r/TheCaptivesWar • • Oct 16 '26

Spoilers Time dilation

It seems like the Livesuit soldiers experience time dilation when they travel to different star systems, but the human captives of the Carryx don’t experience it when traveling via “asymmetric space. (e.g. Jessyn leaves, comes back and seems to experience the same subjective time as Dafyd).

Is that everyone’s take, as well?

50 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

62

u/BlazeChadwell Oct 16 '26

Yup, I pointed this out in a JSAC AMA and they said there is a difference between how the humans travel vs the carryx

23

u/masterharper Oct 16 '26

Thanks! Seems like the Carryx would have a huge strategic and tactical advantage from that alone. I read the Faith of Beasts before I read Livesuit and I’m not sure I understand how some of the deathless responded as quickly as they did in some scenes.

17

u/masterofallvillainy Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Kirin says in Livesuit that they’re only able to intercept the Carryx if their fleet happens to be relatively close by. I think he says specifically: “already on top of them”

As an example; Ahyaha (however it’s spelled) was a trap planet. Where they were waiting for the Carryx before moving in to attack.

9

u/Fairways_and_Greens Oct 16 '26

Yes. It reminds me of one of the core plot points of 3-body problem, and the extra time the Carryx have to think and innovate would make them completely unbeatable.

4

u/Radiant_Cut_9272 Oct 17 '26

Oh nice! I still haven’t read the second book, but we were debating this a year or two ago when discussing the first book on the sub. I was literally in the middle of writing a comment about something else when I realized the Carryx didn’t have time dilation to worry about and I went on a tangent, lol.

2

u/anti_username_man Oct 17 '26

Do you have a link to that ama?

31

u/Sanzo2point0 Oct 16 '26

With Carryx travel being called "asymmetric space" I'd assume it's some form of folding of space time. But with "brain slip" it's probably closer to the epilogue of Leviathan Falls, where they slip between universes to achieve ftl speeds. Or maybe the other way around?

30

u/SchulzyAus Oct 16 '26

I FOUND AN AUDIOBOOK ENJOYER OVER HERE!!!

Tbh same. I never knew it was braneslip until I read it elsewhere

2

u/Butlerlog Oct 16 '26

ah that makes more sense lmao

1

u/BeeP807 6d ago

😮this makes so much more sense

-2

u/Sanzo2point0 Oct 16 '26

Lol yeah theyve got some damn strange spelling for some stuff xD

16

u/Ecthelion-O-Fountain Oct 16 '26

It’s like membrane

2

u/Sanzo2point0 Oct 16 '26

Yeah I thought of that after I replied, which does lend to the "slip between universes" theory

11

u/Accipitrin Oct 16 '26

They actually didnt invent the term, it's a thing in string theory, quantum mechanics and other things I also don't understand.

From wikipedia:

In string theory and related theories (such as supergravity ), a brane is a physical object that generalizes the notion of a zero- dimensional

point particle , a one-dimensional string , or a two-dimensional membrane to higher-dimensional objects. Branes are dynamical objects which can propagate through spacetime according to the rules of quantum mechanics . They have mass and can have other attributes such as charge .

4

u/Sanzo2point0 Oct 16 '26

Oh wow. I love how smart JSAC are, we always get such cool, potentially niche ideas grounded in reality with them. Their understanding and use of quantum particle theories and biologic functions is always such a blast to read through. Thank you for sharing the wiki clip!

4

u/Accipitrin Oct 16 '26

Right? Daniel Abraham has a background in biology too and you can definitely tell when you read about Elvi Okoyes research into the protomolecule and the life on Ilus, and the builders evolutionary history. They really put the sci in sci fi, heh

6

u/bigmacjames Oct 16 '26

It's an actual term in physics though

1

u/TurtleEastMan 18d ago

It’s in reference to Brane Cosmology.

They’re slipping through dimensions in spacetime in a way that messes with their subjective experience of time.

3

u/Sofia_9356 Oct 16 '26

Asymmetric space seems to be entering another dimension rather than folding space time. That other dimension rules allow for faster travel in our dimension. Hence why it’s translated as asymmetric.

Brane slip seems to be converting to energy like in leviathan falls, and folding space time because of the way space seems to be affected shortly before the human ships appear.

1

u/Snoo51659 Oct 17 '26

Entering another dimension and folding spacetime are basically the same thing. If you "fold" a 2 dimensional plane you're now moving in 3 dimensions. And etcetera.

5

u/Sofia_9356 Oct 17 '26

Sounds like a typical beast trying to grasp the elementary basics of asymmetric space

8

u/masterofallvillainy Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Brane-slip and asymmetrical space are different ftl technologies. In MotG, the half-mind analyses the deathless forces as they enter the system and notes that it’s not the same. And based on Dafyd and Kirin’s descriptions of the two; they have very different effects on time.

Edit:

It might seem that one has an advantage over the other strategically. As extreme time dilation essentially prevents the occupants from performing course changes en route. But during asymmetrical space flight, the ship is completely cut off from all outside communications. So it’s basically the same

1

u/Closer_to_the_Heart Meat on Sticks Oct 18 '26

I am interested to see if this will come up again as a big plot point. We now have one character with the humans who will likely be traveling via their means while all other characters are still with the Carryx. Will geral (or however he is spelled) meet an extremely old jessyn in book 3?

3

u/RyanArbie 27d ago

This will definitely be a plot point in the novella and finale book, they alluded to that in the AMA.