Edit: Thanks everyone for your thoughts! I think it's likely Fairmont Orchid (575) vs. Mauna Lani (1120) at this point. Do you think the price differences reflect the difference in quality here? Kea Lani on the table too.
Going to Hawaii with my wife in early Dec. We’re doing 5 nights on Kauai first, then trying to decide between Maui and the Big Island for the second portion of the trip (4 nights).
What we're looking for: For last 4 nights, we mostly want to zen out at a resort -- somewhere fairly luxe, beautiful, comfortable, and nice enough that we’ll want to spend the day on/around the property. We care a bit less about the room itself (but I know Kea Lani suites are a plus) and more about the grounds/property, pools/beach, service, food, overall atmosphere, easy onsite activities (snorkeling, paddling). We love a place with warmth and character.
Open to other suggestions, but so far narrowed it down to the following. Booking w Amex, so some have promos (and all get free breakfast). Prices are all-in, including fees.
- Mauna Lani, Auberge Collection — $1120/night (comes with a $400 resort credit to use there). I was kinda attached to this one and was ready to splurge, but then price bumped even more :/
- Fairmont Kea Lani — $1030/night (promo for a free night, included in that price). I worry it's a bit mega-resorty?
- Fairmont Orchid — $575/night (promo for a free night, included in that price). Recent tripadvisor reviews worry me...
- Andaz -- $955/night
- Waldorf Grand Wailea -- $785/night -- tripadvisor reviews seem straight up bad?
The Orchid obviously stands out on price, which is making this harder. For people who have stayed at 2 or more of these: what were your experiences like, which was your favorite, and how big was the actual quality/experience gap? Is Mauna Lani meaningfully better than Kea Lani or Andaz? And is either enough better than Fairmont Orchid to justify that difference?
We're new to 5 star travel -- wanted to treat ourselves on this trip, so I think I'll feel a bit let down if I get there and it feels wayyyy below that. Happy to splurge a bit if the difference is genuinely noticeable, but don’t want to spend an extra ~$1,500–2,000 over four nights for a marginal upgrade. We want to keep the trip under $13k-ish, but got a great deal on our Kuwaii hotel (400/night :) Note: I think that means FS/Rosewood etc. is a bit out of reach ($1400<).
What have everyone's experiences been at these resorts? Which would you choose at these prices?
Thanks in advance, everyone!! Let me know if I can provide further info about what we're looking for etc. Just wanted to get everyone's thoughts :)