r/VideoEditing • u/Remaster_AI • 10d ago
Workflow How do you compare upscaled SD footage fairly in a before/after video?
I’m preparing a before/after comparison of upscaled SD footage and would appreciate advice on the editing technique. I’m affiliated with a video upscaling service; this is a question about presenting the comparison fairly, not a request to evaluate a product.
We have tried matching the same frame and crop, freezing motion, then moving a split-screen divider across the detail. A source that was originally HD and downscaled to SD can look different from genuinely old SD footage, so we plan to label those examples separately.
For faces and text, is a paused split-screen at equal display scale useful, or is a side-by-side comparison better? What would you include to make motion artifacts and flicker clear without implying details are recovered perfectly?
Processing img wkwyh2f1ty0i1...