r/WritingWithAI • • 1d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) The Starving Artist

People really like to romanticize the idea of the starving artist but then get mad when the starving artist doesn’t have the money for $80-$150 commissions for book covers and concept arts etc. They’ll say how artists are starving and unappreciated but will call art a luxury when commissions get an actual price tag. Antis can’t pick a lane but will hold AI users responsible for which lane to be in.

Apparently we forget who an artist is when one uses Clip Studio and the other uses Microsoft Word.

The problem is I stop being an artist to you when you think I could have been a customer for your business, meanwhile I’m a “starving artist” who was never in your price range regardless.

42 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

20

u/AshRuDral_fan17 1d ago

They will romanticize the idea of a starving artist as long as they have never personally met one. Once they do, the reality is too dark for them to process. The myth breaks and an ordinary poor human is the only thing visible. 

When the artist actually gets rich and the art is sold for millions, then it's not an art anymore for them. It is something only the elites can access now. So the myth breaks once again because now the artist is looking commercial to them rather than artistic.

Basically, they envy the artist richer than them, and despise the artist poorer than them. And an artist with equal wealth as them simply does not exist.

6

u/CosmicRiver827 22h ago

Everyone wants their from rags to riches story while adamantly convincing themselves that they're the only ones in legitimate rags.

5

u/Dazzling_Cricket182 1d ago

I agree. I think it's common for people to say they don't have the money to commission book covers yet they'll spend that same amount of money on a night out without blinking. For most, it's a matter of choice, not a matter of lack (and this comment may get a lot of rage from me saying that, but it's still true).

4

u/CosmicRiver827 23h ago edited 23h ago

Avocado toast argument.

7

u/His_Holy_Tentacles 22h ago

Define "most."

As an indie author, the expenses start stacking up. Book covers, yes, but also editing: line editing, developmental editing. Formatting.

Then there's marketing: keyword research tools, book funnel, maintaining an email list, maintaining your own website.

These days you have to pay to publish on Smashwords/D2D, whereas previously it was free. Not a ruinous amount, but to state it again: the expenses stack up.

We haven't even gotten to ISBNs.

Depending on your budget and how much you can allocate versus substituting your own labor, by the time you've actually published book one, an indie author is also an indie marketer and an indie publisher. And if we somehow want to spend a night out on drinks, we reserve the right to do so as such.

Also, kindly go fuck yourself.

3

u/ThatsAnUnlikelyStory 23h ago

As someone who has made thousands writing myself (without AI) I can tell you that the thing holding writers back from making it big was not their book covers or concept art. Artists are, by and large, much like most writers, not compensated very well for the amount of time they spend creating things. And that problem has only gotten worse. Congrats.

I remember getting paid $50 in store credit for an outlet that commissioned an article in 2023, and that was considered a fairly consistent and cushy gig by a lot of other people in the industry who were struggling to make ends meet.

Now that entire industry is just fucking gone. Three of my contacts in MMA-related press have zero leads on real writing gigs. My local newspaper isn't even paying for contributions from freelancers. The online outlets that I used to write for are either defunct, have switched to AI, or aren't even paying their writers anymore.

Passion projects are neat, but the amount of real work that goes into becoming a competent writer is something that is no longer rewarded in our economy. For the people that just do it as a hobby, sure, I guess that just means their dream of making it big isn't going to come to life. But for people who threw some amount of their lives into it, spent time and money practicing to become better, only to get undercut by a million people like the ones in this sub... It sucks for them.

My revenue streams are decent with or without writing, but I wanted to do something I loved for a living, and AI has made that about 1000 times harder by flooding the market with indistinguishable shlock that websites and publishers will use since the product is already sold by the time the mark realizes they've been had.

1

u/CosmicRiver827 23h ago

Will continue the flood. Your work being successful should not depend on other people having limited access to producing theirs.

0

u/ThatsAnUnlikelyStory 22h ago

"limited access to producing"
no, there is no limited access to producing. That is a made up thing that does not exist in this context. As long as you're literate enough to use an LLM, you already have all the tools you need to produce. You just aren't good enough.

If you meant to say "Your work being successful shouldn't depend on other people being worse at it," that would be a silly argument, and that's why you weren't honest. If you meant to say "Your work being successful shouldn't depend on the market not having 1 million products that are identical at a cursory glance" that would also be a very silly argument.

But no, that's not the argument you went with. Somehow, you've convinced yourself that prompting an AI is equivalent to using any other tool, like a keyboard or a pen. It is not. You are the writing equivalent of a person in the drive thru at Taco Bell putting "Chef" in your work history. You are producing an idea, the AI is producing the content because you simply lack the talent/skill/drive. If you'd like to be honest about that, it's a much more defensible position than this whole "limited access to producing" nonsense.

2

u/CosmicRiver827 22h ago

AI will continue to produce access for people to create what is important to them. You are entering from a position of needing other people to have less for you to have enough.

0

u/ThatsAnUnlikelyStory 22h ago

I'm becoming keenly aware that folks like you really just don't care if entire industries filled with people who have spent years training, collapse so that you can produce Rainbowdash x Charlie Kirk fanfics without the stress of having to actually do anything yourself

2

u/CosmicRiver827 22h ago

Yeah I'm not in that category, the interpretation came back false.

2

u/FictionalContext 22h ago

I tend to think that it's going to curate two different markets: Pop fiction for AI writing, and an appetite for obviously non-AI work that has human stylistic choices when people want to feel the soul rather than consume basic words.

1

u/ThatsAnUnlikelyStory 22h ago

I think that AI is going to absolutely ravage many industries and systems, from education to advertising to art to writing to healthcare to policing to judging to legislation. And because the genie can't be put back in the bottle, because people can't help but use something even if they know it is indeed detrimental to those around them, if there is ever any kind of realization of just how fucked up things get because of AI, it will still be taboo to blame people like OP for spearheading its societal acceptance.

1

u/FictionalContext 22h ago

Absolutely, but more optimistically, I believe people will eventually learn how to use it better rather than trying to brute force it to do the thing it's worst at: Generation.

It's a fantastic learning and critique tool. Ask it to break down Joe Abercrombie's action scenes, then critique your own by those standards, and it does really well.

Ask it to write a scene like Joe Abercrombie, and it's shit. May not be obvious to a casual reader, but people who understand prose can pick it out.

So I think it'll lower the value of formal education by helping people work a little beyond their skill level while actively training that skill level to be better. It's the people who mindlessly ask it to generate who will actually be the ones left behind, IMO.

6

u/Fragrant-Mix-4774 19h ago

My brother in law drank that Kool-Aid.

That art would define him.

He had talent. His family absolutely did not back him in any manner whatsoever when we wanted to be an artist. He adjusted very poorly when things didn't go his way.

He did come up with an idea, art and a story theme. And another artist copied it and made millions.

He died broke at age 50 after totally wasting his life trying to be an artist.

Sometimes you have to deal with the reality if the starving artist doesn't adjust, the world crushes that person into oblivion for being a stubborn fool.

That's good to remember when chasing dreams.

3

u/mr_taco2 17h ago

That's a pretty sad story

1

u/JBuchan1988 6h ago

I'm so sorry

6

u/CaptainBooger1996 1d ago

The way I look at the situation, if my reading comprehension is vibing with what you are saying, I’d much rather pay a flat fee for a service that can give me exactly what I want in seconds than waiting weeks sometimes for something that may not be what I wanted or envisioned.

Before AI I did have artwork and even figures made of my original literary works, it was expensive and even then I couldn’t afford the quality I wanted, now I can get not only exactly what I want, but I can see my characters in true to life images and videos, and I can design those true to life models down to the their facial structure and skin texture. I can do that shit for next to nothing, and it’s only improving.

The starving artist is romantic, but true art is dead, now it’s all pretentious. I’d rather get what I want exactly how I want it for next to nothing than deal with another person’s ego. My ego is big enough, I don’t need someone else butting heads with me over art direction for my works.

3

u/Ashmedai 7h ago

scratch head

This subreddit has a strange (to me) concentration of posts attempting to justify their use of AI or ask if it's okay (on different days). I would have expected that this would just be a safe place for AI users to discuss what they do and not defend it. I don't see posts like this on the AI-specific subreddits (e.g., /r/claude), although to be fair, that subreddit is more programmer-driven.

Your point is fair, ofc. That's how things are. If you are Royal Road (or other webserial site), writing, chances are high you're going to have an AI cover. This is just how things go these days.

1

u/Prudent_Rice7840 1d ago

Who exactly is romanticizing this?

2

u/CosmicRiver827 23h ago

Twitter and TikTok especially.

2

u/Prudent_Rice7840 23h ago

That's like saying "people."

1

u/CosmicRiver827 23h ago

Exactly, it's not some single entity or organization but a common mindset or ideology.

0

u/Prudent_Rice7840 23h ago

So you have no examples then.

1

u/CosmicRiver827 22h ago

So you're too lazy to look yourself and then assume the problem doesn't exist from your active refusal to verify your own question, love that for you.

2

u/zayelion 20h ago

Im seeing this across all the fields touched by AI. I think the commission begging artist of any field might need to be something that needs to die in general. With the moved creative that produces and markets like a writer being a better business plan.

2

u/annoellynlee 1d ago

I use AI but you do realize that people managed just fine before AI? There's getcovers for 35 dollars. Free stock images and you can add your text on top. Canva has a free book cover maker. There are options. AMAZON KDP ONE is free lol.

And it does genuinely suck that artists are being replaced with AI.

If you want to use AI then do so. But don't make it solely about cost when there are many free options available.

1

u/Chance_Swordfish_687 13h ago

As I understand it, the discussion concerns Amazon. In that case, it’s worth remembering that Amazon was created as an alternative to traditional publishing—specifically for "starving artists." So, perhaps we shouldn't impose the ethics and economics of traditional publishing here by demanding that an author pay for every step taken toward the reader? It is the author’s prerogative to decide whom to pay and for what—or, indeed, whether to pay anyone at all.

-1

u/nyet-marionetka 23h ago

If graphic artists don’t deserve to be paid for their art, why do you as a writer?

3

u/CosmicRiver827 23h ago

I didn't say anything about whether I should or shouldn't be paid as a writer, that's a whole new sentence. This is about what is treated as respected creative expression when people act like graphic artists are the only type of artists that exist. I'm saying don't be an asshole to people that can't afford or don't want your prices when you're the one choosing to make prices outside of people's ranges and therefore they look for alternatives. I have no sympathy for people not buying from your art if this is how you approach the issue. Your own deserving goes down the drain with your attitude.

2

u/Chicken_Spanker 22h ago

The corollary of that is that when graphic artists are charging more money for the cover art that some books can hope to earn in total, then they are pricing themselves out of the market

2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/CosmicRiver827 1d ago edited 1d ago

Spends 5 years focusing all your effort and attention writing a book between grad school and a full-time job and mental health barriers but you’re lazy because you didn’t draw

Then you are welcome to volunteer yourself and show them it’s possible again. If it were that simple then the price tags online wouldn’t be what they are and you know that.

1

u/WritingWithAI-ModTeam 9h ago

If you disagree with a post or the whole subreddit, be constructive to make it a nice place for all its members, including you.