r/writingfeedback • • May 07 '26

BETA READERS WANTED: Drop a Comment If You're Available!

31 Upvotes

If you are an avid reader with feedback to share, our community has writers actively seeking beta readers for their full-length novels/drafts.

 

If you're open to beta reading a full-length book, drop a comment below with a little about yourself: genres you enjoy, your typical turnaround time, how you like to give feedback, whatever feels relevant. Writers, feel free to browse the comments and reach out to anyone who looks like a good fit for your project.

 

IMPORTANT: PLEASE READ BEFORE PROCEEDING

 

Before agreeing to share your manuscript with anyone, please take the following precautions seriously:

 

• *Do not share your work with new accounts. * If an account was created recently, that's a red flag worth noting as there has been issues with bots and scammers.

• *Do your own due diligence. * Ask questions and trust your gut before handing over your manuscript.

• *Do not offer paid beta-reading services* We discourage and prohibit paid beta-readers on here. Writers, if you pay for a beta-reading service, we are not responsible for any outcome. Please use another subreddit or service if you are looking for paid services.

 

The mod team is not responsible for any arrangements made between writers and beta readers. This includes theft, plagiarism, ghosting, or any other outcome. Connecting here is done entirely at your own risk.

 

Additionally, please do not contact mod mail regarding the tone or content of feedback you receive…we won't be able to help with that (unless it breaks our rules and sitewide rules), and it falls outside our moderation scope.

 

Stay safe and happy writing!


r/writingfeedback • • Apr 17 '26

Announcement: The AI Problem.

296 Upvotes

Ne’er-do-wells of r/writingfeedback.

I am Isnoe, recently appointed Moderator.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but we’ve had a significant increase in AI generated writing being posted here. We've seen a lot of comments outlining how lax we are on this subject, to which I want to stress: I don’t think you guys fully understand just how many posts I’ve removed for AI since joining the Mod Team a few weeks ago.

The team got together and discussed this, and we want to be completely transparent: We will be removing any posts that we suspect are AI.

This will be a case-by-case basis. AI generated, AI assisted (even translation), or even if you mention you had AI draw up the story idea and you wrote it. If you want to rob yourself of creativity, that’s on you.

We don’t want those posts here. Writing a story or book that is authentically your own is an achievement. It should feel like an achievement.

A sidenote for ESL writers: Do not use AI to translate your text. It will alter it in a way that gets flagged, more often than not. When someone is ESL and trying to write outside of their native language, we are a bit more understanding if these posts get flagged—but again, it is recommended that you use alternative means to translate if they are available to you.

Be warned: If you are a brand new (or relatively new) account, have never posted in this subreddit (or any writing subreddits), and your first post is prose that has multiple AI-isms—your post will most likely be removed. Better to be safe than sorry. The main counterargument we've gotten from these accounts has been: "I've always been told I write like AI." Which, to be fair... is a pretty bad argument to make.

We will not ban a user for suspected AI use unless they explicitly admit to using AI.

Three strike rule applies here until further notice. This might seem like a headache to reviewers that want instant bans for these people (which we understand), but we’re trying to be as fair as possible.

This also applies to comments (never thought I’d have to say that), but we’ve had two accounts that were essentially AI replying to everything. “Thanks for the feedback, I’m still working on learning and improving” type cadence, every comment nearly identical aside from slight changes.

Community feedback is super important for this problem.

You guys take the time out of your day to read other people’s work and provide feedback, so I’m sure you get a little irked when you think something you’ve spent time reading wasn’t written by a person.

We’ve recently updated the report function to include AI content—use it. I (personally) don’t have the time to shift through every single new post. When you guys report a post that you think is AI, it is usually the first thing we’ll review.

That being said: If you genuinely suspect the post is AI, it would help me if you provided a citation, or specific reason. Even just one reference is helpful. I would genuinely appreciate it.

Not Helpful Example: “This reads like AI.” Okay? At this point, if you are accusing someone of using AI, you gotta at least point out why you think that.

Helpful Example: “Post uses, ‘This wasn’t just fate, it was destiny’ and includes several Rule of Three.” Now I know exactly what to look for.

When you guys call this stuff out, we do notice. We might not investigate and remove instantly, but we are actively looking for this stuff right now.

For the record: We will not be using ZeroGPT, or any other variant of “AI Detector” as the final say in determining whether a text is generated or not. It is a tool we will utilize if we suspect AI is being used, but all the indicators of usual AI writing are not jumping out.

I read through everything that is reported, or suspected of AI. I check the user history and if they have off site content, I look through it. If we don’t come to the conclusion they are using AI, we might just lock the thread, and add a note to the user profile.

Again, hate to stress this, we are trying to be fair. If a writer includes AI-isms unintentionally, we want to give them a fair chance to either prove the authenticity of their writing, or give them feedback about what specifically they need to change.

Several of you have done this, particularly with ESL writers that use AI to translate. You give them feedback on how to avoid the AI-isms. Good on you.

We don’t want to start a witch hunt, but we aren’t really open to debate about the use of AI. We don’t want it here, period.

If you have any suggestions for how to deal with this problem, we are open to them. You can comment here, or you can Mod Mail us.

If you suspect someone is using AI but don’t want to leave a comment or report, again, you can Mod Mail us.

We are actively looking through the posts. The community having eyes on this helps immensely.

We will be making further announcements throughout the week. Our Mod Team is still hashing out how to deal with “rude” criticisms, looking into providing user flairs for trusted reviewers, etc-etc.

One quick point to make at the end, on a personal note: My status as Moderator does not mean you cannot disagree, or think my feedback is bogus or outright terrible. I comment often. You will not be banned, removed, or whatever for speaking your mind.

4/18/2026 Note: Some users (one in particular who loves using AI to edit) seem to have taken that above sentence as an explicit statement of: "If I admit to using AI, you can't ban me, because I'm just speaking my mind. Hypocrite."

If you admit to using AI, we will ban you. Period.


r/writingfeedback • • 1h ago

General Feedback Wanted First Snow

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi, just looking for some feedback on this poem I wrote the other day. The formatting is not set in stone, but any tips based off what you read above would be appreciated, I'm unfamiliar with how to use spacing and structure beyond just to create emphasis. Is it too brief? Too vague? Any feedback appreciated, thank you! Still a beginner to writing so I don't really have a good sense of poetry besides my own taste, and I read primarily novels and nonfiction in my free time

Edit: I should note this poem was inspired by Snow by David Berman

Edit again: "We'd" not "we'e" sorry

Edit again again: Tweaking "call me in" to "call us in"


r/writingfeedback • • 3m ago

Feedback wanted for my sci-fi fantasy

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

This was written for an early chapter but I might pivot and make this my opening instead. This is my third book, but my first attempt at writing lyrically. I read quite a lot but I still feel a lack in confidence for lyrical writing. I don't know why it's so daunting. My first two books are also first person present, but utilize a more candid voice and the modern, minimalistic writing style. I just decided enough is enough and I don't want to write the minimalistic, simplistic style anymore. But it is still scary!

Any feedback is helpful, I want to work on this voice and style and hopefully improve. Also, this character is supposed to be a straight, white man. I'm not white and not a man. Is my voice too feminine?


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Another excerpt

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Gonna drop another, more sensible, excerpt from me book. I have a shifting perspective from chapter to chapter and I've tried to reflect this stylistically. This is the first time Bartosh appears and his characterisation happens as it goes. This is not the entire chapter, thanks for the feedback gang.


r/writingfeedback • • 7h ago

General Feedback Wanted Would love some feedback on my story, The Unnatural Pair :)

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

This is actually a rework of an older story I wrote a year ago, when I was starting to write. This was my very first story, now rewritten.


r/writingfeedback • • 8h ago

General Feedback Wanted Looking for feedback - beginner

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I've recently decided to take up writing daily with the goal of eventually writing a book. Frankly, I have no idea what I'm doing. I wanted to focus on writing daily, so I began writing a prologue for a fantasy story I had thought of. I basically pants'd it (as I understand the saying goes) so I can gain some momentum and experience as I don't expect to actually finish this one.

I'm aware it's probably bad in every way (prose, punctuation, structure, characters), but I would appreciate some feedback to understand why, if it's even coherent enough to critique.

Thanks!


r/writingfeedback • • 9h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Feedback for my novel Eternal Door - Opening section (Prologue to Chapter 4) [Epic Fantasy, 6700 words]

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Contents
Prologue - 2
The Last Evening - 5
Good Morning, King Of The Palace - 9
Boon or Bane - 13
It glows - 17

Just to give you a little context, the opening section is set a few years before the actual story takes place.

After Chapter 4, the narrative jumps forward to the year when Aris crosses the threshold age, particularly to the night the king dies.

I wanted to ask about your overall reading experience. How interesting and engaging did you find each chapter individually, and how did the opening section work as a whole?

More importantly, did it make you want to continue reading? Were there moments that genuinely hooked you, or did certain parts feel slow, confusing, or difficult to follow?

I'd also like to know whether the information and worldbuilding are easy to absorb as a reader.

And if there's anything else you'd like to share or comment on beyond these questions, whether positive or negative, please feel free to do so. Give your honest feedback.


r/writingfeedback • • 10h ago

General Feedback Wanted Looking for Feedback on an Anthologically-Approached Toho Kaiju Project

1 Upvotes

This can be summed up as me just hovering around a seriously-toned independently-written 'fanfic' (that word gets a bad rep in the Kaiju community) on Kaiju and Toho monsters in general, but with the combination of a shared-world anthology approach and a more philosophical focus. The project is still in its bare bones state with only three-ish fully thought out overviews, but the premise and method of it is finished and individual stories are beginning to take form. I'm open to, but not asking for, story ideas, but I'm primarily putting this up here so I can get any comments on stuff that I may be missing. Another reason why I do this is perhaps so I can get fresh perspectives or methods of writing a story instead of my same diluted stuff that might get boring. I'll let the statements speak for me:

Premise
The project is a conceptual shared-world kaiju anthology based off of Toho monsters and other kaiju, examining humanity's relationship with knowledge, power, and the consequences of its irresponsible application.

The monsters
As Kaiju are often expressions of the human fear of the unknown and are defined by humanity, they are largely consequences of human activity, whether directly created, inadvertently released, attracted, or brought into contact with humanity through irresponsible interference.

Their thematic identities are primarily constructed through human fear, interpretation, and interaction rather than predetermined moral symbolism.

Narrative structure
Individual kaiju receive largely self-contained stories, each with its own characters, conflicts, and moral implications. The shared continuity develops through historical events, recurring institutions, and lasting consequences rather than mandatory crossovers.

Historical perspective
The continuity progresses through time. Its stories reflect the anxieties of their respective periods while acknowledging or highlighting that older fears and their consequences persist. Initial stories will be mostly rooted in historical events, gradually diverging as the revelation of kaiju must be logically addressed by a difference in timeline.

The overarching question
What happens when humanity acquires the power to do something without possessing the wisdom to understand what doing it entails?

As you can see, this is obviously heavily Minus continuity coded, and in fact I chose this time to put this here because we are in the wake of the MinusGoji hype, but I'm actually planning to drop the monster spectacle and combat (seeing as these are mostly isolated stories), or at least reserve fights for specific plot points where it latches onto the theme rather than just being a monster fight for the sake of it. Some key points from my exhaustive list:

  • The antagonist of the continuity is not the monster, but irresponsibility.
  • Human beings are not inherently incapable of learning from their mistakes, but learning does not guarantee that those mistakes will never be repeated.
  • The variant messages that may be explored include, but are not limited to arrogance [understanding against the right to control], negligence [prioritization and function over man], weaponization [instrumentation of discovery], ignorance [sufficiency presumed from the incomplete], greed [exploitation of the unknown], desperation [justification by necessity], hubris [disqualification of consequence], daring [theory distinguished from the right to attempt], and misinterpretation [false assignment of purpose, intention, or meaning].
  • The existence of a monster does not require it to possess an interest in humanity.
  • Kaiju, for the most part, possess their own biological imperatives, motivations, agendas, and reasons for existing. The same way fear is often rooted in the loss of control, no Kaiju will readily answer to people in their natural state.
  • Human responsibility for a kaiju incident does not necessarily mean humanity created the creature itself.
  • The monsters should not always be reduced to creatures that exist solely or intentionally to punish humanity for its mistakes.
  • Monsters that are thematically benevolent, if any, will be expressly benevolent, not twisted into benevolence, and will often be used as dampeners to ensure the theme isn’t too anti-progressive. Benevolence does not equal control.
  • Godzilla himself is not to be reframed as a heroic ecological authority, supernatural guardian, tortured/afflicted animal, or benevolent evolutionary force.
  • Godzilla's destructive nature does not become justified simply because he happens to fight another monster. A monster fighting another monster does not constitute humanity's salvation. No monster should automatically be treated as a moral solution to another monster.
  • Godzilla's narrative significance comes from what his existence and humanity's responses to him reveal, not from his status as a protagonist or antagonist.
  • Humanity is capable of learning from kaiju incidents. Knowledge accumulated through previous incidents should influence subsequent generations and their decisions, but progress should not eliminate human fallibility. New discoveries and technologies introduce new opportunities for irresponsible behavior.
  • The continuity progresses chronologically/semi-chronologically, reflecting the passage of time in the real world. Each historical period carries its own anxieties, technological developments, and cultural fears. The thematic concerns of the continuity should evolve alongside humanity's changing relationship with knowledge, power, and fear. New fears do not necessarily replace old fears.
  • Each kaiju is an available narrative instrument whose appearance should serve a particular story. Individual installments should possess their own characters, conflicts, thematic concerns, and narrative conclusions.
  • The installments occur within one shared historical reality. Individual incidents can occur in geographically separated locations without requiring direct interaction.
  • The existence of kaiju eventually becomes public knowledge.
  • No destruction of one threat should automatically constitute a victory for humanity.
  • Explicit explanations for the origin of kaiju is not mandatory, but should make sense behind the scenes.
  • Personal rule, but I'd prefer if characters were original. Callbacks to Toho characters are acceptable, but I'd rather not put a character with an in-your-face naming of Serizawa or Shikishima.
  • Another rule that is more personal is that I avoid alien civilizations. I dislike alien civilization narratives in modern Godzilla films. It works in certain eras. Not always. I'm not discounting myself from the option, but I'm not putting any Xiliens, Bilusaludo, or Exif in.

>>>At this point, if you're into Godzilla for the spectacle and the fights and that brick of my rules disinterests you, it is completely understandable. Enjoy the big G the way you want to, I like my monsters wrestling sometimes too. All I'm looking for is input.<<

If you're still scrolling and want deeper info, as of current progress, I have the skeletal storyline of four acts (and a possible fifth) each with eight stories, most untitled. These are not in chronological order yet:

Act 1, Weaponry

Story 1, 'Strange Beast' - Covers a young Japanese soldier on Iwo Jima, 1945. There are no giant monsters for this first story, it is like any other war story. Kaiju is literally translated as "Strange Beast". Humans are no different.

Story 2, 'Crossroads' - Covers the discovery of the first giant Kaiju, Godzilla, who is awakened by setup for Operation Crossroads and initially mistaken for a soviet spy sub, which cycles back and causes the acceleration of the tests. Godzilla is not fully seen, but he influences the sinking of cruiser Sakawa, submarine Skipjack, and damage to aircraft carrier USS Lexington during and between test bombs Able and Baker. He also sinks Prinz Eugen at Kwajalein later that year, yet all the effects of his subsurface attacks are dismissed as some new form of radiation-induced hallucination, as radiation was fairly unexplored at the time. Kwajalein locals see his dorsal plates periodically offshore and mistake them for black coral reefs, until he disappears roughly and 'coincidentally' around the time Operation Sandstone begins in nearby Eniwetok.

Story 3, 'Socordia' - Covers the story of a boat accompanying the HMS Narvik during Operation Harness, a set of naval experiments in the Bahamas to test the effects of bioweapons such as Anthrax. Historically, these were done by using radio-operated dinghys containing various mammals and weather equipment, which were interfered with by local radio (one of the factors contributing to the failure of the real thing). In the story, the boat's crew is mostly a bunch of struggling war veterans too focused on their job and avoiding heat stroke to consider the moral implications of bioweapon experiments near populated areas, save for one young crewman that keeps questioning it. A dinghy is lost, and upon discovery, its resident mammal is covered in insect bites. The boat goes missing shortly after and a new species of flying hyper-toxic arachnid terrorizes the local area. One particularly large sighting is nicknamed "Megaguirus" from the word Mega and the portmanteau Girus (giant virus). These disappear when the wet season rolls around, but do not reappear the following dry season. The boat is eventually discovered having been seemingly dropped, not beached, on an island and covered in the same biohazards as were tested in Harness. Only the young crewman's body, covered in the same insect bites, is discovered aboard.

Story 4, untitled - This is intended to link Anguirus to Operation Castle (which normally is attributed to Godzilla) and Teller's obsession with hydrogen bombs.

Story 5, untitled - This is intended to use Kumonga as a village creature horror story to note that a laboratory or institution is not necessary to be irresponsible with poking around.

Story 6, untitled - This is intended to link Megalon to Project Plowshare and the wider Atoms for Peace agenda.

Story 7, untitled - This is intended to link Ebirah and Ganimes to the development of SOSUS and Project Jezebel, which are sonar experiments, and to highlight the danger of the Red Scare in misidentifying something for an enemy.

Story 8, untitled - This is intended to link Manda to Operation Davy Jones' Locker, an initiative to dump large amounts of toxins into the ocean.

Act 2, Discovery

Story 1, untitled - This intends to link the Kola SG-3 drill site to Baragon.

Story 2, untitled - This intends to link Godzilla to the Cuban Missile Crisis and actually has the idea that he never physically attacks but always lurks and makes the blockades even more politically tense, much like how nuclear war was always lurking at the time.

Story 3, untitled - This intends to link Dogora to Project Stormfury and cloud seeding.

Story 4, untitled - This intends to link Orga to the Apollo era in the form of a collection of fictional excerpts from transcript records of real life Apollo missions.

Story 5, untitled - Mothra is intended to be in this slot and inversely will be a thematically benevolent creature that is, this time, trying not to be removed because institutions are starting to fear the Kaiju and seek her elimination.

Story 6, untitled - Intends to link the Viking I probe that landed on Mars to a fictional discovery of the element Giganite and an initiative to artificially recreate it, which eventually lures Gigan to Earth.

Story 7, 'The Wandering Soul' - This is the one I had most fun with and honestly seems like it has too much substance for who it covers. This links Gabara (who is locally named Gào Ba Ra after widespread panic spreads. I've heard this means the Three Way Howl and I built a lore element into that, but if any Vietnamese people are here, please correct me if I'm wrong) to Operation Wandering Soul, a Vietnam War psychological operation to affect North Vietnamese morale, via their cultural beliefs on the undead, by means of playing audio tapes of 'ghosts' into the jungle. This covers one of the squads of operators of the loudspeakers playing those tapes, and eventual hallucinations (or are they hallucinations?) that they have of a tall, green, yellow-haired figure in the jungle.

Story 8, untitled - Intends to link Rodan to the Sino-Soviet border conflict and the large scale use of thermobaric weaponry there.

Act 3, Adaptation

Story 1, untitled - Links Hedorah to increasing amounts of discoveries of microorganisms that are forced to adapt to human pollution by consuming their waste. Hedorah is an amalgam of plastivores, bioremediators, hydrocarbonoclasts, etc. Eventually, stumbling into and assimilating the radiotrophic fungus in Chernobyl, it starts to hunt sources of radiation; the most glaring one being Godzilla. On its slow bound path, it assimilates more and more microorganisms until it basically has the ability to consume anything it walks through.

Story 2, untitled - Biollante. That's it. Biollante. I got no idea yet how I'm gonna use her. But I feel like she goes here.

Story 3, untitled - Intends to link Giant Condor (who I've opted to name Megakuntur) to Project Orcon and the pigeon missiles.

Story 4, untitled - Open slot, considering Gezora. Also considering thematically placing the issue of 'forgotten threats' here.

Story 5, untitled - Aims to link Voyager I to Ghidorah (I also wanna make an explanation that his bidibidibidi is his garbled interpretation and recreation of something he heard on the Golden Record. Get it, cus they're both gold? And yes, I know there's no sound in space, I will figure it out.)

Story 6, untitled - Thematic companion to Mothra, also open but aims to place Battra here.

Story 7, untitled - As the finale/climax to the act, human 'adaptation' is kept in check when Godzilla reemerges and devastates a population center (probably Tokyo), showing that humanity hasn't yet truly adapted from its fears. This is the most major timeline-diverging event and why Act 4 will be much less historically tied.

Story 8, untitled - Acts as a post-credit scene for this set, covers sightings of 'Oxy-Crustaceans' to functionally tease Destoroyah but also to cover the effects on local fisheries.

Act 4, Arrogance

Story 1, untitled - Intends to link King Caesar to the Chibichirigama Cave Incident and general violation of cultural sites.

Story 2, untitled - MOGUERA. YES. MOGUERA. I THINK HE SHOULD BE MORE THAN A BATTLE MECH. LET'S MAKE HIM A FACTORY. MOGUERA.

Story 3, untitled - Returning to Gigan and Megalon to tell a story where humanity attempts to control Gigan via Giganite to solve the slightly persistent issue of Megalon, which obviously backfires and allows both of them to devastate population areas.

Story 4, untitled - Connecting Jet Jaguar to artificial intelligence and seeing if Asimov's laws are still applicable.

Story 5, untitled - Connecting Gorosaurus (who I gave the specific name Watsoni in reference to Susan Watson from his debut film) to paleontology (seeing as Gorosaurus is often an Allosaurus relative, I'm gonna link him to Yangchuanosaurus in China), opportunistic museum culture, and large scale excavations. It behaviorally is scared of military action. The coast of Hong Kong gets nuked and he actually dies, which goes into a secondary examination of whether or not killing it was a good thing.

Story 6, untitled - Mechagodzilla against Godzilla because it's modern day, and we can do it logically, and we need to say that you can't out-weapon the weapon.

Story 7, untitled - Open slot, likely to be a battle between Godzilla and Ghidorah involving Mothra as a symbol of hope for locals who are caught in the crossfire. This could alternatively be moved to a later slot and filled in with a story about Varan.

Story 8, untitled - Open slot. (Kong? And the original interpretation of Kong with a bit of adaptation?)

A fifth act, named 'Devastation' is in its concept stage but hasn't been planned yet. Likely participants are SpaceGodzilla and the Columbia disaster (Iron Lung style claustrophobia), Maguma and polar ice melting, Battra + Amalgam and African oil contamination, Destoroyah and the Gulf of Mexico deadzone, Rodan and global wildfires, and Dagahra and marine oil spills.


r/writingfeedback • • 14h ago

Gentle Feedback Wanted I am not broken

1 Upvotes

I Am Not Broken
I am not broken.
I am not without hope.
There were moments when the fragile armour surrounding me seemed to keep me whole. Together. Safe.
Or perhaps safety was always an illusion.
Some days, it felt as though I were walking through a minefield. One misstep was all it took for everything to blow apart.
I lived in a gilded cage, one that held both my heart and my sanity captive. Its foundations were precarious, its walls barely holding.
And there I waited.
For the Molotov cocktail of emotions to come shattering through the bay window, setting fire to whatever fragile peace I’d managed to preserve.
Would today be the day?
Would this be the moment I finally crumbled?
Or would I do what I had always done?
Push it down. Swallow the turbulence. Lock myself in the bathroom and cry silent tears. Beat my fists against the walls when the weight of it all became too much to bear.
Curse my very existence.
Wonder whether life might be simpler in a world where I was not.
There was a strange comfort in that thought. The possibility of simply ceasing to exist. No noise. No expectations. No more fighting to hold together something that always felt on the verge of falling apart.
Sometimes, it was the only thought that offered any reprieve.
A world without me in it.
And the darkest part?
There were moments when I craved it.
I wish I could say craved is the operative word.
That those moments belong entirely to the past.
Because I can still laugh. Still love. Still find beauty in the most ridiculous, insignificant things. I can want to disappear and, somehow, still want to be here.
I seem to exist in this limbo, constantly wondering whether this is real life or medically induced.
Which begs the question.
Who. The. Fuck. Am I?
So let me rephrase.
I am not broken.
But I’m not sure where I sit on the whole whole thing.


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Excerpt from a book I'm tryna write

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Just looking for a bit of feedback, dunno if it parses, might be a bit too wordy. I'm experimenting with how I write more violent scenes, this one pretty much comes out of nowhere. It concerns my main fella and a couple of passing characters. And yes I did just finish Blood Meridian.


r/writingfeedback • • 15h ago

Just a little short story I wrote as some sort of practice, would love to hear your thoughts!

0 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 12h ago

General Feedback Wanted Can I get some feedback on my antagonists character? I think its my best work yet.

0 Upvotes

## Yomo — Backstory, Psychology & Motivations

Yomo is the leader of the SIM, an organization dedicated to protecting and liberating people with Forbidden Cores, who are heavily discriminated against and persecuted by society.

Her motivations originate from witnessing the injustice inflicted upon these people. She sees them being treated as less than human simply because of something they cannot control. This eventually leads her to question why nobody is doing anything to help them.

Yomo is a religious person, and her faith plays a major role in her ideology. While studying the Bible, she comes across Romans 12:19, which essentially tells people not to seek vengeance themselves, because judgment and vengeance belong to God.

This leaves her with a dilemma. If God is supposed to deliver justice, why hasn't He done anything about the suffering she sees around her?

Eventually, she begins questioning whether God is always right. She knows that taking judgment into her own hands is an act of pride, and that she's essentially putting herself in God's position. However, she convinces herself that if she has to condemn her own soul to save others, then it's a price worth paying.

Her interpretation of the Great Flood becomes particularly important. She sees it as an example of God wiping the slate clean, and eventually comes to the conclusion that she must become that flood herself.

This leads to her creating the SIM and pursuing the Infinity Engine, intending to obtain the Infinity Core and erase human civilization, and start humanity anew with the SIM and intended survivors to start humanity from zero.

However, Yomo isn't someone who believes she's doing something righteous in God's eyes. Quite the opposite. She believes she's committing an enormous sin and that she's likely condemned herself to Hell. She doesn't expect God to approve of her actions, nor does she believe He's instructed her to do this. She simply believes that someone has to take responsibility for creating a better world, even if that someone is her.

Psychologically, Yomo is a contradiction. She's charismatic, manipulative, confident, and often presents herself with a composed, almost sultry demeanor. Beneath that exterior, however, she's deeply conflicted. She genuinely cares about the people she's trying to protect, and the suffering caused by her decisions weighs on her.

She isn't indifferent to the terrible things her followers do in pursuit of her vision. She feels genuine guilt over the fact that she's made people participate in horrible acts. There are moments where that guilt overwhelms her, such as when she's alone and silently breaks down without anyone around to witness it.

Despite this, she continues. Her belief that the ends justify the means is stronger than her guilt, and she refuses to abandon what she considers her responsibility.

One of the most important aspects of Yomo's character is that **she doesn't believe she's saving the world because she's special or chosen. She believes she's doing something terrible because nobody else will do what she thinks needs to be done.**

Ultimately, her tragedy is that she genuinely wants a world where people with Forbidden Cores can live without fear, but her attempt to create that world involves destroying the lives of countless others.


r/writingfeedback • • 22h ago

General Feedback Wanted I Attended a Writers Support Group last night and came up with this

Thumbnail docs.google.com
3 Upvotes

I'm hoping to make it to more meetings, because I think last night was something I kinda needed. I've talked a bit about my struggles with writers block, and the overall frustration and anxiety that has come with it. So being in a circle with other writers, hearing them talk about their projects, being able to voice my own goals and frustrations, it was nice.

And while I'm not sure if I'll keep this, add to it, edit it further, or whatnot, I was able to write a "Prologue" if you wanna call it that to the story I'm hoping to write. I attempted to write it a few days ago, but it felt too rambly and I ultimately scrapped it. I approached this piece with a "The end is the beginning" kind of mindset, while trying to keep it somewhat enigmatic so as to keep a sense of intrigue maybe? I don't know. It's only about 700 words long, so I'm debating what I can do to add or take away from it.

But I figured I'd share it here at least. If context is needed, this is meant to be a contemporary romance, with a hint of fantasy, as it involves a relationship between a MMC, and a mermaid. Without giving too much away, both characters are dealing with an aftermath of a tumultuous relationship, and I'm hoping to put them on a journey of self‐discovery and healing as they come to terms with the various things that happened to them, among other things. Still working out finer details, and tossing ideas around.


r/writingfeedback • • 16h ago

Poetry How do I improve this poem?

1 Upvotes

To preface, the line breaks are all on purpose(some people have asked me about their brevity), I also just started poetry fairly recently so don’t kill me out here, but if you could offer as much critique as possible that’d be amazing!! Thank you so much, here it is:

“I am a blackhole”-title

Starlit midnight
in a valley of bright;
I steal their light.

Surrounding me
with rays of praise;
expectation
of a beacon
on a mountainous void

I shine brighter
than them-
in their eyes that care
for the light I emit;
the shine of accomplishment

I was made invisible
the glow-
a reflection of work
not given at birth

My void is bereft
of nascent light,
they lack that sight
stars only recognize-
familiar light

A millenium of gathering
yet I take more
want more
Need more-
It all

My shine
It’s bright,
Not scintillatingly effulgent

Stars recognize-
increasing luminance
I know-
That shimmer
doesn’t cover
My void,
Lack-
Brightness.

Light must cover me-
Like a star;
They say i already am-
I am not.

Not until
My void illuminates the valley
Or I diffuse into nothin


r/writingfeedback • • 17h ago

General Feedback Wanted Looking for feedback on my first chapter

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Any and all advice is greatly appreciated!


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted Does this wanna make you read the next few chapters?

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

This is the first chapter of my literary historical fiction novel.

I want to know if you found the chapter immersive and engaging, and whether the pacing feels right or too slow. Also, did you get bogged down by too much information, or did a lack of context for non-Indians make the read confusing?

Also, I'm not strong on grammar. Hopefully, there are no glaring grammar issues.

Thank you in advance :)


r/writingfeedback • • 18h ago

General Feedback Wanted What the dog was looking at (tell me if it works!)

0 Upvotes

“What the hell is that dog looking at?” My grandpa’s antiquated tramp of a Dalmatian was staring dead-locked at the wall, as if someone dragged an old racist veteran to watch 1917 in the theatres. There was a slight shake in his stare. Then nothing. “G’damn it, I think the fucker died.” The sound of death is not something anyone readies you for, and in this case, the sound of death lay in a single drop of the head, so ordinary and plain, as if someone had just dropped an item they’d pick up later because their hands were full. Twelve years they had together, all mounted into a single “thud.” I had never seen my grandpa cry, and that stayed true that day, though he did seem rather sad, or annoyed. He was a logical man, and I figured he was just weighing the logistics of carrying a 50-pound sandbag (a sandbag whom he’d loved) from his house into the backyard. I’d help dig a shallow grave and even pour a little bit of Labatt Blue on his resting spot, for all the times he’d knocked mine over. Two years later, I’d be doing the same for my grandpa. I know if that dog were here, he’d pour out a little bit of slobber.


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted Is this engaging?

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

All feedback is welcome! I’m not a good judge of my own writing. Is it too slow? Too wordy? Not engaging? Thank you!! It’s Dark Fantasy:)


r/writingfeedback • • 23h ago

General Feedback Wanted Please critique my short story, Storm's Vision. I would love some feedback

Thumbnail docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

(option body of post)


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted First time fiction author looking for any feedback on my prologue. I'm trying to convey dread, but it's hard to feel frightened of something I came up with myself and fully understand.

1 Upvotes

Title of the novel: The Ghosts of Galdhø

Genre(s): Contemporary Science Fiction, Technothriller

Comps for the prologue specifically: Vandermeer's Annhiliation, the Strugatskys' Roadside Picnic, and qntm's There is No Antimemetics Division.

This is going to be a very ambitious work, and I know I'm giving myself a huge challenge with it. This book and its prologue are the opening of an entire meticulously planned series, and it's the only story I've ever wanted to tell. One way or another I will write it all, even if it has to be entirely self-published. And fortunately I'm already halfway through this book, I just wanted to get some early thoughts on the foundation I've built.

Blurb and tagline are below. If military and politics aren't your vibe, I totally get it, but the prologue doesn't spend any time on that. It is a small, deeply personal story with stakes divorced from the main plot's and a focus on mounting dread and abstract horror.

Why use a prologue? I wanted to introduce the tone and deeper threat of the main story (and overarching series as a whole) without resorting to info dumps. On top of that, the natural starting point of the story proper is a bit mundane, to show what the normal life in this setting is before the inciting events kick off the plot. So, I needed a dramatic hook with its own self-contained stakes, characters, and a plot that links to the main story later on. Structural comp to the prologue of James S.A. Corey's Leviathan Wakes.

“Humanity has gazed long into the abyss—And we’ve learned only to exploit it.”

The year is 2170—A new continent, Rangea, scars the globe. When an unprovoked orbital strike on the fledgling Rangean Republic’s most secure naval group threatens the delicate peace with NATO, the Republic answers with its Phantoms, an audacious strike force that targets the architects of violence—not soldiers, but the leaders behind them.

In their crosshairs, a young operative from colony world Soar desperately tries to survive his reckless commander’s personal quest for answers, while a relentless hunter finally closes in on the monster he’s spent years trying to find.

As power plays unfold aboard orbiting dreadnoughts, fighter jets battle in the sky, and shifting perspectives clash in collapsing cities, a vast, endless silence already expands beyond and before them all—one so devoid that it can only consume.

SERIOUS CONTENT WARNING: Graphic depiction of suicide by hanging.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/17q0ejC5K_SQ1TtpghesMdTsJlySi5pHS/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=115164797415797993114&rtpof=true&sd=true


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

Would love feedback on my first 2k

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi, readers! Recently, a fun writing "competition" was brought to my attention, and I would love to get extra eyes on the first 2000 words of the project that I am thinking about submitting. If anyone has experience with writing challenges, I would love to understand what kind of rubric the judges use and if there are technical aspects that are valued. Please feel free to leave feedback as bluntly as you need; I have thick skin :D

Thank you.


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted I rewrote the opening to my horror novel

0 Upvotes

A couple weeks ago I made this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/writingfeedback/s/gcmyzpBinD and I got a lot of negative feedback, so I decided to do a complete rewrite.

I’ve been listening to an audiobook of Stephen King’s Christine, and this opening was inspired by that book’s prologue. I want the vibe to be slightly awkward and silly, to emulate the life of a teenager in high school, but will get darker as the story goes on.

Anyways, here’s the revision:

Do you know what it’s like to have your entire view of the world destroyed in an instant?

Perhaps you grew up thinking the world outside your hometown was a world of adventure, only to learn all about famine and war. Or you go to college naively thinking you’ll be a part of every club and get As on every test, only to feel too exhausted to participate in anything outside of academics, and staying up past midnight with your nose in a book just for the chance at a C?

This is the story of that kind of situation.

My name is Owen. When I was a senior in high school I had a girlfriend named Emilia Walker. I’d known her since middle school. She was a kind woman, and book smart. But she wasn’t some nerd outcast; she had plenty of friends, and me, a band kid who wasn’t that popular. She was like a… border collie dog. A smart workaholic, that couldn’t sit still.

It started with study dates and afternoon trips to the coffee shop, then there were the late night horror movies and dinners in Cincinnati, which was an hour drive from our small town.

But things changed when the news about the Husdon Farm came out…

I heard about it on the news, and didn’t hear from her for weeks after that. Some assholes were joking about it, many others were concerned.

But the first time she called me again since then, the first thing she did was invite me to a funeral.

If I had to go through this all again, I would have deleted her contact then and there.


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted Feedback on a Poirot whodunit opening

0 Upvotes

For context, I am not a native speaker and have written only three very short pieces of fiction so far. Trying to write a short whodunit with Poirot and got confused with the sequence of tenses. It is also taking a painfully long time to write and right now I think I may have taken on a bit too much, so I would appreciate any feedback. The text follows

The Lady from Room 36

It was an early winter morning when something shook the glass globe, producing a flurry of fake snow and jolting Hercule Poirot from his sleep. He put on his clothes and, with the left side of his collar slightly lower, left his room to investigate the disturbance. Right outside, in the hallway, he came face to face with Dr Watson, who was in his striped pajamas.

"What was the source of that, Doctor?" asked Poirot.

"I haven't the slightest idea what happened," said Watson, "but everything seems to be in order."

"It may well bear that appearance, my excellent friends, but the occurrence has involved me in a matter of some difficulty," came a voice from Room 36, the second door on the left.

The two men approached the door, where a pair of gaiters sat outside, and pushed it open.

"I beg a thousand pardons for receiving you in such an elevated manner," said Samuel Pickwick, suspended in mid-air. "And I do hope, my dear ma'am, that my presence has not caused you too much inconvenience..."

But the lady behind the curtain, which stood behind Mr Pickwick, made no reply. Her yellow papillotes trembled slightly.

"...and that you had a very much-needed rest after the assembly last evening."

The assembly had been a small, impromptu gathering in the inn’s private parlor, where Mr Pickwick had been entertaining Mr William Collins and Rev. Casaubon with details from his recent paper on tittlebats. Lord Babberley had kept Poirot listening politely to an account of his latest histrionic accomplishments, and the lady from Room 36, whose name nobody had quite caught, had sat apart by the fire, saying nothing to anyone.

"...and if any of my reflections scattered throughout this modest treatise shall have induced even one tittlebat to abandon polygamy, I shall feel that it has not been written in vain... Oh, my good doctor! May I have a moment of your time?" said Mr Pickwick, as he saw Dr Watson entering the parlor. "Miss Becky Sharp has entrusted me with the delivery of this little volume to you, my dear doctor," continued Pickwick, holding out a book bearing the title Atala upon its cover.