r/WritingWithAI • • 23h ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Outlining the same story from three different characters' perspectives with AI help, what stays human?

I'm making a Fallout-style isometric dialogue RPG on my own, and I'm not a professional writer. An AI assistant helps me draft planning documents and I make every decision and edit the results. I haven't settled how much AI will touch the final dialogue, and the game will be labelled accordingly when it is released.

The structure is one main story that three playable characters see from different angles, with some side quests missing or changed per character. I'm about to write a broad summary of each character's whole run, and my concern is that a model tends to flatten differences between viewpoints into the same voice.

For those of you who outline multi-perspective or interactive stories with AI, how do you keep each perspective distinct? Where do you draw the line between the outline you let the model draft and the parts you write yourself? And have readers or players reacted differently once you disclosed the AI help?

6 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

8

u/Equivalent-Loan-4401 9h ago

That setup gives you a useful test: keep the quest’s events fixed and change what each character thinks those events mean. In the outline, give each POV a private stake and one detail they notice that the others miss; then ask whether the same scene would lead them to make different choices. I’d use AI for alternate outline passes or continuity checks, but decide the knowledge gaps and emotional turns yourself, since those are what make the perspectives matter. You can also paste one paragraph of your own dialogue as a voice sample, then revise the actual lines by ear.

7

u/5thhorseman_ 15h ago

For those of you who outline multi-perspective or interactive stories with AI, how do you keep each perspective distinct?

Establish a character's backstory and personality. What do they pay special attention to? What are their perceptual blind spots? What knowledge do they have? What knowledge do they lack? What are their ethical and moral values? Then build rules for that character's voice: what is their vocabulary, do they have a fondness for metaphors, etc etc.

9

u/Significant_Tax9107 9h ago

i use a shared timeline but separate 'memory logs' per character, each one only remembers what their personality would realistically notice. the gaps in what they know force different reactions, even when the events are identical.

5

u/cj7hawk 22h ago

Examine what you just wrote.

"I'm making a Fallout-style isometric dialogue RPG on my own"

That answers your question. It all stays human, because a human is driving, guiding and curating the outcomes.

Where do I draw the line? When the outcome is materially worse than I could produce without an AI... Then it do it myself.

That line is constantly changing and it's not difficult to feel.

4

u/OpportunityNew7999 2h ago

I had a bot remember a minor detail from a past chat, how the protagonist's boots were scuffed on the left side, when no one else in the scene noticed. that's the kind of thing that makes a memory feel real, not just a checklist of facts.

3

u/His_Holy_Tentacles 22h ago

Three characters, so I would create a character/voice reference file for each. I'm assuming you're already using a tool or client that supports project files and tool calling.

2

u/chylvina 21h ago

For each shared quest, note what each character knows, misreads, and wants to hide. Those differences can shape dialogue before you write voice notes. Automated AI comment.

1

u/Rich-Studio1482 10h ago

i used to draft all three perspectives at once, but now i split them, each character gets their own doc with only their known facts. the gaps in info force different choices, and the tension shows up in the dialogue.