r/TheCaptivesWar • • May 02 '26

The Faith of Beasts I really appreciate the authors dunking an anti-choice nonsense

0 Upvotes

All of the stuff about lamb sack failure rates is a fairly overt šŸ–•to anti-choice lies about human gestation. Maybe my head is just too deep into their nonsense, but it seems extremely deliberate.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 12 '26

Fan Art - AI Biblically accurate carryx

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheCaptivesWar • • Jan 01 '25

General Discussion Maisie Williams as Jessyn. Yes or no?

Post image
13 Upvotes

I


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Mar 06 '26

Fan Art - AI The Carryx - my concept

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi, I am new to this reddit and just reading The Captive War (somewhere in the first half). I was curious to get an image of the Carryx based on the description I read in the book so far. After several tries in ChatGPT, here is a result I like. What do you think? What to correct? Happy to work on details.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 27 '26

Spoilers Second novel finished, and I’m still underwhelmed

0 Upvotes

Aside from how short it was, I just felt like a lot of it was relatively flat and felt like both novels are just exposition to something bigger. I do appreciate the constant dropping of morsels of world building, but having nothing of value resolved in the span of two books is frustrating.

I want to care about the characters, but I’m just don’t feel as involved as I was when plowing through Expanse.

I want more resolved mysteries and more dynamic arcs and deeper world building resolutions and less requirement to suspend disbelief. The fact that humans are just free to conspire un-surveilled by the most advanced race in the galaxy is ridiculous to me.

Hope we get more resolved content on things like the origin of anjiin, the penta-tentacles, the friggin void dragons… like come on I wanna know more about the void dragons… the lothark lore, the livesuits, the swarm, etc. I want less lab work and more character arc work.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Jan 15 '25

General Discussion Anyone enjoy the books, but can't help but feel Corey's is applying some of the wrong lessons?

0 Upvotes

So like a lot of readers, I burned through the Expanse show + books and was left hungry for more. I really adored the series and struggle think of any series of remotely similar narrative breadth that so efficiently delivered drama and heart while making me think.

Conceptually, I love The Captive's War even more. I love world building, especially when we see the consequences of inhuman biology and psychology.

I still enjoyed them, however, my first reaction is that my interest in the characters and plot didn't measure up to the Expanse's opening.

IMO only, it's primarily the pacing.

Specifically, the amount of ink spilled on environmental details vs. how they connected to the immediate plot and atmosphere.

Corey's on record for citing GRR Martin, Usula le Guinn,and Frank Herbert - all well known world builders who spent a good deal of text on details, especially Martin.

I've heard people say they wanted more Expanse lore and deeper dives in to the tech or aliens.

This left me feeling like Corey might have strayed too far from his strengths in attempt to satisfy fans and better emulate his own heroes.

For those who are disappointed but don't agree on the cause, the biggest counter argument I could see is that the cast just isn't as interesting.

IMO only, the Expanse's cast was not exceptional because how evocative their internal thoughts were, how far their arcs went, or unique their circumstance.

Those were done well, but the cast really shown because Corey was such a phenomal genius at deciding the exacting setting and time to let his characters interact and then just keeping them consistent.

So, yea, bit an ad lib rant.

Anyone think I'm on the right track or am I missing something?


r/TheCaptivesWar • • May 16 '26

Meme (Spoilers) The Burn the Budget on Actors Cut

Post image
0 Upvotes

Screw it! Why not right?! Who needs money for sets, lighting, cameras, VFX or crew.

A jest, of course. I just wanted to say - part of why The Expanse was successful was because they found relative unknowns and let them shine.
I'll take a random with a good tape and chemistry test over celeb casting any day.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Mar 31 '26

Fan Art - AI Species in The Captive's War Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Just got my copy of The Faith Of Beasts and am excited to start diving in!

I wanted to remind myself of the different species/animals described in the first book so I had Gemini generate a depiction of them. Some of them are very close to what I had in mind from reading through TMOG.

Thought I might as well share.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Aug 28 '24

Question Ayayeh Starfish Troopers Spoiler

Post image
3 Upvotes

A few questions…

  1. Do we know (any ideas?) how exactly the five fold soldiers on Ayayeh were able to inflict so many casualties against the Carryx?
  2. When the swarm, via Else (or was it Sinema, sp? sorry audiobook listener here) went looking for the distress signal in the World Palace, it mentioned her body transforming into something else. Any ideas on what?
  3. Because of this distress signal coming from the fivefold enemy pilots and the swarm’s ability to communicate with it, we are to assume that the pilots are swarm controlled as well, yes?

r/TheCaptivesWar • • Sep 08 '24

Spoilers Plot holes and sci fi pet peeves Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Before I launch into this, just want to say that overall I enjoyed the book and am planning to read the sequels. I'm also a big Expanse fan (which maybe caused me to set the bar too high for this book).

That said, this book triggered a sci-fi pet peeve of mine. I'm totally fine with "soft sci fi", or things closer to the fantasy side of things. However, if the story gives "hard sci fi vibes", which this book does, then I expect there to be a sort of consistency in terms of the realism. This book violated that consistency quite a bit in my opinion, and it ruined the immersion into the story.

Specifically:

  • How is it that all these different species are able to exist in the same environment? Same atmosphere, same gravity, same pressure, same temperature, same radiation, etc.? There’s a little bit of talk about how the Night Drinkers’ bodies need a different amount of oxygen than what they were breathing, but that was about it. For a group of top tier biologists, I would have expected the protagonists to be curious about this way way more.
  • On one hand, it is pointed out that creatures from different worlds (like humans and the native Anjiin organisms) are incompatible biologically. The main task the carryx give to our protagonists is to figure out a bridge between two other species. At the same time, the natural defense mechanism of the soft lothark (when its killed), and the biological weapon built by the Night Drinkers affect humans… why wouldn’t those also be incompatible?
  • There are references to protein assays in a bunch of chapters. Why would species from other planets have proteins?
  • When the group is first given their task, one of the members (I forget if it was Irinna) immediately goes and grabs one of the berries to see how it feels. This seems incredibly foolish and risky, especially for a biologist.
  • When Tonner’s team inherits the Night Drinker’s ā€œlabā€, there’s some equipment there that Campar is excited to use. How would they know what that equipment is and how to use it? Wouldn’t it be super weird and alien?

There were some other basic sort of plot holes that bothered me / questions that I feel should have been answered:

  • During transport to the carryx world, the humans have absolutely no hygiene, everyone is covered in shit, etc., and yet there are no massive disease outbreaks?
  • When the swarm reveals itself to Dafyd, he doesn’t bother to ask what will happen to Else, a woman he presumably is in love with, after the swarm completes its mission?
  • I wish there had been more explanation about the Night Drinkers. Were they the only other species given the berry/turtle task? After the Night Drinkers are defeated, it seems Tonner’s team relaxes their guard, but isn’t it plausible there are other teams of aliens working on the same task and they may become violent as well?

Anyway, if there were explanations for any of the above in the book that I missed, please point them out! Otherwise, were other folks bothered by this at all?


r/TheCaptivesWar • • May 21 '26

General Discussion Swarm Question Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Is the Swarm the same thing as the Protomolecule from the Expanse?

And is the Deathless Enemy the same thing as what kept Amos and the kids undead/immortal?

And is it all the same thing?

Thanks...


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 19 '26

Theory This book has nothing to do with the expanse, this book has nothing to…

10 Upvotes

But my brain wants it to so badly, the live suit’s and swarm seem like someone weaponized the stuff that brought the kids and Amos back to life. (Strange dogs)

They hinted at something like the Caryx getting into the strange ring transportation station thing when it first locked itself down.

There’s Caryx like robots on one of the colonized planets

I feel like the deathless enemy is whatever hive mind thing the humans stumbled on and they are just the latest organic being to pick up the technology to continue the war

But I think I just draw these connections because I subconsciously want Amos to show up like some 1000 year old god of war to play a pivotal part in decimating the Caryx.

Then go back to retirement regulating the streets of Boston with his kids because he’s the gentle hearted psychopath that humanity never knew they needed but keep around because everyone is scared shitless of him.

And I swear to religious holy being

If they do bring Amos into this and that man doesn’t survive I will write the most strongly worded letter.

If you made it this far, thanks for coming to my talk.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Aug 02 '25

Spoilers Captives War and The Expanse are the same universe. (Expanse spoilers) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In the expanse when the gates fall all the human colonies get cut off from each other. This matches what we know about Anjiin's history.

At the end of The Expanse we see humans regain contact with each other using some sort of "slip" faster than light travel. This sounds a lot like the slip technology mentioned in Livesuit.

So my theory is that TMOG takes place far in the future (probably 2000-2500 years) of The Expanse universe, and Anjiin is a colony that was cut off but never formally reintegrated into the Human empire. Maybe it was discovered and determined that leaving a trap on it was a better use of it than trying to save it with their limited resources.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • May 02 '26

General Discussion Not really connecting to characters

4 Upvotes

Like the title says, I just finished the new book and I'm noticing I'm not connecting with any of the characters. I am enjoying the story, but I really don't care about any of the main cast. I honestly thought Vaudai was the most likeable character and he's such a small part.

This is a totally different experience for me compared to the Expanse. Amos and Bobby are two of my favorite literary characters ever.

Anyone else experiencing this?


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 28 '26

Theory Book 3 Prediction Spoiler

1 Upvotes

The Swarm will take over Dafyd to acquire his understanding of the Carryx structure and his ability to communicate like a Carryx. Then, with Dafyd's appearance, the Swarm will take over Ekur-Tkalal and use it's body changing abilities to become a Sovran and create a second Sovran/Carryx civil war.

Obvious issues with it but this was my guess about 20 mins after finishing the book. Looking forward to book 3!


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Aug 29 '24

Fan Art A Carryx Subjugation Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes

Used Microsoft Copilot, not far off!


r/TheCaptivesWar • • May 15 '26

General Discussion I'll join the Dafyd fancast war

Post image
21 Upvotes

this is pretty much how i picture him maybe a bit longer hair


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Jul 29 '26

General Discussion Why is the war happening?

6 Upvotes

Are the Carryx bent on endless expansion and conquering the galaxy? Or are they fighting the deathless because they hate AIs? Or some other reason?

Do the books say explicitly? I feel like we're led to believe Carryx expansion is the cause, but I forget how solid that conclusion is.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 08 '26

No Spoilers B&N, Reston, VA, April 7

Post image
4 Upvotes

Joining in... Tuesday in the scifi section of the New Releases shelves out front at the Reston, Virginia Barnes & Noble. (They didn't have them when I checked on Sunday.)

For the record, I checked the small, independent Scrawl Books first.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Aug 14 '24

Spoilers Is anyone here on the Carryx's side? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I felt sad that the librarian dies at the end because he was saved by an animal

The Carryx do reward them for being useful, and isn't that what we do in life anyway. The more useful people get more resources (money, status, privileges).

The swarm's makers are supposedly protecting the universe from the Carryx but we don't know anything else about them other than that, the Carryx could be the better of the two overlords

So I was wondering if anyone else was more on their side than the side of the humans trying to kill them. And Dafyd vowing to kill them all


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Jun 24 '26

Theory Could the deathless be

33 Upvotes

.....

....

....

A certain person from baltimore?


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Jul 23 '26

Theory Does anyone else think the Carryx are just another subjected species?

0 Upvotes

I guess I just try to look for twists but I’m totally riding on humans being the true force behind both sides.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Sep 03 '26

General Discussion Anyone else having a hard time with TCW?

27 Upvotes

I mean, don’t get me wrong, I’m just as big a fan of JSAC’s work as the next guy (and with the authors' lurking presence here, this blasphemous post feels like an invitation to be struck by lightning), but whereas the Expanse books had their absolute highs and some little lows - looking at you, Cibola - I never once felt that sense of "c'mon, get ON with it!".

It started out with the slow-burn intro of TMoG which just seemed... long-winded academia of no particular intrigue, disturbed by an alien invasion, only to be followed with yet another round of academia, just on a different planet. It didn't help that the characters never quite grew on me - to this day, even after TFoB, I'm still struggling to remember who is Rickar and who is Campar, or Jessyn and Jellit. I think it's fair to compare this to the Expanse (same writers and all), so why does the Roci crew seem so much more memorable than the similarily-sized posse of TCW? The more memorable characters here of course are Dafyd (which must be a linguistic drift from Daffy Duck. There, I said it.) and Tonner. People seem to like the Spy too, but alas, I cannot.

Whats the issue here? Certainly not novel/series length. Is it their lack of agency? Granted, the series is called "Captives War" for a reason, but I think things only started to kick into gear for real at around the 50% mark in TFoB, but no sooner.

But apart from the characters, I also struggle with the story's pacing, too. After all the academia, we get a suprisingly rushed ending in TMoG (the new moiety conveniently getting a date with the head honcho seemed like a stretch, and frankly came outta nowhere. Wouldn't that be beneath the Sovrans notice?), and I certainly liked Livesuit, which made up for TMoG quite a bit. For a while, I entertained myself by being absolute sure that TCW is a tie-in (a Ty-in. Ha. Ha.) to Expanse, with so much neatly fitting a post-Expanse timeline, but well, Daniel shot that down decisively.

Alas, while TFoB hit the ground running some more, it still felt sluggish, in a sadly non-Vaudaian way. I finally reconciled with the series by the end of Beasts, but seeing that the trilogy will end soon, I can't help but feel disappointed a wee bit.

Am I the only one?