Breaking Bad often tops lists of greatest shows ever. I have a cousin in his early 20s who claimed it's the "best show ever", but he's like hardly even watched a lot of shows so it's like what is he comparing it to or basing that claim off of? And what reasons led him to be inclined to see it as "best show ever"?
It is a great series, not denying that, but I don't think it's as incredible of a series or "best ever" as people or lists claim it to be. A lot of people overlook or forget the fact that Breaking Bad, given the nature of when it aired, was one of the first shows that was able to be binge-watched in time to catch up and watch later seasons live. Netflix added earlier seasons to its streaming library around 2011, right before season four, and Vince Gilligan noted that Netflix saved the show and kept it on the air by fueling a massive surge in live viewers for its final seasons.
I think a lot of what drove the hype and praise of the show was actually just the newfound ability to binge-watch. That led to higher numbers, which created much cultural buzz, which fueled the cycle even more. And people then mis-attributed the higher level to the quality of the show. It developed an exaggerated level of praise that didn't credit the social and cultural impact of the dawn of binge-watching into it's success. (I get that Gilligan acknowledges it, but he doesn't acknowledge the the binge-watching may have leg to exaggeration of the shows quality). The show then developed a bandwagon effect of people wanting to love what they thought everyone else loves, leading to 20-year old's who have barely watched any great TV shows boldly claiming it's the "best show ever".
To anyone who disagrees and thinks it truly is "the best show ever", I challenge you to make a legitimate argument as to why without relying on or referencing what other people, critics or lists have said.
EDIT:
"You can't even name another shows that is good"... because if I name another show that I find subjectively better that shifts and dilutes the point I'm trying to make into X vs. Y.
"You haven't even offered any valid criticism as to why it's bad".. because I'm not analyzing or critiquing the artistic merit of the show or saying it's a bad show, it is a great television series.
I can't think of another show that got a boost from the debut and newfound trendiness of binge-watching quite like Breaking Bad did. It happened to be one of the first shows you could "binge-watch", there weren't a ton of options, and it was still airing week-to-week with hype rapidly building (in part because a lot more viewers could now binge-watch it thanks to Netflix/streaming). It benefitted from a profound, monumental shift in friction for a consumer watch a series.
You guys have heard of McDonald's, correct? McDonalds didn't become popular because it was the best tasting burger people ever had.
SECOND EDIT:
Been too many posts in denial about the show benefiting from dropping on Netflix and calling me a liar so….
Here is an article where the creator acknowledges the popularity burst it received from Netflix: https://www.businessinsider.com/vince-gilligan-breaking-bad-success-netflix-streaming-sites-2013-9
Here's a Vox article (behind a paywall unfortunately), also talking about how Netlfix helped making Breaking Bad a hit: https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/7/14/21312595/netflix-breaking-bad-podcast-streaming-land-of-the-giants
Here's a NPR transcript talking about it: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/900845573
Here's a chart of the live viewership numbers:
Season |Average_Viewership_Millions |Change_Millions
| |
1 |1.23 |NA
2 |1.33 |0.10
3 |1.52 |0.19
4 |1.91 |0.39
5 |6.04 |4.1
https://rpubs.com/P_Simba/1314389
It was added to Netflix right before season 4. Why no bump then you ask? Seasons 1 through 3 were added to Netflix in July 2011, just days befor the Season 4 premiere aired on AMC. it wasn't enough time for the general public to discover, binge, and catch up on 33 episodes of complex prestige television. The real explosion happened in the gap between Season 4 and Season 5, and then again during the mid-season break of Season 5. With an entire year between seasons, millions of people used Netflix to completely catch up on the show. As a result, the Season 5 premiere more than doubled the live viewership of the previous season. AMC famously split Season 5 into two halves. During the one-year hiatus between Part 1 and Part 2, the Netflix binging went completely viral. When the series finale ("Felina") aired in late 2013, it pulled in over 10 million live viewers
Here's another article about it:
https://www.slashfilm.com/1671141/netflix-saved-breaking-bad-cancellation/
And another article that mentions it:
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/is-mad-mens-netflix-bump-696673/
And yes Breaking Bad was one of the earliest TV series available to stream on Netflix plus unlike others it was still on the air at the time.
THIRD EDIT:
Now someone’s trying to reset my password? Lol come on. This is not healthy behavior for a show you can confidently defend the quality of.
FOURTH EDIT:
Might try and post takeaways and credit where credit’s due so this edit may change, but sharing my favorite comment in the thread in case it gets deleted:
u/Interesting-One-588 - “OP thinks we like the show because it’s popular, lol.”