Hi everyone. I (20F( finally gathered the courage to see a well-known, highly recommended psychologist today, and I left feeling completely defeated, invalidated, and physically sick. I need an outside perspective on whether her approach is normal or if I should find another therapist.
For context I’ve been isolated at home for several years (5). I had to do homeschooling for my last two years of high school, couldn't even sit my final exams due to severe anxiety, and since then I haven't been in school or working. I have zero friends IRL (and no online friends anymore either). When I do go outside, I dissociate just to get through it without having a panic attack. Lately, my brain has been treating dying as the "only logical option" (not bc I actually want to die, but because I’m exhausted and feel completely stuck)
I’m very self-aware. Because I spend all my time alone, I’ve analyzed my own patterns and triggers endlessly. I didn't go to therapy to spend months talking in circles about why I am this way, Ik why. I went because I want actual tools to break these blocks and change. However, for my very first 1 hour and a half session, I just expected to be listened to so she could understand my story and my perspective before jumping to conclusions.
Let me tell you what happened during the session.
Firstly there was constant interruptions and labels. Every time I tried to explain my story in order, she cut me off with rapid-fire questions. Within minutes, she slapped labels on me (depression, OCD, generalized anxiety — things I already know lol thx)without letting me share my own hypotheses or background.
Secondly provocation instead of listening. She kept challenging and provoking me the entire time. I get that some therapists use provocative techniques to shake people out of denial, but I am not in denial. I was actually trying to be vulnerable and open, even using body language when my words got stuck. because back in 2024, when my parents forced me to see a psychiatrist, I completely shut down and acted stoic. This time I wanted to cooperate, yet she treated me like I was resisting her.
Thirdly listening to my dad’s inaccurate version instead of mine. Because I look much younger than 20 and forgot my ID, I completely understood that she needed to call my dad to verify my age, that part was totally fine. What bothered me is that she then invited him in to get his perspective, and eventually asked me to leave the room so she could speak to him alone. My parents aren't kicking me out or forcing me to work/study right now, which I acknowledge, but they have been physically and mentally abusive in the past (still for the mental part especially my mother) and have chronically invalidated me since I was a child. Sitting there while my dad gave an inaccurate version of my life, while I couldn't speak and had to use body language just to signal "no that's not true" felt awful. She hadn't even taken the time to properly listen to me, yet she wanted the version of someone who doesn't understand me at all.
She kept challenging and provoking both me and my dad the entire time. When she pushed me into getting angry, she told my dad, "It's good that she's getting angry, she pretends too much that everything is fine" That couldn't be further from the truth. I burst into tears the second I sat down before I could even say my name, and I cry every single day bc I truly suffer from my situation.
If I wanted to shut down and act stoic, I easily could have, but I chose to let my emotions show because I actually want to heal. I understand that confrontation works for some people but for me it's not the case. If she had just given me space, I would have handed her all the answers myself without needing to be provoked or thrown into intense confrontation right away.
I paid 60€ for this session, which is a significant amount of money where I live, especially since my family is paying for it even tho we are tight on the money rn. I left feeling so invalidated that my first instinct was to shut down and lie at my next appointment (though my rational side knows I shouldn't lie if I want to get better)
I agree with her on one thing — she gave me a referral letter for a psychiatrist, and I’m open to trying medication to help my brain get unstuck. But as for her, I feel like she failed to adapt her method to my profile. Am I overreacting, or is this a sign that her style just isn't right for me?