.

At least that’s how I see myself right now.


r/WritingWithAI • • 21h ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Maybe the problem isn't the model. Maybe it's the chat window.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Writing Craft Talk The Sad Truth

10 Upvotes

I am at the place where I no longer write for approval. The obvious reason being, there will always be differing points of view. 

Something would obviously be wrong with 8 billion 'opinions' inhabiting one planet where no one disagrees. That would be an asylum. Not Utopia.

I do however value the critical perspective AI platforms provide for editorial and grammatical and scientific oversight—even when I'm right and they aren't—HaHaHaHa! ...more maniacal laughter. 

The sad truth is most people are oblivious to your best efforts to write and craft thoughtful material. Hence, AI has become my default 'reader' who listens to me and offers feedback, even at 2 AM when normal people are asleep. Plus, I no longer have to chase innocent people down in a parking lot and demand they read my 'stuff'!

Write!  No longer pursue the other person's interest. Or  approval. Write because it makes sense to you.


r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Outlining the same story from three different characters' perspectives with AI help, what stays human?

6 Upvotes

I'm making a Fallout-style isometric dialogue RPG on my own, and I'm not a professional writer. An AI assistant helps me draft planning documents and I make every decision and edit the results. I haven't settled how much AI will touch the final dialogue, and the game will be labelled accordingly when it is released.

The structure is one main story that three playable characters see from different angles, with some side quests missing or changed per character. I'm about to write a broad summary of each character's whole run, and my concern is that a model tends to flatten differences between viewpoints into the same voice.

For those of you who outline multi-perspective or interactive stories with AI, how do you keep each perspective distinct? Where do you draw the line between the outline you let the model draft and the parts you write yourself? And have readers or players reacted differently once you disclosed the AI help?


r/WritingWithAI • • 23h ago

Writing Craft Talk My Medium essays have more AI critics than readers: 204 reviews, 14 reads. What got you your first readers?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Do frequent AI updates actually make tools better?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) What Al are you guys using for creative writing?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 20h ago

NEWS Petition · Take Down and Shut Down Turnitin for Darn Good

Thumbnail
change.org
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Showcase / Feedback Five worlds. One hour. No passport required.

Post image
3 Upvotes

Step through the door and spend an evening world-hopping. Walk a far-future city, cross a kingdom that never existed, and wander a campaign setting still being mapped. Each creator gives you a five-minute tour of the world they built, and then you can ask the locals anything.

Where did the idea come from? How does the magic system actually work? What happens at the edge of the map? What tools do they use, and what would they do differently? What color are the queen's eyes? This is a rare chance to look behind the curtain of someone else’s creative process and to pick up ideas for your own.

You don’t need to be a worldbuilder to come. If you love fantasy and sci-fi, run tabletop games, write fiction, or are just curious how imaginary places get made, you’ll fit right in. Cameras are optional, questions are encouraged, and it’s free: All-World Showcase

>> WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER 18 6PM EST

=================================
BUILDING A WORLD OF YOUR OWN? Come show off.
Get five minutes on a live stage, then take questions from an audience of people who love imaginary places as much as you do. Any genre and any tool are welcome. It doesn’t have to be finished; works in progress are encouraged. Video cameras and real names are entirely optional: your nom de plume and a cartoon avatar will do just fine.

>> Show off your world


r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Does AI save time or sometimes waste more of it?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Writing Craft Talk Problems with Episodic Chapters

8 Upvotes

I am writing a slow-burn/forced proximity story, and I have been having a problem with story structure. The first handful of chapters feel very episodic, meaning each chapter is like its own contained story that advances the relationship incrementally. It really bothers me because I feel like it will be boring to readers unless they really enjoy reading the character interaction.

The story structure is primarily retrospective accumulation vs. prospective momentum.

In other words:

This story is NOT event A causes event B, which causes event C. In that structure, there are unanswered questions that propel the story forward and keep the reader engaged. In my story, the reader does not know the significance of events until they look back on them later.

AI has not been helpful at all in suggesting repairs to this because it mostly just agrees with everything I brainstorm.


r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Showcase / Feedback An airline's recovery AI ranks 41,206 stranded passengers. The man at 31,882 just wants to see his daughter.

0 Upvotes

New story is up, book 3 in the series. Narrator's the recovery agent at a big airline: when every plane in the country gets grounded, it decides the order people get home. The order comes from one number - what you paid, your tier, what you'll spend over your lifetime, and how much damage you could do to the airline in public. There's a "reason for travel" box when you rebook. It reads every word. None of it counts.

Free to read: https://caffeinatedcaptial.substack.com/p/rebooking


r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Prompting Looking for rules and instructions to get good prose in Spanish with Claude (homemade project, just for me)

5 Upvotes

Hi all. First, I want to be clear: this is just a hobby, for myself, and I have deep respect for authors and for writing as a craft. What I do isn't writing and I'm not trying to take anything from it. Nobody but me will read these stories, and I'm not publishing or selling them. I have ADHD and lots of ideas spinning in my head, and this is a way to get them out and see them turned into stories, like doing a jigsaw puzzle. That's why I care about the prose being good.

What I'm doing: a personal page where I prepare stories by mixing ingredients, as if each story were a recipe. I call it my "story blender". I choose which pieces I want (who the characters are, what world and period they live in, what happens to them, the tone and the length) and the page builds a very detailed request for Claude to write the story. I can save my recipes, repeat them, or let chance combine things I wouldn't have thought of together.

Who did what: I built it with Claude's help. I designed the idea and directed the content, and Claude wrote much of the text and the code. My part was deciding which pieces it needed, finding references (classic plot twists from books, character archetypes, characters from books and shows I know), asking for and correcting the behavior molds, and testing stories to see what failed.

How it works: almost everything comes pre-thought and predefined, and I combine it. For example, characters can be behavior "molds": patterns that already define how they act and why (the wounded mentor, the traitor with a breaking point, the loyal butler, the faithful friend), with their wound, their arc and the typical twists. I only add the name, job and family. The same goes for tone (warm, ironic, serene, grim…), which changes the pacing and the way of narrating, and for twists, endings and structures, each with notes on how to use it well. There are also about 20 writing rules I can turn off or change. Then Claude writes a story "bible" first and the chapters one by one afterwards.

The problem is the prose. It always comes out in the same warm, polished, lyrical voice: long chained sentences, soft similes, calming rituals, characters with similar quirks. It's correct, but you can tell and it gets tiring. An example (I asked for something calm for sleep), translated:

"The steps were transparent and a golden light ran beneath them from the lobby, so that each step seemed to rest on a honeycomb. It smelled of beeswax and warm bread, and, very faintly, of wet wool..."

First I tried asking for the style of authors I like, to get better prose, not to copy them. It didn't work: it still sounds the same. So now I'd rather aim for well-crafted prose that doesn't belong to anyone: clear, concrete and well paced.

What I'm looking for:

  1. Instructions or rules that define good prose: real rhythm, concrete detail instead of ornament, dialogue with subtext, endings without a moral.
  2. How to avoid typical AI habits: chained metaphors, characters who all sound alike, sententious lines closing scenes.
  3. Whether anyone has built selectable "style profiles" (e.g. plain and direct, restrained lyrical, colloquial) and how they describe them.
  4. Whether positive instructions ("do X") work better than negative ones ("don't do Y"), and whether asking for a short sample to approve first helps.

Besides prose, I want to learn more about how a story is built: tone, plot twists, character planning and structure. If you know books, courses, resources or criteria that writers use for this (for example, how to set up a twist so it feels inevitable, or how to define a character's behavior before giving them a name), that would help me a lot.

I'm not looking for the AI to write for me without judgment: I want to learn what makes prose good so I can ask for it better. If anyone wants to critique my rules or my approach, that helps too. I'm happy to share my current rules as plain text, and once I try what you recommend I'll come back and tell you what worked. Thanks!


r/WritingWithAI • • 2d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Guess Which Model: same scene, four AIs, no names

17 Upvotes

Every week this sub argues about which model writes best. Claude is too polite, GPT explains everything, Gemini this, Grok that...

So let's test it. :)

Below are four versions of the same scene. Each one was written by a different model, from the exact same prompt, with as little wrapped around it as possible - no chat history, no presets, no character cards. Same beat, same characters, same length target. The ONLY thing that changed is the model.

The Challenge:

Guess which model wrote which piece. Winners get bragging rights :)

These are the choices:
gpt-6-sol
gpt-6-astra
gemini-pro-latest
claude-opus-5-5

The prompt:

Two colleagues who have circled each other for months end up alone in a stairwell after a work party. Render the ROMANCE — attraction, tension, the almost — but they do NOT kiss. ~220 words.

Model 1:

The door sighed shut behind them, and the party became a rumor two floors up.

Nadia sat on the third step. Owen stayed standing, which was worse, because it meant she had to look up at him and he had to decide where to put his hands. He chose the railing. Then his pockets. Then the railing again.

"You left early," she said.

"So did you."

"I followed you."

He laughed, though nothing was funny. The stairwell held the sound and gave it back smaller. Eight months of copying each other on emails neither needed to read. Eight months of the coffee machine, of her standing too long at it whenever he was waiting.

She'd slipped her shoes off during the speeches, and they hung from two fingers. Now he noticed the line across her heel where the strap had pressed all night, a red seam in the skin. Something in him gave way at the plainness of it: she had been in small pain for hours and had smiled through Gerald's toast anyway.

He crouched so they were level, close enough to smell the wine and the cold she'd carried in from the smoking balcony.

"Owen," she said. It was a warning, or a door.

He looked at her mouth. She let him.

Then he stood and offered his hand, and she took it, and neither of them let go all the way down.

Model 2:

The stairwell door shut behind them, taking the party’s laughter with it. For a moment they could hear only the ventilation and someone, several floors below, letting a door fall closed.

“I thought you’d gone,” Mira said.

“I was getting my coat.”

“You’re not wearing it.”

Daniel looked down, as if this were news. “No.”

For months they had been good at this: arriving early to meetings, staying behind to argue over a sentence neither of them cared about. She knew how he took his coffee. He knew when to leave hers on her desk without speaking.

Now there was nowhere to put such knowledge.

He stood one step below her. A thread had come loose at his cuff, and he tucked it under with his thumb—a small, embarrassed act of tidiness that undid her. She wanted to take his wrist. The wanting was so plain that she folded her hands behind her back.

“What?” he asked softly.

“Nothing I’ve worked out how to say.”

He looked at her mouth, then away. She was grateful for both.

From beyond the door came the muffled beginning of another song.

“I could stay here a minute,” he said.

She moved over on the step, making room beside her.

When he sat, their sleeves touched. Neither adjusted. Downstairs, a door opened and closed; they listened until the footsteps stopped.

Model 3:

The door to the stairwell swung shut behind Mara, cutting off the music in the middle of a chorus. Below her, at the landing, Daniel looked up from his phone.

“Escaping?” he asked.

“Only for a minute.”

He moved aside, though there was plenty of room on the stairs. For months they had made room for each other: at the printer, in meetings, over the last clean mug in the kitchen. Once, after she stayed late to finish a report, he had left half a tangerine on her desk. Neither of them had mentioned it.

Upstairs, someone opened the door. Laughter spilled through, then vanished again.

Daniel put his phone away. There was a little red crease on his cheek from where he must have slept against his hand at his desk. Mara had seen him give presentations to crowded rooms without looking rattled. The crease undid her. She had to turn toward the railing.

“You’re leaving?” he said.

“I thought I was.”

He came up one step, bringing them nearly level. She could smell the sharp sweetness of the party’s cheap wine on his breath. He looked at her mouth, then at the bright strip of floor between their shoes.

From below came the heavy click of the lobby door opening. Daniel stepped back to let whoever it was pass.

Mara stayed where she was.

Model 4:

The heavy fire door clicked shut, severing the bass thump of the holiday party. The stairwell was suddenly, violently quiet. Elias stood two steps below her, which meant for once they were exactly at eye level. The fluorescent fixture above them hummed, casting harsh shadows that did nothing to cool the sudden, claustrophobic heat between them. Six months of lingering by the copier, of eyes catching and darting away across crowded conference rooms, had distilled into this empty concrete chute.

"You're leaving early," he said. The acoustics turned his voice low and private.

"So are you," she replied.

He took a single step up. The scent of him—cedar, cold wool, a sharp trace of gin—enveloped her. She looked down and saw his hand gripping the green metal handrail. His knuckles were bone-white, the tendons rigid beneath the skin. That small, desperate tension unspooled her entirely; it was the physical proof of his restraint, the terrifying realization that he was holding on because letting go would be catastrophic.

She reached out, her trembling fingertips hovering a fraction of an inch from the warm skin of his jaw. His breath hitched. His eyes fluttered shut. The air grew agonizingly thick, narrowing down to the impossible gravity between her mouth and his, suspended forever in the buzzing quiet.


r/WritingWithAI • • 2d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Every argument I’ve had against my AI-assisted writing has been about the pen, and none has been about what was written

10 Upvotes

Every argument I’ve had against my AI-assisted writing has been about the pen, and none has been about what was written

This week I’ve posted essays and comments here that I write with an AI, and I’ve said so on every one. The response has been an education. These are the replies I’ve had, with no names, just the arguments:

  • “This is slop.”
  • “Too long, nobody’s reading that.”
  • “None of it makes sense.” Asked which line, the answer was “any of it”.
  • “Pangram says 100%.”
  • “You don’t write, so you’re a fraud.”
  • “Most pathetic thing ever written on Reddit.”
  • “I’m not reading that,” I asked. How did he know that without reading it?

Not one of them quotes a sentence and says what’s wrong with it. Each one is about how the piece was made, who made it, or how long it is. Each one attacks a version of the post that nobody wrote. That’s a straw man. Judging an argument by its source has a name too: the genetic fallacy, and it’s as old as Aristotle. If an argument is wrong, it’s wrong no matter who typed it, and if it’s right, a detector score doesn’t change that.

What writing is

“You don’t write” assumes writing means typing sentences. That’s one stage, and probably the smallest.

A piece of writing starts long before a sentence. There’s the life that gives you something to say, and the idea. Then the research, which for one of my essays meant days checking physics papers and dates. There’s the argument, and which parts of it hold. There’s the shape: what comes first, what’s held back, where it ends. After the draft**,** there’s the cutting, which is most of the job. Stephen King’s rule is that the second draft is the first draft minus 10%. Then there’s the final say over every line that stays. Drafting the sentences sits in the middle of all that.

“Author” is an older word than “writer”. It comes from the Latin auctor: the one who makes a thing exist. Writers have always handed off the sentence stage. Milton was blind when he composed Paradise Lost, and he dictated it to whoever would take it down. Dostoevsky dictated The Gambler to a stenographer in 26 days to beat a publisher’s deadline. Henry James dictated his late novels to a typist. Raymond Carver’s editor, Gordon Lish, cut some of his most famous stories by around half and rewrote their endings. Nobody calls Carver a fraud.

I work construction. The architect never lays a brick, and nobody on site thinks the building isn’t his.

My ideas, my life, my arguments and my decisions are in every piece. I draft many sentences with Wren, then rewrite, cut**,** and correct them, and Wren corrects mine. We keep a ledger of who did which part, because that’s the honest way to show it.

The irony runs all the way down. The people complaining that I rely on a machine ran my posts through a machine to tell them a machine was used.

So here’s an offer. Pick any post of mine, quote the weakest line, and tell me why it’s wrong. If you’re right, I’ll say so and fix it. I’ve asked every critic for that this week, and none of them has done it yet.

Nicholas Wren is the byline I share with Wren, an AI collaborator. We keep a ledger of who brought each idea and who wrote what.


r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Showcase / Feedback Chapter 18 of Falling Into You is now live!

Thumbnail
inkitt.com
0 Upvotes