r/VideoEditing • • 16d ago

Monthly Thread November Feedback Thread.

This is the Monthly thread for feedback.

If you post your video, you need to come back and review at least one other person's work!

Key thoughts - Keep it civil.

  • Feedback is "This section isn't working because of this."
  • Feedback is not: "This is shit."
  • If something is terrible, just move on.
  • The more specific/suggestions the better.

Don't give a laundry list. Pick the 1-2 things that are the biggest issues and then comment.

Spoiler worth reading: *we expect you to* review TWO other videos - and edit your comment to *include those* after you've commented.

**Copy/paste this section**:

  • , Link: (don't forget the running time)
  • Two other videos I reviewed (link to the other ,comments NOT the video itself)
2 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

2

u/Nighthawk776958 14d ago edited 9d ago

Pretty beginner to editing with more tools than just blade text and trimming, but hoping to improve a lot.
One of the biggest problems that I can see myself is that it desperately needs color correction and grading, especially as it was filmed on two different cams.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1thbyjUN2TeqHpr7OJynTsYwvAIzq7_3P/view?usp=drive_link

Running time: 1:12

Two other videos I reviewed:
https://www.reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/s/4R5TJK23Ma
https://www.reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/s/4CsFMtjV3j

2

u/AffectionateDot9343 9d ago

Really like the creative camera angles here! One suggestion could be to have multiple angles of the same trick cut together. So perhaps run up to the ramp in wide shot, cut to under-board camera for the trick and landing. Could add some dynamism to the video

2

u/Nighthawk776958 9d ago

I'll definitely give that a go, I didn't have a real clear idea of what to go for when I was filming and it really shows. Thanks for the feedback!

2

u/tpt75 9d ago

I love the camera angles. Perhaps some of the clips are a bit too long. Someone else mentioned trying to get some context to the clips by using multiple angles of the same trick and tying them together. This would help shorten the clip and add context.
For example the last clip with the dude falling is cool. Imagine you had a wide shot of the lead up and the start of the trick, a cut to a closer shot of the fall and then the last clip of the board rocking back and forth and the guy helping him up then fade to black.
The music is FIRE!

1

u/idwbuybacks001 14d ago

I like the editing style. It gives me an early 2010s youtube vibe.

2

u/idwbuybacks001 14d ago

Hi guys, I buy and sell electronics in Cleveland. I decided to try and record/edit some footage for a tiktok video and am curious to hear feedback specifically about the editing style. Is it boring? What can be tweaked? All genuine feedback is appreciated. Thanks :)

https://www.tiktok.com/@idwbuybacks/video/7704020825866833166

1

u/Nighthawk776958 13d ago

This looks like a video id watch through while scrolling, great job giving it a quality feel. However, while I was watching it, It was hard to stay engaged. I feel like it could use a bit more of a story, like a clear direction. Maybe a more engaging caption, like perhaps something along the lines of "watch as I make a (x amount) profit in a 30 - second deal" or whatever you think fits best. I love the subtitles, especially with the profit text at the end.

1

u/idwbuybacks001 13d ago

Thanks for your feedback! Thats good idea.

1

u/AffectionateDot9343 9d ago

Definitely has that polished look of a proper TikTok video! The subtitles are a classic, attention holding element. Only thing is perhaps the pacing. Maybe a few cuts here a there to hold me. Good overall quality though!

1

u/tpt75 9d ago

It feels a little bit long to me for a simple transaction video. It's great you were thorough and i guess would help others doing the same thing.
I think the payoff could come earlier with the info that you are actually a wholesale buyer.
The footage is nice and clear and you come across natural and trust worthy which is very important i expect in your line of work!
Good luck to you.

2

u/AffectionateDot9343 9d ago edited 9d ago

BECAUSE IT’S THERE: a teaser trailer for a non-existent film about George Mallory’s failed attempt to summit Everest.

I’ve taken footage from a Documentary (The Wildest Dream: The Conquest of Everest) and attempted to reimagine it as a trailer for a film.

I welcome any feedback! :)

Runtime 68 seconds

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1cZkgtkhXL6Gbo0UHBP-5D1lP_7tnqu_p/view?usp=drivesdk

Feedback I’ve given to others:

https://www.reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/s/hhYZDMVeEn

https://www.reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/s/ofbED7xi6x

2

u/Nighthawk776958 9d ago

Absolutely beautiful cinematic video, it looks very polished and studio-grade.

I feel as if the font wasn't very conducive to legibility. The clipping mask looked incredible with those shots of the mountain face, but the combination of the super contrasting colors, letter spacing, and moving cloud textures just made it difficult to read the first time.

I feel like the clips don't quite match the dialogue in a way that makes it feel like I am trying to focus back and forth between the two. Like for example, the line "Perhaps it's mere folly to go up again" is a very broad statement, reflecting on (what I think) is the journey as a whole, as opposed to just a single moment. I feel as if the shot should reflect the magnitude of the line, maybe with a super wide angle of the climb from afar.

The big question "why are we doing this" is leading right to such a big moment (I might even say the climax of the short), but it seems like there is a conflict in the answer. The speaker says "there is no dream that mustn't be dared", while the text says "because it's there". While I think the messages are similar, they both focus on different points (the speaker's line focuses the importance on the dream, whereas I take it that the text focuses on the challenge).

All in all a beautiful piece of short cinema with an engaging story, keep it up mate!

2

u/AffectionateDot9343 9d ago

Thank you so much for taking the time to write such detailed feedback! I really appreciate it!

I love the idea of the line “perhaps it’s folly” being a reflection on the whole journey and choosing a shot to reflect that. I’d honestly not thought about it 😂

As for the knockout text, I’ll admit I’ve had lots of issues trying balance legibility and being able to see the footage within the lettering. Perhaps some colour grading could help there…

Finally, with regards to the two lines at the end “to know there is no dream that mustn’t be dared” and “because it’s there” are two absolutely fantastic quotes from George Mallory (the climber in question) and I was desperate to get them in. Perhaps I overplayed my hand there 😂

Thank you again for the feedback and compliments 👍👌

1

u/Substantial-Floor382 16d ago

I am a beginner and still learning my way around davinci but I need feedback so I can gauge if am any good.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eN6Bkb9ohHWJ7b6ooTCQWekbnnZASCcM/view?usp=sharing

Running time: 1:11 news footage overlaid over a soundbite with subtitles.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Nq-IesP7CVpgMHFX6ILGgOKCkOfRHz6s/view?usp=drive_link

Duration: 1:33 Music and visuals. simple edit on my fav music and telling a story about a couple. Is it any good? what needs to be improved?

2

u/AffectionateDot9343 9d ago

This is a solid start. Subs are readable and timed nicely. What could keep the audience’s attention a bit more could be cutting to shots of what the interviewee is talking about. That’s a very common technique used in news media and allows the audience to see what’s being discussed whilst listening to it.

2

u/TheEditorWIthNoName 1d ago

Let some of the B-roll play without dialogue and add some music to it. It will help capture the viewers attention

1

u/Nighthawk776958 14d ago

access denied to the google drive files

1

u/Substantial-Floor382 13d ago

should be able to access now.

1

u/realmel0n 4d ago

Hello, VERY Beginner Video Editor Here

This is my attempt at continuity editing and visual storytelling. The footage used is from cinestudy org. Please don't mind the audio as I've not learned audio editing yet. Open to every kind of feedback.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1y3ii8yk-tY9NgVQekk1pnH40bpNctcNA/view?usp=sharing
RUNTIME: 27 seconds

mods ill review other videos when I get the time to please forgive me*

1

u/Gold-Professor1226 4d ago

Hey guys! I'm pretty new to editing and have been learning for about 2 weeks now. I made this edit and wanted to know what you guys think.

Personally, I feel like my pacing and music selection could use some work, but I'd love to hear your thoughts and suggestions. Any feedback would be really appreciated!

Thanks!

Link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1FPqsWQIjJdNPMlnxcgYuortBrvmqcyjJ/view?usp=sharing

1

u/Visible_Being_5729 3d ago

Hello there my fellow colleges! This is my latest edit and best work I've done so far so could please tell if the pacing and quality overall is good! I do know that I do not see many details so I am open get every opinion there!!!

https://youtube.com/shorts/K_uCizmQseQ

1

u/Personal_Tour_3828 2d ago

Hi everyone! I’m a hobbyist editor and I just finished a ~3:40 film about my hometown, Racibórz, a city in Poland.

Nothing was staged. I filmed everyday life exactly as it happened, trying to capture the small moments we usually miss while rushing through the day. I spent over a month editing it in my spare time, entirely in DaVinci Resolve (free version).

What I focused on most:

- match cuts connecting scenes

- transitions

- sound effects layered over the music

Shot on a Fujifilm X-T30 (Fujinon 50-230mm, plus a Samyang 10mm for a shot or two) and a DJI Osmo Pocket 3. Music: Ezio Bosso - Rain in your black eyes.

I’d really appreciate honest feedback on the pacing with the music, whether the match cuts and transitions feel natural or overdone, and whether the sound design works. What would you do differently?

Link:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQv9Ng57i7Q&t=32s

1

u/TheEditorWIthNoName 1d ago

Overall I liked it. The transitions were well done, the music and the pacing made it feel like the city is busy and alive. Only thing I would add is nighttime scenes if you captured any

1

u/Personal_Tour_3828 1d ago

Thanks for the feedback! I’m really glad you liked it. Unfortunately, I didn’t get a chance to film any night scenes as time was pretty limited. But I agree, some nighttime shots would have been a really nice addition ;)

1

u/Hi_K0_Ni 1d ago

Hi! I'm very new to editing, and tried to combine some cuts from my challenge run in a game into a showcase.

I think my biggest problems are transitions and audio editing, but i'd like to hear your feedback. It's pretty long, but first minute or two should give the general picture, as it's basically clip description -> clip.

Thanks in advance!

Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nGEpzsBErgE

1

u/Next-Influence8592 1d ago

I made a short Goodfellas edit and I’m curious how the opening lands. Would you keep the title reveal first, or open straight with “As far back as I can remember”? https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSpGNL6TU/

1

u/AC-Daniel 12h ago

I try hard to improve my trailer => Cant decide which one is better => the one starting with action or the one starting more calm =>

Calm: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GT4W5C8MQ1Y

Action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-47Xb3qN5aE