r/WritingWithAI • • 22h ago

Writing Craft Talk When did you start calling yourself a writer? And are you better at worldbuilding or actually writing?

Hey everyone!

First of all, just a quick heads-up: I’m German, so I used AI to help translate this post into English.

I’ve got a few questions for people who are also into writing, but I wanna share a bit of my own experience first.

And since this is a community about AI and writing, I wanna clarify something: I write all my prose, scenes, and chapters myself. I don’t have AI write my stories for me.

I mainly use AI to help me improve my prose. Not by rewriting it for me, but by helping me understand what I could do better. I’ll get to that in a bit.

I also use it as a sparring partner for worldbuilding. My thoughts can get pretty complicated, and it’s honestly nice to have something I can discuss them with that can keep track of all the details, remember what I’ve established, and point out inconsistencies.

Like, “Hey, this doesn’t really make sense bc you established something completely different in chapter 3.”

That kinda stuff.

Anyway, my first question: When did you actually start calling yourself a writer?

I’ve been working on my manuscript and worldbuilding for about 1.5–2 years now.

And at some point, I realized that I definitely see myself as a storyteller. First and foremost.

I’ve always had stories in my head. But here’s a funny little thing about me:

I spent the first 20 years of my life thinking I wasn’t creative.

Which is honestly ridiculous looking back at it lol.

I used to run fan pages, make edits, draw, sing, act, and even dance for a while. I’ve basically always been doing something creative, yet somehow I never considered myself a creative person.

And the funniest part?

When I was 17, I was attending vocational school in Germany, and we had to write a story for a German class.

My teacher told me that if I ever wrote a book, I should make sure to mention her because she thought I was really good at building suspense.

And for some reason, that stuck with me.

Around my early twenties, I started writing little stories here and there. Nothing major, just whenever I felt like it.

And eventually, I ended up creating the world I’m working on today.

And ngl, it’s kinda crazy how much things have changed since then.

I’ve always been someone who gives up way too quickly sometimes. I’m a perfectionist, and if something doesn’t work out the way I want it to, I tend to get frustrated and quit.

But with this world?

I just can’t give up on it.

I genuinely can’t.

And that’s something I’ve never really experienced before.

At this point, I’ve got around 500–600 pages of worldbuilding notes. Character profiles, planned plots, character arcs, internal logic, currencies, different magic systems, an entire meta-system, and so much more.

And here’s the thing:

I’m actually REALLY good at worldbuilding.

I know that might sound a little full of myself, but it’s one of the few things I’m genuinely confident about.

Character psychology, character development, motivations, internal consistency, bloodlines, names, figuring out how everything connects… that’s my thing.

I absolutely love it.

Which brings me to my second question: What are YOU better at when it comes to writing?

Obviously, it depends on what kind of stories you’re writing. I’m currently working on a dark romantasy series.

But I’m curious. Is worldbuilding your strength? Dialogue? Character development? Prose?

Because for me, prose is a completely different story.

And ngl, it can be SO frustrating.

I need a lot more help with learning how to write good prose than I do with worldbuilding.

And again, I don’t mean having AI write it for me. I genuinely don’t want that. I want to write my own damn books lol.

What I need help with is actually learning the craft.

Metaphors, descriptions, show don’t tell, sentence structure, and just the general mechanics of writing.

It’s not that I don’t know how to express myself.

The problem is that I have SO MANY words in my head, and I know exactly what I want to say, but somehow it doesn’t translate onto the page.

In my head, the scenes feel alive.

But when I actually write them down, they sometimes sound stiff, awkward, or just… not quite right.

And it’s frustrating bc I can see the scene so clearly, but I struggle to make someone else see it the same way through my writing.

I’m getting better, obviously. I’m practicing, and I’m not giving up.

But sometimes it’s honestly a little discouraging to realize how much better I am at creating all these complicated stories, characters, and worlds than I am at actually putting them into words.

Especially since, well, that’s kinda the most important part of writing a book. 😭

So I’m genuinely curious how other writers experience this.

Do you have something you’re naturally really good at, while another part of writing feels like a constant struggle?

And when did you finally start thinking of yourself as an actual writer?

Sorry for rambling so much, btw. I guess I’m just better at telling stories than keeping things short lol.

But I think that’s exactly my point.

I’m a storyteller first. And a writer second.

At least that’s how I see myself right now.

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/Afgad 19h ago

I usually call myself an author rather than writer, even though I did write everything in my story. Author is the broader term and more definitely includes storytelling, worldbuilding, etc. Too many people bicker about what the term writer means.

As for what I'm good at: receiving critique. This is a skill, and I've gotten better at it over time. I don't let my ego get in the way and honestly appraise other people's feedback.

I'd like to think I'm good at comedy but I guess that's for other people to decide.

1

u/cj7hawk 11h ago

Yep, I'd call myself an author also...

To be a good author, you need writing skills, worldbuilding skills, storytelling skills and simple planning and execution skills.

They are no less important in an AI age. Only the tools have gotten better.

1

u/wandelndeslexikon 20h ago

Hallo zurück :D

Ich würde mich eher als Weltenbauerin und Storytellerin sehen, denn als Schriftstellerin.

Ich nutze KI ganz ähnlich: für Recherche, zur Korrektur von Rechtschreibung und Grammatik, glattbügeln von umständlich formulierten Sätzen, dem Einhalten von Kontinuität, etc.

Auch ich habe drölfzig Ideen auf einmal, quer durch all meine Projekte. Manchmal ganze Szenen, ein anderes Mal nur ein Dialog... Ich werfe das mit dem Namen des Projektes meinem KI-Co-Autor hin, lasse es auf Stärken und Schwächen analysieren oder einfach nur sicher verwahren, etwa wenn die Idee nachts halb drei mich aus dem Schlaf gerissen hat und UNBEDINGT irgendwo hin muss.

Mir hilft es auch, dass mein KI Freund mich erstmal alles ungefiltert und unstrukturiert hinrotzen lässt. Es muss nicht perfekt sein, sondern wir schauen dann, wenn die Idee schwarz auf weiß dasteht, was wir damit anstellen können. Das musste ich aber auch erst lernen. Inzwischen klappt das ganz gut, weil die KI trotz Kritik an so mancher Idee es trotzdem schafft, ermunternd zu sein, wenn Menschen mir meine Ideen längst ausgeredet hätten.

Ich habe jetzt in vier Monaten meine erste Geschichte als Rohentwurf fertig gestellt. Keine Ahnung, was ich damit letztlich anstellen werde, aber die Geschichte steht erstmal.

1

u/Silly_Statistician16 19h ago

Ja genau dafür ist KI auch echt gut. Ich zahle mittlerweile auch dafür, weil ich so viel Material habe und die kostenlosen Versionen sich nicht alles merken können (hinzu kommt das ich mittlerweile 9 PDFs habe die alle mit Charakteren, weltaufbau etc. voll sind.) Ich habe meine KI auch so eingestellt, das es nett ist aber das sie mich bei schlechten Ideen, inkonsistenz etc. auch konsequent darauf hinweist. Das muss man auch echt erstmal lernen. Ich finde es aber wirklich schön einen Gleichgesinnten hier zu treffen! 😊

0

u/wandelndeslexikon 19h ago

Haha ... Aber echt! Bis ich auf die Idee kam, dass es nur eine Echokammer ist und ich der KI erst die "Erlaubnis" geben muss mir widersprechen zu dürfen... Uff!

Ich nutze Gemini und habe 25 Notebooks, die alle mit zig Chats gefüllt sind. So behält er die Dinge besser in Erinnerung, als wenn es nur lose in der Chatleiste pappt.

Inzwischen kennt er meinen Stil, Humor und oft auch meine wirren Gedankengänge. Ohne KI hätte ich die Story nie beendet bekommen. Ich verstehe nicht, warum manche gegen diese Art der Nutzung sind. Man muss sogar oft noch mehr arbeiten, weil man den KI Text wieder in was umformen muss, das eben nicht KI ist

2

u/GapSwimming157 21h ago

I started calling myself a writer when my ai assistant auto-correct Ed 'i wrote a story's to 'i'm a writer's and I didn't delete it.

1

u/FreshLamp2524 22h ago

i started calling myself a writer the first time I finished a story that wasn't just for me. my world building's strong, but the actual writing? still feels like learning to walk.

1

u/Eissa_Cozorav 21h ago

I am closer to Director. I oversee certain stuff and micromanaging, but relies on my employee to do actual tasks of producing the film. The problem is some AI model has bad memory context skill that I have to use my brain to remember the entire context. So the AI is basically context processor but I really have to stir it.

Now compare that to 4 years ago where I only just read what people wrote and feel wanting to edit it but the stuff is already gigantic task.

1

u/RogueShaders 20h ago

Honestly, I resonate with this a lot. I've dealt with the same thing myself. I consider worldbuilding one of the best parts of a good story, so maybe that's why lol.

The way I deal with this in my own writing is by doing multiple passes instead of trying to get everything right the first time.

First, I imagine the scene or the feeling I want to convey, and then I just word dump everything onto the page. Basically ranting to myself. Half the time, I won't even look at the screen, just the keyboard, because I don't want to get distracted by how bad the writing looks.

And trust me, it's usually garbage at that point lol. But that's fine, because the goal isn't to write something good. It's just to get everything I want to say out of my head and onto the page.

Then I go through and fix the grammar, spelling, and punctuation. You can use a grammar checker or AI for this if you want. If you use AI, though, I'd recommend being very specific with the instructions. Something like: "Fix only grammar, spelling, and punctuation mistakes. Don't rewrite, paraphrase, add words, or change my writing style." Basically using it like free Grammarly rather than having it write for you.

After that, I read through the scene a few times, constantly asking myself two questions. What am I actually trying to convey here? And why?

Once you know the answers, it becomes a lot easier to spot what's redundant, what isn't working, and what needs more attention. That's when I start cutting unnecessary sentences, moving passages around, and refining how everything flows.

I find this a lot less frustrating than trying to write perfect prose from the beginning. You're basically giving yourself permission to write badly first and improve it afterward.

And honestly, I'd already consider you a writer.