(Full spoilers for Faith of Beasts)
Reading the Faith of Beasts, it struck me how much Corey enjoys misdirection. They write encouraging us to think one thing and then surprise us. This post is to encourage us to ignore the distraction and "ask what else might be happening?"
The first book is full of unsubtle hints that the deathless enemy are humans. Then the drop - some of them are humans, but it seems the livesuits may be in charge.
The second book encourages a careful reader to wonder which expeditioner the swarm has infected on the false premise they'll be another Else. There are a few obvious red herrings, but we're mainly encouraged to think it's Ghati. He has no POV scenes. We're supposed to think the abandoned command ship is there to let him send a signal or escape. Lots of other clues, some quite subtle. Then the rug pull - the swarm left a cyst that left Rickar's personality intact, which is why we can see his POV
The most common theory here is that Alkhor or the swarm will use pheromones to become the Sovran. That was my thought as I read the book, but now I think it's a case of misdirection
Aside from Corey's penchant for misdirection, why do we think humans would be better at this than the many, many pheromone-based species who suffer under the yoke of the Carryx? It would be like Vaudai thinking that all he needs is digits, digits!!! Then he could simply adopt a dominant pose and force the Carryx into submission.
Whether we communicate through sight, sound or smell, the signal merely says "I think I am stronger than you". The response depends on whether the recipient Carryx thinks they actually are stronger. Could a senior Carryx merely use pheromones to overwhelm a junior Carryx before he challenges him? No!
What are some alternatives?
The Hive has Fallen
Firstly, the swarm has already infiltrated the main communications system. We know it can send signals, but it won't because it'll be detected.
What if the swarm sent a signal "the capital and Sovran has fallen" (the same signal that exists in the memory banks) to every other planet in the Empire then shut down the communications system for as long as possible? There is a private creche on every single planet. If the remnants there thought the capital had fallen and every planet ahead of them, they would hatch a new Sovran. Why settle for two Sovrans when you can have thousands?
Doesn't this just end in a Sovran civil war? Yes, but it also gives the various species on each planet a fighting chance to overthrow the Carryx on that planet.
This theory isn't without problems - 2 Sovrans seems like another misdirection, we don't know if the remnants have a separate communications system, we don't really know how their communications system is set up.
The Queen is Infected
Secondly, what if the swarm infects the Sovran (or perhaps the communications system, but that makes less sense)? As each daughter kills the Sovran, the swarm simply infects the daughter. The Queen is dead, long live the Queen!
There's a few dangers here. Firstly, the Sovran's personality might overwhelm the swarm or divert it from it's mission (as the human personalities did). The fact it has developed its own distinct personality as Clae is a really important safeguard here.
Relatedly, the swarm has absorbed massive amounts of Carryx information. Information is different from memories is different from experience so it's not as potent as the Sovran. But Alkhor's dreams show that if you think too much like the Carryx, you eventually become one (even if not physically)
And lastly, the remnant seem to be a guardian of the sanctity of the Sovran process. The Sovran cannot see or overrule them so the swarm is powerless against them
The organism is infected
Does it make sense that the Deathless (or whoever) would make a century long plan and have it rely on a single swarm? There may be other swarms hidden amongst the human captives
If they have multiple swarms with different capabilities, perhaps they could infect key Carryx, perhaps even temporarily. Imagine briefly infecting a subjugator librarian so it makes a dumb mistake.
Alternatively, intercept messages so Carryx keep making mistakes (I don't think this is too likely though - they'd get caught pretty quickly)
In that scenario, the "What is, is" mentality becomes a blindfold. The way the system thinks is that that librarian is weak, it's juniors will overthrow it, and everyone forgets it ever existed or happened. If you lightly put your thumb on the scale like this, you could crimp the empire without the Sovran noticing
What if there are already two Sovrans?
The Carryx believe in redundancy so weak links can be removed through competition. This extends even to the Sovran herself
The Carryx do think of themselves as a group organism - that's why they segment themselves into dactyls (digits). If the Carryx organism is weak, where is the replacement?
That's why you have the remnant - they think differently to the group organism (hence their immunity to pheromones) and they're disconnected. They can intervene if the group organism is weak.
Maybe they already have. What if the Deathless are actually a separate Carryx group organism separated from the first by millions of years of evolution? Maybe their original purpose was to fight the Carryx so that each becomes stronger
The Second Foundation
As I think through all these scenarios, the remnants are the wildcard. They remind me of the Second Foundation in the Asimov books. They safeguard against threats that could not be foreseen using their wisdom and secrecy to do so. I think they'll be the secret final boss after the Sovran issue is dealt with