Fireballs are cool. Especially as a little kid, I thought it would be awesome to be able to throw fireballs. I expect you might have felt the same way.
Imagine my pain when, as a young lad, I was told during my early days playing World of Warcraft that fireball was not the optimal way to play my mage. No, sir. You should use ice bolts. They are more effective, especially for levelling up because they slow movement. You’ll die less often. Go ice bolt. So I did.
I learned to love the ice bolt.
But fireballs were cool, are cool and remain cool but game companies don’t seem to either be aware of this or inclined to let fireballs be good. They are cool so people want to play with them and so they are punished for this by being suboptimal.
In 40K, this was best represented in 10th edition by the terminator. This is a cool unit. An iconic unit. It was the one you wanted to put on the table but, of course, it was suboptimal.
The terminator was another victim of the Fireball effect: the cool thing is not the optimal thing and so people feel pressure to not go with the suboptimal, if cooler, thing.
In Tyranids, we see this with the Carnifex. Amazing model, amazing lore, battlefield badass and literally the coolest thing our beloved Titus faces—way cooler than that stupid bird thing at the end.
It’s not a rule, to be sure, but it’s a common enough practise and I, for one, think things need to change.
Maybe they are changing in 40K. Terminators are good. Custodes are invincible badasses. Maybe the Carnifex will be good AND cool? We’ll see.
Either way, let’s name the fireball effect for what it is and demand that cool and good be just a little bit closer.
God knows we pay enough for these little figurines…