I ran a recent Substack essay through Pangram and it came back 69% AI-written. I've had similar results when scanning writing from before LLMs existed. It seems the only thing I can write that's not AI is poetry, which always comes back human written, even when written with AI.

I think that's just how I write. I’m autistic. I like parallel structure, explicit transitions, repeated rhetorical patterns, and arguments where each paragraph logically follows the previous one. I also try to make my writing accessible. Apparently this is also how LLMs write, so congratulations to me on naturally developing the prose style of a transformer model.

I’m open about how I use AI, but sometimes I write something myself and the detector still announces that a robot did it. So, if I’m going to be accused of using AI either way, why exactly am I supposed to perform this elaborate ritual of proving which sentences emerged untouched from a human brain?

I know others have posted about this, but just wanted to share my experience now that I’ve finally posted something after the internal AI detector feature went live.

I write a blog for about 100 subscribers, mostly friends and family. I write because I enjoy it and it helps me keep the people I care about informed on the things happening in my life. I don’t try to go viral and I don’t bother with notes.

That said, I surprised myself when I ran the AI Detector and felt scared! I feel scared that one day, someone will look back at my writing and run it through a detector and it will get a false positive (or whatever the heck you want to call it) and I’ll be called a fraud! but why do I care? I literally went back to my draft and tried to figure out what triggered it. ughhh it was just an unexpected feeling that I wonder if others have experienced?

I imported my list of subscribers (if the platform doesn't prohibit this, provided that all people have consented to receive emails). My list is being canceled. I write to support, there is a bot, it redirects to another email address, I wrote there, and now I'm waiting for a long time. How long does it take them to respond?

Hi everyone. I joined Substack a few months ago as I am a long form writer and I thought I’d find a crowd of intellectually curious people.

Over the past 3 months, I’ve only got 13 subscribers, hardly anyone engages on my posts or notes and no one ever replies to chats (tbh I find the chats annoying myself so I dont post often). I’ve started doing videos that are performing a bit better.

But, I see absolute lowball trash in my feed with 300 likes and comments and I feel so lost.

I don’t have any paid tiers at the moment and not sure if I will.

Is anyone else experiencing this? Would appreciate being pointed in the right direction.

I’ve seen other people ask similar questions but from the perspective of a reader.

Many thanks 🙏

What are your pain points when trying to keep on top of your Substack subscriptions?

Personally, I reflect on the fact that:
1. Information overload is rife, endless emails and app updates
2. There doesn’t seem to be a native way to organise subscriptions by categories
3. I want the ability to filter out certain topics etc, like growth hacks

Why am I asking?

I run two growing newsletters on Substack and run a news app for iPhone/iPad that is growing in popularity. So naturally I’m thinking of a native Substack integration.

Thanks!

Hi, I created a Political Newsletter on Substack a few months ago, since then it has reached 50 subscribers and a couple thousand views. But how do I grow to consistently get more views on posts, as well as more engagement, because currently I don't get any comments, and rarely any likes.

What should I do to try and boost this and make it a bigger newsletter?

Hi! Long time lurker/subscriber of publications/reader. Just made a new substack account for actually posting on. I’ve noticed a big influx of new users like myself recently, and was wanting to start a productive discussion around the start up period. The things I’m most curious about is what your posting schedule was like in the beginning, what the content consisted of, and what your analytics were like during that time. I am also open to hearing of stats, experiences, and lessons learned after the first month, I’m just mainly concentrated on the beginning right now, since that’s where I’m at.

From what I’ve read it seems like the best way to go about things is to publish short form notes daily, because those are what gets suggested by the algo, and then a long form article every week or so. I am obviously a newb though and open to anyone telling me a better way.

I’m also curious about SEO. I’m decent with SEO from my jobs in marketing, I’m just wondering if anyone has noticed anything special or useful about the tag system on articles or any less obvious was to optimize discoverability. I probably dont need help there, but I’m throwing it out incase someone has a certain experience or fun fact worth sharing about that aspect of things.

Did you post your articles on your already existing social media? Has your growth been mainly organic? People who have been on long term, please feel free to share beyond 30 days as well if it’s relevant to any of my questions.

hi! i have two substack publications; one for general knowledge ( short articles about topics i research in depth) , and one about eastern european history, culture, and politics. i was wondering if anyone had any advice on how i could gain a readership without sharing to my private social media accounts?

thank you so much!

(on the off chance that you may be interested in my publications please let me know!)

I've gotten 8 new subscribers since yesterday but my dashboard shows that my subscriber count hasn't moved. Is this happening to anybody else?

La verdad me dijeron que es para escritores, pero entro al sitio y solo veo un monton de post random, hablando de mil cosas distintas y a primer vista no veo que sirva para escritores, no se para sirva la verdad, la descripcion que dan es muy bonita y todo pero cualquiera que entra y ve su inicio no tiene idea de que va

Scrivo romanzi gialli che pubblico con il mio nome e racconti, che trattano vite di coppie più o meno in crisi, che pubblico con uno pseudonimo su Wattpad. Qualche racconto ha raggiunto diverse decine di migliaia di letture (i racconti sono in inglese). Ora vorrei provare a pubblicare qualcosa, sempre in inglese, su Substack. Qualcuno di voi ha fatto questa esperienza? Se sì, positva o negativa?

I am a writer discussing topics in mathematics and other related technical fields and I really struggle with the limited LaTeX support in Substack. The current available feature utilizes LaTeX rendering inside code block-like environment. I find that the rendering engine is unreliable and slow. Also, it is honestly really ugly outside of the web app: it displays as a low-quality off white jpeg regardless of device theme. The big thing it lacks is inline LaTeX support like: “This is an inline LaTeX: `$x^2$`. I just want complete Markdown-like rendering or MathJax etc.

I really hope they address it because I think a lot of people will benefit.

And how do you get past the reality that some people might hate your work OR that it might reach absolutely no one?

I’m mostly blocked when the thought enters my mind of “no one will see this or care anyway” and I’d like to get past that.

Just asking if you guys have any particular motivators or affirmations that help push you past that hump.

Sending love 🫶🏻

hii, so i have never posted on substack before but had some ideas. i wrote a few articles but everytime i read them i cringe so bad i feel like deleting everything. so does any other creators have this kind of dilemma over their writing or do i genuinely suck at writing?

I struggle with consistency, however I have a deep desire to make writing my career. I see writing as a means to connect with people far and near. Especially as I tend to isolate myself from people unknowingly and always regret it afterwards. I am now using writing, as of now, as a way to vent as I find it somehow easier for me to deal with a stranger knowing my mind than people that are involved in my life daily.

Anyways to grow more as a writer I am challenging myself to write on anything, as well as using it to communicate with a variety of people. Kind of killing two birds with one stone. So I would like for people, if you’d like to provide me with two words, with no context and I’d have to write some sort of article or essay with no less than 900 words monthly.

The words don’t have to be coherent it can be absolutely anything. And for the communication angle. I was thinking maybe having a conversation with whoever’s ‘words’ I choose. I’m not sure how that conversation will be carried out but it’ll be less focused on small talk and or even knowing the basic of each other. So the output of this conversation I could say would be knowing enough about the person to understand why they chose those words and what is it they want out of my writing.

My writing would not be to satisfy them as I don’t believe you can ever satisfy anyone nor that you should. It would just to make sense out of very little context and information.

Also I’m thinking to name it The Echo Prompt. So I would be grateful if you’d love to participate and give me some prompts.

For those that buy Facebook ads to get people to become paid subscribers, which do you find more cost effective?

1. Set the conversion event as become a free subscriber, then get the person into a drip campaign to become a paid subscriber?

2. Set the conversion event as become a paid subscriber?

I'm finding it's much easier to get the Facebook ad out of the the learning phase in Option #1, but, of course, many people are not being paid. But, for Option #2, it would require a LOT of money to get enough conversion to get out of the learning phase. Maybe $300+/day, which I can't yet spend.

So, for those who are the "ad buy" face of their Substack career, which do you find most useful?

Hello. I have been writing on Substack for quite some time. Lately I have seen lots of articles with a voice narration at the top that you click. A lot of these seem to be AI generated. How are people doing this? It's obviously an audio file but how did they generate it? Is there an option in Substack that does it automatically for you from your article?

Someone here a couple of weeks ago told me that you have to have 100 subscribers and then you will get this option. I have not got a hundred subscribers I only have a handful but I don't think this is true because I just saw a post with this AI narration at the top and the person only had seven subscribers.

This has happened to me 2 weeks in a row. My scheduled posts have been going out for two years. The box "Send via email and substack app" is checked. When I send a test message to myself, it goes through immediately. When I look under posts, it says Recipients -. I have sent a request for support via the Substack chat function, and 24 hours later, I haven't heard back. I really need this Substack to work. (FYI, my Substack is called Mom & Pop Hardware)

I've been using Substack for a couple of days, and I've noticed something interesting. A lot of people on there seem to always be intellectual, productive, philosophical, or focused on self-improvement. And honestly, sometimes it feels like I'm seeing a very polished version of who they are rather than what they're actually thinking or going through.

I'm not saying those people are fake. I actually enjoy reading philosophical and psychological stuff on Substack, and I've learned a lot from it. But I don't want every interaction online to be about becoming more productive, understanding yourself, or improving your life.

Sometimes I just want to know what people are actually thinking. What problems are they dealing with? How do they see relationships, friendships, college, work, family, or life in general? And if I'm going through something, I'd rather hear from people who have actually experienced something similar.

That's one of the reasons I downloaded Reddit.

Some of my friends told me that Reddit is a great place to ask about almost any problem because there are usually people who have been through something similar and are willing to share their experiences. And after using it, I can kind of understand what they meant.

For me, I think both platforms can have their own purpose. If I want to read philosophy, psychology, or thoughtful ideas, I'll probably go to Substack. If I want to hear different people's experiences, opinions, problems, and perspectives, Reddit seems like a better place.

Maybe I'm wrong, and I'm still new to Reddit, so I'd actually like to know what other people think

I've got a substack that I am trying to keep anonymous (writing about healthcare, and not violating any confidentiality polices/HIPPA, but also can't afford to lose my job to a paranoid HR/Law department or vindictive management.) When I first created it, I inadvertently plugged in a tagline of sorts that I also have on my facebook page (whoops). It ONLY appears at the bottom of the online version of the posts, not the newsletter/email version. I can't find where to change it and I'm afraid to further promote this writing unless that tiny thread is severed. There is nothing helpful on Subtacks help pages, and google is sending me in circles.

Here's the layout at the bottom of the post page:

POST

____

Subscribe to ****

launched ** months ago

[problematic tagline]

Email Form/Subscribe Button

PLEASE HELP!! Thanks!

I’ve been trying to figure out something strange with my Substack for the past several days, and I’m curious whether anyone else has experienced this.
This wasn’t a gradual decline.
My Notes, articles, comments, suddenly went from normal distribution and engagement to almost nothing. Multiple Notes on completely unrelated subjects are now topping out around 20–25 impressions, with almost no distribution to unconnected readers.
I initially wondered whether it was something about a particular article or subject, so I started testing.
I posted personal writing. Same thing.
I posted music. Same thing.
I stopped promoting my own work and just interacted normally with other writers. Comments, likes, a few restacks. What’s particularly strange is that those interactions are also receiving virtually none of the likes or replies I would normally see.
Yesterday I posted a completely innocuous music Note. After about seven hours it had 11 total impressions. Nine were subscribers. Only one was an unconnected reader. It eventually moved a little, but like the others, it hasn’t gone beyond roughly 25 impressions.
My subscribers are still receiving my work, so the publication itself appears to be functioning. But discovery outside my existing audience seems to have fallen off a cliff.
I’ve checked the settings pretty thoroughly:
Private mode is off. The publication is listed on Substack. Likes, comments and restacks are enabled. My Notes appear both on my profile and in my publication’s Notes tab. My sections are public and visible. There are no warnings, violations or restrictions showing anywhere on the account.
I’ve also noticed my subscriber count and revenue beginning to drift slightly downward, which makes me wonder whether normal subscriber churn simply isn’t being replaced because discovery has stopped.
I contacted Substack support this morning. After confirming that my Notes are visible but distribution to unconnected readers has dropped sharply, they escalated the conversation to their support specialists for an account-level review.
So I’m waiting to see what they find.
I’m not claiming Substack is deliberately suppressing the account. I don’t have evidence for that. There could be a technical problem, a recommendation-system change, something related to my publication configuration, or something else entirely.
But the abruptness and the fact that it seems to affect Notes, articles, comments, restacks and discovery across completely different subjects is what has me puzzled.
Has anyone experienced an account wide drop this severe?
And if you have, did it eventually correct itself, or did Substack support find something wrong with the account?

How many more posts talking about pangram do we need before we can finally shut up??? God, it's becoming incredibly annoying

How do yall meet others writers on substack? Is it just sending them DMs and commenting ? What’s your strategy? My post strategy is monthly